Resources

A student constructs an electrochemical cell consisting of two identical copper strips, each immersed in a copper(II) sulfate solution, but with different concentrations: Compartment A contains 0.00500 M CuSO40.00500\text{ M }\text{CuSO}_4, and Compartment B contains 1.00 M CuSO41.00\text{ M }\text{CuSO}_4, joined by a salt bridge. A common misconception is that because both electrodes are identical (Ecell∘=0.00 VE^\circ_{\text{cell}} = 0.00\text{ V}), no electrical potential can be generated. (a) Demonstrate why this concentration cell functions spontaneously as a galvanic cell at 298 K298\text{ K} by calculating its initial cell potential EcellE_{\text{cell}} using the Nernst equation with n=2n = 2. (b) Identify whether Compartment A serves as the anode or the cathode, and describe what happens to [Cu2+][\text{Cu}^{2+}] in Compartment A as the cell discharges.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Ecell=+0.0681 VE_{\text{cell}} = +0.0681\text{ V} (spontaneous, Ecell>0E_{\text{cell}} > 0); (b) Compartment A is the anode (oxidation occurs: Cu(s)→Cu2+(aq)+2e−\text{Cu(s)} \rightarrow \text{Cu}^{2+}\text{(aq)} + 2e^-), so [Cu2+][\text{Cu}^{2+}] in Compartment A increases toward equilibrium.

Steps

Part (a): Calculating the Initial Cell Potential (EcellE_{\text{cell}})

A concentration cell consists of two identical half-cells differing only in ion concentrations. The standard cell potential is zero because both compartments involve the same chemical species: Ecell∘=Ecathode∘−Eanode∘=0.00 VE^\circ_{\text{cell}} = E^\circ_{\text{cathode}} - E^\circ_{\text{anode}} = 0.00\text{ V}

To operate spontaneously as a galvanic cell, the cell potential must be positive (Ecell>0E_{\text{cell}} > 0). According to Le Chatelier's principle and thermodynamics, the system spontaneously drives the two concentrations toward equality:

  • The more dilute half-cell produces CuX2+\ce{Cu^{2+}} ions through oxidation: Cu(s)→CuX2+(aq,dilute)+2 eX−\ce{Cu(s) -> Cu^{2+}(aq, \text{dilute}) + 2e^-}
  • The more concentrated half-cell consumes CuX2+\ce{Cu^{2+}} ions through reduction: CuX2+(aq,concentrated)+2 eX−→Cu(s)\ce{Cu^{2+}(aq, \text{concentrated}) + 2e^- -> Cu(s)}

Combining these gives the overall net cell reaction: CuX2+(aq,concentrated)→CuX2+(aq,dilute)\ce{Cu^{2+}(aq, \text{concentrated}) -> Cu^{2+}(aq, \text{dilute})}

The reaction quotient QQ is: Q=[CuX2+]dilute[CuX2+]concentrated=[CuX2+]A[CuX2+]B=0.00500 M1.00 M=5.00×10−3Q = \frac{[\ce{Cu^{2+}}]_{\text{dilute}}}{[\ce{Cu^{2+}}]_{\text{concentrated}}} = \frac{[\ce{Cu^{2+}}]_A}{[\ce{Cu^{2+}}]_B} = \frac{0.00500\text{ M}}{1.00\text{ M}} = 5.00 \times 10^{-3}

Applying the Nernst equation at 298 K298\text{ K} with n=2n = 2 electrons transferred: Ecell=Ecell∘−0.05916 Vnlog⁡10QE_{\text{cell}} = E^\circ_{\text{cell}} - \frac{0.05916\text{ V}}{n} \log_{10} Q

Ecell=0.00 V−0.05916 V2log⁡10(5.00×10−3)E_{\text{cell}} = 0.00\text{ V} - \frac{0.05916\text{ V}}{2} \log_{10}(5.00 \times 10^{-3})

