Resources

An industrial manufacturing line produces ibuprofen (C13H18O2\text{C}_{13}\text{H}_{18}\text{O}_2, molar mass 206.28 g/mol206.28\,\text{g/mol}) using an optimized catalytic three-step sequence. In a production run targeting 500.0 kg500.0\,\text{kg} of ibuprofen, the plant consumes a total input mass of raw materials (including organic reactants, stoichiometric reagents, and consumed process catalysts) equal to 1825.0 kg1825.0\,\text{kg}, yielding 435.0 kg435.0\,\text{kg} of isolated pure active pharmaceutical ingredient. Rather than calculating traditional percent yield, environmental metrics evaluate mass efficiency. Calculate: (a) the Sheldon Environmental Factor (EE-factor, defined as total mass of wastemass of desired product\frac{\text{total mass of waste}}{\text{mass of desired product}}), and (b) the Process Mass Intensity (PMI, defined as total mass of all raw materialsmass of desired product\frac{\text{total mass of all raw materials}}{\text{mass of desired product}}).

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) E-factor=3.20E\text{-factor} = 3.20; (b) PMI=4.20\text{PMI} = 4.20.

Steps

01

Identify the Given Values and Mass Balance

From the production run data:

  • Total input mass of raw materials: mraw=1825.0 kgm_{\text{raw}} = 1825.0\text{ kg}
  • Mass of desired product (isolated ibuprofen): mproduct=435.0 kgm_{\text{product}} = 435.0\text{ kg}

By conservation of mass, all input mass that does not end up in the isolated product becomes waste: mwaste=mraw−mproductm_{\text{waste}} = m_{\text{raw}} - m_{\text{product}} mwaste=1825.0 kg−435.0 kg=1390.0 kgm_{\text{waste}} = 1825.0\text{ kg} - 435.0\text{ kg} = 1390.0\text{ kg}


02

Calculate the Environmental Factor (EE-factor)

The Sheldon Environmental Factor (EE-factor) measures the mass of waste generated per unit mass of desired product: E-factor=mwastemproductE\text{-factor} = \frac{m_{\text{waste}}}{m_{\text{product}}}

Substitute the values: E-factor=1390.0 kg435.0 kg≈3.1954≈3.20E\text{-factor} = \frac{1390.0\text{ kg}}{435.0\text{ kg}} \approx 3.1954 \approx 3.20


03

Calculate the Process Mass Intensity (PMI)

The Process Mass Intensity (PMI) evaluates the total mass of input materials required to produce one unit mass of product: PMI=mrawmproduct\text{PMI} = \frac{m_{\text{raw}}}{m_{\text{product}}}

Substitute the values: PMI=1825.0 kg435.0 kg≈4.1954≈4.20\text{PMI} = \frac{1825.0\text{ kg}}{435.0\text{ kg}} \approx 4.1954 \approx 4.20

Key Relationship & Verification: Because mraw=mwaste+mproductm_{\text{raw}} = m_{\text{waste}} + m_{\text{product}}, the two metrics are directly related by: PMI=mwaste+mproductmproduct=E-factor+1\text{PMI} = \frac{m_{\text{waste}} + m_{\text{product}}}{m_{\text{product}}} = E\text{-factor} + 1 Checking the results: PMI=3.20+1=4.20\text{PMI} = 3.20 + 1 = 4.20 This confirms both calculations are consistent.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student uses the theoretical target mass of product (500.0 kg) rather than the actual isolated product mass (435.0 kg) when calculating mass efficiency metrics.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Mass of waste=1825.0 kg−500.0 kg=1325.0 kg\text{Mass of waste} = 1825.0\text{ kg} - 500.0\text{ kg} = 1325.0\text{ kg}

    Correct

    mwaste=mraw−mproduct=1825.0 kg−435.0 kg=1390.0 kgm_{\text{waste}} = m_{\text{raw}} - m_{\text{product}} = 1825.0\text{ kg} - 435.0\text{ kg} = 1390.0\text{ kg}

    You subtracted the target mass (500.0 kg500.0\text{ kg}) instead of the actual isolated product mass (435.0 kg435.0\text{ kg}). By mass balance, waste is the unrecovered input mass: 1825.0 kg−435.0 kg=1390.0 kg1825.0\text{ kg} - 435.0\text{ kg} = 1390.0\text{ kg}.

