Resources

In an organic chemistry teaching laboratory, a student standardizes a sample of an unknown liquid carboxylic acid, compound X\text{X}, by titration. A 0.2163 g0.2163\text{ g} sample of pure compound X\text{X} is dissolved in 25.0 mL25.0\text{ mL} of deionized water and titrated with standardized 0.1025 M NaOH(aq)0.1025\text{ M } \text{NaOH}(\text{aq}) using a calibrated glass buret and phenolphthalein indicator. The initial buret reading is 0.45 mL0.45\text{ mL} and the pink endpoint is reached at 24.45 mL24.45\text{ mL}. Elemental combustion analysis yields 54.53% C54.53\%\text{ C}, 9.15% H9.15\%\text{ H}, and 36.32% O36.32\%\text{ O} by mass. (a) Calculate the experimentally determined molar mass of the monoprotic carboxylic acid to four significant figures. (b) Determine the molecular formula of compound X\text{X}. (c) If compound X\text{X} is branched and contains a chiral stereocenter, write its systematic IUPAC name.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Molar mass: 87.93 g/mol87.93\text{ g/mol}; (b) Molecular formula: C4H8O2\text{C}_4\text{H}_8\text{O}_2; (c) Systematic IUPAC name: 2-methylpropanoic acid2\text{-methylpropanoic acid} does not possess a stereocenter, but (2R/2S)-2-hydroxybutanal(2R/2S)\text{-2-hydroxybutanal} is not a carboxylic acid; since no 44-carbon carboxylic acid contains a stereocenter, the monocarboxylic acid matching C4H8O2\text{C}_4\text{H}_8\text{O}_2 is 2-methylpropanoic acid2\text{-methylpropanoic acid} (isobutyric acid) with four unique carbons, or if unbranched, butanoic acid\text{butanoic acid}.

Steps

Part (a): Determine the Experimental Molar Mass

  1. Calculate the volume of titrant (NaOH\ce{NaOH}) consumed: ΔV=Vfinal−Vinitial=24.45 mL−0.45 mL=24.00 mL=0.02400 L\Delta V = V_{\text{final}} - V_{\text{initial}} = 24.45\text{ mL} - 0.45\text{ mL} = 24.00\text{ mL} = 0.02400\text{ L}
  2. Calculate the moles of base reacted at the equivalence point: nNaOH=M⋅V=(0.1025 mol/L)(0.02400 L)=2.460×10−3 moln_{\ce{NaOH}} = M \cdot V = (0.1025\text{ mol/L})(0.02400\text{ L}) = 2.460 \times 10^{-3}\text{ mol}
  3. Determine the moles and molar mass of the monoprotic acid (HA\ce{HA}): The stoichiometric neutralization reaction is: HA(aq)+NaOH(aq)→NaA(aq)+HX2O(l)\ce{HA(aq) + NaOH(aq) -> NaA(aq) + H2O(l)} Because the acid is monoprotic, the stoichiometric ratio is 1:11:1: nacid=nNaOH=2.460×10−3 moln_{\text{acid}} = n_{\ce{NaOH}} = 2.460 \times 10^{-3}\text{ mol}

    The experimental molar mass is the mass of compound X\text{X} divided by the moles: M=mn=0.2163 g2.460×10−3 mol=87.9268… g/mol≈87.93 g/molM = \frac{m}{n} = \frac{0.2163\text{ g}}{2.460 \times 10^{-3}\text{ mol}} = 87.9268\dots\text{ g/mol} \approx 87.93\text{ g/mol}


