Resources

A common intuitive fallacy suggests that performing a chemical synthesis with 100%100\% atom economy guarantees a low-hazard and zero-waste process. Consider the direct addition synthesis of 1,2-dichloroethane (molar mass 98.96 g/mol98.96\text{ g/mol}) from ethylene (molar mass 28.05 g/mol28.05\text{ g/mol}) and chlorine gas (molar mass 70.91 g/mol70.91\text{ g/mol}): C2H4(g)+Cl2(g)→C2H4Cl2(l)\text{C}_2\text{H}_4(\text{g}) + \text{Cl}_2(\text{g}) \rightarrow \text{C}_2\text{H}_4\text{Cl}_2(\text{l}). Although the reaction has an ideal atom economy of 100.0%100.0\%, the use of pressurized Cl2\text{Cl}_2 introduces high toxicity (OSHA ceiling limit of 1.0 ppm1.0\text{ ppm}). Furthermore, to prevent runaway exothermic polymerization and thermal decomposition, an industrial plant uses 850.0 g850.0\text{ g} of an inert, non-reactive recycled high-boiling solvent per 1.00 mol1.00\text{ mol} of C2H4\text{C}_2\text{H}_4 converted. If the single-pass isolated yield of 1,2-dichloroethane is 91.0%91.0\%, calculate: (a) the theoretical atom economy of the balanced reaction, and (b) the actual Process Mass Intensity (PMI\text{PMI}) for this operation including the process solvent.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Atom Economy=100.0%\text{Atom Economy} = 100.0\%; (b) PMI=10.55\text{PMI} = 10.55

Steps

01

Calculate the Theoretical Atom Economy

Atom economy evaluates the efficiency of a chemical reaction in terms of the atoms incorporated into the desired target molecule from the balanced stoichiometric equation:

Atom Economy=Molar Mass of Desired Product∑Molar Masses of All Reactants×100%\text{Atom Economy} = \frac{\text{Molar Mass of Desired Product}}{\sum \text{Molar Masses of All Reactants}} \times 100\%

For the addition reaction: CX2HX4(g)+ClX2(g)→CX2HX4ClX2(l)\ce{C2H4(g) + Cl2(g) -> C2H4Cl2(l)}

  • Molar mass of desired product (CX2HX4ClX2\ce{C2H4Cl2}): 98.96 g/mol98.96\text{ g/mol}
  • Sum of reactant molar masses (CX2HX4+ClX2\ce{C2H4} + \ce{Cl2}): 28.05 g/mol+70.91 g/mol=98.96 g/mol28.05\text{ g/mol} + 70.91\text{ g/mol} = 98.96\text{ g/mol}

Substituting into the formula: Atom Economy=98.96 g/mol98.96 g/mol×100%=100.0%\text{Atom Economy} = \frac{98.96\text{ g/mol}}{98.96\text{ g/mol}} \times 100\% = 100.0\%

Because this is a direct addition reaction with no stoichiometric co-products, all reactant atoms are theoretically incorporated into the product.


02

Determine Total Input Mass and Actual Product Mass

Consider a basis of 1.00 mol1.00\text{ mol} of CX2HX4\ce{C2H4} converted with an equimolar quantity of ClX2\ce{Cl2}:

  1. Mass of Reactants Fed:

    • Mass of CX2HX4=1.00 mol×28.05 g/mol=28.05 g\ce{C2H4} = 1.00\text{ mol} \times 28.05\text{ g/mol} = 28.05\text{ g}
    • Mass of ClX2=1.00 mol×70.91 g/mol=70.91 g\ce{Cl2} = 1.00\text{ mol} \times 70.91\text{ g/mol} = 70.91\text{ g}
  2. Mass of Process Solvent:

    • Mass of solvent =850.0 g= 850.0\text{ g}
  3. Total Input Mass: Total Input Mass=28.05 g+70.91 g+850.0 g=948.96 g\text{Total Input Mass} = 28.05\text{ g} + 70.91\text{ g} + 850.0\text{ g} = 948.96\text{ g}
  4. Actual Isolated Mass of Desired Product:

