Resources

Consider the series of ionic oxoacid salts of chlorine paired with chromium(III), Cr3+\text{Cr}^{3+}. As the formal oxidation state of chlorine decreases systematically across its oxoanions from perchlorate to hypochlorite: ClO4−\text{ClO}_4^-, ClO3−\text{ClO}_3^-, ClO2−\text{ClO}_2^-, and ClO−\text{ClO}^-. (a) Write the neutral chemical formula for chromium(III) perchlorate. (b) Write the neutral chemical formula for chromium(III) hypochlorite. (c) State the total number of atoms contained within one formula unit of chromium(III) hypochlorite compared to one formula unit of chromium(III) perchlorate.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Cr(ClO4)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO}_4)_3, (b) Cr(ClO)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO})_3, (c) Chromium(III) hypochlorite contains 77 atoms per formula unit (1 Cr+3 Cl+3 O1\text{ Cr} + 3\text{ Cl} + 3\text{ O}), whereas chromium(III) perchlorate contains 1616 atoms per formula unit (1 Cr+3 Cl+12 O1\text{ Cr} + 3\text{ Cl} + 12\text{ O}).

Steps

01

Determine the Chemical Formula of Chromium(III) Perchlorate

An ionic compound must be electrically neutral, meaning the sum of positive charges from the cations must balance the sum of negative charges from the anions.

  1. Identify the ions:

    • The Roman numeral in chromium(III) indicates a cation with a +3+3 charge: CrX3+\ce{Cr^3+}.
    • The perchlorate anion has a −1-1 charge: ClOX4X−\ce{ClO4^-}.
  2. Balance the charges:

    • The lowest common multiple of the ion charges (33 and 11) is 33.
    • Combining one CrX3+\ce{Cr^3+} ion (+3+3) with three ClOX4X−\ce{ClO4^-} ions (3×(−1)=−33 \times (-1) = -3) gives a net neutral charge: (+3)+3(−1)=0(+3) + 3(-1) = 0
  3. Write the formula:

    • When more than one polyatomic ion is present in a formula unit, enclose the polyatomic ion in parentheses and write the count as a subscript outside: Cr(ClOX4)X3\ce{Cr(ClO4)3}.

02

Determine the Chemical Formula of Chromium(III) Hypochlorite

  1. Identify the ions:

    • Cation: CrX3+\ce{Cr^3+}
    • Hypochlorite anion: ClOX−\ce{ClO^-}
  2. Balance the charges:

    • Combining one CrX3+\ce{Cr^3+} ion with three ClOX−\ce{ClO^-} ions balances the charge: (+3)+3(−1)=0(+3) + 3(-1) = 0
  3. Write the formula:

    • Enclose the hypochlorite anion in parentheses with a subscript of 33: Cr(ClO)X3\ce{Cr(ClO)3}.

Pitfall: Parentheses cannot be omitted for polyatomic ions appearing more than once. Writing CrClOX3\ce{CrClO3} would represent chromium chlorate containing one chlorate ion (ClOX3X−\ce{ClO3^-}) and a chromium(I) cation, rather than three hypochlorite ions.


03

Count the Total Number of Atoms in Each Formula Unit

Multiply the number of each type of atom inside the parentheses by the subscript outside the parentheses, then add the single chromium atom:

  1. For chromium(III) hypochlorite, Cr(ClO)X3\ce{Cr(ClO)3}:

    • Chromium (Cr\ce{Cr}): 11 atom
    • Chlorine (Cl\ce{Cl}): 3×1=33 \times 1 = 3 atoms
    • Oxygen (O\ce{O}): 3×1=33 \times 1 = 3 atoms
    • Total: 1+3+3=71 + 3 + 3 = 7 atoms per formula unit.
  2. For chromium(III) perchlorate, Cr(ClOX4)X3\ce{Cr(ClO4)3}:

    • Chromium (Cr\ce{Cr}): 11 atom
    • Chlorine (Cl\ce{Cl}): 3×1=33 \times 1 = 3 atoms
    • Oxygen (O\ce{O}): 3×4=123 \times 4 = 12 atoms
    • Total: 1+3+12=161 + 3 + 12 = 16 atoms per formula unit.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misidentifies the hypochlorite ion by confusing the prefix hypo- with chlorite, writing ClO2⁻ instead of ClO⁻.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Cr3++3 ClO4−→Cr(ClO4)3  ⟹  Formula: Cr(ClO4)3\text{Cr}^{3+} + 3\,\text{ClO}_4^- \to \text{Cr}(\text{ClO}_4)_3 \implies \text{Formula: } \text{Cr}(\text{ClO}_4)_3

