Resources

A pharmaceutical chemist is designing an alternative catalytic oxidation pathway for synthesizing an aldehyde target (molar mass 144.20 g/mol144.20\text{ g/mol}) using an organic primary alcohol starting material (molar mass 146.22 g/mol146.22\text{ g/mol}). The target environmental objective mandates that the reaction maintain a percent atom economy of at least 89.0%89.0\%. If the proposed reaction mechanism couples the alcohol with an oxidant Ox\text{Ox} to yield the target product and a single stoichiometric byproduct B\text{B} according to the stoichiometry 1 Alcohol+1 Ox→1 Target+1 B1\text{ Alcohol} + 1\text{ Ox} \rightarrow 1\text{ Target} + 1\text{ B}, determine the maximum permissible molar mass (MBM_{\text{B}}) of the byproduct B\text{B} in g/mol\text{g/mol} to three significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

17.8 g/mol17.8\text{ g/mol}

Steps

01

Principle of Atom Economy

Percent Atom Economy measures the efficiency of a chemical reaction in terms of how many atoms from the reactants end up in the desired target product:

Atom Economy=Molar mass of desired productTotal molar mass of all reactants×100%\text{Atom Economy} = \frac{\text{Molar mass of desired product}}{\text{Total molar mass of all reactants}} \times 100\%

According to the Law of Conservation of Mass, the total mass of the reactants equals the total mass of all products formed in a stoichiometric reaction:

∑Mreactants=∑Mproducts=MTarget+MB\sum M_{\text{reactants}} = \sum M_{\text{products}} = M_{\text{Target}} + M_{\text{B}}

Substituting this into the atom economy formula simplifies the expression:

Atom Economy=MTargetMTarget+MB×100%\text{Atom Economy} = \frac{M_{\text{Target}}}{M_{\text{Target}} + M_{\text{B}}} \times 100\%


02

Setting Up the Inequality

The process requires an atom economy of at least 89.0%89.0\% (0.8900.890):

MTargetMTarget+MB≥0.890\frac{M_{\text{Target}}}{M_{\text{Target}} + M_{\text{B}}} \ge 0.890

Substitute the known molar mass of the desired target (MTarget=144.20 g/molM_{\text{Target}} = 144.20\text{ g/mol}):

144.20144.20+MB≥0.890\frac{144.20}{144.20 + M_{\text{B}}} \ge 0.890


03

Solving for the Maximum Permissible Molar Mass (MBM_{\text{B}})

Rearrange and solve for MBM_{\text{B}}:

144.20≥0.890⋅(144.20+MB)144.20 \ge 0.890 \cdot (144.20 + M_{\text{B}})

144.20≥128.338+0.890⋅MB144.20 \ge 128.338 + 0.890 \cdot M_{\text{B}}

Subtract 128.338128.338 from both sides:

15.862≥0.890⋅MB15.862 \ge 0.890 \cdot M_{\text{B}}

MB≤15.8620.890≈17.822 g/molM_{\text{B}} \le \frac{15.862}{0.890} \approx 17.822\text{ g/mol}

Rounding to three significant figures yields:

MB≤17.8 g/molM_{\text{B}} \le 17.8\text{ g/mol}

Common Pitfall: A common mistake is attempting to compute the mass of oxidant Ox\text{Ox} from the alcohol's molar mass alone without realizing that total reactant mass is identically equal to total product mass (MTarget+MBM_{\text{Target}} + M_{\text{B}}). Using the sum of products avoids needing unknown stoichiometric details of the oxidant.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses atom economy with percentage yield or calculates the denominator using only the alcohol reactant instead of all reactants or total products, leading to an incorrect denominator of 146.22 + M_B.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Atom Economy=MTargetTotal Mass of Reactants≥89.0%\text{Atom Economy} = \frac{M_{\text{Target}}}{\text{Total Mass of Reactants}} \ge 89.0\%

  2. Step 2

    Reactants=Alcohol+B  ⟹  144.20146.22+MB≥0.890\text{Reactants} = \text{Alcohol} + \text{B} \implies \frac{144.20}{146.22 + M_{\text{B}}} \ge 0.890

    Correct

    ∑Mreactants=∑Mproducts=MTarget+MB  ⟹  144.20144.20+MB≥0.890\sum M_{\text{reactants}} = \sum M_{\text{products}} = M_{\text{Target}} + M_{\text{B}} \implies \frac{144.20}{144.20 + M_{\text{B}}} \ge 0.890

    Byproduct B\text{B} is a product, not a reactant. By the law of conservation of mass, the total reactant mass equals the total product mass (MTarget+MBM_{\text{Target}} + M_{\text{B}}), which should be 144.20+MB144.20 + M_{\text{B}}, not 146.22+MB146.22 + M_{\text{B}}.

