Resources

A sealed tube contains an unknown mass of solid iron powder that reacts completely with pure chlorine gas according to the combination reaction: 2Fe(s)+3Cl2(g)→2FeCl3(s)2\text{Fe}(s) + 3\text{Cl}_2(g) \rightarrow 2\text{FeCl}_3(s). After the reaction reaches completion, exactly 32.44 g32.44\text{ g} of solid iron(III) chloride is recovered as the sole product. If exactly 21.27 g21.27\text{ g} of chlorine gas was consumed during the process, apply the law of conservation of mass to determine the initial mass of iron powder present in the vessel.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Initial mass of Fe=32.44 g−21.27 g=11.17 g\text{Initial mass of Fe} = 32.44\text{ g} - 21.27\text{ g} = 11.17\text{ g}.

Steps

01

Apply the Law of Conservation of Mass

The Law of Conservation of Mass states that in any chemical reaction occurring in a closed system, mass is neither created nor destroyed. Consequently, the total mass of the reactants consumed must equal the total mass of the products formed:

Total mass of reactants=Total mass of products\text{Total mass of reactants} = \text{Total mass of products}

02

Set Up the Mass Balance Equation

In this combination reaction, iron (Fe\ce{Fe}) and chlorine gas (ClX2\ce{Cl2}) react completely to form iron(III) chloride (FeClX3\ce{FeCl3}) as the only product:

mFe+mClX2=mFeClX3m_{\text{Fe}} + m_{\ce{Cl2}} = m_{\ce{FeCl3}}

Where:

  • mFem_{\text{Fe}} is the initial mass of iron powder consumed.
  • mClX2=21.27 gm_{\ce{Cl2}} = 21.27\text{ g} is the mass of chlorine gas consumed.
  • mFeClX3=32.44 gm_{\ce{FeCl3}} = 32.44\text{ g} is the total mass of iron(III) chloride produced.
03

Calculate the Mass of Iron

Rearranging the equation to solve for the mass of iron:

mFe=mFeClX3−mClX2m_{\text{Fe}} = m_{\ce{FeCl3}} - m_{\ce{Cl2}}

Substitute the given values into the equation:

Initial mass of Fe=32.44 g−21.27 g=11.17 g\text{Initial mass of Fe} = 32.44\text{ g} - 21.27\text{ g} = 11.17\text{ g}

Common Pitfall to Avoid: Do not convert the values to moles using the coefficients from the balanced chemical equation unless specifically required to find molar quantities. When all reactants and products are accounted for in a closed reaction, a simple mass balance is the direct and exact method.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student mistakenly adds the mass of chlorine gas consumed to the mass of iron(III) chloride product instead of subtracting it, yielding 53.71 g.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    mass of Fe=mass of FeCl3+mass of Cl2\text{mass of Fe} = \text{mass of FeCl}_3 + \text{mass of Cl}_2

    Correct

    mass of Fe+mass of Cl2=mass of FeCl3  ⟹  mass of Fe=mass of FeCl3−mass of Cl2\text{mass of Fe} + \text{mass of Cl}_2 = \text{mass of FeCl}_3 \implies \text{mass of Fe} = \text{mass of FeCl}_3 - \text{mass of Cl}_2

    According to the Law of Conservation of Mass, the sum of reactant masses equals the sum of product masses (mFe+mCl2=mFeCl3m_{\text{Fe}} + m_{\text{Cl}_2} = m_{\text{FeCl}_3}). To isolate the unknown reactant mass, you must subtract the known reactant mass from the product mass.

  2. Step 2

    mass of Fe=32.44 g+21.27 g  ⟹  mass of Fe=53.71 g\text{mass of Fe} = 32.44\text{ g} + 21.27\text{ g} \implies \text{mass of Fe} = 53.71\text{ g}

    Correct

    mass of Fe=32.44 g−21.27 g=11.17 g\text{mass of Fe} = 32.44\text{ g} - 21.27\text{ g} = 11.17\text{ g}

    Your addition 32.44 g+21.27 g=53.71 g32.44\text{ g} + 21.27\text{ g} = 53.71\text{ g} is arithmetically correct, but it evaluates an incorrect formula.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You extracted the given masses (32.44 g32.44\text{ g} and 21.27 g21.27\text{ g}) with correct units.

You carried out the decimal addition accurately without arithmetic slips.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect Mass Conservation Equation Setup

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the reaction as if all given values belong on the same side of the balance or confused which substances were reactants versus products, adding a reactant mass to a product mass rather than setting total reactants equal to total products.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Classify reactants and products
  • Substances before the reaction arrow are reactants; substances after the arrow are products.

  • Write Reactants→Products\text{Reactants} \rightarrow \text{Products} and identify that Fe\text{Fe} and Cl2\text{Cl}_2 combine to form FeCl3\text{FeCl}_3.

Set up the balance before solving
  • ∑mreactants=∑mproducts\sum m_{\text{reactants}} = \sum m_{\text{products}}.

