Resources

A newly synthesized artificial element consists of a primary isotope 284E^{284}\text{E} with an isotopic mass of 284.000 amu284.000\text{ amu} and a secondary trace isotope 286E^{286}\text{E} with an isotopic mass of 286.010 amu286.010\text{ amu}. High-precision mass spectrometry requires that the shift in the weighted average atomic mass relative to the base isotope 284E^{284}\text{E} must not exceed a critical threshold limit of Δm=0.0500 amu\Delta m = 0.0500\text{ amu}. Determine the maximum allowable percent abundance of the heavier isotope 286E^{286}\text{E} to satisfy this boundary condition.

Answer and steps

Final answer

2.49%2.49\%

Steps

01

Define the relationship for the average atomic mass

Let xx represent the fractional abundance of the heavier trace isotope 286E^{286}\ce{E}. Since the element consists of only two isotopes, the fractional abundance of the base isotope 284E^{284}\ce{E} is: 1−x1 - x

The weighted average atomic mass mavgm_{\text{avg}} is the sum of the products of each isotope's mass and its fractional abundance: mavg=(1−x)⋅m1+x⋅m2m_{\text{avg}} = (1 - x) \cdot m_1 + x \cdot m_2

where:

  • m1=284.000 amum_1 = 284.000\text{ amu} (mass of 284E^{284}\ce{E})
  • m2=286.010 amum_2 = 286.010\text{ amu} (mass of 286E^{286}\ce{E})

Expanding and rearranging the terms gives: mavg=m1+x(m2−m1)m_{\text{avg}} = m_1 + x(m_2 - m_1)


02

Relate the mass shift to the abundance

The mass shift Δm\Delta m relative to the base isotope 284E^{284}\ce{E} is the difference between the average atomic mass and m1m_1: Δm=mavg−m1=x(m2−m1)\Delta m = m_{\text{avg}} - m_1 = x(m_2 - m_1)

Calculate the mass difference between the two isotopes: m2−m1=286.010 amu−284.000 amu=2.010 amum_2 - m_1 = 286.010\text{ amu} - 284.000\text{ amu} = 2.010\text{ amu}

Therefore, the condition that the mass shift cannot exceed 0.0500 amu0.0500\text{ amu} is written as: x⋅2.010 amu≤0.0500 amux \cdot 2.010\text{ amu} \le 0.0500\text{ amu}


03

Solve for the maximum percent abundance

Isolate the fractional abundance xx: x≤0.0500 amu2.010 amu≈0.024876x \le \frac{0.0500\text{ amu}}{2.010\text{ amu}} \approx 0.024876

Convert the fractional abundance to a percentage by multiplying by 100%100\%: Percent abundance≤0.024876×100%≈2.49%\text{Percent abundance} \le 0.024876 \times 100\% \approx 2.49\%

(Common pitfall: Dividing the mass shift by the mass of the heavier isotope itself instead of the mass difference between the two isotopes ΔM=m2−m1\Delta M = m_2 - m_1.)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates the mass difference using nominal mass numbers rather than high-precision isotopic masses, leading to an overestimation of the allowable percentage.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Δm=(286−284)x=2x\Delta m = (286 - 284)x = 2x

    Correct

    Δm=(286.010−284.000)x=2.010x\Delta m = (286.010 - 284.000)x = 2.010x

    You correctly set up the mass shift equation as Δm=(m2−m1)x\Delta m = (m_2 - m_1)x, but you substituted the integer mass numbers (286286 and 284284) rather than the provided high-precision isotopic masses (286.010 amu286.010\text{ amu} and 284.000 amu284.000\text{ amu}).

  2. Step 2

    2x≤0.0500  ⟹  x≤0.02502x \le 0.0500 \implies x \le 0.0250

    Correct

    2.010x≤0.0500  ⟹  x≤0.0248762.010x \le 0.0500 \implies x \le 0.024876

    Your algebraic steps to isolate the fractional abundance xx were correct, but the calculation was affected by using 22 instead of 2.0102.010 in the denominator.

