Resources
In the industrial synthesis of sodium hydride, molten sodium reacts with hydrogen gas: . Subsequently, sodium hydride reacts violently with water: . For each reaction: (a) Assign the oxidation state of hydrogen in , , and . (b) Identify whether acts as an oxidizing agent or reducing agent in the first reaction. (c) Identify which specific species is oxidized and which is reduced in the second reaction, and state the reducing agent.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) In , ; in , (hydride ion); in , . (b) In the first reaction, is reduced from to , so acts as the oxidizing agent. (c) In the second reaction, the hydride ion in is oxidized from to (in ), while the proton in is reduced from to (in ); the reducing agent is .
Steps
Part (a): Determine Oxidation States of Hydrogen
To assign the oxidation state () of hydrogen across different compounds, apply standard oxidation state rules:
-
Free Element Rule: An atom in its elemental, uncombined form has an oxidation state of .
- In elemental hydrogen gas, :
-
Metal Hydrides Rule: Group 1 alkali metals always take an oxidation state of in compounds. In binary ionic hydrides with metals, hydrogen forms the hydride ion ().
- In sodium hydride, :
-
Covalent Compounds with Nonmetals Rule: Hydrogen bonded to more electronegative nonmetals (such as oxygen) carries an oxidation state of .
- In water, :
Part (b): Role of in the First Reaction
Consider the reaction:
- Sodium goes from an oxidation state of in to in (an increase in oxidation number, which represents oxidation).
- Hydrogen goes from an oxidation state of in to in (a decrease in oxidation number, which represents reduction).
By definition, a substance that undergoes reduction causes another substance to be oxidized and acts as an oxidizing agent. Therefore, is the oxidizing agent.
Common Pitfall: Students frequently assume hydrogen always acts as a reducing agent or has an oxidation number of . When reacting with highly electropositive active metals (like alkali metals), hydrogen gains electrons and functions as an oxidizing agent.
Part (c): Redox Changes and Reducing Agent in the Second Reaction
Consider the reaction:
Track the oxidation states of each atom from reactants to products:
- Sodium (): in in (unchanged spectator ion).
- Oxygen (): in in (unchanged).
- Hydride ion ( in ): goes from in to in (an increase in oxidation state oxidized).
- Hydrogen in water ( in ): goes from in to in (a decrease in oxidation state reduced).
- Species oxidized: Hydride ion () in .
- Species reduced: Hydrogen () in .
- Reducing agent: The substance that provides the electrons and contains the oxidized atom is .
Typical errors
01 A student rigidly applies the general rule that hydrogen always has an oxidation state of +1 in compounds, failing to recognize that it forms a hydride with an oxidation state of -1 in metal hydrides.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
; ;
You correctly assigned to elemental and to in water. However, sodium is an alkali metal (Group 1) and always has an oxidation state of in compounds. To balance the neutral charge of , hydrogen must be (the hydride ion, ).
- Step 2Correct
In , decreases from to (reduction), so is the oxidizing agent.
Your logic connecting oxidation to acting as a reducing agent was logically consistent, but it relied on your incorrect assignment for in . Because hydrogen actually gains an electron to go from to , it is reduced and functions as the oxidizing agent.
- Step 3Correct
in is oxidized from to (in ), while in is reduced from to (in ); the reducing agent is .
Because in is actually , it increases in oxidation state from to in , representing oxidation. Simultaneously, in decreases from to , representing reduction. This makes the reaction a redox (comproportionation) reaction where acts as the reducing agent.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that elemental hydrogen in has an oxidation state of .
You correctly determined that hydrogen bonded to oxygen in has an oxidation state of .
You correctly applied the definition that a species undergoing oxidation acts as a reducing agent.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou rigidly applied the general rule that hydrogen has an oxidation number of in compounds, missing the crucial exception for binary metal hydrides where highly electropositive active metals force hydrogen to act as an anion (hydride, with an oxidation state of ).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Priority of Group 1 and 2 Metals
In compounds, Group 1 alkali metals always take an oxidation state of and Group 2 alkaline earth metals take . Their rules take precedence over nonmetals.
Assign the metal's oxidation state first, then deduce hydrogen's oxidation state from overall electrical neutrality.
- Recognizing Binary Hydrides
When hydrogen is directly bonded only to a metal (e.g., , , ), it exists as the hydride ion with an oxidation state of .
Check if hydrogen is bonded to a metal; if so, assign hydrogen rather than .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationAssign as in , which forces to be .
In reaction 1 (), changes from to (reduction); therefore, is the oxidizing agent.
In reaction 2 (), from goes from to (oxidation), while from goes from to (reduction).
Identify in as oxidized, in as reduced, and as the reducing agent.
(a) ; ; . (b) is the oxidizing agent. (c) Oxidized: in ; Reduced: in ; Reducing agent: .
