Resources

A student predicts that adding 500.0 mL500.0\text{ mL} of pure water to a boiling 0.500 m0.500\text{ m} aqueous glucose solution will make the solution boil at an even higher temperature because "adding more liquid increases total heat absorption." Explain why this intuition is conceptually flawed using colligative principles, and calculate the new boiling point of the solution if the original mixture contained 250.0 g250.0\text{ g} of water and 500.0 g500.0\text{ g} of water was subsequently added. (For water, Tb0=100.000∘CT_b^0 = 100.000^\circ\text{C}, Kb=0.512∘C⋅kg/molK_b = 0.512^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol}).

Answer and steps

Final answer

The student's intuition is incorrect because boiling point elevation depends on molal solute particle concentration, not total volume; dilution decreases molality (mm), reducing ΔTb\Delta T_b. The new boiling point is 100.085∘C100.085^\circ\text{C}.

Steps

01

Find the moles of dissolved glucose in the initial solution

Conceptual Analysis of the Student's Claim

Boiling occurs when the vapor pressure of a liquid equals the external atmospheric pressure. Boiling point is an intensive property; it does not depend on the total amount or volume of liquid, nor does it increase simply because a larger mass of water can absorb more total thermal energy (an extensive quantity). Boiling point elevation (ΔTb\Delta T_b) is a colligative property, governed by the relation: ΔTb=i⋅Kb⋅m\Delta T_b = i \cdot K_b \cdot m where:

  • ii is the van 't Hoff factor (i=1i = 1 for non-ionizing solutes such as glucose),
  • KbK_b is the ebullioscopic constant of the solvent,
  • mm is the molality of the solution (moles of solute/kilograms of solvent\text{moles of solute} / \text{kilograms of solvent}). Solute particles lower the solvent's vapor pressure by occupying surface area and stabilizing the liquid state through intermolecular interactions, requiring a higher temperature to reach atmospheric pressure. Adding pure water dilutes the solution, which decreases the molality (mm). Consequently, the vapor pressure increases toward that of pure water, reducing ΔTb\Delta T_b and causing the boiling point to decrease back toward 100.000∘C100.000^\circ\text{C}, contrary to the student's prediction.

Quantitative Calculation of the New Boiling Point

The initial solution has a molality of m1=0.500 mol/kgm_1 = 0.500\text{ mol/kg} and contains 250.0 g=0.2500 kg250.0\text{ g} = 0.2500\text{ kg} of water:

nglucose=m1⋅mass of initial solvent=0.500 mol/kg⋅0.2500 kg=0.125 moln_{\text{glucose}} = m_1 \cdot \text{mass of initial solvent} = 0.500\text{ mol/kg} \cdot 0.2500\text{ kg} = 0.125\text{ mol}

02

Determine the total mass of the solvent after dilution

Adding 500.0 g500.0\text{ g} of pure water gives:

mass of solventnew=250.0 g+500.0 g=750.0 g=0.7500 kg\text{mass of solvent}_{\text{new}} = 250.0\text{ g} + 500.0\text{ g} = 750.0\text{ g} = 0.7500\text{ kg}

03

Calculate the new molality (mnewm_{\text{new}})

mnew=nglucosemass of solventnew=0.125 mol0.7500 kg=16 mol/kg≈0.1667 mm_{\text{new}} = \frac{n_{\text{glucose}}}{\text{mass of solvent}_{\text{new}}} = \frac{0.125\text{ mol}}{0.7500\text{ kg}} = \frac{1}{6}\text{ mol/kg} \approx 0.1667\text{ m}

04

Calculate the new boiling point elevation (ΔTb\Delta T_b)

Since glucose is a molecular non-electrolyte, i=1i = 1:

ΔTb=(1)⋅(0.512∘C⋅kg/mol)⋅(0.125 mol0.7500 kg)≈0.0853∘C≈0.085∘C\Delta T_b = (1) \cdot (0.512^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol}) \cdot \left(\frac{0.125\text{ mol}}{0.7500\text{ kg}}\right) \approx 0.0853^\circ\text{C} \approx 0.085^\circ\text{C}

05

Determine the new boiling point (TbT_b)

Tb=Tb0+ΔTb=100.000∘C+0.085∘C=100.085∘CT_b = T_b^0 + \Delta T_b = 100.000^\circ\text{C} + 0.085^\circ\text{C} = 100.085^\circ\text{C}


Common Pitfall

A frequent error is confusing heat capacity (an extensive measure of heat required to raise temperature) with boiling temperature (an intensive equilibrium threshold). While more energy is required to bring a larger total mass of liquid to a boil, the temperature at which it boils depends strictly on vapor pressure and solute concentration.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates the boiling point elevation using only the added mass of water as the solvent instead of the total combined mass of water.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Boiling point depends on solute concentration rather than liquid volume or heat capacity. Adding pure water dilutes the solution, decreasing molality and therefore lowering the boiling point.