  3. Step 3

    Maximum percent abundance=2.50%\text{Maximum percent abundance} = 2.50\%

    Correct

    Maximum percent abundance=2.49%\text{Maximum percent abundance} = 2.49\%

    You correctly converted your fraction to a percentage, but because of the initial rounding in the mass difference, your answer rounded to 2.50%2.50\% instead of the exact 2.49%2.49\%.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly expressed the average mass shift as Δm=x(m2−m1)\Delta m = x(m_2 - m_1).

You set up the boundary inequality accurately using the threshold limit of 0.0500 amu0.0500\text{ amu}.

You correctly converted the fractional abundance into a percentage.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Mass number substituted for isotopic mass

You used the integer mass numbers (286286 and 284284) instead of the given high-precision isotopic values (286.010 amu286.010\text{ amu} and 284.000 amu284.000\text{ amu}).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating nominal mass numbers (the total count of protons and neutrons, AA) with actual, high-precision isotopic masses (mm). In high-precision mass spectrometry, nuclear binding energy causes actual isotopic masses to deviate slightly from whole numbers, and these small differences are significant when dividing by small mass shifts.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Isotopic Mass vs. Mass Number
  • Always substitute given high-precision isotopic masses (mim_i) rather than integer mass numbers (AA) unless the problem explicitly states that isotopic masses equal mass numbers.

  • Check the problem statement for given isotopic masses with decimal places and use their full precision in differences.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the precise mass difference between the two isotopes: ΔM=286.010 amu−284.000 amu=2.010 amu\Delta M = 286.010\text{ amu} - 284.000\text{ amu} = 2.010\text{ amu}.

  2. Formulate the threshold inequality: 2.010x≤0.0500 amu2.010x \le 0.0500\text{ amu}.

  3. Solve for the maximum fractional abundance: x≤0.05002.010≈0.024876x \le \frac{0.0500}{2.010} \approx 0.024876.

  4. Convert to percentage with appropriate significant figures: 0.024876×100%≈2.49%0.024876 \times 100\% \approx 2.49\%.

Final answer

2.49%2.49\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • When calculating mass differences in atomic structure or mass spectrometry problems, double-check that you are using high-precision isotopic masses with all provided decimal places.

  • Practice tracking significant figures during multi-step division involving small mass differences.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student correctly calculates the fractional abundance but forgets to multiply by 100% to convert it to a percent abundance.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    mdiff=286.010−284.000=2.010 amum_{\text{diff}} = 286.010 - 284.000 = 2.010\text{ amu}

  2. Step 2

    2.010⋅x≤0.0500  ⟹  x≤0.0500/2.010≈0.02492.010 \cdot x \le 0.0500 \implies x \le 0.0500 / 2.010 \approx 0.0249

  3. Step 3

    Maximum percent abundance=0.0249%\text{Maximum percent abundance} = 0.0249\%

    Correct

    Percent abundance=x×100%=0.0249×100%=2.49%\text{Percent abundance} = x \times 100\% = 0.0249 \times 100\% = 2.49\%

    To convert a decimal fraction to a percentage, you must multiply by 100%100\%. Appending the percent symbol without multiplying reduces the value by a factor of 100100.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the isotopic mass difference ΔM=2.010 amu\Delta M = 2.010\text{ amu}.

You accurately set up the inequality relating the fractional abundance to the critical mass shift threshold.

You correctly evaluated the numerical quotient to find the fractional abundance x≈0.0249x \approx 0.0249.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Fraction-to-percent conversion omission

You attached the percent sign directly to the decimal fractional abundance without scaling by 100100.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing decimal fractional abundance with percent abundance by treating the percent symbol as a decorative unit rather than an operator representing division by 100100.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Converting Decimal to Percentage
  • Percent (%)=Fractional value×100%\text{Percent (\%)} = \text{Fractional value} \times 100\%

  • Always multiply any decimal proportion by 100100 before writing the %\% sign.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Take the fractional abundance x≈0.024876x \approx 0.024876.