Evaluating the logarithm: log⁡10(5.00×10−3)=log⁡10(5.00)+log⁡10(10−3)≈0.6990−3=−2.3010\log_{10}(5.00 \times 10^{-3}) = \log_{10}(5.00) + \log_{10}(10^{-3}) \approx 0.6990 - 3 = -2.3010

Substitute this back into the expression: Ecell=−0.02958 V×(−2.3010)=+0.0681 VE_{\text{cell}} = -0.02958\text{ V} \times (-2.3010) = +0.0681\text{ V}

Because Ecell>0E_{\text{cell}} > 0 (and correspondingly ΔG=−nFEcell<0\Delta G = -nFE_{\text{cell}} < 0), the cell operates spontaneously as a galvanic cell despite having identical electrodes.


Part (b): Identifying the Anode and the Concentration Change

  1. Electrode Identification:

    • Oxidation occurs at the anode: In the dilute compartment (Compartment A, 0.00500 M0.00500\text{ M}), copper metal is oxidized to copper(II) ions: Cu(s)→CuX2+(aq)+2 eX−\ce{Cu(s) -> Cu^{2+}(aq) + 2e^-}
    • Therefore, Compartment A serves as the anode.
  2. Change in Concentration:

    • As oxidation proceeds, Cu(s)\ce{Cu(s)} dissolves from the electrode, causing [CuX2+aq][\ce{Cu^{2+}}_{\text{aq}}] in Compartment A to increase.
    • Simultaneously, reduction at the cathode (Compartment B) consumes CuX2+\ce{Cu^{2+}}, decreasing [CuX2+]B[\ce{Cu^{2+}}]_B until both concentrations become equal at equilibrium, at which point Q=1Q = 1 and Ecell=0 VE_{\text{cell}} = 0\text{ V}.

Common Pitfall: A frequent mistake is inverting Q=[concentrated][dilute]Q = \frac{[\text{concentrated}]}{[\text{dilute}]}, which yields a negative potential. Remember that for a galvanic cell to be spontaneous, EcellE_{\text{cell}} must be positive, which requires Q<1Q < 1 so that −log⁡10Q>0-\log_{10} Q > 0. Therefore, QQ must always be [ion]dilute[ion]concentrated\frac{[\ce{ion}]_{\text{dilute}}}{[\ce{ion}]_{\text{concentrated}}}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student inverts the reaction quotient Q by placing the concentrated solution in the numerator, resulting in a negative cell potential.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Ecell=0.00 V−(0.0592 V2)log⁡(1.000.00500)  ⟹  Ecell=−0.0296 V×log⁡(200)  ⟹  Ecell=−0.0296 V×2.301=−0.0681 VE_{\text{cell}} = 0.00\text{ V} - \left(\frac{0.0592\text{ V}}{2}\right)\log\left(\frac{1.00}{0.00500}\right) \implies E_{\text{cell}} = -0.0296\text{ V} \times \log(200) \implies E_{\text{cell}} = -0.0296\text{ V} \times 2.301 = -0.0681\text{ V}

    Correct

    Ecell=0.00 V−(0.0592 V2)log⁡(0.005001.00)=−0.0296 V×(−2.301)=+0.0681 VE_{\text{cell}} = 0.00\text{ V} - \left(\frac{0.0592\text{ V}}{2}\right)\log\left(\frac{0.00500}{1.00}\right) = -0.0296\text{ V} \times (-2.301) = +0.0681\text{ V}

    You inverted the reaction quotient QQ. In a spontaneous concentration cell, oxidation produces ions in the dilute compartment (products) while reduction consumes ions in the concentrated compartment (reactants). Therefore, Q=[Cu2+]dilute[Cu2+]concentrated=0.005001.00=5.00×10−3Q = \frac{[\text{Cu}^{2+}]_{\text{dilute}}}{[\text{Cu}^{2+}]_{\text{concentrated}}} = \frac{0.00500}{1.00} = 5.00 \times 10^{-3}.