  • Write mFe+mCl2=mFeCl3m_{\text{Fe}} + m_{\text{Cl}_2} = m_{\text{FeCl}_3} first, then algebraically rearrange to mFe=mFeCl3−mCl2m_{\text{Fe}} = m_{\text{FeCl}_3} - m_{\text{Cl}_2} before substituting numbers.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the mass conservation equation: mFe+mCl2=mFeCl3m_{\text{Fe}} + m_{\text{Cl}_2} = m_{\text{FeCl}_3}.

  2. Isolate the unknown mass of iron: mFe=mFeCl3−mCl2m_{\text{Fe}} = m_{\text{FeCl}_3} - m_{\text{Cl}_2}.

  3. Substitute the given masses: mFe=32.44 g−21.27 g=11.17 gm_{\text{Fe}} = 32.44\text{ g} - 21.27\text{ g} = 11.17\text{ g}.

Final answer

11.17 g11.17\text{ g}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write down the basic conservation identity total reactant mass=total product mass\text{total reactant mass} = \text{total product mass} before inserting values.

  • Check that your isolated reactant mass is strictly less than the total mass of the combined synthesis product.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student attempts to multiply the given masses by stoichiometric coefficients from the balanced equation (multiplying FeCl₃ by 2 and Cl₂ by 3) before subtracting, resulting in 1.07 g.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    mass of Fe=2(mass of FeClX3)−3(mass of ClX2)  ⟹  mass of Fe=2(32.44 g)−3(21.27 g)\text{mass of Fe} = 2(\text{mass of } \ce{FeCl3}) - 3(\text{mass of } \ce{Cl2}) \implies \text{mass of Fe} = 2(32.44\text{ g}) - 3(21.27\text{ g})

    Correct

    mass of Fe=mass of FeClX3−mass of ClX2=32.44 g−21.27 g\text{mass of Fe} = \text{mass of } \ce{FeCl3} - \text{mass of } \ce{Cl2} = 32.44\text{ g} - 21.27\text{ g}

    You multiplied the measured masses by the coefficients 22 and 33 from the balanced equation. Stoichiometric coefficients represent particle or mole ratios, not mass multipliers. Under the Law of Conservation of Mass, the actual masses of reactants directly add up to the total mass of products.

  2. Step 2

    mass of Fe=64.88 g−63.81 g  ⟹  mass of Fe=1.07 g\text{mass of Fe} = 64.88\text{ g} - 63.81\text{ g} \implies \text{mass of Fe} = 1.07\text{ g}

    Correct

    mass of Fe=11.17 g\text{mass of Fe} = 11.17\text{ g}

    You calculated the subtraction correctly according to your setup, but the final value of 1.07 g1.07\text{ g} is incorrect because of the coefficient scaling in the first step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that iron and chlorine combine to yield iron(III) chloride as the only product.

You correctly set up a subtraction to isolate the missing reactant from the total product mass.

You accurately performed the arithmetic on the numbers you set up.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Multiplying masses by stoichiometric coefficients

Multiplying measured gram quantities by chemical equation coefficients instead of applying direct mass balance.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing mole ratios with mass conservation. Stoichiometric coefficients indicate molar proportions in a balanced equation, whereas total mass in grams is conserved directly (mreactants=mproductsm_{\text{reactants}} = m_{\text{products}}) without multiplying by coefficients.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Conservation of Mass vs. Stoichiometry
  • In any closed system, ∑mreactants=∑mproducts\sum m_{\text{reactants}} = \sum m_{\text{products}} holds directly in grams.

  • Do not multiply masses in grams by balanced equation coefficients.

When to Use Coefficients
  • Coefficients (2,3,22, 3, 2) apply only when counting particles or converting moles, never directly to raw grams.

  • Use coefficients only in mole-to-mole ratios after converting grams to moles.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the Law of Conservation of Mass directly to the given quantities: mFe+mClX2=mFeClX3m_{\ce{Fe}} + m_{\ce{Cl2}} = m_{\ce{FeCl3}}.

  2. Substitute the measured values without multiplying by coefficients: mFe+21.27 g=32.44 gm_{\ce{Fe}} + 21.27\text{ g} = 32.44\text{ g}.

  3. Subtract to solve for the mass of iron: mFe=32.44 g−21.27 g=11.17 gm_{\ce{Fe}} = 32.44\text{ g} - 21.27\text{ g} = 11.17\text{ g}.

Final answer

Initial mass of Fe=11.17 g\text{Initial mass of Fe} = 11.17\text{ g}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the mass conservation formula mreactants=mproductsm_{\text{reactants}} = m_{\text{products}} using substance masses directly whenever total grams are given.