02 A student confuses the definitions of oxidizing and reducing agents, identifying the reduced species as the reducing agent.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
is reduced, so it acts as the oxidizing agent.
An agent causes a process in another substance: a substance that is reduced gains electrons from something else, causing that other substance to be oxidized. Therefore, the reduced species is the oxidizing agent, not the reducing agent.
- Step 4
- Step 5Correct
The substance that is oxidized is , so is the reducing agent.
Because is oxidized (losing electrons to water), provides electrons and acts as the reducing agent.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly assigned the oxidation states of hydrogen in all three species.
You correctly identified that is reduced in the first reaction.
You accurately identified the species oxidized () and reduced () in the second reaction.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo, this is a conceptual misunderstanding of the definition of redox agents rather than an arithmetic or transcription slip.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou equated 'being reduced' with being the 'reducing agent' (and 'being oxidized' with being the 'oxidizing agent'). An agent is defined by the effect it exerts on the other reactant: the substance that is reduced gains electrons and oxidizes the other reactant (making it the oxidizing agent), while the substance that is oxidized loses electrons and reduces the other reactant (making it the reducing agent).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Connecting Redox Process to Agent Role
A reducing agent loses electrons and is itself oxidized; an oxidizing agent gains electrons and is itself reduced.
Always ask yourself: 'What is this substance doing to the partner reactant?' If a substance gains electrons (reduced), it took them from its partner, thereby acting as an oxidizing agent.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIn reaction 1, is reduced from to by accepting electrons from . Because it causes to be oxidized, is the oxidizing agent.
In reaction 2, contains hydride () which is oxidized from to . Because it donates electrons to reduce , is the reducing agent.
(a) in , in , and in . (b) is the oxidizing agent. (c) In the second reaction, in is oxidized, in is reduced, and is the reducing agent.
03 A student assumes hydrogen gas in redox reactions always acts as a reducing agent regardless of its oxidation state change.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
_2\text{ gains electrons from sodium to form }$$\text{NaH}. \text{Therefore, }$$\text{H}2
Correct_2(g)0-1\text{, so }$$\text{H}2(g)$$
You rightly recognized that gains electrons from sodium. However, gaining electrons means is reduced, which by definition makes it the oxidizing agent, not the reducing agent. Always follow electron transfer and oxidation state changes rather than general tendencies.
- Step 3
\text{In }$$\text{NaH} + _2 + _2, \text{H in }$$\text{NaH}$$\text{ changes from }-10, \text{so }$$\text{NaH}$$\text{ is oxidized.} \text{H in }$$\text{H}_2\text{O}$$\text{ changes from }+10, \text{so }$$\text{H}_2\text{O}$$\text{ is reduced.} \text{The reducing agent is }$$\text{NaH}.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly assigned the oxidation state of hydrogen in all three species.
You correctly observed that gains electrons from sodium in the synthesis of .
You correctly identified the oxidized species, reduced species, and reducing agent in the reaction of with water.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou noticed that gains electrons, but defaulted to its common role as a reducing agent instead of applying the core definition.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisOver-relying on the common generalization that hydrogen gas is always a reducing agent, which caused you to invert the fundamental relationship: a species that is reduced (gains electrons) acts as an oxidizing agent.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Define Agents by Electron Flow
Oxidizing agent = electron acceptor (undergoes reduction, oxidation number decreases). Reducing agent = electron donor (undergoes oxidation, oxidation number increases).
Whenever you determine whether a reactant is an oxidizing or reducing agent, always base your conclusion on whether that specific reactant gains or loses electrons in the given equation.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIn , the oxidation state of hydrogen decreases from in to in .
Because gains electrons and undergoes reduction, it causes sodium to be oxidized.
Therefore, is the oxidizing agent in this reaction.
2(g)
Lock it in
What is the oxidation state of hydrogen when bonded to active metals (such as in or )?
. In binary ionic metal hydrides, hydrogen gains an electron from the metal to form the hydride ion ().
Similar question
Determine the oxidation state of hydrogen in each of the following species: (a) , (b) , and (c) .
Answer
(a) : Lithium is a Group 1 metal (), making a hydride ion (). (b) : Carbon is more electronegative than hydrogen, so is and is . (c) : In peroxides, oxygen is and hydrogen remains .
Calcium hydride reacts with water according to: . Identify the oxidizing agent and the reducing agent in this reaction.
Answer
Reducing agent: (the hydride is oxidized from to in ). Oxidizing agent: (hydrogen is reduced from to in ).
Consider the reaction: , followed by . For each reaction, state whether is being formed by oxidation, reduction, or both, specifying the initial and final oxidation states of hydrogen.
Answer
In the first reaction, is consumed (reduced from to ). In the second reaction, is formed by both oxidation and reduction (comproportionation): in is oxidized from to , and in is reduced from to .