Resources
A beaker contains an equilibrium mixture of of liquid water and of solid ice cubes at and . A student reasons that because the system contains only pure molecules throughout, it must be classified as a homogeneous mixture. (a) Critique the student's reasoning and provide the correct classification of this ice-water system in terms of pure substance vs. mixture, and homogeneous vs. heterogeneous. (b) Calculate the minimum thermal energy in kilojoules () that must be absorbed by the system at constant temperature to transform it into a completely uniform, single-phase liquid system (enthalpy of fusion , molar mass of ).
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) The student's reasoning is incorrect; the system is a heterogeneous pure substance consisting of two distinct physical phases (solid and liquid); (b)
Steps
Part (a): Classification of the System
-
Critique of the Student's Reasoning:
- The student confuses chemical composition with physical phase homogeneity.
- A mixture requires two or more chemically distinct substances physically combined. Because the system contains exclusively water molecules (), it cannot be classified as a mixture at all; it is a pure substance.
- Furthermore, a system is homogeneous only if its properties and physical state are completely uniform throughout on a macroscopic scale (i.e., a single phase). Because ice is a solid and water is a liquid, distinct phase boundaries exist between the ice cubes and the liquid water. Therefore, the system is heterogeneous.
-
Correct Classification:
- The ice-water system is a heterogeneous pure substance (a two-phase, one-component system consisting of solid ice and liquid water in equilibrium).
Part (b): Calculation of Required Thermal Energy
To convert the two-phase heterogeneous system into a completely uniform, single-phase liquid system at , only the solid phase (the of ice) needs to undergo a phase change (fusion) into liquid water. The of liquid water is already in the liquid state and remains at .
- Calculate the moles of ice () to be melted:
- Calculate the heat () required for fusion:
- Round to three significant figures:
(Common Pitfall: Do not include the of water in the latent heat calculation. Latent heat of fusion only applies to the mass undergoing the phase transition, not the liquid already present.)
Typical errors
01 The student mistakenly includes the total mass of the system (125.0 g) instead of only the mass of ice that needs to melt (25.0 g) to achieve a single-phase liquid system, resulting in an calculated energy of 41.7 kJ.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
a) The student is incorrect because pure is a single chemical compound, so it is a pure substance, not a mixture. b) Since solid ice and liquid water coexist as two distinct phases, the system is heterogeneous. c) The correct classification is a heterogenous pure substance.
- Step 2Correct
To convert the system into a single-phase liquid at , only the solid ice must absorb latent heat to melt. The of liquid water is already in the liquid phase at and requires no phase change.
- Step 3Correct
Your calculation setup and unit conversions were mathematically correct, but your final energy value was inflated because it carried over the total mass from the previous step.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly distinguished between a chemical mixture and a pure substance based on molecular composition.
You accurately identified that coexisting solid and liquid states make a system physically heterogeneous.
You correctly applied molar mass and enthalpy of fusion to determine the thermal energy required for a phase transition.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the total mass of the system with the mass of the specific phase that must undergo the phase transition. Latent heat () is only absorbed by the substance actually changing from solid to liquid, not by the portion that is already liquid.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Target the Changing Phase
When calculating latent heat (), only substitute the amount of substance actively undergoing the phase transition.
Identify which specific phase must change to reach the target state and exclude any mass already in that target state.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the mass of ice that needs to melt: .
Calculate the moles of ice: .
Calculate the heat required for fusion: .
(a) The student's reasoning is incorrect; the system is a heterogeneous pure substance consisting of two distinct physical phases (solid and liquid); (b)
02 The student confuses the physical boundary definition of a mixture with chemical composition, classifying the system as a heterogeneous mixture rather than a pure substance.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The student is incorrect... because solid and liquid exist as separate phases, making it heterogeneous.
- Step 2
Because ice and water are in different physical states, it should be treated as a mixture of two phases. The system is classified as a heterogeneous mixture.
CorrectBecause the system consists exclusively of molecules, it is chemically a pure substance, making the overall classification a heterogeneous pure substance.
