Resources

Boron exhibits an average atomic mass of 10.811 amu10.811\text{ amu} and consists of two stable isotopes: 10B^{10}\text{B} (10.013 amu10.013\text{ amu}) and 11B^{11}\text{B} (11.009 amu11.009\text{ amu}). A student reasons intuitively that because the atomic mass is numerically closer to 1111 than 1010, the isotope 11B^{11}\text{B} must be more abundant, but assumes an exact 3:13:1 integer abundance ratio. Calculate the true percent abundance of 10B^{10}\text{B} and explain whether the intuitive 3:13:1 assumption underestimates or overestimates the actual abundance of 10B^{10}\text{B}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

True abundance of 10B=19.88%^{10}\text{B} = 19.88\%; The 3:13:1 assumption assigns 10B^{10}\text{B} an abundance of 25.00%25.00\%, which overestimates the actual abundance.

Steps

01

Set up the weighted average equation

The average atomic mass of an element is the weighted average of the atomic masses of its naturally occurring isotopes.

Let xx represent the fractional abundance of X10X2210B\ce{^{10}B}. Since the sum of fractional abundances of all isotopes equals 11, the fractional abundance of X11X2211B\ce{^{11}B} is 1−x1 - x.

Using the given isotopic masses and average atomic mass: Average atomic mass=x⋅(mass of X10X2210B)+(1−x)⋅(mass of X11X2211B)\text{Average atomic mass} = x \cdot (\text{mass of }\ce{^{10}B}) + (1 - x) \cdot (\text{mass of }\ce{^{11}B})

Substitute the values: 10.811=x(10.013)+(1−x)(11.009)10.811 = x(10.013) + (1 - x)(11.009)

02

Solve for the abundance of X10X2210B\ce{^{10}B}

Expand and group like terms: 10.811=10.013x+11.009−11.009x10.811 = 10.013x + 11.009 - 11.009x 10.811−11.009=(10.013−11.009)x10.811 - 11.009 = (10.013 - 11.009)x −0.198=−0.996x-0.198 = -0.996x

Isolate xx: x=−0.198−0.996≈0.198795x = \frac{-0.198}{-0.996} \approx 0.198795

Convert the fractional abundance to a percentage: Percent abundance of X10X2210B=0.198795×100%≈19.88%\text{Percent abundance of }\ce{^{10}B} = 0.198795 \times 100\% \approx 19.88\%

03

Evaluate the intuitive 3:13:1 assumption

An assumed ratio of 3:13:1 for X11X2211B\ce{^{11}B} to X10X2210B\ce{^{10}B} implies: Assumed abundance of X10X2210B=13+1=14=0.2500 or 25.00%\text{Assumed abundance of }\ce{^{10}B} = \frac{1}{3 + 1} = \frac{1}{4} = 0.2500\text{ or }25.00\%

Comparing the assumed value to the true calculated value: 25.00%>19.88%25.00\% > 19.88\%

Therefore, the intuitive 3:13:1 assumption overestimates the actual abundance of X10X2210B\ce{^{10}B}.

Common Pitfall: Assuming isotopic masses are simple integers (1010 and 1111) when estimating abundances can introduce noticeable error. While 10.810.8 is roughly 80%80\% of the way from 1010 to 1111 (yielding a 4:14:1 ratio, or 20%20\%), imprecise rounding to a 3:13:1 ratio (25%25\%) misjudges the weighting. Always use the full decimal masses when calculating precise abundances.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misinterprets the 3:1 ratio of 11B to 10B as 1/3 (33.3%) instead of 1/4 (25%), incorrectly calculating the assumed abundance while still concluding it overestimates.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    10.013x+11.009(1−x)=10.811  ⟹  10.013x+11.009−11.009x=10.811  ⟹  −0.996x=−0.198  ⟹  x=0.1988  ⟹  Abundance of 10B=19.88%10.013x + 11.009(1-x) = 10.811 \implies 10.013x + 11.009 - 11.009x = 10.811 \implies -0.996x = -0.198 \implies x = 0.1988 \implies \text{Abundance of }^{10}\text{B} = 19.88\%

  2. Step 2

    For a 3:1 ratio, the abundance of 10B is 13=33.33%.\text{For a 3:1 ratio, the abundance of }^{10}\text{B}\text{ is }\frac{1}{3} = 33.33\%.

