Resources
Phosphorus disproportionates at the threshold of strong alkaline conditions according to the reaction: . Determine: (a) the oxidation state of phosphorus in elemental , in , and in the hypophosphite ion , (b) the specific substance acting simultaneously as both the oxidizing agent and the reducing agent, and (c) the exact fraction of the total phosphorus atoms that undergoes oxidation.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) In , the oxidation state of is ; in , the oxidation state of is ; in , the oxidation state of is . (b) Elemental phosphorus, , acts as both the oxidizing agent and the reducing agent (disproportionation). (c) Exactly (or ) of the total phosphorus atoms undergo oxidation to .
Steps
Part (a): Oxidation State of Phosphorus
To assign the oxidation number of phosphorus () in each species, apply the standard oxidation-state rules:
-
In elemental phosphorus ():
- Any element in its uncombined or homonuclear elemental form has an oxidation state of .
- Therefore, the oxidation state of in is .
-
In phosphine ():
- Hydrogen bonded to a non-metal has an oxidation state of .
- Since is neutral, the sum of oxidation numbers is zero:
- Therefore, the oxidation state of in is .
-
In the hypophosphite ion ():
- Hydrogen has an oxidation state of , and oxygen has an oxidation state of .
- The sum of oxidation numbers equals the net charge of the ion ():
- Therefore, the oxidation state of in is .
Part (b): Identification of the Oxidizing and Reducing Agents
- An oxidizing agent gains electrons and undergoes a decrease in oxidation state (reduction). Here, phosphorus atoms change from in to in .
- A reducing agent loses electrons and undergoes an increase in oxidation state (oxidation). Here, phosphorus atoms change from in to in .
Because the same reactant is simultaneously oxidized and reduced, this reaction is a disproportionation reaction. The specific substance acting as both the oxidizing agent and the reducing agent is elemental phosphorus, .
Part (c): Fraction of Phosphorus Atoms Undergoing Oxidation
From the balanced chemical equation:
- Total phosphorus atoms reacted:
- Each formula unit of contains phosphorus atoms.
- Phosphorus atoms oxidized:
- Oxidation forms , where each ion contains phosphorus atom in the state.
- With a stoichiometric coefficient of , exactly phosphorus atoms are oxidized to .
- Phosphorus atoms reduced:
- Reduction forms , accounting for the remaining phosphorus atom in the state.
Therefore, the fraction of the total phosphorus atoms that undergoes oxidation is:
(Pitfall to avoid: Do not confuse the stoichiometric coefficient of the molecular reactant , which is , with the total atom count of phosphorus, which is .)
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the fraction of phosphorus oxidized with the stoichiometric coefficient ratio from the balanced equation or calculates the fraction reduced as 1/4 instead of 3/4.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Oxidation state of in is ; In : , so ; In : , so
- Step 2
acts as both the oxidizing agent and the reducing agent
- Step 3
Total phosphorus atoms Phosphorus reduced to Fraction undergoing oxidation
CorrectYou correctly identified that out of phosphorus atoms is reduced to , but the question asked for the fraction that undergoes oxidation. Oxidation converts from to in , which accounts for out of the atoms, giving a fraction of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou assigned the correct oxidation states for elemental phosphorus and both product species.
You accurately identified as acting as both the oxidizing and reducing agent.
You correctly counted a total of phosphorus atoms per reactant molecule and atom reduced to .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou found that phosphorus atom was reduced to and inadvertently reported as the fraction oxidized instead of the fraction reduced.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisIn disproportionation reactions, phosphorus splits into two different products with different oxidation states. After identifying that atom undergoes reduction to , you reported that reduced fraction without taking the complement or counting the atoms oxidized to .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Match the process to the product
Oxidation corresponds to an increase in oxidation state (loss of electrons); reduction corresponds to a decrease (gain of electrons).
Label each product branch explicitly as either 'oxidation' or 'reduction' before calculating the atom ratios.
- Account for all reacted atoms
The sum of the fraction oxidized and the fraction reduced must equal in a single-element disproportionation: .
Check that the two fractions sum to : here, .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationThe remaining phosphorus atoms are oxidized to : .
Divide the number of oxidized atoms by the total number of reactant phosphorus atoms: .
(or )
02 The student assumes hydrogen in PH3 acts as a hydride with an oxidation state of -1 rather than +1, leading to an incorrect oxidation state of +3 for phosphorus.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Oxidation state of P in is
- Step 2
In , assuming is : , so
CorrectIn , is :
Hydrogen takes an oxidation state of when bonded to nonmetals. It only takes in ionic metal hydrides (such as or ). With hydrogen as , phosphorus in phosphine has an oxidation state of .