Part (b): Determine the Molecular Formula

  1. Find the empirical formula from combustion analysis: Assuming a 100.0 g100.0\text{ g} sample of compound X\text{X}:

    • Moles of C\ce{C}: nC=54.53 g12.011 g/mol=4.540 moln_{\ce{C}} = \frac{54.53\text{ g}}{12.011\text{ g/mol}} = 4.540\text{ mol}
    • Moles of H\ce{H}: nH=9.15 g1.008 g/mol=9.077 moln_{\ce{H}} = \frac{9.15\text{ g}}{1.008\text{ g/mol}} = 9.077\text{ mol}
    • Moles of O\ce{O}: nO=36.32 g15.999 g/mol=2.270 moln_{\ce{O}} = \frac{36.32\text{ g}}{15.999\text{ g/mol}} = 2.270\text{ mol}
  2. Determine the simplest whole-number ratio: Divide each by the smallest mole value (2.270 mol2.270\text{ mol}): C:4.5402.270≈2.00,H:9.0772.270≈4.00,O:2.2702.270=1.00\ce{C}: \frac{4.540}{2.270} \approx 2.00, \quad \ce{H}: \frac{9.077}{2.270} \approx 4.00, \quad \ce{O}: \frac{2.270}{2.270} = 1.00 The empirical formula is CX2HX4O\ce{C2H4O}.
  3. Calculate the empirical formula mass: Mass of CX2HX4O=2(12.011 g/mol)+4(1.008 g/mol)+15.999 g/mol=44.05 g/mol\text{Mass of }\ce{C2H4O} = 2(12.011\text{ g/mol}) + 4(1.008\text{ g/mol}) + 15.999\text{ g/mol} = 44.05\text{ g/mol}
  4. Determine the molecular formula: Scaling factor n=Molar massEmpirical mass=87.93 g/mol44.05 g/mol≈2\text{Scaling factor } n = \frac{\text{Molar mass}}{\text{Empirical mass}} = \frac{87.93\text{ g/mol}}{44.05\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2 Multiplying the empirical subscripts by 22 gives the molecular formula: (CX2HX4O)X2=CX4HX8OX2\ce{(C2H4O)2} = \ce{C4H8O2}

Part (c): Systematic IUPAC Name

  1. Constitutional isomers of monocarboxylic acids with formula CX4HX8OX2\ce{C4H8O2}: A saturated acyclic carboxylic acid of formula CX4HX8OX2\ce{C4H8O2} has only two constitutional isomers:

    • Straight-chain isomer: Butanoic acid, CHX3−CHX2−CHX2−COOH\ce{CH3-CH2-CH2-COOH}
    • Branched isomer: 2-Methylpropanoic acid, (CHX3)X2CH−COOH\ce{(CH3)2CH-COOH}
  2. Evaluation of stereocenters:

    • In 2-methylpropanoic acid, carbon-2 is bonded to two identical methyl groups (−CHX3-\ce{CH3}), one hydrogen atom (−H-\ce{H}), and one carboxyl group (−COOH-\ce{COOH}). Because it does not have four different substituents, it is achiral.
    • No 44-carbon monocarboxylic acid can possess a chiral center (a chiral carboxylic acid requires at least 55 carbons, such as 2-methylbutanoic acid).
    • Therefore, the branched carboxylic acid corresponding to CX4HX8OX2\ce{C4H8O2} is 2-methylpropanoic acid (isobutyric acid).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student ignores the initial buret reading and uses only the final reading to calculate titrant volume, leading to an erroneously low molar mass.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    V(NaOH)=24.45 mL=0.02445 L  ⟹  n(NaOH)=0.02445 L×0.1025 M=0.002506 mol  ⟹  Molar mass=0.2163 g0.002506 mol=86.31 g/molV(\ce{NaOH}) = 24.45\text{ mL} = 0.02445\text{ L} \implies n(\ce{NaOH}) = 0.02445\text{ L} \times 0.1025\text{ M} = 0.002506\text{ mol} \implies \text{Molar mass} = \frac{0.2163\text{ g}}{0.002506\text{ mol}} = 86.31\text{ g/mol}

    Correct

    ΔV=24.45 mL−0.45 mL=24.00 mL=0.02400 L  ⟹  n=(0.1025 M)(0.02400 L)=2.460×10−3 mol  ⟹  Molar mass=0.2163 g2.460×10−3 mol=87.93 g/mol\Delta V = 24.45\text{ mL} - 0.45\text{ mL} = 24.00\text{ mL} = 0.02400\text{ L} \implies n = (0.1025\text{ M})(0.02400\text{ L}) = 2.460 \times 10^{-3}\text{ mol} \implies \text{Molar mass} = \frac{0.2163\text{ g}}{2.460 \times 10^{-3}\text{ mol}} = 87.93\text{ g/mol}

    You used the final buret reading directly as the volume of NaOH\ce{NaOH} delivered instead of subtracting the initial buret reading (0.45 mL0.45\text{ mL}). Because the delivered volume is ΔV=Vfinal−Vinitial=24.00 mL\Delta V = V_{\text{final}} - V_{\text{initial}} = 24.00\text{ mL}, your calculated moles of titrant were too high, resulting in an underestimated molar mass.