  2. Step 2

    Because Ecell<0, the reaction is non-spontaneous.\text{Because } E_{\text{cell}} < 0\text{, the reaction is non-spontaneous.}

    Correct

    Because Ecell=+0.0681 V>0, the cell operates spontaneously as a galvanic cell.\text{Because } E_{\text{cell}} = +0.0681\text{ V} > 0\text{, the cell operates spontaneously as a galvanic cell.}

    This conclusion followed directly from your negative cell potential in Step 1. Because the correct EcellE_{\text{cell}} is positive (+0.0681 V+0.0681\text{ V}), the cell reaction is spontaneous.

  3. Step 3

    Compartment A is the anode. [Cu2+] in Compartment A increases as the cell discharges.\text{Compartment A is the anode. } [\text{Cu}^{2+}] \text{ in Compartment A increases as the cell discharges.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified Compartment A as the anode where oxidation takes place.

You correctly recognized that the concentration of copper(II) ions in Compartment A must increase as the cell discharges toward equilibrium.

You correctly applied the mathematical form of the Nernst equation and handled the logarithmic arithmetic accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted reaction quotient in Nernst equation

You accidentally placed the concentrated solution over the dilute solution in the logarithm ratio instead of putting products over reactants.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

In concentration cells, spontaneous discharge always drives the system toward equal concentrations. The dilute compartment produces ions (extproduct ext{product}), while the concentrated compartment consumes ions (extreactant ext{reactant}). Remembering that Q=[ion]dilute[ion]concentrated<1Q = \frac{[\text{ion}]_{\text{dilute}}}{[\text{ion}]_{\text{concentrated}}} < 1 ensures that log⁡Q<0\log Q < 0, yielding the required positive cell potential (Ecell>0E_{\text{cell}} > 0).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define the Net Cell Reaction First
  • Spontaneous direction: ionconcentrated→iondilute\text{ion}_{\text{concentrated}} \rightarrow \text{ion}_{\text{dilute}}.

  • Always write down the net transfer reaction before substituting values into the Nernst equation to verify which concentration belongs in the numerator.

Sanity Check the Sign of E_cell
  • A functioning galvanic cell must have Ecell>0E_{\text{cell}} > 0.

  • Since Ecell∘=0 VE^\circ_{\text{cell}} = 0\text{ V} for concentration cells, Ecell=−0.0592nlog⁡QE_{\text{cell}} = -\frac{0.0592}{n}\log Q. For EcellE_{\text{cell}} to be positive, QQ must be less than 11.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the overall cell reaction: Cu2+(conc, 1.00 M)→Cu2+(dilute, 0.00500 M)\text{Cu}^{2+}(\text{conc, 1.00 M}) \rightarrow \text{Cu}^{2+}(\text{dilute, 0.00500 M}).

  2. Express the reaction quotient: Q=[Cu2+]dilute[Cu2+]conc=0.005001.00=5.00×10−3Q = \frac{[\text{Cu}^{2+}]_{\text{dilute}}}{[\text{Cu}^{2+}]_{\text{conc}}} = \frac{0.00500}{1.00} = 5.00 \times 10^{-3}.

  3. Apply the Nernst equation: Ecell=0.00 V−(0.0592 V2)log⁡(5.00×10−3)=−0.0296 V×(−2.301)=+0.0681 VE_{\text{cell}} = 0.00\text{ V} - \left(\frac{0.0592\text{ V}}{2}\right)\log(5.00 \times 10^{-3}) = -0.0296\text{ V} \times (-2.301) = +0.0681\text{ V}.

Final answer

(a) Ecell=+0.0681 VE_{\text{cell}} = +0.0681\text{ V} (spontaneous); (b) Compartment A is the anode, and [Cu2+][\text{Cu}^{2+}] increases.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how to write net cell reactions for concentration cells by identifying which side acts as products.