A mixture requires two or more chemically distinct substances. Even though two physical phases are present, all particles are chemically identical (), so it is a heterogeneous pure substance, not a mixture.
- Step 3
Only the ice needs to melt to become liquid water. ⟹ ⟹
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that the presence of multiple physical states (solid and liquid) makes the system heterogeneous.
You correctly determined that only the ice absorbs heat during the constant-temperature phase change.
You accurately calculated the moles of ice and the required enthalpy of fusion using correct significant figures.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated multiple coexisting physical phases as a 'mixture of phases' and concluded the system is a chemical mixture, overlooking that a mixture requires two or more chemically different substances.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Pure Substance vs. Mixture
A system containing only one type of chemical formula or compound is always a pure substance, regardless of how many physical states (phases) are present.
Check whether the system contains more than one chemically distinct component before labeling it a mixture.
- Homogeneous vs. Heterogeneous
Homogeneity refers to macroscopic uniformity of physical state (single phase), while purity refers to chemical composition.
Separate your classification into two independent axes: chemical composition (pure substance vs. mixture) and physical uniformity (homogeneous vs. heterogeneous).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the chemical composition: The system contains only molecules, so it has only one chemical component.
Apply the definition of a pure substance: A single chemical component cannot be a mixture; it is a pure substance.
Identify the physical state: Ice (solid) and water (liquid) form two distinct phases with macroscopic boundaries, so it is heterogeneous.
Combine both classifications: The system is a heterogeneous pure substance.
(a) The student's reasoning is incorrect; the system is a heterogeneous pure substance consisting of two distinct physical phases. (b)
03 The student multiplies the molar mass by the mass of ice instead of dividing to find the number of moles, leading to an incorrect energy requirement of 2710 kJ.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The student is incorrect because a system consisting of only molecules is a pure substance, not a mixture. Because there are two distinct phases present (solid and liquid), the system is heterogeneous. The correct classification is a heterogeneous pure substance.
- Step 2Correct
To convert mass to moles, you need to divide mass by molar mass (). Multiplying grams by grams per mole yields units of rather than moles.
- Step 3Correct
Your formula setup for enthalpy of fusion was correct, but the calculated value was thrown off by the incorrect number of moles from the previous step.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that a sample of only molecules is a pure substance rather than a mixture.
You recognized that having two separate physical states (solid and liquid) makes the system heterogeneous.
You correctly identified that only the of ice needs to absorb heat of fusion to reach a single liquid phase.
You correctly applied the relationship .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou inverted the dimensional analysis factor for molar mass, multiplying by instead of dividing by it (multiplying by ).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Dimensional Analysis for Moles
Always write out units and cancel them explicitly: .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the moles of ice to be melted: .
Calculate the required thermal energy: .
(a) The student is incorrect; the system is a heterogeneous pure substance. (b)
Lock it in
Does an equilibrium mixture of liquid water and ice cubes count as a pure substance or a mixture? Why?
It is a pure substance because it consists exclusively of one chemical compound (). A mixture requires two or more chemically distinct substances.
Similar question
A flask contains of liquid ethanol () and of solid ethanol at its freezing point (). (a) Classify this system as a pure substance or mixture, and homogeneous or heterogeneous. (b) Calculate the energy in needed to completely melt the solid ethanol (, molar mass of ethanol ).
Answer
(a) Heterogeneous pure substance (one chemical compound present in two distinct physical phases). (b) Only the of solid ethanol melts: . .
A rigid container holds of liquid water and of water vapor at . How much heat in must be removed at constant temperature to condense all the vapor into a completely uniform liquid system? (, molar mass )
Answer
Only the of vapor undergoes condensation: . Heat removed: .
A mixture is prepared by dissolving of solid completely into of liquid water at . (a) Classify this resulting system in terms of pure substance vs. mixture, and homogeneous vs. heterogeneous. (b) If an additional of is added such that some solid salt settles undissolved at the bottom, how does the classification change?
Answer
(a) Homogeneous mixture (a solution with uniform composition and a single liquid phase throughout). (b) Heterogeneous mixture (two chemically distinct substances with distinct solid and liquid phase boundaries coexisting).