  2. Step 2

    Hypochlorite is ClO2−  ⟹  Cr3++3 ClO2−→Cr(ClO2)3  ⟹  Formula: Cr(ClO2)3\text{Hypochlorite is } \text{ClO}_2^- \implies \text{Cr}^{3+} + 3\,\text{ClO}_2^- \to \text{Cr}(\text{ClO}_2)_3 \implies \text{Formula: } \text{Cr}(\text{ClO}_2)_3

    Correct

    Hypochlorite is ClO−  ⟹  Cr3++3 ClO−→Cr(ClO)3\text{Hypochlorite is } \text{ClO}^- \implies \text{Cr}^{3+} + 3\,\text{ClO}^- \to \text{Cr}(\text{ClO})_3

    You identified hypochlorite as ClO2−\text{ClO}_2^-, but ClO2−\text{ClO}_2^- is the chlorite ion. The hypochlorite ion has only one oxygen atom, ClO−\text{ClO}^-, making the formula Cr(ClO)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO})_3.

  3. Step 3

    Cr(ClO2)3 has 1+3+6=10 atoms  ⟹  Cr(ClO4)3 has 1+3+12=16 atoms  ⟹  10 atoms in Cr(ClO2)3 compared to 16 atoms in Cr(ClO4)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO}_2)_3 \text{ has } 1 + 3 + 6 = 10 \text{ atoms} \implies \text{Cr}(\text{ClO}_4)_3 \text{ has } 1 + 3 + 12 = 16 \text{ atoms} \implies 10 \text{ atoms in } \text{Cr}(\text{ClO}_2)_3 \text{ compared to } 16 \text{ atoms in } \text{Cr}(\text{ClO}_4)_3

    Correct

    Cr(ClO)3 has 1+3(1)+3(1)=7 atoms;  Cr(ClO4)3 has 1+3(1)+3(4)=16 atoms\text{Cr}(\text{ClO})_3 \text{ has } 1 + 3(1) + 3(1) = 7 \text{ atoms};\; \text{Cr}(\text{ClO}_4)_3 \text{ has } 1 + 3(1) + 3(4) = 16 \text{ atoms}

    Your method for counting atoms across the formula units was completely accurate, but your total of 1010 atoms for chromium(III) hypochlorite was affected by using chlorite (textClO2−\\text{ClO}_2^-) instead of hypochlorite (textClO−\\text{ClO}^-). One formula unit of textCr(textClO)3\\text{Cr}(\\text{ClO})_3 contains 1+3+3=71 + 3 + 3 = 7 atoms.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You balanced the +3+3 charge of Cr3+\text{Cr}^{3+} with three −1-1 polyatomic anions correctly.

You used parentheses around polyatomic ions when multiple units are present.

You accurately counted individual atoms by multiplying subscripts inside parentheses by outer subscripts.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Polyatomic Ion Nomenclature Confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the prefix-suffix naming conventions for chlorine oxoanions by assigning the formula ClO2−\text{ClO}_2^- (chlorite) to the hypochlorite ion rather than the lowest oxoanion, ClO−\text{ClO}^-.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Chlorine Oxoanion Series
  • The chlorine oxoanion family spans four members from highest to lowest oxygen count: perchlorate (ClO4−\text{ClO}_4^-), chlorate (ClO3−\text{ClO}_3^-), chlorite (ClO2−\text{ClO}_2^-), and hypochlorite (ClO−\text{ClO}^-).

  • Associate the prefix 'hypo-' (meaning 'below' or 'under') with the lowest oxygen count in the series (ClO−\text{ClO}^-).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the correct formula of hypochlorite: ClO−\text{ClO}^-.

  2. Combine one Cr3+\text{Cr}^{3+} with three ClO−\text{ClO}^- ions to form Cr(ClO)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO})_3.