  • Practice using the rule Q=[dilute][concentrated]Q = \frac{[\text{dilute}]}{[\text{concentrated}]} on concentration cell problems to guarantee Ecell>0E_{\text{cell}} > 0.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misidentifies the more dilute compartment as the cathode, mistakenly concluding that Cu²⁺ undergoes reduction in Compartment A and that its concentration decreases.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Ecell=0.00 V−0.0592 V2log⁡(0.005001.00)  ⟹  Ecell=−0.0296 V×(−2.301)=+0.0681 V  ⟹  Since Ecell>0, the cell operates spontaneously.E_{\text{cell}} = 0.00\text{ V} - \frac{0.0592\text{ V}}{2}\log\left(\frac{0.00500}{1.00}\right) \implies E_{\text{cell}} = -0.0296\text{ V} \times (-2.301) = +0.0681\text{ V} \implies \text{Since } E_{\text{cell}} > 0\text{, the cell operates spontaneously.}

  2. Step 2

    Compartment A serves as the cathode.\text{Compartment A serves as the cathode.}

    Correct

    Compartment A serves as the anode.\text{Compartment A serves as the anode.}

    To move toward equilibrium, the concentration cell must increase the ion concentration in the dilute solution. This requires oxidation (Cu(s)→CuX2+(aq)+2 eX−\ce{Cu(s) -> Cu^{2+}(aq) + 2e^-}), which takes place at the anode.

  3. Step 3

    Reduction occurs in Compartment A, so [CuX2+] decreases as the cell discharges.\text{Reduction occurs in Compartment A, so } [\ce{Cu^{2+}}] \text{ decreases as the cell discharges.}

    Correct

    Oxidation occurs in Compartment A, so [CuX2+] increases as the cell discharges.\text{Oxidation occurs in Compartment A, so } [\ce{Cu^{2+}}] \text{ increases as the cell discharges.}

    Because Compartment A was misidentified as the cathode, you concluded that reduction occurs there; in reality, oxidation occurs at the anode, causing [CuX2+][\ce{Cu^{2+}}] in Compartment A to increase.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the Nernst equation to determine that the cell potential is +0.0681 V+0.0681\text{ V}.

You correctly connected a positive cell potential to spontaneous galvanic cell operation.

You understood that reduction at a cathode decreases aqueous cation concentration.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Concentration cell half-cell role misidentification

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated the dilute compartment with reduction rather than oxidation, overlooking that a concentration cell spontaneously drives concentrations toward equality by generating more ions in the dilute compartment (oxidation at the anode) and removing ions from the concentrated compartment (reduction at the cathode).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Equilibrium Direction in Concentration Cells
  • Concentration cells spontaneously discharge toward equal ion concentrations in both half-cells.

  • Assign oxidation (anode) to the dilute chamber so it gains ions, and reduction (cathode) to the concentrated chamber so it loses ions.

Connecting Reaction Quotient to Cell Half-Reactions
  • In the cell reaction MXn+(aq,conc)→MXn+(aq,dil)\ce{M^{n+}(aq, conc) -> M^{n+}(aq, dil)}, the dilute ions are products.

  • Since dilute ions are formed as products, metal is oxidized to aqueous ions at the anode: M(s)→MXn+(dil)+n eX−\ce{M(s) -> M^{n+}(dil) + n e^-}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Establish the physical goal of the concentration cell: both compartments must move toward equal concentrations.

  2. Compartment A is dilute (0.00500 M0.00500\text{ M}), so its concentration must increase: Cu(s)→CuX2+(aq)+2 eX−\ce{Cu(s) -> Cu^{2+}(aq) + 2e^-}.

  3. Because oxidation occurs in Compartment A, Compartment A is the anode.

  4. As the cell discharges, oxidation continuously dissolves Cu(s)\ce{Cu(s)}, meaning [CuX2+][\ce{Cu^{2+}}] in Compartment A increases toward equilibrium.