- Step 3
In : , so
- Step 4
acts as both the oxidizing agent and the reducing agent
- Step 5
Total phosphorus atoms in Phosphorus atoms oxidized to Fraction of phosphorus atoms oxidized
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly assigned an oxidation state of to elemental phosphorus in .
You correctly set up and solved the oxidation state equation for the hypophosphite ion .
You correctly concluded that is both the oxidizing agent and reducing agent in this disproportionation reaction.
You correctly counted the individual phosphorus atoms and calculated the oxidized fraction as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed hydrogen acts as a hydride () in phosphine (). In standard oxidation-state hierarchy rules, hydrogen is assigned whenever it is bonded to nonmetals, and only takes an oxidation state of when bonded to active metals.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Hydrogen Oxidation State Rule
Assign an oxidation state of when bonded to nonmetals (e.g., , , , ), and only when bonded to metals (e.g., , ).
Check the partner element: if it is a nonmetal or metalloid, set .
- Consistency with Redox Roles
In a disproportionation reaction, the starting element (here at ) must both increase in oxidation state (oxidation) and decrease in oxidation state (reduction).
Since increases to in , its oxidation state in must be less than , confirming that must be , not .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet the sum of oxidation numbers equal to the neutral charge of the molecule: .
Substitute for each hydrogen atom: .
Solve for the oxidation state of phosphorus: .
(a) In : ; in : ; in : . (b) . (c) (or ).
03 The student identifies the product species instead of the reactant as the oxidizing and reducing agents.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
Oxidizing agents and reducing agents must always be reactant species that undergo the redox change, not products. Because elemental is simultaneously oxidized (to ) and reduced (to ), itself acts as both the oxidizing agent and reducing agent.
- Step 3
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly assigned oxidation states to phosphorus in elemental form and in both polyatomic species.
You correctly identified that phosphorus undergoes oxidation to form hypophosphite and reduction to form phosphine.
You tracked the atom stoichiometry accurately to determine the exact fraction of phosphorus atoms oxidized.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou selected the product species instead of the starting reactant when identifying the oxidizing agent and reducing agent, overlooking that agents in a redox reaction are always reactants. In a disproportionation reaction, the single reactant acts as both agents.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Agents Are Always Reactants
An oxidizing agent causes another species to be oxidized by taking electrons, and a reducing agent causes another species to be reduced by giving electrons. Both must be chosen from the reactants of the forward reaction.
When asked to identify an oxidizing or reducing agent, select exclusively from the left-hand side (reactants) of the chemical equation.
- Disproportionation Recognition
When a single element in a single reactant species is simultaneously oxidized to a higher oxidation state and reduced to a lower oxidation state, that reactant is both the oxidizing agent and the reducing agent.
Identify the reactant containing the element with the intermediate oxidation state as both the oxidizing and reducing agent.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the reactants and products in the balanced equation: .
Recall that redox agents must be reactants. The only reactant containing phosphorus undergoing oxidation-state change is .
Because is reduced from oxidation state to (acting as the oxidizing agent) and oxidized from to (acting as the reducing agent), acts as both.
(a) In : ; in : ; in : . (b) Elemental phosphorus, , is simultaneously the oxidizing agent and the reducing agent. (c) (or ).
Lock it in
In a disproportionation reaction, how do you distinguish which product corresponds to oxidation versus reduction?
Compare the oxidation state of the element in each product to the reactant: an increase in oxidation number indicates oxidation, while a decrease indicates reduction.
Similar question
Chlorine disproportionates in cold dilute base: . Determine the oxidation state of chlorine in each species and find the fraction of total chlorine atoms that undergoes oxidation.
Answer
In , ; in , (reduction); in , (oxidation). Exactly out of chlorine atoms is oxidized, so the fraction undergoing oxidation is .
In hot concentrated alkali, chlorine disproportionates differently: . Calculate: (a) the fraction of chlorine atoms reduced, and (b) the fraction of chlorine atoms oxidized.
Answer
Total chlorine atoms . Five atoms form (, reduction) and one atom forms (, oxidation). Therefore: (a) fraction reduced ; (b) fraction oxidized .
Solid sulfur disproportionates in hot alkaline solution: . Find the oxidation state of sulfur in each species and determine the exact percentage of sulfur atoms that undergoes oxidation.
Answer
In , . In , (reduction). In , (oxidation). Total sulfur atoms . Atoms oxidized . Atoms reduced . Fraction oxidized (or approximately ).