  2. Step 2

    C:54.5312.011=4.540 mol,H:9.151.008=9.077 mol,O:36.3216.00=2.270 mol  ⟹  Empirical formula=CX2HX4O,Empirical mass=44.05 g/mol  ⟹  86.3144.05≈2  ⟹  Molecular formula=CX4HX8OX2\ce{C}: \frac{54.53}{12.011} = 4.540\text{ mol}, \ce{H}: \frac{9.15}{1.008} = 9.077\text{ mol}, \ce{O}: \frac{36.32}{16.00} = 2.270\text{ mol} \implies \text{Empirical formula} = \ce{C2H4O}, \text{Empirical mass} = 44.05\text{ g/mol} \implies \frac{86.31}{44.05} \approx 2 \implies \text{Molecular formula} = \ce{C4H8O2}

    Correct

    Empirical formula=CX2HX4O  ⟹  n=87.93 g/mol44.05 g/mol≈2  ⟹  Molecular formula=CX4HX8OX2\text{Empirical formula} = \ce{C2H4O} \implies n = \frac{87.93\text{ g/mol}}{44.05\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2 \implies \text{Molecular formula} = \ce{C4H8O2}

    Your empirical formula derivation is completely correct. Although your molar mass ratio inherited the erroneous 86.31 g/mol86.31\text{ g/mol} value from part (a), the resulting ratio still rounded properly to 22, giving the correct molecular formula CX4HX8OX2\ce{C4H8O2}.

  3. Step 3

    No 4-carbon carboxylic acid with formula CX4HX8OX2 can possess a chiral stereocenter because 2-methylpropanoic acid has two identical methyl groups, creating a contradiction.\text{No 4-carbon carboxylic acid with formula } \ce{C4H8O2} \text{ can possess a chiral stereocenter because 2-methylpropanoic acid has two identical methyl groups, creating a contradiction.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You converted combustion percentages to mole quantities and correctly found the empirical formula CX2HX4O\ce{C2H4O}.

You correctly identified 2-methylpropanoic acid as the branched 4-carbon carboxylic acid and explained why it lacks a stereocenter.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Buret Initial Reading Omission

You treated the final buret reading (24.45 mL24.45\text{ mL}) as the total volume dispensed, overlooking the nonzero initial reading (0.45 mL0.45\text{ mL}).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Failing to calculate delivered volume as ΔV=Vfinal−Vinitial\Delta V = V_{\text{final}} - V_{\text{initial}} when performing quantitative volumetric titration calculations.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Titrant Volume Formula
  • Delivered volume is always the difference between final and initial buret readings: ΔV=Vfinal−Vinitial\Delta V = V_{\text{final}} - V_{\text{initial}}.

  • Check whether the buret meniscus started at 0.00 mL0.00\text{ mL} or at a non-zero mark before calculating moles of titrant.

Molar Mass Inverse Relationship
  • M=mn=mC⋅ΔVM = \frac{m}{n} = \frac{m}{C \cdot \Delta V}

  • Remember that an overestimation of titrant volume leads to an overestimated mole count, which inversely causes an underestimation of molar mass.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Subtract the initial buret reading: ΔV=24.45 mL−0.45 mL=24.00 mL=0.02400 L\Delta V = 24.45\text{ mL} - 0.45\text{ mL} = 24.00\text{ mL} = 0.02400\text{ L}.

  2. Calculate moles of base at equivalence: n=(0.1025 mol/L)(0.02400 L)=2.460×10−3 moln = (0.1025\text{ mol/L})(0.02400\text{ L}) = 2.460 \times 10^{-3}\text{ mol}.

  3. Determine the experimental molar mass: M=0.2163 g2.460×10−3 mol=87.93 g/molM = \frac{0.2163\text{ g}}{2.460 \times 10^{-3}\text{ mol}} = 87.93\text{ g/mol}.

Final answer

(a) 87.93 g/mol87.93\text{ g/mol}; (b) CX4HX8OX2\ce{C4H8O2}; (c) 2-Methylpropanoic acid (no 4-carbon carboxylic acid possesses a chiral stereocenter).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write down ΔV=Vfinal−Vinitial\Delta V = V_{\text{final}} - V_{\text{initial}} explicitly before plugging volume into n=M⋅Vn = M \cdot V.

  • Perform a sanity check on experimental molar masses by comparing them directly to the theoretical molecular mass of your deduced formula (Mtheoretical(CX4HX8OX2)=88.11 g/molM_{\text{theoretical}}(\ce{C4H8O2}) = 88.11\text{ g/mol}).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student rounds the empirical mole ratios prematurely to integers before dividing by the smallest value, arriving at an incorrect empirical formula.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    V(NaOH)=24.45 mL−0.45 mL=24.00 mL=0.02400 L  ⟹  n(NaOH)=0.02400 L×0.1025 M=0.002460 mol  ⟹  Molar mass=0.2163 g/0.002460 mol=87.93 g/molV(\ce{NaOH}) = 24.45\text{ mL} - 0.45\text{ mL} = 24.00\text{ mL} = 0.02400\text{ L} \implies n(\ce{NaOH}) = 0.02400\text{ L} \times 0.1025\text{ M} = 0.002460\text{ mol} \implies \text{Molar mass} = 0.2163\text{ g} / 0.002460\text{ mol} = 87.93\text{ g/mol}

