Resources
A chemistry student mistakenly names as 'chromium nitrate' and as 'tin(II) chloride'. (a) Identify the exact charge/oxidation state and oxoanion convention errors made by the student. (b) Provide the correct systematic Stock IUPAC names for both compounds.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) For , the student confused the nitrite ion () with the nitrate ion (); for , the student failed to balance the four chloride ions and assigned an incorrect oxidation state to tin instead of . (b) : Chromium(III) nitrite; : Tin(IV) chloride
Steps
Part (a): Identifying the Errors
-
Analysis of :
- Oxoanion Naming Convention Error: The anion present is , which is the nitrite ion. The nitrate ion has the chemical formula . The student incorrectly used the suffix -ate instead of -ite.
- Stock System / Oxidation State Error: Chromium () is a transition metal with variable oxidation states, requiring a Roman numeral in parentheses. Because three nitrite ions have a total charge of , the chromium cation must have an oxidation state of (). The student omitted the Roman numeral entirely, failing to specify the oxidation state.
-
Analysis of :
- Oxidation State Calculation Error: Chloride is a monoatomic anion with a charge of (). Four chloride ions contribute a total charge of .
- For the compound to be electrically neutral, tin must balance this with a charge of :
- The student incorrectly assigned tin an oxidation state of instead of , mistakenly writing instead of .
Part (b): Systematic Stock IUPAC Names
-
For :
- Cation: Chromium with a oxidation state Chromium(III)
- Anion: nitrite
- Correct Name: Chromium(III) nitrite
-
For :
- Cation: Tin with a oxidation state Tin(IV)
- Anion: chloride
- Correct Name: Tin(IV) chloride
Common Pitfall
- Do not rely on common fixed charges for metals in the d-block or lower p-block (like and ); always deduce the metal's charge from the known charge of the accompanying anions to determine the correct Roman numeral.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses roman numerals with the subscript of the metal rather than its oxidation state, naming SnCl4 as tin(I) chloride.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
Roman numerals in the Stock system represent the oxidation state (cation charge), not the chemical subscript. Since four ions carry a total charge of , tin must be .
- Step 3
- Step 4Correct
This name carried forward the incorrect oxidation state from your earlier step. The correct name is tin(IV) chloride.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that is nitrite rather than nitrate.
You correctly noted that the original name omitted chromium's oxidation state.
You accurately named as chromium(III) nitrite.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that the Roman numeral in parentheses corresponds to the metal atom's subscript in the formula, rather than the metal's oxidation state found by balancing the anion charges.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Meaning of Roman Numerals in Stock Nomenclature
The Roman numeral indicates the cation's oxidation state (charge), never its stoichiometric subscript.
Always compute the cation's oxidation state by setting the sum of all cation and anion charges in the neutral formula unit equal to .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the charge of the anion: each chloride ion is (charge of ).
Multiply by the number of anions: .
Set the compound to neutral charge: .
Express the oxidation state as Roman numeral .
Combine the cation and anion names: .
Tin(IV) chloride
02 The student assumes nitrate and nitrite have different charges and assigns NO2 a charge of -2, leading to an incorrect metal oxidation state of +6.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The anion has a charge, so is instead of uncharged, and nitrite was misnamed nitrate.
CorrectThe anion (nitrite) has a charge, so three nitrite ions contribute , requiring chromium to have an oxidation state of (). The original student committed two errors: confusing nitrite with nitrate and omitting the Roman numeral for chromium's oxidation state.
You correctly noted that the anion is nitrite rather than nitrate. However, the nitrite ion has a charge of (), not . Consequently, has an oxidation state of rather than .
- Step 2
For , is so is , but the student mistakenly used .
- Step 3
is chromium(VI) nitrite
Correctis chromium(III) nitrite
This step propagates your earlier error where you assigned a charge of . Because nitrite carries a charge, the compound is chromium(III) nitrite.
- Step 4
is tin(IV) chloride
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the oxoanion is named nitrite rather than nitrate.
You accurately determined that tin carries a oxidation state in and named it tin(IV) chloride.
You correctly diagnosed that the original student assigned an incorrect oxidation state to tin.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that the nitrite polyatomic ion carries a charge instead of , likely confusing the oxygen subscript in with its ionic charge or conflating it with other polyatomic ions. This caused you to calculate an oxidation state of for chromium instead of .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Polyatomic Family Charge Invariance
Changing the suffix from '-ate' to '-ite' removes one oxygen atom but never changes the overall charge of the polyatomic ion (e.g., both and have a charge).