    • Theoretical yield for 1.00 mol1.00\text{ mol}: 1.00 mol×98.96 g/mol=98.96 g1.00\text{ mol} \times 98.96\text{ g/mol} = 98.96\text{ g}
    • With a single-pass isolated yield of 91.0%91.0\% (0.9100.910): Isolated Product Mass=0.910×98.96 g≈90.05 g\text{Isolated Product Mass} = 0.910 \times 98.96\text{ g} \approx 90.05\text{ g}

03

Calculate the Process Mass Intensity (PMI\text{PMI})

Process Mass Intensity (PMI\text{PMI}) is defined as the ratio of the total mass of all input materials (reactants, solvents, reagents, and processing aids) to the mass of the final isolated product:

PMI=Total Mass of All InputsMass of Isolated Product\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{Total Mass of All Inputs}}{\text{Mass of Isolated Product}}

Substituting the values: PMI=948.96 g90.05 g≈10.55\text{PMI} = \frac{948.96\text{ g}}{90.05\text{ g}} \approx 10.55


Key Takeaway and Pitfall to Avoid

  • Common Pitfall: Assuming a 100%100\% atom economy implies an environmentally benign or zero-waste process.
  • Reality: Atom economy only considers stoichiometric reaction stoichiometry; it ignores incomplete conversion, chemical hazards (such as toxic, pressurized ClX2\ce{Cl2} gas), reaction exothermicity, and the large quantities of auxiliary solvents and separation media quantified by metrics such as PMI\text{PMI}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student omits the solvent mass from the total input mass when calculating PMI, confusing PMI with the reciprocal of fractional yield.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Atom economy=(98.96/(28.05+70.91))×100%  ⟹  Atom economy=100.0%\text{Atom economy} = (98.96 / (28.05 + 70.91)) \times 100\% \implies \text{Atom economy} = 100.0\%

  2. Step 2

    Basis: 1.00 mol CX2HX4 converted  ⟹  Mass of reactants=28.05 g+70.91 g=98.96 g  ⟹  Actual mass of product=0.910×98.96 g=90.05 g\text{Basis: } 1.00\text{ mol }\ce{C2H4}\text{ converted} \implies \text{Mass of reactants} = 28.05\text{ g} + 70.91\text{ g} = 98.96\text{ g} \implies \text{Actual mass of product} = 0.910 \times 98.96\text{ g} = 90.05\text{ g}

  3. Step 3

    PMI=total mass of inputsmass of product=98.96 g90.05 g  ⟹  PMI=1.10\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{total mass of inputs}}{\text{mass of product}} = \frac{98.96\text{ g}}{90.05\text{ g}} \implies \text{PMI} = 1.10

    Correct

    PMI=Total Mass of All InputsMass of Product=28.05 g+70.91 g+850.0 g90.05 g=948.96 g90.05 g≈10.55\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{Total Mass of All Inputs}}{\text{Mass of Product}} = \frac{28.05\text{ g} + 70.91\text{ g} + 850.0\text{ g}}{90.05\text{ g}} = \frac{948.96\text{ g}}{90.05\text{ g}} \approx 10.55

    You omitted the 850.0 g850.0\text{ g} of process solvent from the total mass of inputs. Process Mass Intensity (PMI) accounts for all materials fed into the process, including auxiliary solvents, reagents, and processing aids, not just stoichiometric reactants.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the balanced stoichiometric equation to find that the addition reaction has an atom economy of 100.0%100.0\%.

You correctly determined the isolated mass of the product based on the 91.0%91.0\% yield.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Auxiliary Solvents in PMI Calculation

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated 'total mass of inputs' as the stoichiometric reactant mass only, confusing PMI with the reciprocal of chemical yield (1yield=10.910≈1.10\frac{1}{\text{yield}} = \frac{1}{0.910} \approx 1.10) and ignoring auxiliary process materials such as solvents.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define Inputs in PMI
  • PMI=∑mraw materials+∑msolvents+∑mwater+∑mreagentsmisolated product\text{PMI} = \frac{\sum m_{\text{raw materials}} + \sum m_{\text{solvents}} + \sum m_{\text{water}} + \sum m_{\text{reagents}}}{m_{\text{isolated product}}}

  • Always add solvents, wash reagents, and process aids to the numerator alongside stoichiometric reactants.

