Resources

Consider the gas-phase synthesis of ammonia: N2(g)+3H2(g)⇌2NH3(g)\text{N}_2(g) + 3\text{H}_2(g) \rightleftharpoons 2\text{NH}_3(g), which has an equilibrium constant Kc=1.20K_c = 1.20 at 375∘C375^\circ\text{C}. A reaction mixture at this temperature contains [N2]=0.500 M[\text{N}_2] = 0.500\text{ M} and [NH3]=0.300 M[\text{NH}_3] = 0.300\text{ M}. What minimum molar concentration of H2(g)\text{H}_2(g) must be present in the container to drive the reaction forward to produce more NH3(g)\text{NH}_3(g)?

Answer and steps

Final answer

[H2]>0.531 M[\text{H}_2] > 0.531\text{ M}

Steps

01

Write the Reaction Quotient Expression

To determine the condition under which the reaction proceeds in the forward direction, we compare the reaction quotient (QcQ_c) to the equilibrium constant (KcK_c).

For the reversible reaction: NX2(g)+3 HX2(g)⇌2 NHX3(g)\ce{N2(g) + 3H2(g) <=> 2NH3(g)}

The reaction quotient expression based on molar concentrations is: Qc=[NHX3]2[NX2][HX2]3Q_c = \frac{[\ce{NH3}]^2}{[\ce{N2}][\ce{H2}]^3}

02

Condition for the Reaction to Shift Forward

A reaction shifts forward (toward products) when the current ratio of products to reactants is lower than the equilibrium ratio: Qc<KcQ_c < K_c

Substituting the expression for QcQ_c and the value of Kc=1.20K_c = 1.20: [NHX3]2[NX2][HX2]3<1.20\frac{[\ce{NH3}]^2}{[\ce{N2}][\ce{H2}]^3} < 1.20

03

Substitute the Given Concentrations and Solve for [HX2][\ce{H2}]

Substitute [NX2]=0.500 M[\ce{N2}] = 0.500\text{ M} and [NHX3]=0.300 M[\ce{NH3}] = 0.300\text{ M}: (0.300)2(0.500)[HX2]3<1.20\frac{(0.300)^2}{(0.500)[\ce{H2}]^3} < 1.20

Simplify the numerator and denominator: 0.09000.500⋅[HX2]3<1.20\frac{0.0900}{0.500 \cdot [\ce{H2}]^3} < 1.20

0.180[HX2]3<1.20\frac{0.180}{[\ce{H2}]^3} < 1.20

Rearrange to solve for [HX2]3[\ce{H2}]^3 (since [HX2]>0[\ce{H2}] > 0, multiplying both sides by [HX2]3[\ce{H2}]^3 and dividing by 1.201.20 maintains the inequality direction relative to [HX2]3[\ce{H2}]^3): [HX2]3>0.1801.20[\ce{H2}]^3 > \frac{0.180}{1.20}

[HX2]3>0.150[\ce{H2}]^3 > 0.150

Take the cube root of both sides: [HX2]>(0.150)1/3≈0.531 M[\ce{H2}] > (0.150)^{1/3} \approx 0.531\text{ M}

Common Pitfall: Remember that the stoichiometric coefficient of 3 for HX2\ce{H2} appears as an exponent in both the QcQ_c and KcK_c expressions. Additionally, because [HX2][\ce{H2}] is in the denominator, increasing [HX2][\ce{H2}] decreases QcQ_c, driving the reaction forward when [HX2]>0.531 M[\ce{H2}] > 0.531\text{ M}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to cube the concentration of H2 and/or square the concentration of NH3, treating stoichiometric coefficients as multipliers instead of exponents in the equilibrium expression.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Qc=[NHX3]2[NX2]⋅3[HX2]<1.20Q_c = \frac{[\ce{NH3}]^2}{[\ce{N2}] \cdot 3[\ce{H2}]} < 1.20

    Correct

    Qc=[NHX3]2[NX2][HX2]3<1.20Q_c = \frac{[\ce{NH3}]^2}{[\ce{N2}][\ce{H2}]^3} < 1.20

    You correctly recognized that Qc<KcQ_c < K_c shifts the equilibrium to the right, and you correctly squared [NHX3][\ce{NH3}]. However, stoichiometric coefficients must be placed as exponents, so the hydrogen term must be [HX2]3[\ce{H2}]^3 rather than 3[HX2]3[\ce{H2}].