Final answer

Compartment A serves as the anode, and [CuX2+][\ce{Cu^{2+}}] in Compartment A increases as the cell discharges.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the mnemonic: 'Dilute = Anode' (D−AD-A) and 'Concentrated = Cathode' (C−CC-C) for any single-element concentration cell.

  • Practice sketching concentration cells showing electron flow leaving the dilute anode and moving toward the concentrated cathode.

  • Solve follow-up concentration cell problems involving ions of different charges such as AgX+\ce{Ag+} or AlX3+\ce{Al^3+}.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student uses n = 1 instead of n = 2 for the Cu²⁺/Cu redox couple, doubling the calculated cell potential.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Ecell=0.00 V−(0.0592 V1)log⁡(0.005001.00)  ⟹  Ecell=−0.0592 V×(−2.301)=+0.136 VE_{\text{cell}} = 0.00\text{ V} - \left(\frac{0.0592\text{ V}}{1}\right)\log\left(\frac{0.00500}{1.00}\right) \implies E_{\text{cell}} = -0.0592\text{ V} \times (-2.301) = +0.136\text{ V}

    Correct

    Ecell=0.00 V−(0.0592 V2)log⁡(0.005001.00)=−0.0296 V×(−2.301)=+0.0681 VE_{\text{cell}} = 0.00\text{ V} - \left(\frac{0.0592\text{ V}}{2}\right)\log\left(\frac{0.00500}{1.00}\right) = -0.0296\text{ V} \times (-2.301) = +0.0681\text{ V}

    You used n=1n = 1 in the denominator of the Nernst equation. Because the redox couple involves the transfer of two electrons (CuX2++2 eX−⇌Cu\ce{Cu^{2+} + 2e^- <=> Cu}), the number of moles of electrons transferred is n=2n = 2.

  2. Step 2

    Ecell>0, so the galvanic cell operates spontaneously.E_{\text{cell}} > 0\text{, so the galvanic cell operates spontaneously.}

  3. Step 3

    Compartment A is the anode.\text{Compartment A is the anode.}

  4. Step 4

    [CuX2+] in Compartment A increases during discharge.[\ce{Cu^{2+}}]\text{ in Compartment A increases during discharge.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the standard potential Ecell∘=0.00 VE^\circ_{\text{cell}} = 0.00\text{ V} for identical copper electrodes.

You set up the reaction quotient correctly as Q=[CuX2+]dilute[CuX2+]concentrated=0.005001.00Q = \frac{[\ce{Cu^{2+}}]_{\text{dilute}}}{[\ce{Cu^{2+}}]_{\text{concentrated}}} = \frac{0.00500}{1.00}.

You correctly determined that Compartment A is the anode and that its [CuX2+][\ce{Cu^{2+}}] will increase over time.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect electron transfer number (n)

You substituted n=1n = 1 into the Nernst denominator instead of the given n=2n = 2, doubling your resulting potential.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the ionic charge of the electroactive species (CuX2+\ce{Cu^{2+}} requires two electrons per ion reduced or oxidized: CuX2++2 eX−⇌Cu\ce{Cu^{2+} + 2e^- <=> Cu}), leading to using n=1n = 1 instead of n=2n = 2.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Determine $n$ from Balanced Half-Reactions
  • In the Nernst equation, nn represents the number of moles of electrons transferred in the balanced overall redox reaction.

  • Always write down the half-reaction (e.g., CuX2+(aq)+2 eX−→Cu(s)\ce{Cu^{2+}(aq) + 2e^- -> Cu(s)}) to verify the value of nn before computing.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute n=2n = 2 into the Nernst pre-factor: 0.0592 V2=0.0296 V\frac{0.0592\text{ V}}{2} = 0.0296\text{ V}.

  2. Compute the logarithm: log⁡10(5.00×10−3)≈−2.301\log_{10}(5.00 \times 10^{-3}) \approx -2.301.

  3. Multiply to find the potential: Ecell=0.00 V−(0.0296 V)(−2.301)=+0.0681 VE_{\text{cell}} = 0.00\text{ V} - (0.0296\text{ V})(-2.301) = +0.0681\text{ V}.