  2. Multiply by 100%100\%: 0.024876×100%=2.4876%0.024876 \times 100\% = 2.4876\%.

  3. Round to three significant figures to match the given data: 2.49%2.49\%.

Final answer

2.49%2.49\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between a dimensionless fractional abundance (which sums to 11) and a percent abundance (which sums to 100%100\%).

  • Perform a sanity check on final percentage values: 0.0249%0.0249\% would mean roughly 11 atom out of 40004000, whereas 0.0500/2.0100.0500 / 2.010 represents roughly 11 atom out of 4040, which is 2.5%2.5\%.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student divides the mass shift limit by the mass of the heavier isotope itself rather than the difference between the isotopic masses.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    286.010⋅x≤0.0500286.010 \cdot x \le 0.0500

    Correct

    (286.010−284.000)⋅x≤0.0500  ⟹  2.010x≤0.0500(286.010 - 284.000) \cdot x \le 0.0500 \implies 2.010x \le 0.0500

    The shift Δm\Delta m relative to the base isotope 284E^{284}\text{E} is caused only by the excess mass per heavier atom, (m2−m1)=2.010 amu(m_2 - m_1) = 2.010\text{ amu}, not by the entire mass of 286E^{286}\text{E}.

  2. Step 2

    x≤0.0500/286.010≈0.0001748x \le 0.0500 / 286.010 \approx 0.0001748

    Correct

    x≤0.05002.010≈0.02488x \le \frac{0.0500}{2.010} \approx 0.02488

    This calculation followed correctly from your formula, but it carries forward the incorrect divisor from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    Maximum percent abundance=0.0175%\text{Maximum percent abundance} = 0.0175\%

    Correct

    Maximum percent abundance=2.49%\text{Maximum percent abundance} = 2.49\%

    You correctly converted your fraction to a percentage by multiplying by 100%100\%, but the numerical value is affected by the earlier setup error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the threshold limit defines an upper-bound inequality for the fractional abundance xx.

You accurately solved your algebraic inequality and converted the resulting decimal fraction into a percent abundance.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
divisor choice in mass shift equation

You substituted the absolute mass of the heavier isotope (286.010 amu286.010\text{ amu}) into the rate of mass change rather than its excess mass over the base isotope (2.010 amu2.010\text{ amu}).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the total mass contribution of an isotope (m2xm_2 x) with its incremental contribution to the shift in average mass relative to a base isotope (Δm=(m2−m1)x\Delta m = (m_2 - m_1)x).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Average Mass Shift Formula
  • When a mixture has a base isotope of mass m1m_1 and a secondary isotope of mass m2m_2 with fractional abundance xx, the average mass is mavg=m1+x(m2−m1)m_{\text{avg}} = m_1 + x(m_2 - m_1), meaning Δm=x(m2−m1)\Delta m = x(m_2 - m_1).

  • Always define the mass shift using the mass difference ΔM=m2−m1\Delta M = m_2 - m_1 rather than the absolute mass m2m_2.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the incremental mass added by each 286E^{286}\text{E} atom: ΔM=286.010 amu−284.000 amu=2.010 amu\Delta M = 286.010\text{ amu} - 284.000\text{ amu} = 2.010\text{ amu}.

  2. Write the mass shift inequality: x⋅2.010 amu≤0.0500 amux \cdot 2.010\text{ amu} \le 0.0500\text{ amu}.

  3. Isolate the fractional abundance: x≤0.05002.010≈0.024876x \le \frac{0.0500}{2.010} \approx 0.024876.

  4. Convert the fractional abundance to a percentage: x×100%≤2.49%x \times 100\% \le 2.49\%.

Final answer

2.49%2.49\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out mavg=(1−x)m1+xm2m_{\text{avg}} = (1-x)m_1 + xm_2 and algebraically rearrange it to mavg−m1=x(m2−m1)m_{\text{avg}} - m_1 = x(m_2 - m_1) before plugging in values.