  2. Step 2

    (0.300)2(0.500⋅3[HX2])<1.20  ⟹  0.09001.50[HX2]<1.20\frac{(0.300)^2}{(0.500 \cdot 3[\ce{H2}])} < 1.20 \implies \frac{0.0900}{1.50[\ce{H2}]} < 1.20

    Correct

    (0.300)20.500⋅[HX2]3<1.20  ⟹  0.180[HX2]3<1.20\frac{(0.300)^2}{0.500 \cdot [\ce{H2}]^3} < 1.20 \implies \frac{0.180}{[\ce{H2}]^3} < 1.20

    You substituted the given concentrations and simplified the arithmetic accurately based on your expression, but the values are affected by the missing exponent on [HX2][\ce{H2}].

  3. Step 3

    [HX2]>0.09001.80=0.0500 M  ⟹  Minimum [HX2]=0.0500 M[\ce{H2}] > \frac{0.0900}{1.80} = 0.0500\text{ M} \implies \text{Minimum }[\ce{H2}] = 0.0500\text{ M}

    Correct

    [HX2]3>0.1801.20=0.150  ⟹  [HX2]>0.531 M[\ce{H2}]^3 > \frac{0.180}{1.20} = 0.150 \implies [\ce{H2}] > 0.531\text{ M}

    Your inequality rearrangement is algebraically correct for your linear expression, but because [HX2][\ce{H2}] was not cubed, taking the cube root was omitted and the final numerical threshold is incorrect.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly determined that driving the reaction forward requires the reaction quotient to be less than the equilibrium constant (Qc<KcQ_c < K_c).

You correctly identified that the stoichiometric coefficient of 2 for NHX3\ce{NH3} becomes an exponent in the numerator ([NHX3]2[\ce{NH3}]^2).

You executed the algebraic rearrangement to isolate the unknown concentration cleanly and accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Stoichiometric coefficient treated as multiplier instead of exponent

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the stoichiometric coefficient 3 for HX2\ce{H2} as a scalar multiplier (3[HX2]3[\ce{H2}]) instead of raising the concentration to the third power ([HX2]3[\ce{H2}]^3) in the reaction quotient expression.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Law of Mass Action Exponents
  • In equilibrium constant (KcK_c) and reaction quotient (QcQ_c) expressions, every stoichiometric coefficient from the balanced equation appears strictly as an exponent on that species' molar concentration, never as a multiplying factor outside or inside the brackets.

  • Always place stoichiometric numbers as superscripts: for aA+bB⇌cCa\ce{A} + b\ce{B} \rightleftharpoons c\ce{C}, write Qc=[C]c[A]a[B]bQ_c = \frac{[\ce{C}]^c}{[\ce{A}]^a [\ce{B}]^b}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the proper reaction quotient expression using exponents for all coefficients: Qc=[NHX3]2[NX2][HX2]3Q_c = \frac{[\ce{NH3}]^2}{[\ce{N2}][\ce{H2}]^3}.

  2. Apply the condition for shifting forward toward products: Qc<Kc  ⟹  (0.300)2(0.500)[HX2]3<1.20Q_c < K_c \implies \frac{(0.300)^2}{(0.500)[\ce{H2}]^3} < 1.20.

  3. Simplify the numerator and isolate [HX2]3[\ce{H2}]^3: 0.09000.500[HX2]3<1.20  ⟹  0.180[HX2]3<1.20  ⟹  [HX2]3>0.1801.20=0.150\frac{0.0900}{0.500[\ce{H2}]^3} < 1.20 \implies \frac{0.180}{[\ce{H2}]^3} < 1.20 \implies [\ce{H2}]^3 > \frac{0.180}{1.20} = 0.150.

  4. Take the cube root of both sides to solve for [HX2][\ce{H2}]: [HX2]>(0.150)1/3≈0.531 M[\ce{H2}] > (0.150)^{1/3} \approx 0.531\text{ M}.

Final answer

[HX2]>0.531 M[\ce{H2}] > 0.531\text{ M}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check every term in equilibrium and reaction quotient expressions to ensure all coefficients become powers, never multipliers.

  • When an unknown concentration is raised to a power such as 2 or 3, remember to take the corresponding root as your final algebraic step.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student inverts the reaction quotient expression as reactants over products, leading to an incorrect inequality and concentration.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Qc=[N2][H2]3[NH3]2<KcQ_c = \frac{[\text{N}_2][\text{H}_2]^3}{[\text{NH}_3]^2} < K_c

    Correct

    Qc=[NH3]2[N2][H2]3<KcQ_c = \frac{[\text{NH}_3]^2}{[\text{N}_2][\text{H}_2]^3} < K_c

    You correctly noted that the reaction shifts forward when Qc<KcQ_c < K_c. However, the reaction quotient is always written as product concentrations divided by reactant concentrations: Qc=[products]coeffs[reactants]coeffsQ_c = \frac{[\text{products}]^{\text{coeffs}}}{[\text{reactants}]^{\text{coeffs}}}. You placed the reactants in the numerator and products in the denominator.