Final answer

(a) Ecell=+0.0681 VE_{\text{cell}} = +0.0681\text{ V} (spontaneous); (b) Compartment A is the anode, and [CuX2+][\ce{Cu^{2+}}] in Compartment A increases during discharge.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check the ionic oxidation states involved in the cell reaction to assign nn reliably.

  • Practice calculating cell potentials for concentration cells with different metal ions (e.g., AgX+\ce{Ag+}, ZnX2+\ce{Zn^{2+}}, AlX3+\ce{Al^{3+}}) to build fluency with values of nn.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A concentration cell is constructed from two zinc electrodes in ZnSO4\text{ZnSO}_4 solutions of 0.010 M0.010\text{ M} and 2.00 M2.00\text{ M} at 298 K298\text{ K}. Calculate the initial cell potential EcellE_{\text{cell}} using the Nernst equation with n=2n = 2.

Answer

Ecell=+0.068 VE_{\text{cell}} = +0.068\text{ V}. Set Q=[Zn2+]dilute[Zn2+]conc=0.0102.00=5.0×10−3Q = \frac{[\text{Zn}^{2+}]_{\text{dilute}}}{[\text{Zn}^{2+}]_{\text{conc}}} = \frac{0.010}{2.00} = 5.0 \times 10^{-3}. Then Ecell=0.00−0.05922log⁡(5.0×10−3)=−0.0296×(−2.301)=+0.068 VE_{\text{cell}} = 0.00 - \frac{0.0592}{2}\log(5.0 \times 10^{-3}) = -0.0296 \times (-2.301) = +0.068\text{ V}.

02

An electrochemical cell has two silver electrodes: Compartment 1 contains 0.025 M Ag+0.025\text{ M }\text{Ag}^+ and Compartment 2 contains 0.50 M Ag+0.50\text{ M }\text{Ag}^+ at 298 K298\text{ K}. (n=1n = 1). (a) Write the net cell reaction. (b) Calculate EcellE_{\text{cell}}.

Answer

(a) Ag+(aq, 0.50 M)→Ag+(aq, 0.025 M)\text{Ag}^+(\text{aq, 0.50 M}) \rightarrow \text{Ag}^+(\text{aq, 0.025 M}). (b) Ecell=+0.077 VE_{\text{cell}} = +0.077\text{ V}. Here Q=0.0250.50=0.050Q = \frac{0.025}{0.50} = 0.050. Ecell=0.00−0.0592log⁡(0.050)=−0.0592(−1.301)=+0.077 VE_{\text{cell}} = 0.00 - 0.0592\log(0.050) = -0.0592(-1.301) = +0.077\text{ V}.

03

A concentration cell consisting of Cu(s)∣Cu2+(x M)∣∣Cu2+(1.50 M)∣Cu(s)\text{Cu(s)}|\text{Cu}^{2+}(x\text{ M})||\text{Cu}^{2+}(1.50\text{ M})|\text{Cu(s)} generates a potential of +0.0888 V+0.0888\text{ V} at 298 K298\text{ K} (n=2n = 2). Find the unknown concentration xx of the dilute compartment.

Answer

x=1.50×10−3 Mx = 1.50 \times 10^{-3}\text{ M}. Use Ecell=−0.05922log⁡Q  ⟹  0.0888=−0.0296log⁡Q  ⟹  log⁡Q=−3.00  ⟹  Q=1.00×10−3E_{\text{cell}} = -\frac{0.0592}{2}\log Q \implies 0.0888 = -0.0296\log Q \implies \log Q = -3.00 \implies Q = 1.00 \times 10^{-3}. Since Q=x1.50Q = \frac{x}{1.50}, x=1.50×10−3 Mx = 1.50 \times 10^{-3}\text{ M}.

Loading workspace…