  2. Step 2

    E-factor=1325.0 kg/500.0 kg=2.65E\text{-factor} = 1325.0\text{ kg} / 500.0\text{ kg} = 2.65

    Correct

    E-factor=1390.0 kg435.0 kg≈3.20E\text{-factor} = \frac{1390.0\text{ kg}}{435.0\text{ kg}} \approx 3.20

    Your formula structure and arithmetic were correct, but the result is affected because you divided by the target mass and used your previous incorrect waste value.

  3. Step 3

    PMI=1825.0 kg/500.0 kg=3.65\text{PMI} = 1825.0\text{ kg} / 500.0\text{ kg} = 3.65

    Correct

    PMI=1825.0 kg435.0 kg≈4.20\text{PMI} = \frac{1825.0\text{ kg}}{435.0\text{ kg}} \approx 4.20

    Your setup follows the correct definition of PMI=mrawmproduct\text{PMI} = \frac{m_{\text{raw}}}{m_{\text{product}}}, but dividing by the target mass (500.0 kg500.0\text{ kg}) instead of the actual yield (435.0 kg435.0\text{ kg}) led to an incorrect value.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the mass conservation relationship connecting raw materials, product, and waste.

You used the correct mathematical definitions for both Sheldon EE-factor and Process Mass Intensity (PMI).

You maintained the fundamental consistency rule PMI=E-factor+1\text{PMI} = E\text{-factor} + 1 across your values.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Theoretical vs. Actual Mass Confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You substituted the nominal target batch mass (500.0 kg500.0\text{ kg}) instead of the actual mass of desired product recovered (435.0 kg435.0\text{ kg}). Green chemistry mass-efficiency metrics evaluate real process performance, so the denominator must always be the isolated product mass.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Denominator in Green Chemistry Mass Metrics
  • Both EE-factor and Process Mass Intensity (PMI) define 'desired product' as the actual isolated mass obtained from the process, never the planned or theoretical target mass.

  • Always scan the problem statement for the actual isolated yield and use that specific quantity in the denominator.

Mass Balance Consistency
  • Total raw materials=actual product mass+actual waste mass\text{Total raw materials} = \text{actual product mass} + \text{actual waste mass}, leading directly to PMI=E-factor+1\text{PMI} = E\text{-factor} + 1.

  • Verify that your waste mass equals raw materials minus actual isolated product before computing ratios.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Determine the actual waste generated: mwaste=1825.0 kg−435.0 kg=1390.0 kgm_{\text{waste}} = 1825.0\text{ kg} - 435.0\text{ kg} = 1390.0\text{ kg}.

  2. Calculate the EE-factor: E-factor=1390.0 kg435.0 kg≈3.1954≈3.20E\text{-factor} = \frac{1390.0\text{ kg}}{435.0\text{ kg}} \approx 3.1954 \approx 3.20.

  3. Calculate the Process Mass Intensity: PMI=1825.0 kg435.0 kg≈4.1954≈4.20\text{PMI} = \frac{1825.0\text{ kg}}{435.0\text{ kg}} \approx 4.1954 \approx 4.20.

Final answer

(a) E-factor=3.20E\text{-factor} = 3.20; (b) PMI=4.20\text{PMI} = 4.20

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Reread industrial chemistry prompts carefully to distinguish between target/theoretical values and actual isolated yields.

  • Practice using the identity PMI=E-factor+1\text{PMI} = E\text{-factor} + 1 to check your results quickly on exams.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the definition of E-factor with Process Mass Intensity, substituting total input mass directly for total mass of waste in part (a).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    E-factor=1825.0 kg435.0 kg=4.20E\text{-factor} = \frac{1825.0\text{ kg}}{435.0\text{ kg}} = 4.20

    Correct

    E-factor=mwastemproduct=1825.0 kg−435.0 kg435.0 kg=1390.0 kg435.0 kg≈3.20E\text{-factor} = \frac{m_{\text{waste}}}{m_{\text{product}}} = \frac{1825.0\text{ kg} - 435.0\text{ kg}}{435.0\text{ kg}} = \frac{1390.0\text{ kg}}{435.0\text{ kg}} \approx 3.20

    The Sheldon Environmental Factor (EE-factor) measures waste produced per unit of desired product, not total raw materials used. You used the total raw material mass (1825.0 kg1825.0\text{ kg}) in the numerator instead of subtracting the product mass to find the waste mass (1390.0 kg1390.0\text{ kg}).

