Resources

Two identical 1.00 L1.00\text{ L} rigid sealed flasks at STP (0∘C0^\circ\text{C} and 1 atm1\text{ atm}) contain pure gases: Flask A contains methane gas (CH4\text{CH}_4, molar mass =16.04 g/mol= 16.04\text{ g/mol}), and Flask B contains sulfur hexafluoride gas (SF6\text{SF}_6, molar mass =146.06 g/mol= 146.06\text{ g/mol}). Students frequently assume that because SF6\text{SF}_6 is over nine times heavier per mole, Flask B must contain fewer gas molecules or occupy a different molar quantity under identical conditions. (a) By applying Avogadro's hypothesis, determine the molar ratio of gas in Flask A to Flask B (nCH4:nSF6n_{\text{CH}_4} : n_{\text{SF}_6}). (b) Calculate the mass in grams of the gas in each flask. (c) Determine the ratio of the total number of atoms in Flask A compared to Flask B.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) nCH4:nSF6=1:1n_{\text{CH}_4} : n_{\text{SF}_6} = 1 : 1 (n=0.0446 moln = 0.0446\text{ mol} each), (b) mCH4=0.716 gm_{\text{CH}_4} = 0.716\text{ g}, mSF6=6.52 gm_{\text{SF}_6} = 6.52\text{ g}, (c) Natoms, ANatoms, B=57≈0.714\frac{N_{\text{atoms, A}}}{N_{\text{atoms, B}}} = \frac{5}{7} \approx 0.714

Steps

Part (a): Determine the Molar Ratio Using Avogadro's Hypothesis

Avogadro's hypothesis states that equal volumes of all gases at the same temperature and pressure contain an equal number of molecules (and therefore an equal number of moles).

Both flasks have identical conditions:

  • Volume: V=1.00 LV = 1.00\text{ L}
  • Temperature: T=0∘C=273.15 KT = 0^\circ\text{C} = 273.15\text{ K}
  • Pressure: P=1 atmP = 1\text{ atm}

Because VV, TT, and PP are identical for both gases, the number of moles must be equal: nCHX4=nSFX6n_{\ce{CH4}} = n_{\ce{SF6}}

At standard temperature and pressure (STP\text{STP}), the molar volume of an ideal gas is Vm≈22.414 L/molV_m \approx 22.414\text{ L/mol}. Calculating the moles in each flask gives: n=VVm=1.00 L22.414 L/mol≈0.0446 moln = \frac{V}{V_m} = \frac{1.00\text{ L}}{22.414\text{ L/mol}} \approx 0.0446\text{ mol}

Thus, the molar ratio is: nCHX4:nSFX6=1:1(n=0.0446 mol each)n_{\ce{CH4}} : n_{\ce{SF6}} = 1 : 1\quad (n = 0.0446\text{ mol}\text{ each})

Common Pitfall: Do not confuse mass with molar amount. Gas volume at standard conditions is determined by the number of independent particles, not by the size or mass of the individual molecules.


Part (b): Calculate the Mass of Gas in Each Flask

The mass (mm) of a gas sample is the product of its amount in moles (nn) and its molar mass (MM): m=n⋅Mm = n \cdot M

  • Flask A (CHX4\ce{CH4}): mCHX4=0.04462 mol⋅16.04 g/mol≈0.716 gm_{\ce{CH4}} = 0.04462\text{ mol} \cdot 16.04\text{ g/mol} \approx 0.716\text{ g}
  • Flask B (SFX6\ce{SF6}): mSFX6=0.04462 mol⋅146.06 g/mol≈6.52 gm_{\ce{SF6}} = 0.04462\text{ mol} \cdot 146.06\text{ g/mol} \approx 6.52\text{ g}

Even though both containers hold the exact same number of gas molecules, Flask B has significantly greater mass because each SFX6\ce{SF6} molecule is much heavier than a CHX4\ce{CH4} molecule.