  2. Step 2

    0.500×[H2]3(0.300)2<1.20  ⟹  0.500×[H2]30.0900<1.20  ⟹  [H2]3<1.20×0.09000.500=0.216\frac{0.500 \times [\text{H}_2]^3}{(0.300)^2} < 1.20 \implies \frac{0.500 \times [\text{H}_2]^3}{0.0900} < 1.20 \implies [\text{H}_2]^3 < \frac{1.20 \times 0.0900}{0.500} = 0.216

    Correct

    (0.300)20.500⋅[H2]3<1.20  ⟹  0.180[H2]3<1.20  ⟹  [H2]3>0.1801.20=0.150\frac{(0.300)^2}{0.500 \cdot [\text{H}_2]^3} < 1.20 \implies \frac{0.180}{[\text{H}_2]^3} < 1.20 \implies [\text{H}_2]^3 > \frac{0.180}{1.20} = 0.150

    Your algebraic isolation of [H2]3[\text{H}_2]^3 was executed without arithmetic slips, but it is affected by the inverted QcQ_c formula from Step 1. Because [H2][\text{H}_2] actually belongs in the denominator, clearing the fraction gives [H2]3>0.150[\text{H}_2]^3 > 0.150 rather than an upper bound.

  3. Step 3

    [H2]=(0.216)13=0.600 M  ⟹  Minimum [H2]=0.600 M[\text{H}_2] = (0.216)^{\frac{1}{3}} = 0.600\text{ M} \implies \text{Minimum } [\text{H}_2] = 0.600\text{ M}

    Correct

    [H2]>(0.150)1/3≈0.531 M[\text{H}_2] > (0.150)^{1/3} \approx 0.531\text{ M}

    You evaluated the cube root correctly for your value, but the final numerical concentration and inequality are incorrect due to the initial inverted expression.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the criterion Qc<KcQ_c < K_c required to shift the equilibrium in the forward direction.

You correctly assigned stoichiometric coefficients as exponents for each chemical species.

You carried out the algebraic rearrangement and cube root calculation accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Reaction Quotient Expression

You accidentally placed reactants over products when writing the equilibrium quotient expression.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the numerator and denominator in the law of mass action, writing [reactants][products]\frac{[\text{reactants}]}{[\text{products}]} instead of the standard convention [products][reactants]\frac{[\text{products}]}{[\text{reactants}]}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Mass Action Convention
  • For any generic reaction aA+bB⇌cC+dDa\text{A} + b\text{B} \rightleftharpoons c\text{C} + d\text{D}, the reaction quotient is always defined as Qc=[C]c[D]d[A]a[B]b=[products][reactants]Q_c = \frac{[\text{C}]^c[\text{D}]^d}{[\text{A}]^a[\text{B}]^b} = \frac{[\text{products}]}{[\text{reactants}]}.

  • Always write 'Products over Reactants' as a quick header before substituting species formulas.

Le Chatelier Consistency Check
  • Adding more reactant drives the reaction forward (lowering QQ below KK).

  • Check that increasing a reactant's concentration appears in the denominator, which decreases QcQ_c and favors product formation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the correct reaction quotient: Qc=[NH3]2[N2][H2]3Q_c = \frac{[\text{NH}_3]^2}{[\text{N}_2][\text{H}_2]^3}.

  2. Set up the forward-shift condition Qc<KcQ_c < K_c: (0.300)2(0.500)[H2]3<1.20\frac{(0.300)^2}{(0.500)[\text{H}_2]^3} < 1.20.

  3. Simplify the numerator: 0.09000.500[H2]3=0.180[H2]3<1.20\frac{0.0900}{0.500[\text{H}_2]^3} = \frac{0.180}{[\text{H}_2]^3} < 1.20.

  4. Multiply both sides by [H2]3[\text{H}_2]^3 and divide by 1.201.20: [H2]3>0.1801.20=0.150[\text{H}_2]^3 > \frac{0.180}{1.20} = 0.150.

  5. Take the cube root of both sides: [H2]>(0.150)1/3≈0.531 M[\text{H}_2] > (0.150)^{1/3} \approx 0.531\text{ M}.

Final answer

[H2]>0.531 M[\text{H}_2] > 0.531\text{ M}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the mnemonic 'P over R' (Products over Reactants) for all equilibrium and reaction quotient expressions.