  3. Count the atoms in Cr(ClO)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO})_3: 1 Cr+3(1 Cl)+3(1 O)=7 atoms1\text{ Cr} + 3(1\text{ Cl}) + 3(1\text{ O}) = 7\text{ atoms}.

  4. Compare with Cr(ClO4)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO}_4)_3, which has 1+3(1)+3(4)=16 atoms1 + 3(1) + 3(4) = 16\text{ atoms}.

Final answer

(a) Cr(ClO4)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO}_4)_3, (b) Cr(ClO)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO})_3, (c) Chromium(III) hypochlorite has 77 atoms per formula unit compared to 1616 atoms in chromium(III) perchlorate.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the standard 4-member halogen oxoanion naming ladder: per-...-ate (44), -ate (33), -ite (22), hypo-...-ite (11).

  • Double-check your oxoanion formula before calculating subscripts and atom counts in downstream steps.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to use parentheses around polyatomic ions when balancing charges, placing the subscript directly on oxygen.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Cr3+ requires three ClO4−  ⟹  Formula: CrClO3\text{Cr}^{3+} \text{ requires three } \text{ClO}_4^- \implies \text{Formula: } \text{CrClO}_3

    Correct

    Cr(ClO4)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO}_4)_3

    You correctly determined that three perchlorate ions (ClO4−\text{ClO}_4^-) are needed to balance one Cr3+\text{Cr}^{3+} ion. However, you must enclose the polyatomic ion in parentheses when multiplying it: Cr(ClO4)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO}_4)_3. Writing CrClO3\text{CrClO}_3 omits the perchlorate structure entirely and represents chromium chlorate.

  2. Step 2

    Cr3+ requires three ClO−  ⟹  Formula: CrClO3\text{Cr}^{3+} \text{ requires three } \text{ClO}^- \implies \text{Formula: } \text{CrClO}_3

    Correct

    Cr(ClO)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO})_3

    You correctly recognized the 1:31:3 ratio between Cr3+\text{Cr}^{3+} and ClO−\text{ClO}^-. However, placing the subscript 33 directly after the oxygen without parentheses gives CrClO3\text{CrClO}_3, which suggests one chromium atom, one chlorine atom, and three oxygen atoms (a chlorate ion). To indicate three complete hypochlorite units, write Cr(ClO)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO})_3.

  3. Step 3

    CrClO3:1 Cr+1 Cl+3 O=5 atoms  ⟹  CrClO43:1 Cr+1 Cl+43 O=45 atoms  ⟹  5 atoms compared to 45 atoms\text{CrClO}_3: 1\text{ Cr} + 1\text{ Cl} + 3\text{ O} = 5\text{ atoms} \implies \text{CrClO}_43: 1\text{ Cr} + 1\text{ Cl} + 43\text{ O} = 45\text{ atoms} \implies 5\text{ atoms compared to } 45\text{ atoms}

    Correct

    Cr(ClO)3 contains 7 atoms (1 Cr+3 Cl+3 O), and Cr(ClO4)3 contains 16 atoms (1 Cr+3 Cl+12 O)\text{Cr}(\text{ClO})_3 \text{ contains } 7\text{ atoms } (1\text{ Cr} + 3\text{ Cl} + 3\text{ O}), \text{ and } \text{Cr}(\text{ClO}_4)_3 \text{ contains } 16\text{ atoms } (1\text{ Cr} + 3\text{ Cl} + 12\text{ O})

    Because parentheses were omitted in the formulas, the atom counts were evaluated incorrectly. In Cr(ClO)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO})_3, the outer subscript distributes across the ion, giving 1+3(1)+3(1)=7 atoms1 + 3(1) + 3(1) = 7\text{ atoms}. In Cr(ClO4)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO}_4)_3, the outer subscript multiplies the internal oxygen count, giving 1 Cr+3 Cl+(3×4) O=16 atoms1\text{ Cr} + 3\text{ Cl} + (3 \times 4)\text{ O} = 16\text{ atoms}, rather than reading the digits 44 and 33 as 4343.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the charges of the chromium(III) cation and the respective chlorine oxoanions.

You correctly recognized that three −1-1 anions balance one +3+3 cation to form a neutral compound.