Part (c): Determine the Ratio of Total Atoms

While both flasks contain the same number of molecules (Nmolecules=n⋅NAN_{\text{molecules}} = n \cdot N_A), the number of atoms per molecule differs:

  • Each molecule of methane (CHX4\ce{CH4}) contains 1+4=51 + 4 = 5 atoms.
  • Each molecule of sulfur hexafluoride (SFX6\ce{SF6}) contains 1+6=71 + 6 = 7 atoms.

Using the total number of molecules NN: Natoms, A=5⋅NN_{\text{atoms, A}} = 5 \cdot N Natoms, B=7⋅NN_{\text{atoms, B}} = 7 \cdot N

Taking the ratio of total atoms in Flask A to Flask B gives: Natoms, ANatoms, B=57≈0.714\frac{N_{\text{atoms, A}}}{N_{\text{atoms, B}}} = \frac{5}{7} \approx 0.714

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses molar amount with mass or assumes heavier gas molecules occupy more volume, concluding the heavier gas has fewer moles in inverse proportion to molar mass.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Heavier gas particles take up more space so there are fewer moles in Flask B.   ⟹  nCH4:nSF6=146.06:16.04=9.11:1\implies n_{\text{CH}_4} : n_{\text{SF}_6} = 146.06 : 16.04 = 9.11 : 1

    Correct

    nCH4:nSF6=1:1n_{\text{CH}_4} : n_{\text{SF}_6} = 1 : 1

    According to Avogadro's hypothesis, equal volumes of gases at the same temperature and pressure contain the same number of moles, regardless of the size or molar mass of the molecules. Since both flasks have a volume of 1.00 L1.00\text{ L} at STP, they contain identical molar amounts.

  2. Step 2

    n=1.00 L22.4 L/mol=0.0446 mol  ⟹  Mass of CH4=0.0446 mol×16.04 g/mol=0.715 gn = \frac{1.00\text{ L}}{22.4\text{ L/mol}} = 0.0446\text{ mol} \implies \text{Mass of CH}_4 = 0.0446\text{ mol} \times 16.04\text{ g/mol} = 0.715\text{ g}, Mass of SF6=0.0446 mol×146.06 g/mol=6.51 g\text{Mass of SF}_6 = 0.0446\text{ mol} \times 146.06\text{ g/mol} = 6.51\text{ g}

  3. Step 3

    CH4\text{CH}_4 has 55 atoms per molecule and SF6\text{SF}_6 has 77 atoms per molecule.   ⟹  Atoms ratio=(5×9.11):(7×1)=45.55:7=6.51:1\implies \text{Atoms ratio} = (5 \times 9.11) : (7 \times 1) = 45.55 : 7 = 6.51 : 1

    Correct

    Natoms, ANatoms, B=57≈0.714\frac{N_{\text{atoms, A}}}{N_{\text{atoms, B}}} = \frac{5}{7} \approx 0.714

    You correctly counted 55 atoms in CH4\text{CH}_4 and 77 atoms in SF6\text{SF}_6, but your final ratio was distorted because you carried forward the incorrect 9.11:19.11 : 1 molar ratio from part (a) instead of using the true 1:11 : 1 ratio.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the molar volume of an ideal gas at STP (22.4 L/mol22.4\text{ L/mol}) to determine the moles of gas.

You correctly multiplied moles by molar mass to find the mass of each gas sample in grams.

You correctly identified the number of atoms present in one molecule of CH4\text{CH}_4 (55 atoms) and SF6\text{SF}_6 (77 atoms).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Avogadro's Hypothesis vs. Molecular Mass Confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that heavier or larger gas molecules occupy more volume, confusing particle mass with gas volume. Under ideal gas behavior, the physical volume of individual molecules is negligible compared to the total gas volume, so volume depends solely on the number of gas particles, temperature, and pressure.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Avogadro's Law Rule
  • At identical TT and PP, V∝nV \propto n. Gas volume does not depend on molecular size or mass.

  • Whenever two gases share the same TT, PP, and VV, set their molar amounts equal (n1=n2n_1 = n_2).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall from part (a) that because VV, TT, and PP are identical, the mole ratio is nCH4:nSF6=1:1n_{\text{CH}_4} : n_{\text{SF}_6} = 1 : 1.

