Resources
At , the solubility of potassium nitrate () in water is per of . A solution is prepared by completely dissolving of in of water at , and then carefully cooling the sealed, undisturbed container to without agitation, forming a metastable supersaturated solution with zero visible precipitation. (a) Classify this supersaturated system prior to precipitation as homogeneous or heterogeneous. (b) A single microscopic seed crystal of mass is dropped into the container, inducing rapid crystallization until thermodynamic equilibrium is restored. Classify the resulting final system and calculate the mass of that precipitates out of solution.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Homogeneous mixture; (b) Heterogeneous mixture, with of precipitated.
Steps
Part (a): Classifying the Metastable Supersaturated System
-
Definition of Mixture Types by Phases:
- A homogeneous mixture (or solution) consists of a single uniform phase with uniform physical and chemical properties throughout. The solute particles are dispersed at the molecular or ionic level, with no visible boundaries or separated phases.
- A heterogeneous mixture consists of two or more distinct phases with definite boundaries separating regions of different compositions or states of matter.
-
Evaluating the Supersaturated Solution:
- Even though the solution holds more dissolved solute () than the equilibrium solubility limit () at , all is fully dissolved in the liquid phase with zero solid present.
- Because it exists strictly as a single, uniform liquid phase, the system prior to crystallization is classified as a homogeneous mixture.
Part (b): Mass of Precipitate and Final Mixture Classification
-
Calculating the Mass of Precipitate:
- At thermodynamic equilibrium at , the maximum mass of that remains stably dissolved in of water is its solubility limit:
- The excess solute that cannot remain dissolved once crystallization is initiated precipitates out:
- (Note: The mass of the tiny seed crystal, , serves as a nucleation site but is negligible compared to the of newly precipitated solid.)
-
Classifying the Final System:
- Once crystallization finishes, the container holds two distinct phases: a liquid phase (a saturated aqueous solution of ) and a solid phase ( crystals at the bottom).
- Because there are two physically distinct phases with an interface separating them, the final system is classified as a heterogeneous mixture.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses an unstable supersaturated state with a two-phase mixture, incorrectly classifying a solution with no visible precipitate as heterogeneous.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Dissolved mass = in Exceeds solubility of Heterogeneous because it is supersaturated
CorrectHomogeneous mixture
You noted that the dissolved solute exceeds the equilibrium solubility, but thermodynamic instability does not create a second phase. Because all remains completely dissolved in a single, uniform liquid phase with no phase boundaries, the system is a homogeneous mixture.
- Step 2
Heterogeneous Precipitated mass =
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the equilibrium solubility limit at .
You calculated the mass of precipitated solid accurately by subtracting the equilibrium solubility from the total dissolved mass.
You correctly classified the two-phase system (liquid solution + solid crystals) as heterogeneous.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated a supersaturated state with a multi-phase system, assuming that exceeding the saturation limit automatically makes a mixture heterogeneous even when all solute remains entirely dissolved in a single phase.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Phase Count vs. Saturation State
Homogeneous versus heterogeneous classification depends solely on the number of physical phases present (single uniform phase vs. two or more distinct phases separated by boundaries), not on whether the solution is unsaturated, saturated, or supersaturated.
Always count the physical phases currently present in the system: if all solute is completely dissolved in the liquid with zero solid or interface present, the mixture is homogeneous.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCount the physical phases present before seeding: only one uniform liquid phase exists.
Apply the definition: a single-phase mixture with uniform composition throughout is a homogeneous mixture.
(a) Homogeneous mixture; (b) Heterogeneous mixture, with of precipitated.
02 The student misinterprets precipitation as all dissolved solute falling out of solution rather than only the excess above the solubility limit.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Homogeneous
- Step 2
Heterogeneous
- Step 3
All dissolved solute precipitates upon seeding ⟹ Precipitated mass = 42.0 g
CorrectSeeding relieves supersaturation by precipitating only the excess solute beyond the equilibrium solubility limit (), leaving a saturated solution behind.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly classified the supersaturated liquid phase as a homogeneous mixture.
You correctly identified that the coexisting solid crystals and liquid phase form a heterogeneous mixture.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeAssuming all dissolved solute falls out of solution upon seeding rather than stopping at the saturation limit.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated crystallization as an all-or-nothing event that empties the solvent of solute, overlooking that precipitation ceases as soon as the liquid phase reaches dynamic saturation equilibrium at .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Saturation Equilibrium
When a supersaturated solution is seeded, crystallization stops once the solution reaches its saturation limit (), not when all solute is removed.
Subtract the equilibrium solubility from the total dissolved solute mass: .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationState the equilibrium solubility at : of per of .
Calculate the mass of excess solute that crystallizes: .
(a) Homogeneous mixture; (b) Heterogeneous mixture, with of precipitated.
03 The student believes that rapid precipitation depletes the solution down to zero solute remaining dissolved, concluding that the entire original solute mass precipitates.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Homogeneous
- Step 2
Heterogeneous
- Step 3
Precipitated mass = 38.0 g ⟹ Mass of precipitate = 38.0 g
CorrectYou took the solubility limit () as the precipitate mass. The solubility limit represents the maximum mass of solute that stays dissolved in the liquid phase at equilibrium; only the excess solute above this threshold precipitates.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that a completely dissolved supersaturated solution forms a single phase and is therefore homogeneous.
You correctly identified that a mixture containing both solid crystals and liquid solution is heterogeneous.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the equilibrium solubility value (the amount of solute that remains dissolved in solution) with the amount of solute that crystallizes out of solution.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Solubility vs. Precipitate
At thermodynamic equilibrium, .
Identify the solubility as the portion that remains in the liquid phase, then subtract it from the total initial solute to find the solid precipitate.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecall that the solubility of at is per , meaning remains dissolved at equilibrium.
Subtract the dissolved equilibrium mass from the initial dissolved mass: .
(a) Homogeneous mixture; (b) Heterogeneous mixture, with of precipitated.
Lock it in
How is a mixture classified as homogeneous versus heterogeneous?
By the number of distinct physical phases: one uniform phase throughout is homogeneous; two or more phases separated by visible boundaries are heterogeneous.
Similar question
At , the solubility of in water is per of . If of is added to of water and completely dissolves after stirring, classify the resulting mixture as homogeneous or heterogeneous.
Answer
Homogeneous mixture. The amount of solute () is below the solubility limit (), forming an unsaturated solution that consists of a single uniform liquid phase with no solid present.
At , the solubility of copper(II) sulfate () is per of water. A student adds of to of water at and stirs thoroughly until equilibrium is reached. Classify the resulting system and determine the mass of undissolved solid at the bottom.
Answer
Heterogeneous mixture; of undissolved solid. At equilibrium, only can dissolve, leaving . Because both a saturated aqueous solution phase and an undissolved solid phase coexist with a phase boundary, the mixture is heterogeneous.
A sealed flask contains of water and of sodium acetate (). At , the solubility of sodium acetate is per of water. The mixture was heated until all solid dissolved, then slowly cooled to without disturbance, yielding a clear liquid with no solid. (a) Classify this undisturbed state. (b) A seed crystal is introduced, causing crystallization. After equilibrium is reached at , classify the final state and calculate the mass of sodium acetate that crystallizes out.
Answer
(a) Homogeneous mixture. All solute is dissolved in a single liquid phase with no phase boundaries. (b) Heterogeneous mixture, with crystallized. The maximum dissolved mass in of water at is . The mass precipitated is . The coexistence of solid crystals and liquid solution makes the final system heterogeneous.