  2. Step 2

    PMI=1825.0 kg435.0 kg=4.20\text{PMI} = \frac{1825.0\text{ kg}}{435.0\text{ kg}} = 4.20

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the given values for total input mass and isolated product mass.

You correctly calculated the Process Mass Intensity (PMI) using the ratio of total raw materials to product mass.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula confusion between E-factor and PMI

You set the numerator of the EE-factor to total raw material input rather than total waste.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the definition of EE-factor (mass of waste divided by product mass) with Process Mass Intensity (mass of all raw materials divided by product mass). Remembering that waste=raw materials−product\text{waste} = \text{raw materials} - \text{product}, or using the identity PMI=E-factor+1\text{PMI} = E\text{-factor} + 1, will prevent this confusion.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Calculate Waste Mass First
  • By conservation of mass, mwaste=mraw materials−mproductm_{\text{waste}} = m_{\text{raw materials}} - m_{\text{product}}.

  • Always subtract the isolated product mass from the total input mass before computing the EE-factor.

Sanity Check with PMI = E + 1
  • PMI=mwaste+mproductmproduct=E-factor+1\text{PMI} = \frac{m_{\text{waste}} + m_{\text{product}}}{m_{\text{product}}} = E\text{-factor} + 1.

  • Check whether your calculated PMI\text{PMI} is exactly 11 unit larger than your EE-factor.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Determine the mass of waste generated: mwaste=1825.0 kg−435.0 kg=1390.0 kgm_{\text{waste}} = 1825.0\text{ kg} - 435.0\text{ kg} = 1390.0\text{ kg}.

  2. Substitute into the EE-factor definition: E-factor=1390.0 kg435.0 kg≈3.1954≈3.20E\text{-factor} = \frac{1390.0\text{ kg}}{435.0\text{ kg}} \approx 3.1954 \approx 3.20.

Final answer

(a) E-factor=3.20E\text{-factor} = 3.20; (b) PMI=4.20\text{PMI} = 4.20

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice finding mass balance differences before substituting into green chemistry metric formulas.

  • Use the relationship PMI=E-factor+1\text{PMI} = E\text{-factor} + 1 to quickly cross-check both values whenever working with the same batch data.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student inverts the definition of Process Mass Intensity by dividing the mass of desired product by the total mass of raw materials.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Mass of waste=1825.0 kg−435.0 kg=1390.0 kg\text{Mass of waste} = 1825.0\,\text{kg} - 435.0\,\text{kg} = 1390.0\,\text{kg}

  2. Step 2

    E-factor=1390.0 kg/435.0 kg=3.20E\text{-factor} = 1390.0\,\text{kg} / 435.0\,\text{kg} = 3.20

  3. Step 3

    PMI=435.0 kg/1825.0 kg=0.238\text{PMI} = 435.0\,\text{kg} / 1825.0\,\text{kg} = 0.238

    Correct

    PMI=mrawmproduct=1825.0 kg435.0 kg≈4.20\text{PMI} = \frac{m_{\text{raw}}}{m_{\text{product}}} = \frac{1825.0\,\text{kg}}{435.0\,\text{kg}} \approx 4.20

    You inverted the numerator and denominator for Process Mass Intensity. The metric measures how many kilograms of raw input materials are needed per kilogram of product, so total raw material mass belongs in the numerator.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used mass conservation to determine the total waste mass.