  2. Both flasks therefore contain the same number of molecules: Nmolecules, A=Nmolecules, B=NN_{\text{molecules, A}} = N_{\text{molecules, B}} = N.

  3. Multiply the number of molecules by the atoms per molecule: Natoms, A=5NN_{\text{atoms, A}} = 5N and Natoms, B=7NN_{\text{atoms, B}} = 7N.

  4. Take the ratio: Natoms, ANatoms, B=5N7N=57\frac{N_{\text{atoms, A}}}{N_{\text{atoms, B}}} = \frac{5N}{7N} = \frac{5}{7}.

Final answer

(a) nCH4:nSF6=1:1n_{\text{CH}_4} : n_{\text{SF}_6} = 1 : 1, (b) mCH4=0.716 gm_{\text{CH}_4} = 0.716\text{ g}, mSF6=6.52 gm_{\text{SF}_6} = 6.52\text{ g}, (c) Natoms, ANatoms, B=57≈0.714\frac{N_{\text{atoms, A}}}{N_{\text{atoms, B}}} = \frac{5}{7} \approx 0.714

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Avogadro's hypothesis to reinforce why gas volume is independent of molar mass.

  • Practice problems comparing molar amounts versus masses for different gases under identical conditions.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the ratio of total atoms with the ratio of molecules or moles, failing to multiply by the number of atoms per molecule.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Equal volumes at STP have equal moles.   ⟹  nCHX4:nSFX6=1:1  ⟹  n=1.00 L22.4 L/mol=0.0446 mol\implies n_{\ce{CH4}} : n_{\ce{SF6}} = 1 : 1 \implies n = \frac{1.00\text{ L}}{22.4\text{ L/mol}} = 0.0446\text{ mol}

  2. Step 2

    Mass of CHX4=0.0446 mol×16.04 g/mol=0.715 g  ⟹  Mass of SFX6=0.0446 mol×146.06 g/mol=6.51 g\text{Mass of } \ce{CH4} = 0.0446\text{ mol} \times 16.04\text{ g/mol} = 0.715\text{ g} \implies \text{Mass of } \ce{SF6} = 0.0446\text{ mol} \times 146.06\text{ g/mol} = 6.51\text{ g}

  3. Step 3

    Since nCHX4:nSFX6=1:1, the number of molecules is equal.  ⟹  Ratio of total atoms in Flask A to Flask B=1:1\text{Since } n_{\ce{CH4}} : n_{\ce{SF6}} = 1 : 1\text{, the number of molecules is equal.} \implies \text{Ratio of total atoms in Flask A to Flask B} = 1 : 1

    Correct

    Natoms, ANatoms, B=5⋅N7⋅N=57≈0.714\frac{N_{\text{atoms, A}}}{N_{\text{atoms, B}}} = \frac{5 \cdot N}{7 \cdot N} = \frac{5}{7} \approx 0.714

    You treated the ratio of total atoms as identical to the ratio of molecules. While both flasks contain the same number of molecules NN, each molecule of CHX4\ce{CH4} contains 55 atoms (1 C+4 H1\text{ C} + 4\text{ H}) and each molecule of SFX6\ce{SF6} contains 77 atoms (1 S+6 F1\text{ S} + 6\text{ F}), giving an atom ratio of 5:75 : 7.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied Avogadro's hypothesis to establish a 1:11 : 1 molar ratio for identical gas volumes at STP.

You accurately calculated the gas mass in both containers using m=n⋅Mm = n \cdot M.

You correctly recognized that equal moles correspond to an equal number of gas molecules.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing molecules with total constituent atoms

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You equated molecular quantity with atomic quantity without accounting for chemical formula subscripts (atomicity).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Particle Level Distinction
  • Equal moles of molecular compounds guarantee equal numbers of molecules, not equal numbers of constituent atoms.

  • Always count the total number of atoms per formula unit (e.g., CHX4=5\ce{CH4} = 5 atoms, SFX6=7\ce{SF6} = 7 atoms) before comparing atom counts.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Count the number of constituent atoms in one molecule of each gas: CHX4\ce{CH4} has 1+4=51 + 4 = 5 atoms per molecule, and SFX6\ce{SF6} has 1+6=71 + 6 = 7 atoms per molecule.