Differentiate Atom Economy from PMI
  • Atom economy is a theoretical stoichiometric parameter that excludes solvents and incomplete conversion; PMI is an empirical metric tracking every gram of material required per gram of isolated product.

  • Check whether the problem specifies solvents or purification aids; if present, they must be included in the PMI input total.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Sum all input masses fed to the process: Total inputs=mCX2HX4+mClX2+msolvent=28.05 g+70.91 g+850.0 g=948.96 g\text{Total inputs} = m_{\ce{C2H4}} + m_{\ce{Cl2}} + m_{\text{solvent}} = 28.05\text{ g} + 70.91\text{ g} + 850.0\text{ g} = 948.96\text{ g}.

  2. Divide by the isolated product mass: PMI=948.96 g90.05 g≈10.54 to 10.55\text{PMI} = \frac{948.96\text{ g}}{90.05\text{ g}} \approx 10.54\text{ to } 10.55.

Final answer

(a) Atom Economy=100.0%\text{Atom Economy} = 100.0\%; (b) PMI=10.55\text{PMI} = 10.55

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Include all non-reactant streams (solvents, catalysts, quench solutions) in the input numerator whenever calculating PMI.

  • Verify your final PMI value: for industrial processes using large solvent volumes, PMI is typically significantly greater than 11.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student divides total input mass by the theoretical yield instead of the actual isolated product mass.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Atom economy=(98.9698.96)×100%=100.0%\text{Atom economy} = \left(\frac{98.96}{98.96}\right) \times 100\% = 100.0\%

  2. Step 2

    Basis: 1.00 mol CX2HX4  ⟹  Total input mass=28.05 g+70.91 g+850.0 g=948.96 g\text{Basis: } 1.00\text{ mol }\ce{C2H4} \implies \text{Total input mass} = 28.05\text{ g} + 70.91\text{ g} + 850.0\text{ g} = 948.96\text{ g}

  3. Step 3

    Theoretical mass of product=98.96 g  ⟹  PMI=total mass of inputstheoretical mass of product=948.96 g98.96 g=9.59\text{Theoretical mass of product} = 98.96\text{ g} \implies \text{PMI} = \frac{\text{total mass of inputs}}{\text{theoretical mass of product}} = \frac{948.96\text{ g}}{98.96\text{ g}} = 9.59

    Correct

    Isolated product mass=0.910×98.96 g=90.05 g  ⟹  PMI=948.96 g90.05 g≈10.55\text{Isolated product mass} = 0.910 \times 98.96\text{ g} = 90.05\text{ g} \implies \text{PMI} = \frac{948.96\text{ g}}{90.05\text{ g}} \approx 10.55

    Process Mass Intensity measures the total mass of inputs needed to produce a unit mass of isolated, real product. Because the yield is 91.0%91.0\%, the actual product mass isolated is 90.05 g90.05\text{ g}, giving PMI=10.55\text{PMI} = 10.55.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the theoretical atom economy as 100.0%100.0\%.

You accurately summed all material inputs, including reactants and the process solvent, to find 948.96 g948.96\text{ g}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Used theoretical yield instead of actual isolated yield in PMI denominator

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating theoretical yield with actual isolated product mass in the Process Mass Intensity (PMI) denominator. PMI is an empirical operational efficiency metric, so its denominator must always be the real, isolated mass of product produced by the process.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Denominator in Process Mass Intensity (PMI)
  • PMI=∑Mass of All Inputs (reagents, solvents, catalysts)Actual Mass of Isolated Product\text{PMI} = \frac{\sum \text{Mass of All Inputs (reagents, solvents, catalysts)}}{\text{Actual Mass of Isolated Product}}

  • Always multiply the theoretical product mass by the isolated reaction yield fraction before dividing.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the actual isolated mass of CX2HX4ClX2\ce{C2H4Cl2}: mproduct=0.910×98.96 g=90.0536 gm_{\text{product}} = 0.910 \times 98.96\text{ g} = 90.0536\text{ g}.