  3. Step 3

    144.20≥130.136+0.890MB  ⟹  0.890MB≤14.064144.20 \ge 130.136 + 0.890 M_{\text{B}} \implies 0.890 M_{\text{B}} \le 14.064

    Correct

    144.20≥128.338+0.890MB  ⟹  0.890MB≤15.862144.20 \ge 128.338 + 0.890 M_{\text{B}} \implies 0.890 M_{\text{B}} \le 15.862

    Your algebraic clearing of the denominator and isolation of MBM_{\text{B}} was carried out correctly, but the numerical values were inherited from the incorrect denominator.

  4. Step 4

    MB≤15.8 g/molM_{\text{B}} \le 15.8\text{ g/mol}

    Correct

    MB≤17.8 g/molM_{\text{B}} \le 17.8\text{ g/mol}

    Solving the corrected inequality yields MB≤15.8620.890≈17.8 g/molM_{\text{B}} \le \frac{15.862}{0.890} \approx 17.8\text{ g/mol}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You stated the correct theoretical formula for atom economy.

You solved the linear inequality step-by-step with sound algebraic manipulation.

You rounded your final numerical result correctly to three significant figures.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect total reactant mass identity in atom economy

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the reaction byproduct B as if it were a reactant added to the starting alcohol, instead of applying the law of conservation of mass where total reactant mass equals total product mass (MTarget+MBM_{\text{Target}} + M_{\text{B}}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Conservation of Mass in Atom Economy
  • For any stoichiometric chemical equation, ∑Mreactants=∑Mproducts\sum M_{\text{reactants}} = \sum M_{\text{products}}.

  • When individual reactant masses (like an unknown oxidant) are missing, express the denominator of atom economy as the sum of all stoichiometric products: Mdesired+∑MbyproductsM_{\text{desired}} + \sum M_{\text{byproducts}}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the conservation of mass: Total reactant mass=MTarget+MB=144.20+MB\text{Total reactant mass} = M_{\text{Target}} + M_{\text{B}} = 144.20 + M_{\text{B}}.

  2. Set up the inequality: 144.20144.20+MB≥0.890\frac{144.20}{144.20 + M_{\text{B}}} \ge 0.890.

  3. Multiply both sides by (144.20+MB)(144.20 + M_{\text{B}}): 144.20≥128.338+0.890MB144.20 \ge 128.338 + 0.890 M_{\text{B}}.

  4. Subtract 128.338128.338 from both sides: 15.862≥0.890MB15.862 \ge 0.890 M_{\text{B}}.

  5. Divide by 0.8900.890: MB≤17.822 g/molM_{\text{B}} \le 17.822\text{ g/mol}.

Final answer

17.8 g/mol17.8\text{ g/mol}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between reactants and byproducts in green chemistry metrics.

  • Practice using the identity ∑Mreactants=∑Mproducts\sum M_{\text{reactants}} = \sum M_{\text{products}} when calculating atom economy from product distributions.

  • Solve follow-up problems where one reactant molar mass is not explicitly given.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student defines atom economy relative to the mass of the byproduct rather than the total mass, writing M_Target / M_B ≥ 89% or (M_Target - M_B) / M_Target ≥ 89%, erroneously concluding that M_B is directly 11.0% of the target mass.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Waste percentage=100%−89.0%=11.0%\text{Waste percentage} = 100\% - 89.0\% = 11.0\%

  2. Step 2

    MBMTarget≤0.110  ⟹  MB≤0.110×144.20\frac{M_{\text{B}}}{M_{\text{Target}}} \le 0.110 \implies M_{\text{B}} \le 0.110 \times 144.20

    Correct

    MBMTarget+MB≤0.110  ⟹  MB≤0.110(144.20+MB)\frac{M_{\text{B}}}{M_{\text{Target}} + M_{\text{B}}} \le 0.110 \implies M_{\text{B}} \le 0.110(144.20 + M_{\text{B}})

    By definition, atom economy and waste percentages are calculated relative to the total mass of all products (or all reactants), not relative to the target product alone. The denominator must be the sum of all product molar masses, MTarget+MBM_{\text{Target}} + M_{\text{B}}.

  3. Step 3

    MB≤15.9 g/molM_{\text{B}} \le 15.9\text{ g/mol}

    Correct

    MB≤17.8 g/molM_{\text{B}} \le 17.8\text{ g/mol}

    Because the inequality in the previous step omitted MBM_{\text{B}} from the denominator, this calculated upper bound is too low.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly related the maximum allowable waste percentage to the required atom economy by subtracting 89.0%89.0\% from 100%100\%.