  2. Multiply the number of molecules NN by the atomicity of each gas: Natoms, A=5NN_{\text{atoms, A}} = 5N and Natoms, B=7NN_{\text{atoms, B}} = 7N.

  3. Take the ratio of total atoms: Natoms, ANatoms, B=5N7N=57\frac{N_{\text{atoms, A}}}{N_{\text{atoms, B}}} = \frac{5N}{7N} = \frac{5}{7}.

Final answer

Natoms, ANatoms, B=57≈0.714\frac{N_{\text{atoms, A}}}{N_{\text{atoms, B}}} = \frac{5}{7} \approx 0.714

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • When asked for total atoms in a molecular gas sample, first find the number of molecules, then multiply by the total number of atoms shown in the chemical formula.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student miscounts the number of atoms in the polyatomic molecules by considering only the peripheral halogen/hydrogen atoms and ignoring the central atom.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    By Avogadro's hypothesis, equal volumes at STP contain equal moles.   ⟹  nCH4:nSF6=1:1\implies n_{\text{CH}_4} : n_{\text{SF}_6} = 1 : 1   ⟹  n=1.00 L22.4 L/mol=0.0446 mol\implies n = \frac{1.00\text{ L}}{22.4\text{ L/mol}} = 0.0446\text{ mol}

  2. Step 2

    Mass of CH4=0.0446 mol×16.04 g/mol=0.715 g\text{Mass of CH}_4 = 0.0446\text{ mol} \times 16.04\text{ g/mol} = 0.715\text{ g}   ⟹  Mass of SF6=0.0446 mol×146.06 g/mol=6.51 g\implies \text{Mass of SF}_6 = 0.0446\text{ mol} \times 146.06\text{ g/mol} = 6.51\text{ g}

  3. Step 3

    CH4 has 4 H atoms and SF6 has 6 F atoms.  ⟹  Ratio of total atoms in Flask A to Flask B=4:6=2:3\text{CH}_4\text{ has } 4\text{ H atoms and } \text{SF}_6\text{ has } 6\text{ F atoms.} \implies \text{Ratio of total atoms in Flask A to Flask B} = 4 : 6 = 2 : 3

    Correct

    Atoms in CH4=1+4=5\text{Atoms in }\text{CH}_4 = 1 + 4 = 5, atoms in SF6=1+6=7  ⟹  Natoms, ANatoms, B=57≈0.714\text{atoms in }\text{SF}_6 = 1 + 6 = 7 \implies \frac{N_{\text{atoms, A}}}{N_{\text{atoms, B}}} = \frac{5}{7} \approx 0.714

    You omitted the central atom of each molecule. A molecule of CH4\text{CH}_4 has 1 C+4 H=5 atoms1\text{ C} + 4\text{ H} = 5\text{ atoms}, and a molecule of SF6\text{SF}_6 has 1 S+6 F=7 atoms1\text{ S} + 6\text{ F} = 7\text{ atoms}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You stated and applied Avogadro's hypothesis correctly to find a 1:11:1 molar ratio.

You correctly calculated the number of moles using molar volume at STP.

You used the relationship m=n⋅Mm = n \cdot M correctly to calculate the mass of each gas sample.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted central atom in total atom count

You noticed the subscript numbers 44 and 66 for the outer atoms but overlooked the implicit subscript 11 on the central carbon and sulfur atoms.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the number of bonded peripheral ligands/substituents with the total atom count of a polyatomic molecule.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Account for implicit subscripts
  • Every chemical symbol without an explicit subscript represents exactly one atom in the molecular formula.

  • Write out the count of every element explicitly before summing: CH4→1 C+4 H=5 atoms\text{CH}_4 \rightarrow 1\text{ C} + 4\text{ H} = 5\text{ atoms}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify all atoms in one molecule of methane: 1 C+4 H=5 atoms1\text{ C} + 4\text{ H} = 5\text{ atoms}.