  • Reserve stoichiometric coefficients strictly for mole-ratio conversions (n1:n2n_1 : n_2), never for scaling masses (gg).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student subtracts the mass of product from the mass of chlorine gas, producing an impossible negative mass of -11.17 g.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    mass of Fe=mass of ClX2−mass of FeClX3\text{mass of Fe} = \text{mass of } \ce{Cl2} - \text{mass of } \ce{FeCl3}

    Correct

    mass of Fe+mass of ClX2=mass of FeClX3  ⟹  mass of Fe=mass of FeClX3−mass of ClX2\text{mass of Fe} + \text{mass of } \ce{Cl2} = \text{mass of } \ce{FeCl3} \implies \text{mass of Fe} = \text{mass of } \ce{FeCl3} - \text{mass of } \ce{Cl2}

    Because iron and chlorine gas combine to form iron(III) chloride, their masses add up to the total mass of product: mFe+mClX2=mFeClX3m_{\ce{Fe}} + m_{\ce{Cl2}} = m_{\ce{FeCl3}}. When you isolate the mass of iron, you must subtract the consumed chlorine from the product mass, not the other way around.

  2. Step 2

    mass of Fe=21.27 g−32.44 g\text{mass of Fe} = 21.27\text{ g} - 32.44\text{ g}

    Correct

    mass of Fe=32.44 g−21.27 g\text{mass of Fe} = 32.44\text{ g} - 21.27\text{ g}

    You substituted the given values correctly into your setup, but the subtraction order was carried over from the incorrect equation in Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    −11.17 g-11.17\text{ g}

    Correct

    11.17 g11.17\text{ g}

    Your arithmetic was accurate for the expression you evaluated, but mass cannot be negative. The correct difference yields a positive mass of 11.17 g11.17\text{ g}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that iron and chlorine combine to yield iron(III) chloride.

You used direct mass conservation without getting distracted by molar conversions.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equation rearrangement error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You reversed the minuend and subtrahend when solving for an unknown reactant mass, subtracting the larger product mass from the reactant mass rather than subtracting the known reactant from the total product.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Conservation of Mass Setup
  • ∑mreactants=∑mproducts\sum m_{\text{reactants}} = \sum m_{\text{products}} in any closed reaction system.

  • Always write the full addition equation (mA+mB=mCm_A + m_B = m_C) before isolating any single term.

Physical Reality Check
  • Mass is a scalar quantity and cannot be negative (m>0m > 0).

  • If your calculated mass is negative, pause immediately to re-check which quantity is the total product and which is the reactant.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the mass conservation equation: mFe+mClX2=mFeClX3m_{\ce{Fe}} + m_{\ce{Cl2}} = m_{\ce{FeCl3}}.

  2. Isolate the unknown mass of iron: mFe=mFeClX3−mClX2m_{\ce{Fe}} = m_{\ce{FeCl3}} - m_{\ce{Cl2}}.

  3. Substitute the given quantities: mFe=32.44 g−21.27 g=11.17 gm_{\ce{Fe}} = 32.44\text{ g} - 21.27\text{ g} = 11.17\text{ g}.

Final answer

11.17 g11.17\text{ g}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the fundamental balance equation mreactants=mproductsm_{\text{reactants}} = m_{\text{products}} before rearranging.

  • Perform a sanity check on signs and magnitudes: a single reactant's mass must always be strictly less than the total mass of the combined product.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A sample of magnesium metal burns completely in oxygen gas to yield 20.15 g20.15\text{ g} of magnesium oxide (MgO\text{MgO}). If 8.00 g8.00\text{ g} of oxygen gas was consumed in the sealed vessel, calculate the initial mass of magnesium reacted.

Answer

12.15 g12.15\text{ g}. By conservation of mass, mMg+mO2=mMgOm_{\text{Mg}} + m_{\text{O}_2} = m_{\text{MgO}}, so mMg=20.15 g−8.00 g=12.15 gm_{\text{Mg}} = 20.15\text{ g} - 8.00\text{ g} = 12.15\text{ g}.

02

When heated in an enclosed container, calcium carbonate decomposes completely according to CaCO3(s)→CaO(s)+CO2(g)\text{CaCO}_3(s) \rightarrow \text{CaO}(s) + \text{CO}_2(g). If 50.05 g50.05\text{ g} of CaCO3\text{CaCO}_3 produces 28.04 g28.04\text{ g} of solid calcium oxide, what mass of carbon dioxide gas escaped into the sealed chamber?

Answer

22.01 g22.01\text{ g}. For decomposition, mCaCO3=mCaO+mCO2m_{\text{CaCO}_3} = m_{\text{CaO}} + m_{\text{CO}_2}, so mCO2=50.05 g−28.04 g=22.01 gm_{\text{CO}_2} = 50.05\text{ g} - 28.04\text{ g} = 22.01\text{ g}.

03

In a single-displacement reaction, 13.08 g13.08\text{ g} of zinc reacts completely with 32.00 g32.00\text{ g} of copper(II) sulfate in solution to produce copper metal and zinc sulfate. If 12.71 g12.71\text{ g} of copper metal precipitates out, what mass of zinc sulfate remains dissolved in the solution?

Answer

32.37 g32.37\text{ g}. Total reactant mass is 13.08 g+32.00 g=45.08 g13.08\text{ g} + 32.00\text{ g} = 45.08\text{ g}. Total product mass must equal 45.08 g45.08\text{ g}, so mZnSO4=45.08 g−12.71 g=32.37 gm_{\text{ZnSO}_4} = 45.08\text{ g} - 12.71\text{ g} = 32.37\text{ g}.

Loading workspace…