  2. Step 2

    moles of glucose=0.500 mol/kg×0.2500 kg=0.125 mol\text{moles of glucose} = 0.500\text{ mol/kg} \times 0.2500\text{ kg} = 0.125\text{ mol}

  3. Step 3

    mass of water=500.0 g=0.5000 kg  ⟹  mnew=0.125 mol0.5000 kg=0.250 mol/kg\text{mass of water} = 500.0\text{ g} = 0.5000\text{ kg} \implies m_{\text{new}} = \frac{0.125\text{ mol}}{0.5000\text{ kg}} = 0.250\text{ mol/kg}

    Correct

    mwater, total=250.0 g+500.0 g=750.0 g=0.7500 kg  ⟹  mnew=0.125 mol0.7500 kg=16 mol/kg≈0.1667 mol/kgm_{\text{water, total}} = 250.0\text{ g} + 500.0\text{ g} = 750.0\text{ g} = 0.7500\text{ kg} \implies m_{\text{new}} = \frac{0.125\text{ mol}}{0.7500\text{ kg}} = \frac{1}{6}\text{ mol/kg} \approx 0.1667\text{ mol/kg}

    You used only the added 500.0 g500.0\text{ g} of water as the denominator. The denominator must be the total combined solvent mass: 250.0 g+500.0 g=750.0 g=0.7500 kg250.0\text{ g} + 500.0\text{ g} = 750.0\text{ g} = 0.7500\text{ kg}.

  4. Step 4

    ΔTb=0.512∘C⋅kg/mol×0.250 mol/kg=0.128∘C  ⟹  Tb=100.000∘C+0.128∘C=100.128∘C\Delta T_b = 0.512^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol} \times 0.250\text{ mol/kg} = 0.128^\circ\text{C} \implies T_b = 100.000^\circ\text{C} + 0.128^\circ\text{C} = 100.128^\circ\text{C}

    Correct

    ΔTb=(1)(0.512∘C⋅kg/mol)(0.125 mol0.7500 kg)≈0.085∘C  ⟹  Tb=100.000∘C+0.085∘C=100.085∘C\Delta T_b = (1)(0.512^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol})\left(\frac{0.125\text{ mol}}{0.7500\text{ kg}}\right) \approx 0.085^\circ\text{C} \implies T_b = 100.000^\circ\text{C} + 0.085^\circ\text{C} = 100.085^\circ\text{C}

    Your formulas for ΔTb\Delta T_b and TbT_b were set up properly, but the numerical answer was thrown off by the incorrect molality from Step 3.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You clearly distinguished intensive colligative properties from extensive heat capacity.

You correctly reasoned that adding solvent decreases molality and therefore lowers the boiling point.

You accurately calculated the initial moles of dissolved glucose.

You correctly applied the boiling point elevation formula ΔTb=iKbm\Delta T_b = i K_b m and added the elevation to the pure solvent boiling point.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted Initial Solvent Mass in Dilution

You substituted only the newly added mass of water (500.0 g500.0\text{ g}) into the molality formula rather than the total mass of water present in the mixture.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

In dilution problems, it is easy to conflate the quantity of solvent added with the final total quantity of solvent. Molality is defined per kilogram of total solvent in the final solution.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define Total Solvent Mass
  • msolvent, final=msolvent, initial+msolvent, addedm_{\text{solvent, final}} = m_{\text{solvent, initial}} + m_{\text{solvent, added}}

  • Always write down an explicit sum for total solvent mass before computing the new molality.