  • Verify your inequality using Le Chatelier's principle: since H2\text{H}_2 is a reactant, increasing [extH2][ ext{H}_2] must decrease QcQ_c below KcK_c, meaning [extH2][ ext{H}_2] must exceed a threshold value.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student omits the exponent on [H2], writing [H2] instead of [H2]³ while correctly squaring [NH3].

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Qc=[NH3]2([N2][H2])<KcQ_c = \frac{[\text{NH}_3]^2}{([\text{N}_2][\text{H}_2])} < K_c

    Correct

    Qc=[NH3]2[N2][H2]3<KcQ_c = \frac{[\text{NH}_3]^2}{[\text{N}_2][\text{H}_2]^3} < K_c

    In the reaction quotient expression, each concentration must be raised to the power equal to its stoichiometric coefficient in the balanced equation. Because the coefficient of H2\text{H}_2 is 33, its concentration must be cubed as [H2]3[\text{H}_2]^3.

  2. Step 2

    (0.300)2(0.500⋅[H2])<1.20  ⟹  0.09000.500⋅[H2]<1.20  ⟹  0.180[H2]<1.20\frac{(0.300)^2}{(0.500 \cdot [\text{H}_2])} < 1.20 \implies \frac{0.0900}{0.500 \cdot [\text{H}_2]} < 1.20 \implies \frac{0.180}{[\text{H}_2]} < 1.20

    Correct

    (0.300)20.500⋅[H2]3<1.20  ⟹  0.180[H2]3<1.20\frac{(0.300)^2}{0.500 \cdot [\text{H}_2]^3} < 1.20 \implies \frac{0.180}{[\text{H}_2]^3} < 1.20

    Your arithmetic and fraction simplification are correct, but this step carries forward the missing exponent from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    [H2]>0.1801.20=0.150 M[\text{H}_2] > \frac{0.180}{1.20} = 0.150\text{ M}

    Correct

    [H2]3>0.1801.20=0.150  ⟹  [H2]>(0.150)1/3≈0.531 M[\text{H}_2]^3 > \frac{0.180}{1.20} = 0.150 \implies [\text{H}_2] > (0.150)^{1/3} \approx 0.531\text{ M}

    You correctly rearranged the inequality by multiplying by [H2][\text{H}_2] and dividing by 1.201.20, but the term being solved should be [H2]3[\text{H}_2]^3.

  4. Step 4

    Minimum [H2]=0.150 M\text{Minimum } [\text{H}_2] = 0.150\text{ M}

    Correct

    [H2]>0.531 M[\text{H}_2] > 0.531\text{ M}

    Because [H2]3>0.150[\text{H}_2]^3 > 0.150, taking the cube root yields [H2]>0.531 M[\text{H}_2] > 0.531\text{ M}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly established the condition for shifting the reaction forward as Qc<KcQ_c < K_c.

You correctly squared [NH3][\text{NH}_3] according to its stoichiometric coefficient of 22.

You accurately simplified the numerical values and handled the inequality direction when solving for the unknown.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted Stoichiometric Exponent

You wrote [H2][\text{H}_2] as a first-power term rather than cubing it as [H2]3[\text{H}_2]^3.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You overlooked that the stoichiometric coefficient of 33 for H2(g)\text{H}_2(g) in the balanced chemical equation must be included as an exponent in the law of mass action / reaction quotient expression.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Exponents in Equilibrium Expressions
  • In any equilibrium or reaction quotient expression for aA+bB⇌cC+dDa\text{A} + b\text{B} \rightleftharpoons c\text{C} + d\text{D}, every concentration term must have an exponent matching its coefficient: Q=[C]c[D]d[A]a[B]bQ = \frac{[\text{C}]^c [\text{D}]^d}{[\text{A}]^a [\text{B}]^b}.

  • Double-check every species against the balanced chemical equation before substituting numerical values to confirm all non-unity coefficients are present as exponents.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the complete reaction quotient with all stoichiometric coefficients as exponents: Qc=[NH3]2[N2][H2]3<KcQ_c = \frac{[\text{NH}_3]^2}{[\text{N}_2][\text{H}_2]^3} < K_c.

  2. Substitute the given values: (0.300)2(0.500)[H2]3<1.20\frac{(0.300)^2}{(0.500)[\text{H}_2]^3} < 1.20.

  3. Simplify the numerator and evaluate the quotient: 0.09000.500[H2]3<1.20  ⟹  0.180[H2]3<1.20\frac{0.0900}{0.500[\text{H}_2]^3} < 1.20 \implies \frac{0.180}{[\text{H}_2]^3} < 1.20.