Keep the overall charge constant when converting between related '-ate' and '-ite' oxoanions.
- Electrical Neutrality for Transition Metal Compounds
The sum of all cation and anion charges in a neutral compound must equal zero: .
Multiply the correct individual anion charge by the subscript outside the parentheses before solving for the metal's Roman numeral.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecall that both nitrate () and nitrite () have a net charge of .
Set up the charge-balance equation for : .
Combine the cation name with its Roman numeral and the correct anion name: chromium(III) nitrite.
(a) For , nitrite () was misnamed nitrate (), and the oxidation state Roman numeral was omitted; for , tin was mistakenly assigned an oxidation state of instead of . (b) : Chromium(III) nitrite; : Tin(IV) chloride
03 The student uses covalent Greek prefix nomenclature rather than Roman numeral Stock system names for multivalent transition and post-transition metals.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
is [crossed out], not nitrate. ⟹ Both compounds are made of nonmetals or metals that require Greek prefixes like tri- and tetra- rather than Roman numerals.
CorrectFor , is nitrite, not nitrate; the student also omitted the Roman numeral for chromium (). For , four chloride ions ( each) require tin to be in the oxidation state, not .
You did not identify the oxidation state errors in either compound. Both chromium () and tin () are metals with variable oxidation states that form ionic or coordination compounds requiring Roman numerals in the Stock system, not Greek numerical prefixes.
- Step 2
is chromium trinitrite ⟹ is tin tetrachloride
Correct: Chromium(III) nitrite; : Tin(IV) chloride
You provided Greek prefix names instead of the requested systematic Stock IUPAC names. Because is and is , the correct Stock names are chromium(III) nitrite and tin(IV) chloride.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou noticed that the oxoanion in the original name was incorrect.
You correctly counted the subscript stoichiometries when choosing numerical descriptors.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated compounds containing multivalent transition and post-transition metals ( and ) as covalent nonmetal compounds, applying Greek prefixes (tri-, tetra-) instead of determining the metal's oxidation state and expressing it as a Roman numeral.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Metal vs. Nonmetal Classification
Binary molecular nomenclature (using mono-, di-, tri-) applies strictly to compounds composed entirely of nonmetals. Compounds with metals use ionic naming rules.
Check the periodic table position of the first element; if it is a metal, never use Greek prefixes in simple salt nomenclature.
- Stock Oxidation State Determination
The oxidation state of a multivalent metal is deduced from the net charge of the anions: .
Multiply the charge of the known anion by its subscript, set the sum to zero, and write the resulting metal charge as a Roman numeral in parentheses right after the metal name.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDetermine the charge of the anion: in , each nitrite ion is , giving . Thus, has an oxidation state of , named chromium(III).
Combine the cation and anion names: chromium(III) + nitrite chromium(III) nitrite.
Determine the charge of the anion in : each chloride ion is , giving . Tin must balance this with , named tin(IV).
Combine the cation and anion names: tin(IV) + chloride tin(IV) chloride.
(a) In , the anion is nitrite (), not nitrate (), and chromium's oxidation state was omitted. In , tin has an oxidation state of (balancing four chlorides), not . (b) : Chromium(III) nitrite; : Tin(IV) chloride.
Lock it in
In the Stock system for naming ionic compounds, what does the Roman numeral in parentheses represent?
It represents the oxidation state (positive charge) of the metal cation, never its subscript.
Similar question
Write the systematic Stock IUPAC name for .
Answer
Iron(III) chloride. Chloride has a charge of , so three chlorides contribute . For electrical neutrality, iron must be in the oxidation state: . Therefore, the Roman numeral is .
Determine the oxidation state of the metal and provide the systematic Stock IUPAC name for .
Answer
Titanium(IV) sulfate. Each sulfate ion () has a charge, so two sulfates give a total charge of . Titanium must balance this with a charge (), yielding the name titanium(IV) sulfate.
A compound has the formula . A student incorrectly writes its name as 'manganese(II) oxide'. Identify the student's error, show the charge balance calculation, and state the correct IUPAC name.
Answer
Error: The student mistakenly used the subscript of manganese () instead of its oxidation state. Calculation: Seven oxide ions contribute . To balance this, the two manganese atoms must contribute , meaning each manganese has an oxidation state of . Correct name: Manganese(VII) oxide.