  2. Compute the actual PMI: PMI=948.96 g90.0536 g≈10.55\text{PMI} = \frac{948.96\text{ g}}{90.0536\text{ g}} \approx 10.55.

Final answer

(a) Atom Economy=100.0%\text{Atom Economy} = 100.0\%; (b) PMI=10.55\text{PMI} = 10.55

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • When calculating green chemistry metrics, categorize them into theoretical metrics (such as Atom Economy) versus operational metrics (such as PMI and E-factor).

  • Remember that operational metrics always use the actual isolated product mass in the denominator, never the 100%100\% theoretical yield.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student multiplies by the 91.0% yield in the numerator instead of calculating product mass in the denominator, treating PMI as an efficiency percentage.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Atom economy=98.9628.05+70.91×100%=100.0%\text{Atom economy} = \frac{98.96}{28.05 + 70.91} \times 100\% = 100.0\%

  2. Step 2

    Total input=28.05 g+70.91 g+850.0 g=948.96 g  ⟹  Actual product=98.96 g×0.910=90.05 g\text{Total input} = 28.05\text{ g} + 70.91\text{ g} + 850.0\text{ g} = 948.96\text{ g} \implies \text{Actual product} = 98.96\text{ g} \times 0.910 = 90.05\text{ g}

  3. Step 3

    PMI=(actual producttotal inputs)×100%=(90.05 g948.96 g)×100%\text{PMI} = \left(\frac{\text{actual product}}{\text{total inputs}}\right) \times 100\% = \left(\frac{90.05\text{ g}}{948.96\text{ g}}\right) \times 100\%

    Correct

    PMI=Total Mass of All InputsMass of Isolated Product=948.96 g90.05 g\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{Total Mass of All Inputs}}{\text{Mass of Isolated Product}} = \frac{948.96\text{ g}}{90.05\text{ g}}

    You used the inverted ratio and multiplied by 100%100\%. Process Mass Intensity is defined as the total mass of all inputs divided by the mass of isolated product, and it is expressed as a dimensionless ratio (or kg/kg\text{kg}/\text{kg}), not as a percentage.

  4. Step 4

    PMI=9.49%\text{PMI} = 9.49\%

    Correct

    PMI=10.55\text{PMI} = 10.55

    This result follows directly from your inverted formula. Dividing 948.96 g948.96\text{ g} by 90.05 g90.05\text{ g} gives a PMI of 10.5510.55.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the atom economy using the balanced stoichiometry.

You accurately summed the total input mass, including the process solvent.

You correctly calculated the isolated product mass using the given reaction yield.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted PMI Formula

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated Process Mass Intensity (PMI) with a fractional efficiency metric (such as Mass Productivity, which is 1/PMI×100%1/\text{PMI} \times 100\%). PMI measures how many mass units of raw materials are consumed per unit mass of final product, so total inputs must be in the numerator.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Defining Process Mass Intensity
  • PMI=∑(mass of all inputs including solvents, reagents, aids)mass of isolated product\text{PMI} = \frac{\sum (\text{mass of all inputs including solvents, reagents, aids})}{\text{mass of isolated product}}

  • Always place the total input mass in the numerator and the desired isolated product mass in the denominator. A sustainable process has a PMI close to 1.01.0.

Distinguishing PMI from Mass Productivity
  • Mass Productivity (MP)=1PMI×100%=mass of producttotal mass of inputs×100%\text{Mass Productivity (MP)} = \frac{1}{\text{PMI}} \times 100\% = \frac{\text{mass of product}}{\text{total mass of inputs}} \times 100\%

  • Check the units and scale: PMI is a ratio greater than or equal to 1.01.0 and is not expressed as a percentage.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the standard PMI definition: PMI=Total Mass of All InputsMass of Isolated Product\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{Total Mass of All Inputs}}{\text{Mass of Isolated Product}}.