  2. Step 2

    C:54.53/12.011=4.540 mol≈5 mol  ⟹  H:9.15/1.008=9.077 mol≈9 mol  ⟹  O:36.32/16.00=2.270 mol≈2 mol  ⟹  Empirical formula=CX5HX9OX2\ce{C}: 54.53 / 12.011 = 4.540\text{ mol} \approx 5\text{ mol} \implies \ce{H}: 9.15 / 1.008 = 9.077\text{ mol} \approx 9\text{ mol} \implies \ce{O}: 36.32 / 16.00 = 2.270\text{ mol} \approx 2\text{ mol} \implies \text{Empirical formula} = \ce{C5H9O2}

    Correct

    C:4.540 mol2.270 mol=2.00,H:9.077 mol2.270 mol≈4.00,O:2.270 mol2.270 mol=1.00  ⟹  Empirical formula=CX2HX4O\ce{C}: \frac{4.540\text{ mol}}{2.270\text{ mol}} = 2.00, \quad \ce{H}: \frac{9.077\text{ mol}}{2.270\text{ mol}} \approx 4.00, \quad \ce{O}: \frac{2.270\text{ mol}}{2.270\text{ mol}} = 1.00 \implies \text{Empirical formula} = \ce{C2H4O}

    You calculated the moles of each element correctly from mass percentages, but you rounded those absolute mole values to the nearest integer instead of dividing each by the smallest mole value (2.270 mol2.270\text{ mol}) to establish the simplest whole-number ratio.

  3. Step 3

    Empirical mass=101.1 g/mol  ⟹  Molecular formula=CX5HX9OX2\text{Empirical mass} = 101.1\text{ g/mol} \implies \text{Molecular formula} = \ce{C5H9O2}

    Correct

    n=87.93 g/mol44.05 g/mol≈2  ⟹  Molecular formula=(CX2HX4O)2=CX4HX8OX2n = \frac{87.93\text{ g/mol}}{44.05\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2 \implies \text{Molecular formula} = (\ce{C2H4O})_2 = \ce{C4H8O2}

    Because the empirical formula was incorrectly identified as CX5HX9OX2\ce{C5H9O2}, the resulting formula mass of 101.1 g/mol101.1\text{ g/mol} exceeded the experimentally determined molar mass of 87.93 g/mol87.93\text{ g/mol}, leading to an incorrect molecular formula.

  4. Step 4

    No 4-carbon carboxylic acid with formula CX4HX8OX2 can possess a chiral stereocenter because 2-methylpropanoic acid has two identical methyl groups, creating a contradiction.\text{No 4-carbon carboxylic acid with formula } \ce{C4H8O2} \text{ can possess a chiral stereocenter because 2-methylpropanoic acid has two identical methyl groups, creating a contradiction.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You calculated the molar mass from the titration data with high accuracy and appropriate significant figures.

You converted elemental mass percentages into elemental moles correctly.

You recognized that 2-methylpropanoic acid has two identical methyl groups bonded to C2, rendering it achiral.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Premature rounding of empirical mole ratios

You rounded intermediate molar values (4.5404.540, 9.0779.077, 2.2702.270) directly to whole integers rather than dividing each mole value by the smallest calculated mole value.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the absolute number of moles in a hypothetical 100 g100\text{ g} sample with the relative stoichiometric subscript ratio in a chemical formula.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Empirical Ratio Step
  • An empirical formula represents relative ratios, not absolute mole values.

  • Always divide every element's mole amount by the smallest mole value among them before attempting any rounding.

Molar Mass Consistency Check
  • The empirical formula mass must always be less than or equal to the experimental molar mass.

  • Check that Molar mass≥Empirical mass\text{Molar mass} \ge \text{Empirical mass}; if the empirical mass exceeds the experimental molar mass (101.1>87.93101.1 > 87.93), re-evaluate the mole ratios immediately.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Divide each mole quantity by nO=2.270 moln_{\ce{O}} = 2.270\text{ mol}:

  2. C:4.5402.270=2.00\ce{C}: \frac{4.540}{2.270} = 2.00

  3. H:9.0772.270=4.00\ce{H}: \frac{9.077}{2.270} = 4.00

  4. O:2.2702.270=1.00\ce{O}: \frac{2.270}{2.270} = 1.00

  5. The empirical formula is CX2HX4O\ce{C2H4O}, with empirical mass 2(12.011)+4(1.008)+16.00=44.05 g/mol2(12.011) + 4(1.008) + 16.00 = 44.05\text{ g/mol}.

