Resources
A textile dyeing plant neutralizes an acidic effluent containing sulfuric acid (). An operator assumes that simply diluting the acidic waste ten-fold with tap water ( of waste diluted to ) is more environmentally benign than chemical neutralization. The operator hypothesizes that because is a strong diprotic acid, a -fold dilution will shift the pH upward by exactly . However, for , the first proton dissociates completely, while the hydrogen sulfate ion is a weak acid with at : . By solving the equilibrium expression for without neglecting the second ionization: (a) calculate the exact of the undiluted solution, and (b) calculate the exact of the -fold diluted solution (), demonstrating why the student's intuition fails.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; (b) (a shift of only , rather than the intuitive )
Steps
Exact of the Undiluted Effluent ()
Conceptual Overview
Sulfuric acid () is a diprotic acid that dissociates in two distinct stages:
- First dissociation (complete):
- Second dissociation (equilibrium): If both protons dissociated completely, a -fold dilution of a strong acid would decrease by a factor of , causing an exact increase in of . However, because is a weak acid, dilution drives the equilibrium to shift to the right according to Le Chatelier's principle (the degree of dissociation of increases). Consequently, the concentration of does not drop by a full factor of , and the change in is less than .
From the complete first ionization:
Let be the molar concentration of that dissociates in the second step:
Substitute these equilibrium concentrations into the equilibrium expression:
Setting this up as a standard quadratic equation with :
Solving for the positive root:
Calculate total and the initial :
Exact of the Diluted Solution ()
A -fold dilution decreases the nominal concentration to .
From the complete first dissociation:
Let be the concentration of that dissociates at this lower concentration:
Rearranging into quadratic form:
Solving the quadratic formula for the physically meaningful root :
Notice the fraction of dissociated:
- In the solution:
- In the solution:
Because the degree of dissociation nearly triples upon dilution, extra ions are released into solution.
Calculate total and the diluted :
Comparison and Evaluation of Intuition
Calculate the change in :
- Why the operator's hypothesis fails: The assumption of holds only for a strong monoprotic acid (or a fully dissociated polyprotic acid). Diluting weak acids shifts equilibrium toward products (Ostwald's dilution law), releasing additional and dampening the increase.
- Environmental significance: Simple tap water dilution yields an effluent that remains strongly acidic (, well outside typical sewer and stream discharge limits of ) while multiplying wastewater volume ten-fold. Proper chemical neutralization is essential.
Typical errors
01 The student treats sulfuric acid as a fully dissociated diprotic strong acid in both steps, assuming [H+] = 2 * C.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You treated sulfuric acid as a diprotic strong acid that fully dissociates both protons. While the first ionization is complete, the second stage is an equilibrium governed by .
- Step 2Correct
You repeated the full dissociation assumption for the diluted solution. Because dilution increases the percent ionization of from to , does not drop by a factor of 10.
- Step 3Correct
Because the pH values were calculated using complete second dissociation rather than the equilibrium condition, your comparison concluded that the operator's intuition holds instead of demonstrating why it fails.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used the definition of pH as the negative base-10 logarithm of hydrogen ion concentration.
You recognized the theoretical implication that complete dissociation of both protons would indeed yield a pH shift of 1.00 upon a ten-fold dilution.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed sulfuric acid behaves as a strong acid for both ionization steps (), overlooking that is a weak acid whose equilibrium must be solved explicitly via .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Sulfuric Acid Ionization Stages
For aqueous , only the first proton dissociates completely (). The second proton dissociates partially according to .
Always set up an ICE table with initial and initial , then solve for the equilibrium shift using .
- Dilution Effect on Weak Electrolytes
Diluting a weak acid shifts the equilibrium toward higher percent dissociation (Le Chatelier's principle / Ostwald's dilution law).
Expect the change in pH upon 10-fold dilution of a partially dissociated acid to be strictly less than .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet up the equilibrium for undiluted : , , and .
Solve to get .
Calculate undiluted .
Repeat for diluted : , giving .
Calculate diluted .