  2. Substitute the previously determined masses: PMI=948.96 g90.05 g\text{PMI} = \frac{948.96\text{ g}}{90.05\text{ g}}.

  3. Evaluate the quotient: 948.9690.05≈10.548...≈10.55\frac{948.96}{90.05} \approx 10.548... \approx 10.55.

Final answer

(a) Atom Economy=100.0%\text{Atom Economy} = 100.0\%; (b) PMI=10.55\text{PMI} = 10.55

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the definitions of the ACS Green Chemistry Institute metrics, specifically distinguishing PMI from Mass Productivity and E-factor.

  • Remember that the ideal baseline value for PMI is 1.01.0 (when 100%100\% of all inputs end up in the isolated product with no solvent or waste), which helps you recall that total inputs must be in the numerator.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A hydrogenation reaction converts 50.0 g50.0\text{ g} of substrate using 1.2 g1.2\text{ g} of HX2\ce{H2} gas and 200.0 g200.0\text{ g} of methanol solvent. If 46.0 g46.0\text{ g} of purified product is isolated, calculate the Process Mass Intensity (PMI).

Answer

PMI=5.46\text{PMI} = 5.46. Key steps: Total inputs =50.0 g+1.2 g+200.0 g=251.2 g= 50.0\text{ g} + 1.2\text{ g} + 200.0\text{ g} = 251.2\text{ g}. Product mass =46.0 g= 46.0\text{ g}. PMI=251.2 g46.0 g≈5.46\text{PMI} = \frac{251.2\text{ g}}{46.0\text{ g}} \approx 5.46.

02

An esterification uses 60.0 g60.0\text{ g} of acetic acid and 46.0 g46.0\text{ g} of ethanol with 2.0 g2.0\text{ g} of concentrated HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4} catalyst and 150.0 g150.0\text{ g} of toluene as solvent. The isolated yield of ethyl acetate is 70.4 g70.4\text{ g} (80.0%80.0\% of theoretical). Calculate (a) the theoretical atom economy and (b) the PMI.

Answer

(a) Atom Economy=83.0%\text{Atom Economy} = 83.0\%; (b) PMI=3.67\text{PMI} = 3.67. Key steps: (a) CHX3COOH+CX2HX5OH→CHX3COOCX2HX5+HX2O\ce{CH3COOH} + \ce{C2H5OH} \rightarrow \ce{CH3COOC2H5} + \ce{H2O}; AE=88.1160.05+46.07×100%≈83.0%\text{AE} = \frac{88.11}{60.05 + 46.07} \times 100\% \approx 83.0\%. (b) Total inputs =60.0+46.0+2.0+150.0=258.0 g= 60.0 + 46.0 + 2.0 + 150.0 = 258.0\text{ g}. PMI=258.0 g70.4 g≈3.67\text{PMI} = \frac{258.0\text{ g}}{70.4\text{ g}} \approx 3.67.

03

A chemist attempts to lower the PMI of a batch reaction. In Batch A, 100 kg100\text{ kg} of inputs (including 80 kg80\text{ kg} solvent) produces 10 kg10\text{ kg} of product. In Batch B, the solvent is reduced by 50%50\% while reactant mass remains 20 kg20\text{ kg}, but the isolated yield drops slightly to 8.5 kg8.5\text{ kg}. Did the PMI improve? Justify with calculations.

Answer

Yes, PMI improved from 10.010.0 to 7.17.1. Key steps: Batch A PMI=100 kg10 kg=10.0\text{PMI} = \frac{100\text{ kg}}{10\text{ kg}} = 10.0. Batch B inputs =20 kg+40 kg=60 kg= 20\text{ kg} + 40\text{ kg} = 60\text{ kg}; Batch B PMI=60 kg8.5 kg≈7.06\text{PMI} = \frac{60\text{ kg}}{8.5\text{ kg}} \approx 7.06. Despite the lower yield, the major solvent reduction significantly reduced overall process mass intensity.

Loading workspace…