Molality Definition Check
  • m=nsolutetotal kg of solventm = \frac{n_{\text{solute}}}{\text{total kg of solvent}}

  • Verify that the denominator accounts for all solvent present in the container, not just the volume or mass transferred in the dilution step.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the total mass of solvent: msolvent, total=250.0 g+500.0 g=750.0 g=0.7500 kgm_{\text{solvent, total}} = 250.0\text{ g} + 500.0\text{ g} = 750.0\text{ g} = 0.7500\text{ kg}.

  2. Compute the new molality: mnew=0.125 mol0.7500 kg=0.1667 mol/kgm_{\text{new}} = \frac{0.125\text{ mol}}{0.7500\text{ kg}} = 0.1667\text{ mol/kg}.

  3. Calculate the boiling point elevation: ΔTb=(1)(0.512∘C⋅kg/mol)(0.1667 mol/kg)≈0.0853∘C\Delta T_b = (1)(0.512^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol})(0.1667\text{ mol/kg}) \approx 0.0853^\circ\text{C}.

  4. Determine the new boiling point: Tb=100.000∘C+0.0853∘C=100.085∘CT_b = 100.000^\circ\text{C} + 0.0853^\circ\text{C} = 100.085^\circ\text{C}.

Final answer

The student's intuition is conceptually incorrect because boiling point elevation is a colligative property that depends on molality, not total liquid mass; adding water dilutes the solution, which lowers the boiling point. The correct new boiling point is 100.085∘C100.085^\circ\text{C}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • In future dilution problems, label minitialm_{\text{initial}}, maddedm_{\text{added}}, and mtotalm_{\text{total}} as separate lines before calculating molality.

  • Practice checking whether your final solvent mass is larger than both the initial mass and the added mass.

  • Work through the practice problems below to practice combining solvent masses when electrolytes and non-electrolytes are diluted.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student treats glucose as an electrolyte with a van 't Hoff factor of i = 2 instead of nonelectrolyte i = 1.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Boiling point elevation is a colligative property determined by particle molality, not heat absorption. Diluting with water decreases solute concentration, lowering ΔTb\Delta T_b closer to pure water's boiling point.

  2. Step 2

    moles of glucose=0.500 mol/kg×0.2500 kg=0.125 mol  ⟹  total water=0.2500 kg+0.5000 kg=0.7500 kg  ⟹  mnew=0.125 mol0.7500 kg=0.1667 mol/kg\text{moles of glucose} = 0.500\text{ mol/kg} \times 0.2500\text{ kg} = 0.125\text{ mol} \implies \text{total water} = 0.2500\text{ kg} + 0.5000\text{ kg} = 0.7500\text{ kg} \implies m_{\text{new}} = \frac{0.125\text{ mol}}{0.7500\text{ kg}} = 0.1667\text{ mol/kg}

  3. Step 3

    ΔTb=2×0.512∘C⋅kg/mol×0.1667 mol/kg=0.171∘C\Delta T_b = 2 \times 0.512^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol} \times 0.1667\text{ mol/kg} = 0.171^\circ\text{C}

    Correct

    ΔTb=(1)(0.512∘C⋅kg/mol)(0.1667 mol/kg)≈0.085∘C\Delta T_b = (1)(0.512^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol})(0.1667\text{ mol/kg}) \approx 0.085^\circ\text{C}

    You substituted i=2i = 2, but glucose (CX6HX12OX6\ce{C6H12O6}) is a molecular nonelectrolyte that does not dissociate in water, so its van 't Hoff factor is i=1i = 1.

  4. Step 4

    Tb=100.000∘C+0.171∘C=100.171∘CT_b = 100.000^\circ\text{C} + 0.171^\circ\text{C} = 100.171^\circ\text{C}

    Correct

    Tb=100.000∘C+0.085∘C=100.085∘CT_b = 100.000^\circ\text{C} + 0.085^\circ\text{C} = 100.085^\circ\text{C}

    You added your calculated ΔTb\Delta T_b correctly to the normal boiling point of water, but this step inherited the factor-of-two error from Step 3.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You provided an accurate conceptual rebuttal showing that boiling point depends on solute concentration rather than total heat capacity.

You correctly calculated the moles of solute and updated the solvent mass to find the new diluted molality.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect van 't Hoff factor for a nonelectrolyte

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated molecular glucose as an electrolyte that dissociates into two ions rather than recognizing it as a covalent nonelectrolyte where i=1i = 1.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Classify the solute before setting $i$
  • Soluble covalent molecular substances (such as sugars, urea, and alcohols) do not dissociate into ions, so i=1i = 1. Only ionic salts and strong electrolytes yield i>1i > 1.