  4. Rearrange for [H2]3[\text{H}_2]^3: [H2]3>0.1801.20=0.150[\text{H}_2]^3 > \frac{0.180}{1.20} = 0.150.

  5. Take the cube root of both sides: [H2]>(0.150)1/3≈0.531 M[\text{H}_2] > (0.150)^{1/3} \approx 0.531\text{ M}.

Final answer

[H2]>0.531 M[\text{H}_2] > 0.531\text{ M}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out the general algebraic expression for QcQ_c (including all exponents) and verify it against the balanced equation before inserting numbers.

  • Practice taking higher roots (such as cube roots) on your calculator when solving for concentrations with coefficients greater than 22.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

For the reaction 2SOX2(g)+OX2(g)⇌2SOX3(g)2\ce{SO2}(g) + \ce{O2}(g) \rightleftharpoons 2\ce{SO3}(g), write the reaction quotient expression QcQ_c and calculate its value when [SOX2]=0.20 M[\ce{SO2}] = 0.20\text{ M}, [OX2]=0.10 M[\ce{O2}] = 0.10\text{ M}, and [SOX3]=0.40 M[\ce{SO3}] = 0.40\text{ M}.

Answer

Write the expression using coefficients as powers: Qc=[SOX3]2[SOX2]2[OX2]Q_c = \frac{[\ce{SO3}]^2}{[\ce{SO2}]^2 [\ce{O2}]}. Substitute the given values: Qc=(0.40)2(0.20)2(0.10)=0.160(0.040)(0.10)=0.1600.0040=40Q_c = \frac{(0.40)^2}{(0.20)^2 (0.10)} = \frac{0.160}{(0.040)(0.10)} = \frac{0.160}{0.0040} = 40.

02

Consider the reaction CO(g)+2HX2(g)⇌CHX3OH(g)\ce{CO}(g) + 2\ce{H2}(g) \rightleftharpoons \ce{CH3OH}(g) with Kc=10.5K_c = 10.5. A reaction vessel contains [CO]=0.200 M[\ce{CO}] = 0.200\text{ M} and [CHX3OH]=0.420 M[\ce{CH3OH}] = 0.420\text{ M}. What minimum concentration of HX2(g)\ce{H2}(g) must be present to drive the reaction forward to produce more CHX3OH\ce{CH3OH}?

Answer

To shift forward, Qc<KcQ_c < K_c: [CHX3OH][CO][HX2]2<10.5\frac{[\ce{CH3OH}]}{[\ce{CO}][\ce{H2}]^2} < 10.5. Substitute knowns: 0.420(0.200)[HX2]2<10.5  ⟹  2.10[HX2]2<10.5\frac{0.420}{(0.200)[\ce{H2}]^2} < 10.5 \implies \frac{2.10}{[\ce{H2}]^2} < 10.5. Rearrange: [HX2]2>2.1010.5=0.200[\ce{H2}]^2 > \frac{2.10}{10.5} = 0.200. Take the square root: [HX2]>0.200≈0.447 M[\ce{H2}] > \sqrt{0.200} \approx 0.447\text{ M}.

03

For the Haber synthesis NX2(g)+3HX2(g)⇌2NHX3(g)\ce{N2}(g) + 3\ce{H2}(g) \rightleftharpoons 2\ce{NH3}(g) with Kc=1.20K_c = 1.20, suppose a vessel contains equal concentrations of [NX2]=[HX2]=c[\ce{N2}] = [\ce{H2}] = c. If [NHX3]=0.600 M[\ce{NH3}] = 0.600\text{ M}, what condition must cc satisfy for the mixture to proceed forward toward equilibrium?

Answer

Set Qc<KcQ_c < K_c: [NHX3]2[NX2][HX2]3<1.20  ⟹  (0.600)2c⋅c3<1.20  ⟹  0.360c4<1.20\frac{[\ce{NH3}]^2}{[\ce{N2}][\ce{H2}]^3} < 1.20 \implies \frac{(0.600)^2}{c \cdot c^3} < 1.20 \implies \frac{0.360}{c^4} < 1.20. Rearrange for c4c^4: c4>0.3601.20=0.300c^4 > \frac{0.360}{1.20} = 0.300. Take the fourth root: c>(0.300)1/4≈0.740 Mc > (0.300)^{1/4} \approx 0.740\text{ M}. Thus, both [NX2][\ce{N2}] and [HX2][\ce{H2}] must exceed 0.740 M0.740\text{ M}.

Loading workspace…