  • Check the physical reasonableness of your result: since the isotopes differ by about 2 amu2\text{ amu}, an allowable shift of 0.05 amu0.05\text{ amu} should be roughly 0.052≈2.5%\frac{0.05}{2} \approx 2.5\%, not 0.018%0.018\%.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A sample of element X\text{X} contains base isotope 70X^{70}\text{X} (69.924 amu69.924\text{ amu}) and trace isotope 72X^{72}\text{X} (71.928 amu71.928\text{ amu}). If the average atomic mass cannot exceed 69.964 amu69.964\text{ amu}, determine the maximum allowable percent abundance of 72X^{72}\text{X}.

Answer

The mass shift is Δm=69.964−69.924=0.040 amu\Delta m = 69.964 - 69.924 = 0.040\text{ amu}. The isotopic mass difference is m2−m1=71.928−69.924=2.004 amum_2 - m_1 = 71.928 - 69.924 = 2.004\text{ amu}. Setting Δm=x(m2−m1)\Delta m = x(m_2 - m_1) gives x=0.0402.004≈0.01996x = \frac{0.040}{2.004} \approx 0.01996. Therefore, the maximum abundance is 2.00%2.00\%.

02

An analytical standard for element Q\text{Q} consists of 120Q^{120}\text{Q} (119.902 amu119.902\text{ amu}) and 122Q^{122}\text{Q} (121.908 amu121.908\text{ amu}). A laboratory protocol specifies that the average atomic mass must remain within 0.100 amu0.100\text{ amu} of 120Q^{120}\text{Q}. Calculate the maximum allowed percent abundance of 122Q^{122}\text{Q}, and find the error in percent abundance if one mistakenly uses nominal mass numbers (122−120=2122 - 120 = 2).

Answer

Using precise masses: ΔM=121.908−119.902=2.006 amu\Delta M = 121.908 - 119.902 = 2.006\text{ amu}, so x=0.1002.006≈0.04985  ⟹  4.99%x = \frac{0.100}{2.006} \approx 0.04985 \implies 4.99\%. Using nominal numbers: x=0.1002=0.0500  ⟹  5.00%x = \frac{0.100}{2} = 0.0500 \implies 5.00\%. The overestimation error is 5.00%−4.99%=+0.01%5.00\% - 4.99\% = +0.01\%.

03

A synthetic actinide element consists of three isotopes: base 240An^{240}\text{An} (240.053 amu240.053\text{ amu}, 95.0%95.0\%), trace 241An^{241}\text{An} (241.057 amu241.057\text{ amu}, xx), and trace 242An^{242}\text{An} (242.062 amu242.062\text{ amu}, 5.0%−x5.0\% - x). Find the value of xx (as a percentage) such that the average atomic mass equals exactly 240.150 amu240.150\text{ amu}.

Answer

Let mass shifts be relative to 240An^{240}\text{An}: Δm=240.150−240.053=0.097 amu\Delta m = 240.150 - 240.053 = 0.097\text{ amu}. Isotopic differences: Δm1=241.057−240.053=1.004 amu\Delta m_1 = 241.057 - 240.053 = 1.004\text{ amu} and Δm2=242.062−240.053=2.009 amu\Delta m_2 = 242.062 - 240.053 = 2.009\text{ amu}. Total shift equation: x(1.004)+(0.050−x)(2.009)=0.097x(1.004) + (0.050 - x)(2.009) = 0.097. Expanding: 1.004x+0.10045−2.009x=0.097  ⟹  −1.005x=−0.00345  ⟹  x≈0.0034331.004x + 0.10045 - 2.009x = 0.097 \implies -1.005x = -0.00345 \implies x \approx 0.003433, which corresponds to 0.34%0.34\%.

Loading workspace…