  • Always verify whether the solute is ionic (metal + nonmetal / polyatomic ion) or covalent (all nonmetals, non-acid) before assigning the van 't Hoff factor.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Use i=1i = 1 for molecular glucose in the colligative formula: ΔTb=i⋅Kb⋅m=(1)(0.512∘C⋅kg/mol)(0.1667 mol/kg)≈0.0853∘C\Delta T_b = i \cdot K_b \cdot m = (1)(0.512^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol})(0.1667\text{ mol/kg}) \approx 0.0853^\circ\text{C}.

  2. Add this elevation to the boiling point of pure water: Tb=100.000∘C+0.085∘C=100.085∘CT_b = 100.000^\circ\text{C} + 0.085^\circ\text{C} = 100.085^\circ\text{C}.

Final answer

The new boiling point is 100.085∘C100.085^\circ\text{C}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how to distinguish ionic salts from molecular compounds to choose the correct van 't Hoff factor (ii).

  • Practice calculating boiling point elevation and freezing point depression across both molecular solutes (sugars, glycols) and ionic salts (such as NaCl\ce{NaCl} or CaClX2\ce{CaCl2}).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student reports the boiling point elevation ΔTb as the final boiling point instead of adding it to the normal boiling point of pure water.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Boiling point elevation depends on solute concentration rather than total heat capacity. Adding pure water dilutes the solution, decreasing molality and lowering the boiling point.

  2. Step 2

    moles of glucose=0.500 mol/kg×0.2500 kg=0.125 mol  ⟹  total water=250.0 g+500.0 g=750.0 g=0.7500 kg  ⟹  mnew=0.125 mol0.7500 kg=0.1667 mol/kg\text{moles of glucose} = 0.500\text{ mol/kg} \times 0.2500\text{ kg} = 0.125\text{ mol} \implies \text{total water} = 250.0\text{ g} + 500.0\text{ g} = 750.0\text{ g} = 0.7500\text{ kg} \implies m_{\text{new}} = \frac{0.125\text{ mol}}{0.7500\text{ kg}} = 0.1667\text{ mol/kg}

  3. Step 3

    ΔTb=0.512∘C⋅kg/mol×0.1667 mol/kg=0.0853∘C\Delta T_b = 0.512^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol} \times 0.1667\text{ mol/kg} = 0.0853^\circ\text{C}

  4. Step 4

    Tb=0.0853∘CT_b = 0.0853^\circ\text{C}

    Correct

    Tb=Tb0+ΔTb=100.000∘C+0.0853∘C≈100.085∘CT_b = T_b^0 + \Delta T_b = 100.000^\circ\text{C} + 0.0853^\circ\text{C} \approx 100.085^\circ\text{C}

    You reported the boiling point elevation ΔTb\Delta T_b directly as the final boiling point TbT_b. Because water boils at 100.000∘C100.000^\circ\text{C} under standard conditions, you must add ΔTb\Delta T_b to Tb0T_b^0.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly dismantled the student's intuition using colligative principles and dilution.

You accurately calculated the moles of solute and the diluted molality.

You correctly computed the boiling point elevation ΔTb\Delta T_b using the ebullioscopic constant.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating Temperature Change with Absolute Temperature

Reporting ΔTb\Delta T_b directly as the boiling point TbT_b.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the elevation value ΔTb\Delta T_b as the boiling temperature itself instead of applying the relationship Tb=Tb0+ΔTbT_b = T_b^0 + \Delta T_b. A boiling point elevation of 0.085∘C0.085^\circ\text{C} means the solution boils 0.085∘C0.085^\circ\text{C} above water's normal boiling point (100.000∘C100.000^\circ\text{C}), not at 0.085∘C0.085^\circ\text{C}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Temperature Change vs. Final Temperature
  • ΔTb\Delta T_b is the change in boiling temperature relative to the pure solvent: Tb=Tb0+ΔTbT_b = T_b^0 + \Delta T_b.

  • After calculating ΔTb\Delta T_b, check whether your answer is near the normal boiling point of the solvent (100∘C100^\circ\text{C} for water) before writing down the final temperature.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Add the elevation ΔTb\Delta T_b to the normal boiling point of pure water: Tb=Tb0+ΔTbT_b = T_b^0 + \Delta T_b.