(a) Initial pH = 1.24; (b) Diluted pH = 2.14 (giving a shift of )
02 The student forgets that the first dissociation already provides an initial concentration of H+, writing [H+] = x instead of 0.050 + x in the numerator of Ka2.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
Because the first dissociation of is complete, the solution already contains before the second dissociation reaches equilibrium. The equilibrium concentration of is , so the numerator must be rather than .
- Step 2Correct
Your formula is conceptually correct, but substituting your overstated value of led to an incorrect of .
- Step 3Correct
Just as in the undiluted step, the initial from the first proton dissociation is , so the numerator in must be rather than .
- Step 4Correct
Using your calculated produced an inaccurate diluted .
- Step 5
, failing the expectation
Correct, confirming dilution shifts equilibrium and produces a change less than
Your final difference serendipitously equaled , but both individual values were incorrect due to the omitted common ion in both equilibrium expressions.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the complete first dissociation contributes to the total hydrogen ion concentration in solution.
You set up quadratic equations and solved them accurately using the quadratic formula.
You correctly concluded that the actual shift upon ten-fold dilution is less than .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the weak second dissociation as an isolated ionization with in the numerator, forgetting that the strong first dissociation establishes a non-zero initial concentration that must appear in the law of mass action as .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Initial $[ ext{H}^+]$ from Prior Dissociation
For a strong-weak diprotic acid like , the first step yields and .
Always list initial concentrations before writing equilibrium variables: , not just .
- Equilibrium Law Substitution
, where represents the total free proton concentration at equilibrium.
Substitute the full expression into the numerator: .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the ICE table for with initial : , , .
Substitute into : , yielding .
Find initial , so .
Repeat for : , yielding .
Find diluted , so .
(a) Initial ; (b) Diluted (a shift of ).
03 The student assumes the 5% approximation holds and neglects x in the denominator, setting 0.050 - x ≈ 0.050.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You assumed that , but with , the ratio exceeds , well above the threshold for neglecting . You must solve the quadratic equation directly.
- Step 2Correct
You neglected relative to , which yielded . This is physically impossible because the initial concentration of is only , so cannot exceed .
- Step 3Correct
Your subtraction and conceptual conclusion correctly followed from your computed values, but your numerical result was distorted by the invalid approximations in earlier steps.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the two dissociation stages of sulfuric acid.
You correctly set up the algebraic equilibrium expressions including the common-ion from the first dissociation.
You correctly recognized that a weak acid equilibrium dampens the expected pH shift upon a ten-fold dilution.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou canceled without checking whether .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou reflexively applied the simplifying approximation () without validating whether is sufficiently small relative to the analytical concentration . For sulfuric acid's second dissociation (), the equilibrium constant is of comparable magnitude to ( and ), which requires solving the full quadratic equation.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- 5% Rule Validation
The approximation is only valid if (typically requiring ).
Always compute before canceling terms; if , use the quadratic formula.
- Physical Reality Check
The change in a dissociation reaction cannot exceed the starting concentration of the reactant ().
If your calculated is greater than the initial concentration, reject the approximation immediately and solve the quadratic equation.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet up the quadratic equation for : .
Solve for the positive root: , so , giving .
Set up the quadratic equation for : .
Solve for the positive root: , so , giving .
(a) Initial pH = 1.24; (b) Diluted pH = 2.14 (shift of 0.90 pH units)
Lock it in
Is a strong diprotic acid in both ionization steps in aqueous solution?
No. Only the first dissociation is complete (). The second proton comes from hydrogen sulfate (), which is a weak acid with .
Similar question
Calculate the hydrogen ion concentration in a solution of , given .
Answer
. From complete first dissociation, and . Setting up yields . Solving gives , so .
A student dissolves of potassium hydrogen sulfate () in water to make of solution. Given for , calculate the pH of the solution.
Answer
. The salt dissociates completely into and , so . Equilibrium: . Solving yields , giving .
A wastewater stream containing has . Determine the percentage of that is dissociated at equilibrium, and calculate the solution pH.
Answer
Dissociation percentage ; . Setting up gives . Solving yields . The fraction dissociated is (or solving more precisely, , with dissociation ). Dilution at very low concentrations drives dissociation near completion.