You correctly identified that the primary alcohol starting material and the oxidant combine to form the target and byproduct B\text{B} according to mass conservation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect denominator in atom economy ratio

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the atom economy percentage as a ratio of byproduct mass directly to the desired product mass (MB/MTargetM_{\text{B}} / M_{\text{Target}}) rather than to the total mass of all products combined (MB/(MTarget+MB)M_{\text{B}} / (M_{\text{Target}} + M_{\text{B}})).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define the Denominator of Atom Economy
  • % Atom Economy=∑Mdesired∑Mreactants×100%=∑Mdesired∑Mall products×100%\text{\% Atom Economy} = \frac{\sum M_{\text{desired}}}{\sum M_{\text{reactants}}} \times 100\% = \frac{\sum M_{\text{desired}}}{\sum M_{\text{all products}}} \times 100\%

  • Always write the total mass (sum of all stoichiometric products) in the denominator before rearranging.

Rearrange with Byproduct in Both Terms
  • If MTargetMTarget+MB≥A\frac{M_{\text{Target}}}{M_{\text{Target}} + M_{\text{B}}} \ge A, then MB≤MTarget(1−AA)M_{\text{B}} \le M_{\text{Target}}\left(\frac{1 - A}{A}\right)

  • Ensure MBM_{\text{B}} appears in the denominator and is grouped properly when isolating MBM_{\text{B}}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the atom economy inequality using total product mass: 144.20144.20+MB≥0.890\frac{144.20}{144.20 + M_{\text{B}}} \ge 0.890

  2. Multiply both sides by (144.20+MB)(144.20 + M_{\text{B}}): 144.20≥0.890(144.20)+0.890MB144.20 \ge 0.890(144.20) + 0.890 M_{\text{B}}

  3. Simplify the product: 144.20≥128.338+0.890MB144.20 \ge 128.338 + 0.890 M_{\text{B}}

  4. Subtract 128.338128.338 from both sides: 15.862≥0.890MB15.862 \ge 0.890 M_{\text{B}}

  5. Divide by 0.8900.890: MB≤15.8620.890≈17.822 g/molM_{\text{B}} \le \frac{15.862}{0.890} \approx 17.822\text{ g/mol}

Final answer

17.8 g/mol17.8\text{ g/mol}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the formal definition of atom economy to ensure you always divide by total reactant or product mass, never just desired product mass.

  • Practice solving atom economy inequalities where the unknown molar mass appears in both the denominator and the overall balance.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student sets up the denominator of the atom economy as the sum of all species including both reactants and products or uses M_Alcohol + M_Target.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Atom Economy=MTargetMAlcohol+MTarget+MB≥0.890\text{Atom Economy} = \frac{M_{\text{Target}}}{M_{\text{Alcohol}} + M_{\text{Target}} + M_{\text{B}}} \ge 0.890

    Correct

    Atom Economy=MTargetMTarget+MB≥0.890\text{Atom Economy} = \frac{M_{\text{Target}}}{M_{\text{Target}} + M_{\text{B}}} \ge 0.890

    Atom economy is defined as the mass of the desired product divided by the total mass of all reactants. By the Law of Conservation of Mass, the total mass of reactants equals the total mass of products: ∑Mreactants=MTarget+MB\sum M_{\text{reactants}} = M_{\text{Target}} + M_{\text{B}}. Adding the alcohol reactant to the products double-counts the starting material in the denominator.

  2. Step 2

    144.20(146.22+144.20+MB)≥0.890  ⟹  144.20290.42+MB≥0.890  ⟹  144.20≥258.47+0.890MB  ⟹  0.890MB≤−114.27\frac{144.20}{(146.22 + 144.20 + M_{\text{B}})} \ge 0.890 \implies \frac{144.20}{290.42 + M_{\text{B}}} \ge 0.890 \implies 144.20 \ge 258.47 + 0.890 M_{\text{B}} \implies 0.890 M_{\text{B}} \le -114.27

    Correct

    144.20144.20+MB≥0.890  ⟹  144.20≥128.338+0.890MB  ⟹  15.862≥0.890MB\frac{144.20}{144.20 + M_{\text{B}}} \ge 0.890 \implies 144.20 \ge 128.338 + 0.890 M_{\text{B}} \implies 15.862 \ge 0.890 M_{\text{B}}

    Your algebraic isolation and arithmetic steps were carried out consistently, but they inherited the incorrect denominator from the previous step.

  3. Step 3

    MB≤−128 g/mol, which is impossibleM_{\text{B}} \le -128\text{ g/mol}\text{, which is impossible}

    Correct

    MB≤17.8 g/molM_{\text{B}} \le 17.8\text{ g/mol}

    Because of the double-counted denominator, you arrived at a negative value rather than the correct maximum permissible molar mass of 17.8 g/mol17.8\text{ g/mol}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly placed the molar mass of the desired target product in the numerator.