    Correct

    For a 3:1 ratio of 11B to 10B, the abundance of 10B is 13+1=14=25.00%.\text{For a 3:1 ratio of }^{11}\text{B}\text{ to }^{10}\text{B}\text{, the abundance of }^{10}\text{B}\text{ is }\frac{1}{3+1} = \frac{1}{4} = 25.00\%.

    A 3:13:1 ratio represents 33 parts of 11B^{11}\text{B} for every 11 part of 10B^{10}\text{B}, giving a total of 3+1=43 + 1 = 4 parts. Therefore, the assumed fraction of 10B^{10}\text{B} is 14\frac{1}{4} (25.00%25.00\%), not 13\frac{1}{3}.

  3. Step 3

    Since 33.33% is greater than 19.88%, the assumption overestimates the actual abundance of 10B.\text{Since }33.33\%\text{ is greater than }19.88\%,\text{ the assumption overestimates the actual abundance of }^{10}\text{B}.

    Correct

    Since 25.00%>19.88%, the assumption overestimates the actual abundance of 10B.\text{Since }25.00\% > 19.88\%,\text{ the assumption overestimates the actual abundance of }^{10}\text{B}.

    Your comparison logic was correct, but it relied on the incorrectly calculated value of 33.33%33.33\% rather than the correct assumed value of 25.00%25.00\%.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly set up the linear equation for the weighted average atomic mass using fractional abundances xx and 1−x1 - x.

You executed the algebraic steps cleanly and found the exact true abundance of 10B^{10}\text{B} to be 19.88%19.88\%.

You correctly compared your assumed percentage with the true abundance to deduce the direction of the error.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Ratio-to-Fraction Conversion Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated a part-to-part ratio of a:ba:b as a fraction of the total ba\frac{b}{a} rather than ba+b\frac{b}{a+b}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Converting Part-to-Part Ratio to Part-to-Whole Fraction
  • In an A:BA:B ratio, the total number of equal parts is A+BA + B. The fraction represented by BB is BA+B\frac{B}{A + B}.

  • Always add the two terms of the ratio together to find the denominator for the total mixture before converting to a percentage.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. A ratio of 3:13:1 between 11B^{11}\text{B} and 10B^{10}\text{B} means there are 33 parts 11B^{11}\text{B} and 11 part 10B^{10}\text{B}, giving a total of 3+1=43 + 1 = 4 parts.

  2. Calculate the assumed fraction of 10B^{10}\text{B}: 13+1=14=0.2500=25.00%\frac{1}{3 + 1} = \frac{1}{4} = 0.2500 = 25.00\%.

  3. Compare the assumed value to the true abundance: 25.00%>19.88%25.00\% > 19.88\%, so the assumption overestimates the actual abundance of 10B^{10}\text{B}.

Final answer

True abundance of 10B=19.88%^{10}\text{B} = 19.88\%; The 3:13:1 assumption corresponds to 25.00%25.00\%, which overestimates the actual abundance.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how to convert part-to-part ratios into part-to-whole fractions by summing the ratio components.

  • Practice converting various ratios (such as 3:13:1, 4:14:1, and 2:32:3) into percentages of the whole mixture.

  • Always perform a quick sanity check: make sure the sum of all isotopic fractional abundances equals 100%100\%.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student rounds the isotopic masses to whole integers (10 and 11) in the weighted average formula, arriving at an inaccurate abundance of 18.9% for 10B.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    10x + 11(1 - x) = 10.811

    Correct

    10.013x + 11.009(1 - x) = 10.811

    You substituted the integer mass numbers 1010 and 1111 instead of the precise isotopic masses 10.013 amu10.013\text{ amu} and 11.009 amu11.009\text{ amu}.

  2. Step 2

    10x + 11 - 11x = 10.811   ⟹  \implies -x = -0.189   ⟹  \implies x = 0.189   ⟹  \implies Abundance of \text{Abundance of }^{10}B\text{B} = 18.9%

    Correct

    10.013x + 11.009 - 11.009x = 10.811   ⟹  \implies -0.996x = -0.198   ⟹  \implies x ≈\approx 0.1988   ⟹  \implies Abundance of \text{Abundance of }^{10}B\text{B} = 19.88%

    Your algebraic steps were correct for the equation you wrote, but using integer masses propagated an error into your calculated percentage (18.9%18.9\% instead of 19.88%19.88\%).