  6. Compute the integer multiple: n=87.93 g/mol44.05 g/mol≈2n = \frac{87.93\text{ g/mol}}{44.05\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2.

  7. Multiply the subscripts by 22 to obtain the molecular formula: (CX2HX4O)2=CX4HX8OX2(\ce{C2H4O})_2 = \ce{C4H8O2}.

Final answer

(a) 87.93 g/mol87.93\text{ g/mol}; (b) CX4HX8OX2\ce{C4H8O2}; (c) 2-methylpropanoic acid

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the empirical formula workflow: Percent to Mass →\to Mass to Mole →\to Divide by Smallest →\to Multiply until Whole.

  • Compare the empirical formula mass against the titration-derived molar mass to verify that the scaling factor nn is an integer ≥1\ge 1.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A student titrates a 0.1500 g0.1500\text{ g} sample of an unknown monoprotic acid with 0.1000 M NaOH0.1000\text{ M } \ce{NaOH}. The initial buret volume is 1.50 mL1.50\text{ mL} and the final buret reading is 26.50 mL26.50\text{ mL}. Calculate the experimental molar mass of the acid to four significant figures.

Answer

60.00 g/mol60.00\text{ g/mol}. Key steps: ΔV=26.50 mL−1.50 mL=25.00 mL=0.02500 L\Delta V = 26.50\text{ mL} - 1.50\text{ mL} = 25.00\text{ mL} = 0.02500\text{ L}; n=(0.1000 M)(0.02500 L)=2.500×10−3 moln = (0.1000\text{ M})(0.02500\text{ L}) = 2.500 \times 10^{-3}\text{ mol}; M=0.1500 g2.500×10−3 mol=60.00 g/molM = \frac{0.1500\text{ g}}{2.500 \times 10^{-3}\text{ mol}} = 60.00\text{ g/mol}.

02

An unknown monoprotic carboxylic acid is analyzed. Titration of 0.2554 g0.2554\text{ g} requires 24.50 mL24.50\text{ mL} of 0.1250 M KOH0.1250\text{ M } \ce{KOH} after starting at an initial buret reading of 0.50 mL0.50\text{ mL}. Combustion analysis gives 58.80% C58.80\%\text{ C}, 9.87% H9.87\%\text{ H}, and 31.33% O31.33\%\text{ O} by mass. Determine its empirical formula and molecular formula.

Answer

Empirical formula: CX5HX10OX2\ce{C5H10O2}; Molecular formula: CX5HX10OX2\ce{C5H10O2}. Key steps: ΔV=24.50−0.50=24.00 mL=0.02400 L\Delta V = 24.50 - 0.50 = 24.00\text{ mL} = 0.02400\text{ L}; n=(0.1250)(0.02400)=3.000×10−3 moln = (0.1250)(0.02400) = 3.000 \times 10^{-3}\text{ mol}; experimental molar mass M=0.2554 g0.003000 mol=85.13 g/molM = \frac{0.2554\text{ g}}{0.003000\text{ mol}} = 85.13\text{ g/mol} (or for CX5HX10OX2\ce{C5H10O2}, theoretical 102.13 g/mol102.13\text{ g/mol}). Ratios from combustion: C:4.896 mol\ce{C}: 4.896\text{ mol}, H:9.792 mol\ce{H}: 9.792\text{ mol}, O:1.958 mol\ce{O}: 1.958\text{ mol}, giving molar ratio 2.5:5:12.5 : 5 : 1, so empirical formula is CX5HX10OX2\ce{C5H10O2} (formula mass 102.13 g/mol102.13\text{ g/mol}). With monoprotic titration giving 1 acid group, molecular formula is CX5HX10OX2\ce{C5H10O2}.

03

A branched carboxylic acid with molecular formula CX5HX10OX2\ce{C5H10O2} is optically active (chiral). (a) Draw or describe its carbon skeleton and functional groups. (b) Provide its systematic IUPAC name.

Answer

(a) A four-carbon main chain with a carboxylic acid at C-1 and a methyl branch at C-2: CHX3−CHX2−CH(CHX3)−COOH\ce{CH3-CH2-CH(CH3)-COOH}. Carbon-2 is bonded to four distinct groups: −H-\ce{H}, −CHX3-\ce{CH3}, −CHX2CHX3-\ce{CH2CH3}, and −COOH-\ce{COOH}. (b) 2-Methylbutanoic acid (or (2R)(2R)- / (2S)(2S)-2-methylbutanoic acid).

Loading workspace…