You set up and manipulated the inequality with sound algebraic rules.

You recognized that a negative molar mass is physically impossible rather than accepting an absurd numerical result.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Double-counting species in atom economy denominator

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the denominator of percent atom economy as the sum of all chemical species present in the entire reaction equation (both reactants and products) rather than equating total reactant mass to total product mass via mass conservation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Denominator of Atom Economy
  • % Atom Economy=∑Mdesired product∑Mall reactants×100%\text{\% Atom Economy} = \frac{\sum M_{\text{desired product}}}{\sum M_{\text{all reactants}}} \times 100\%

  • Always choose either the sum of all reactants OR the sum of all products for the denominator, never both combined.

Conservation of Mass Shortcut
  • ∑Mreactants=∑Mproducts=MTarget+MByproducts\sum M_{\text{reactants}} = \sum M_{\text{products}} = M_{\text{Target}} + M_{\text{Byproducts}}

  • When oxidant or reagent mass is unknown, express the denominator solely in terms of total product masses.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply conservation of mass: ∑Mreactants=MTarget+MB=144.20+MB\sum M_{\text{reactants}} = M_{\text{Target}} + M_{\text{B}} = 144.20 + M_{\text{B}}.

  2. Set up the minimum atom economy inequality: 144.20144.20+MB≥0.890\frac{144.20}{144.20 + M_{\text{B}}} \ge 0.890.

  3. Multiply both sides by (144.20+MB)(144.20 + M_{\text{B}}): 144.20≥128.338+0.890MB144.20 \ge 128.338 + 0.890 M_{\text{B}}.

  4. Subtract 128.338128.338 from both sides: 15.862≥0.890MB15.862 \ge 0.890 M_{\text{B}}.

  5. Divide by 0.8900.890: MB≤17.822 g/molM_{\text{B}} \le 17.822\text{ g/mol}.

Final answer

17.8 g/mol17.8\text{ g/mol}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the formal definition of atom economy to ensure the denominator contains only reactants or only products.

  • Practice using the Law of Conservation of Mass to eliminate unknown reactant terms in green chemistry equations.

  • Solve the practice problems below to master calculating byproduct mass thresholds.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A catalytic reaction converts an alkene into an epoxide target (molar mass 88.10 g/mol88.10\text{ g/mol}) alongside water (18.02 g/mol18.02\text{ g/mol}) as the sole stoichiometric byproduct. Calculate the percent atom economy to three significant figures.

Answer

83.0%83.0\%. Key step: Atom Economy=88.1088.10+18.02×100%=88.10106.12×100%≈83.0%\text{Atom Economy} = \frac{88.10}{88.10 + 18.02} \times 100\% = \frac{88.10}{106.12} \times 100\% \approx 83.0\%.

02

A chemical synthesis must attain at least 75.0%75.0\% atom economy. It produces a target drug intermediate with molar mass 210.0 g/mol210.0\text{ g/mol} and a single byproduct X\text{X}. Determine the maximum allowable molar mass of X\text{X} in g/mol\text{g/mol}.

Answer

70.0 g/mol70.0\text{ g/mol}. Key step: 210.0210.0+MX≥0.750  ⟹  210.0≥157.5+0.750MX  ⟹  MX≤52.50.750=70.0 g/mol\frac{210.0}{210.0 + M_{\text{X}}} \ge 0.750 \implies 210.0 \ge 157.5 + 0.750 M_{\text{X}} \implies M_{\text{X}} \le \frac{52.5}{0.750} = 70.0\text{ g/mol}.

03

An esterification couples carboxylic acid A\text{A} and alcohol B\text{B} to produce an ester (M=180.0 g/molM = 180.0\text{ g/mol}) and water (M=18.0 g/molM = 18.0\text{ g/mol}) in a 1:11:1 stoichiometric ratio. If acid A\text{A} has a molar mass of 102.0 g/mol102.0\text{ g/mol}, find the molar mass of alcohol B\text{B} and the reaction's percent atom economy.

Answer

MB=96.0 g/molM_{\text{B}} = 96.0\text{ g/mol} and Atom Economy=90.9%\text{Atom Economy} = 90.9\%. Key steps: Total mass =180.0+18.0=198.0 g/mol= 180.0 + 18.0 = 198.0\text{ g/mol}, so MB=198.0−102.0=96.0 g/molM_{\text{B}} = 198.0 - 102.0 = 96.0\text{ g/mol}. Atom economy =180.0198.0×100%≈90.9%= \frac{180.0}{198.0} \times 100\% \approx 90.9\%.

Loading workspace…