  3. Step 3

    A \text{A } 3:1  ratio means \text{ ratio means }^{10}B\text{B}  is \text{ is } 1/(3+1) = 25%.  Since \text{ Since } 25% > 18.9%,  the intuitive assumption overestimates the actual abundance of \text{ the intuitive assumption overestimates the actual abundance of }^{10}B\text{B}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly established the weighted average relationship using xx and 1−x1-x.

You solved your linear equation without algebraic errors.

You correctly interpreted the 3:13:1 ratio as a 25%25\% fractional abundance and drew the correct qualitative comparison.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Premature rounding or using mass numbers instead of precise isotopic masses

No, this was a conceptual decision to replace exact isotopic masses with whole-number mass numbers.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the mass number AA (an integer count of nucleons) with the actual isotopic mass (a non-integer mass in amu due to nuclear binding energy and subatomic mass differences). In weighted average calculations, you must always retain the full measured isotopic masses to prevent substantial rounding errors in fractional abundances.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Mass Number vs. Isotopic Mass
  • The mass number AA is an integer (1010), whereas the isotopic mass is an experimentally measured value (10.013 amu10.013\text{ amu}).

  • Always look for given decimal isotopic masses in the prompt and plug them into the equation exactly as stated.

Abundance Sensitivity
  • Because isotopic masses differ by small amounts, even minor rounding in mass inputs produces noticeable deviations in calculated abundances.

  • Keep all given significant figures for isotopic masses throughout the algebraic solution.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Expand the terms: 10.013x+11.009−11.009x=10.81110.013x + 11.009 - 11.009x = 10.811

  2. Combine like terms: −0.996x=10.811−11.009=−0.198-0.996x = 10.811 - 11.009 = -0.198

  3. Solve for xx: x=−0.198−0.996≈0.1988x = \frac{-0.198}{-0.996} \approx 0.1988

  4. Convert to percentage: 0.1988×100%=19.88%0.1988 \times 100\% = 19.88\%

Final answer

The true percent abundance of 10B^{10}\text{B} is 19.88%19.88\%. The 3:13:1 assumption yields 25.00%25.00\%, which overestimates the actual abundance.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Re-solve the boron problem using the exact values 10.013 amu10.013\text{ amu} and 11.009 amu11.009\text{ amu} to verify the difference between 18.9%18.9\% and 19.88%19.88\%.

  • Practice identifying when a prompt provides exact isotopic masses versus when an approximation using mass numbers is acceptable.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student associates the ratio 3:1 with 10B being 3 parts instead of 1 part, calculating 75% for 10B and reaching an erroneously high assumed value.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    10.013x+11.009(1−x)=10.811  ⟹  11.009−0.996x=10.811  ⟹  0.996x=0.198  ⟹  x=0.1988  ⟹  Abundance of 10B=19.88%10.013x + 11.009(1-x) = 10.811 \implies 11.009 - 0.996x = 10.811 \implies 0.996x = 0.198 \implies x = 0.1988 \implies \text{Abundance of }^{10}\text{B} = 19.88\%

  2. Step 2

    Assuming a 3:13:1 ratio gives an abundance of 3/4=75%3/4 = 75\% for 10B^{10}\text{B}.

    Correct

    Assumed abundance of 10B=13+1=14=25.00%\text{Assumed abundance of }^{10}\text{B} = \frac{1}{3 + 1} = \frac{1}{4} = 25.00\%

    Because the average atomic mass (10.811 amu10.811\text{ amu}) is closer to 1111 than to 1010, 11B^{11}\text{B} is the more abundant isotope and represents 33 parts, while 10B^{10}\text{B} represents 11 part. Therefore, 10B^{10}\text{B} should be 14=25.00%\frac{1}{4} = 25.00\%, not 34=75%\frac{3}{4} = 75\%.

  3. Step 3

    Since 75%75\% is much higher than 19.88%19.88\%, the assumption overestimates the actual abundance of 10B^{10}\text{B}.

    Correct

    Since 25.00%>19.88%25.00\% > 19.88\%, the assumption overestimates the actual abundance of 10B^{10}\text{B}.

    Your qualitative conclusion that the assumption overestimates the abundance happens to be correct, but it was based on your incorrect value of 75%75\% rather than the intended 25.00%25.00\%.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly formulated the weighted average equation using xx and 1−x1-x.

You accurately solved for the true percent abundance of 10B^{10}\text{B} as 19.88%19.88\%.

You recognized that a 3:13:1 ratio corresponds to fractional parts out of 44.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Ratio Assignment Inversion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You inverted which isotope corresponds to the larger term in the 3:13:1 ratio, attributing 33 parts to 10B^{10}\text{B} even though the average atomic mass is closer to 11B^{11}\text{B}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Match Proximity to Abundance
  • The isotope closer to the weighted average atomic mass must have the higher percent abundance.