  2. Identify all atoms in one molecule of sulfur hexafluoride: 1 S+6 F=7 atoms1\text{ S} + 6\text{ F} = 7\text{ atoms}.

  3. Because both flasks have equal moles (nCH4=nSF6n_{\text{CH}_4} = n_{\text{SF}_6}), the ratio of total atoms is the ratio of atoms per molecule: Natoms, ANatoms, B=57≈0.714\frac{N_{\text{atoms, A}}}{N_{\text{atoms, B}}} = \frac{5}{7} \approx 0.714.

Final answer

(a) nCH4:nSF6=1:1n_{\text{CH}_4} : n_{\text{SF}_6} = 1 : 1, (b) mCH4=0.715 gm_{\text{CH}_4} = 0.715\text{ g} (or 0.716 g0.716\text{ g}), mSF6=6.51 gm_{\text{SF}_6} = 6.51\text{ g} (or 6.52 g6.52\text{ g}), (c) Natoms, ANatoms, B=57\frac{N_{\text{atoms, A}}}{N_{\text{atoms, B}}} = \frac{5}{7}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice summing all element subscripts, including implicit ones, when calculating total atoms in chemical formulas.

  • Always distinguish between 'number of molecules' and 'total number of constituent atoms' when comparing gas mixtures.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Two rigid 2.00 L2.00\text{ L} bulbs at 25∘C25^\circ\text{C} and 1.00 atm1.00\text{ atm} contain Helium (He\text{He}) and Krypton (Kr\text{Kr}). Determine: (a) the mole ratio nHe:nKrn_{\text{He}} : n_{\text{Kr}}, and (b) the mass ratio mKr:mHem_{\text{Kr}} : m_{\text{He}} (molar masses: He=4.00 g/mol\text{He} = 4.00\text{ g/mol}, Kr=83.80 g/mol\text{Kr} = 83.80\text{ g/mol}).

Answer

(a) nHe:nKr=1:1n_{\text{He}} : n_{\text{Kr}} = 1 : 1 by Avogadro's law since VV, TT, and PP are identical. (b) Since moles are equal, mKrmHe=n⋅MKrn⋅MHe=83.804.00=20.95:1\frac{m_{\text{Kr}}}{m_{\text{He}}} = \frac{n \cdot M_{\text{Kr}}}{n \cdot M_{\text{He}}} = \frac{83.80}{4.00} = 20.95 : 1.

02

Container X (3.00 L3.00\text{ L}) holds carbon monoxide (CO\text{CO}) gas and Container Y (3.00 L3.00\text{ L}) holds carbon dioxide (CO2\text{CO}_2) gas, both at STP. Calculate the ratio of the total number of oxygen atoms in Container X to Container Y.

Answer

Ratio is 1:21 : 2. By Avogadro's hypothesis, both containers have equal moles and therefore equal molecules (NN). CO\text{CO} has 11 oxygen atom per molecule (NO, X=1⋅NN_{\text{O, X}} = 1 \cdot N) and CO2\text{CO}_2 has 22 oxygen atoms per molecule (NO, Y=2⋅NN_{\text{O, Y}} = 2 \cdot N), yielding a ratio of 12\frac{1}{2}.

03

A mixture contains equal masses of methane (CH4\text{CH}_4, 16.04 g/mol16.04\text{ g/mol}) and sulfur dioxide (SO2\text{SO}_2, 64.06 g/mol64.06\text{ g/mol}) in a rigid container. (a) What is the mole ratio nCH4:nSO2n_{\text{CH}_4} : n_{\text{SO}_2}? (b) What fraction of the total pressure is exerted by CH4\text{CH}_4?

Answer

(a) Let mass be mm. nCH4=m16.04n_{\text{CH}_4} = \frac{m}{16.04} and nSO2=m64.06n_{\text{SO}_2} = \frac{m}{64.06}, so nCH4:nSO2=64.0616.04≈4:1n_{\text{CH}_4} : n_{\text{SO}_2} = \frac{64.06}{16.04} \approx 4 : 1. (b) Mole fraction χCH4=44+1=0.80\chi_{\text{CH}_4} = \frac{4}{4 + 1} = 0.80, so CH4\text{CH}_4 exerts 80%80\% (0.800.80) of the total pressure.

Loading workspace…