  2. Substitute the values: Tb=100.000∘C+0.0853∘C=100.0853∘CT_b = 100.000^\circ\text{C} + 0.0853^\circ\text{C} = 100.0853^\circ\text{C}.

  3. Round to the appropriate precision: Tb=100.085∘CT_b = 100.085^\circ\text{C}.

Final answer

Tb=100.085∘CT_b = 100.085^\circ\text{C}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out the explicit relationship Tb=Tb0+ΔTbT_b = T_b^0 + \Delta T_b before substituting numbers.

  • Perform a physical reality check on aqueous solutions: boiling points should always be slightly above 100∘C100^\circ\text{C}, whereas freezing points should be slightly below 0∘C0^\circ\text{C}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A solution contains 0.200 mol0.200\text{ mol} of sucrose dissolved in 400.0 g400.0\text{ g} of water. If you add 600.0 g600.0\text{ g} of pure water to this solution, what is the new molality of the sucrose solution?

Answer

0.200 m0.200\text{ m}. Key steps: Total mass of solvent =400.0 g+600.0 g=1000.0 g=1.000 kg= 400.0\text{ g} + 600.0\text{ g} = 1000.0\text{ g} = 1.000\text{ kg}. Molality m=0.200 mol1.000 kg=0.200 mol/kgm = \frac{0.200\text{ mol}}{1.000\text{ kg}} = 0.200\text{ mol/kg}.

02

An aqueous solution is prepared by dissolving 0.100 mol0.100\text{ mol} of NaCl\ce{NaCl} (i=2i = 2) into 200.0 g200.0\text{ g} of water. Then, 300.0 g300.0\text{ g} of pure water is added. Calculate the boiling point of the resulting diluted solution. (Kb=0.512∘C⋅kg/molK_b = 0.512^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol}, Tb0=100.000∘CT_b^0 = 100.000^\circ\text{C}).

Answer

100.205∘C100.205^\circ\text{C}. Key steps: Total solvent mass =200.0 g+300.0 g=500.0 g=0.5000 kg= 200.0\text{ g} + 300.0\text{ g} = 500.0\text{ g} = 0.5000\text{ kg}. Molality m=0.100 mol0.5000 kg=0.200 mm = \frac{0.100\text{ mol}}{0.5000\text{ kg}} = 0.200\text{ m}. Elevation ΔTb=iKbm=2×0.512∘C⋅kg/mol×0.200 mol/kg=0.2048∘C≈0.205∘C\Delta T_b = i K_b m = 2 \times 0.512^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol} \times 0.200\text{ mol/kg} = 0.2048^\circ\text{C} \approx 0.205^\circ\text{C}. Boiling point Tb=100.000∘C+0.205∘C=100.205∘CT_b = 100.000^\circ\text{C} + 0.205^\circ\text{C} = 100.205^\circ\text{C}.

03

A 300.0 g300.0\text{ g} sample of an aqueous glucose solution initially boils at 100.256∘C100.256^\circ\text{C}. How much pure water must be added to lower its boiling point to 100.128∘C100.128^\circ\text{C}? (Kb=0.512∘C⋅kg/molK_b = 0.512^\circ\text{C}\cdot\text{kg/mol}, glucose is non-ionizing).

Answer

Add an amount of water equal to the initial mass of water (doubling the solvent mass cuts ΔTb\Delta T_b in half). Key steps: Initial elevation ΔTb1=0.256∘C  ⟹  m1=0.2560.512=0.500 m\Delta T_{b1} = 0.256^\circ\text{C} \implies m_1 = \frac{0.256}{0.512} = 0.500\text{ m}. Target elevation ΔTb2=0.128∘C  ⟹  m2=0.1280.512=0.250 m\Delta T_{b2} = 0.128^\circ\text{C} \implies m_2 = \frac{0.128}{0.512} = 0.250\text{ m}. Since m2=12m1m_2 = \frac{1}{2}m_1, the total solvent mass must double: msolvent, final=2msolvent, initialm_{\text{solvent, final}} = 2 m_{\text{solvent, initial}}. Thus, the mass of water to add equals the original mass of water in the solution.

Loading workspace…