  • Check which isotope mass is closer to the average (10.81110.811 is closer to 11.00911.009 than 10.01310.013), meaning 11B>10B^{11}\text{B} > ^{10}\text{B}.

Assign Parts of a Ratio Carefully
  • In an A:BA:B ratio where AA is more abundant, the more abundant component gets AA parts and the less abundant gets BB parts.

  • Assign 33 parts to 11B^{11}\text{B} and 11 part to 10B^{10}\text{B}, giving 10B=13+1=25%^{10}\text{B} = \frac{1}{3+1} = 25\%.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify that since the atomic mass 10.811 amu10.811\text{ amu} is closer to 11.009 amu11.009\text{ amu} than 10.013 amu10.013\text{ amu}, 11B^{11}\text{B} has the higher abundance.

  2. In the 3:13:1 ratio of 11B^{11}\text{B} to 10B^{10}\text{B}, 10B^{10}\text{B} accounts for 13+1=14=25.00%\frac{1}{3+1} = \frac{1}{4} = 25.00\%.

  3. Compare the assumed value (25.00%25.00\%) to the true abundance (19.88%19.88\%): since 25.00%>19.88%25.00\% > 19.88\%, the assumption overestimates the actual abundance of 10B^{10}\text{B} by about 5.12%5.12\%.

Final answer

True abundance of 10B=19.88%^{10}\text{B} = 19.88\%; the 3:13:1 assumption gives an abundance of 25.00%25.00\% for 10B^{10}\text{B}, which overestimates the true abundance.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before converting a ratio to percentages, write down explicitly which isotope has the larger share based on proximity to the average atomic mass.

  • Practice converting qualitative statements like 'isotope A is roughly three times as common as isotope B' directly into explicit fractional parts 14\frac{1}{4} and 34\frac{3}{4}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A sample of neon contains only two isotopes, 20Ne^{20}\text{Ne} and 22Ne^{22}\text{Ne}, present in an assumed ratio of 9:19:1. What is the assumed percent abundance of 22Ne^{22}\text{Ne}?

Answer

10%10\%. Total parts = 9+1=109 + 1 = 10. The fraction of 22Ne^{22}\text{Ne} is 110=0.10\frac{1}{10} = 0.10, which equals 10%10\%.

02

An element consists of isotope XX (63.00 amu63.00\text{ amu}) and isotope YY (65.00 amu65.00\text{ amu}). An estimate assumes an abundance ratio of X:Y=3:1X:Y = 3:1. Calculate the estimated average atomic mass and determine if it overestimates or underestimates a true average atomic mass of 63.55 amu63.55\text{ amu}.

Answer

Estimated average atomic mass = 63.50 amu63.50\text{ amu}; it underestimates the true mass. Fractional abundance of XX is 33+1=0.75\frac{3}{3+1} = 0.75 and YY is 14=0.25\frac{1}{4} = 0.25. Estimated mass = 0.75(63.00)+0.25(65.00)=47.25+16.25=63.50 amu0.75(63.00) + 0.25(65.00) = 47.25 + 16.25 = 63.50\text{ amu}. Since 63.50 amu<63.55 amu63.50\text{ amu} < 63.55\text{ amu}, it underestimates.

03

A fictional element has two stable isotopes: 50E^{50}\text{E} (50.00 amu50.00\text{ amu}) and 52E^{52}\text{E} (52.00 amu52.00\text{ amu}). If the actual average atomic mass is 51.40 amu51.40\text{ amu}, determine the true percent abundance of 50E^{50}\text{E} and compare it to an intuitive estimate of a 2:12:1 ratio of 52E^{52}\text{E} to 50E^{50}\text{E}.

Answer

True abundance of 50E=30.0%^{50}\text{E} = 30.0\%; the intuitive estimate (33.33%33.33\%) overestimates the actual abundance. Solving 50.00x+52.00(1−x)=51.4050.00x + 52.00(1-x) = 51.40 yields x=0.300=30.0%x = 0.300 = 30.0\%. For a 2:12:1 ratio, the assumed abundance of 50E^{50}\text{E} is 12+1=13≈33.33%\frac{1}{2+1} = \frac{1}{3} \approx 33.33\%, which overestimates 30.0%30.0\%.

Loading workspace…