You correctly identified and applied the formula for the Sheldon Environmental Factor.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted metric ratio

You divided the product mass by the raw materials mass instead of dividing total raw materials by the product mass.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating Process Mass Intensity (PMI, which is an intensity metric and always ≥1\ge 1) with fractional mass productivity or mass recovery (which is always ≤1\le 1).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check metric baseline
  • Process Mass Intensity (PMI) is defined as total raw material massproduct mass\frac{\text{total raw material mass}}{\text{product mass}}, meaning an ideal process with zero waste has a baseline PMI=1.0\text{PMI} = 1.0.

  • Always verify that your calculated PMI value is greater than or equal to 1.01.0.

Verify using the $E$-factor identity
  • Because mraw=mwaste+mproductm_{\text{raw}} = m_{\text{waste}} + m_{\text{product}}, PMI and EE-factor satisfy the identity PMI=E-factor+1\text{PMI} = E\text{-factor} + 1.

  • Add 11 to your EE-factor to double-check your PMI result immediately.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. PMI=total mass of all raw materialsmass of desired product\text{PMI} = \frac{\text{total mass of all raw materials}}{\text{mass of desired product}}

  2. PMI=1825.0 kg435.0 kg≈4.1954≈4.20\text{PMI} = \frac{1825.0\,\text{kg}}{435.0\,\text{kg}} \approx 4.1954 \approx 4.20

Final answer

(a) E-factor=3.20E\text{-factor} = 3.20; (b) PMI=4.20\text{PMI} = 4.20

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Remember that PMI answers 'How much raw material do we put in per unit of product?', meaning the larger input mass belongs in the numerator.

  • Use the consistency check PMI=E-factor+1\text{PMI} = E\text{-factor} + 1 whenever both metrics are computed for the same system.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A pilot synthesis targets 100.0 kg100.0\text{ kg} of a fragrance compound. The reaction uses 650.0 kg650.0\text{ kg} of total input materials and produces 80.0 kg80.0\text{ kg} of isolated pure fragrance. Calculate the EE-factor and PMI.

Answer

E-factor=7.13E\text{-factor} = 7.13, PMI=8.13\text{PMI} = 8.13. Key steps: mwaste=650.0 kg−80.0 kg=570.0 kgm_{\text{waste}} = 650.0\text{ kg} - 80.0\text{ kg} = 570.0\text{ kg}; E-factor=570.080.0=7.125≈7.13E\text{-factor} = \frac{570.0}{80.0} = 7.125 \approx 7.13; PMI=650.080.0=8.125≈8.13\text{PMI} = \frac{650.0}{80.0} = 8.125 \approx 8.13.

02

A continuous flow pharmaceutical process has a measured PMI=12.5\text{PMI} = 12.5. If a campaign yields 240.0 kg240.0\text{ kg} of isolated drug substance, calculate the total input mass consumed and the Sheldon EE-factor.

Answer

mraw=3000 kgm_{\text{raw}} = 3000\text{ kg}, E-factor=11.5E\text{-factor} = 11.5. Key steps: mraw=PMI×mproduct=12.5×240.0 kg=3000 kgm_{\text{raw}} = \text{PMI} \times m_{\text{product}} = 12.5 \times 240.0\text{ kg} = 3000\text{ kg}; E-factor=PMI−1=12.5−1=11.5E\text{-factor} = \text{PMI} - 1 = 12.5 - 1 = 11.5.

03

A manufacturing run with a target output of 2.00 tonnes2.00\text{ tonnes} consumes 14.50 tonnes14.50\text{ tonnes} of raw materials, solvents, and reagents. The reaction achieves an 85.0%85.0\% yield relative to the target. Calculate the actual EE-factor of the process.

Answer

E-factor=7.53E\text{-factor} = 7.53. Key steps: mproduct=0.850×2.00 tonnes=1.70 tonnesm_{\text{product}} = 0.850 \times 2.00\text{ tonnes} = 1.70\text{ tonnes}; mwaste=14.50−1.70=12.80 tonnesm_{\text{waste}} = 14.50 - 1.70 = 12.80\text{ tonnes}; E-factor=12.80 tonnes1.70 tonnes≈7.529≈7.53E\text{-factor} = \frac{12.80\text{ tonnes}}{1.70\text{ tonnes}} \approx 7.529 \approx 7.53.

Loading workspace…