You systematically set up the atom counting step by breaking down each element present in your written formulas.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Parentheses for Polyatomic Ions

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated polyatomic ions as indivisible strings without grouping punctuation, causing you to place the stoichiometric multiplier directly onto the last element's subscript instead of wrapping the entire polyatomic ion in parentheses.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Grouping Polyatomic Ions
  • When a formula unit contains two or more units of a polyatomic ion, enclose the entire polyatomic formula inside parentheses before writing the multiplier subscript on the outside.

  • Check whether the anion contains more than one atom. If it does and you need more than one of them, always write (polyatomic ion)n(\text{polyatomic ion})_n.

Counting Atoms with Parentheses
  • An external subscript multiplies every atom inside the parentheses: in M(XaYb)n\text{M}(\text{X}_a\text{Y}_b)_n, total Y=b×n\text{Y} = b \times n.

  • Multiply the inner subscript by the outer subscript; never concatenate adjacent digits.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the ions and charges: Cr3+\text{Cr}^{3+} and ClO4−\text{ClO}_4^-. To reach net charge zero, one Cr3+\text{Cr}^{3+} pairs with three ClO4−\text{ClO}_4^-.

  2. Enclose the polyatomic ion in parentheses and place the multiplier as an outer subscript: Cr(ClO4)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO}_4)_3.

  3. Identify the ions for the second salt: Cr3+\text{Cr}^{3+} and ClO−\text{ClO}^-. Enclosing the hypochlorite ion in parentheses gives Cr(ClO)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO})_3.

  4. Count atoms in Cr(ClO)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO})_3: 1 Cr+3(1 Cl)+3(1 O)=1+3+3=7 atoms1\text{ Cr} + 3(1\text{ Cl}) + 3(1\text{ O}) = 1 + 3 + 3 = 7\text{ atoms}.

  5. Count atoms in Cr(ClO4)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO}_4)_3: 1 Cr+3(1 Cl)+3(4 O)=1+3+12=16 atoms1\text{ Cr} + 3(1\text{ Cl}) + 3(4\text{ O}) = 1 + 3 + 12 = 16\text{ atoms}.

Final answer

(a) Cr(ClO4)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO}_4)_3, (b) Cr(ClO)3\text{Cr}(\text{ClO})_3, (c) Chromium(III) hypochlorite contains 77 atoms per formula unit, whereas chromium(III) perchlorate contains 1616 atoms per formula unit.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice placing parentheses around polyatomic ions whenever the required subscript is greater than 11.

  • Practice distributing the outside subscript across all elements within parentheses when determining formula unit atom totals.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student does not distribute the outer subscript of 3 to the chlorine atoms inside the parentheses when counting total atoms.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    CrX3++3 ClOX4X−→Cr(ClOX4)X3  ⟹  Formula: Cr(ClOX4)X3\ce{Cr^3+ + 3 ClO4^- -> Cr(ClO4)3} \implies \text{Formula: } \ce{Cr(ClO4)3}

  2. Step 2

    CrX3++3 ClOX−→Cr(ClO)X3  ⟹  Formula: Cr(ClO)X3\ce{Cr^3+ + 3 ClO^- -> Cr(ClO)3} \implies \text{Formula: } \ce{Cr(ClO)3}

  3. Step 3

    Cr(ClO)X3 has 1 Cr+1 Cl+3 O=5 atoms  ⟹  Cr(ClOX4)X3 has 1 Cr+1 Cl+12 O=14 atoms\ce{Cr(ClO)3} \text{ has } 1\text{ Cr} + 1\text{ Cl} + 3\text{ O} = 5\text{ atoms} \implies \ce{Cr(ClO4)3} \text{ has } 1\text{ Cr} + 1\text{ Cl} + 12\text{ O} = 14\text{ atoms}

    Correct

    Cr(ClO)X3 has 1 Cr+3 Cl+3 O=7 atoms;Cr(ClOX4)X3 has 1 Cr+3 Cl+12 O=16 atoms\ce{Cr(ClO)3} \text{ has } 1\text{ Cr} + 3\text{ Cl} + 3\text{ O} = 7\text{ atoms}; \ce{Cr(ClO4)3} \text{ has } 1\text{ Cr} + 3\text{ Cl} + 12\text{ O} = 16\text{ atoms}

    The subscript 33 outside the parentheses multiplies every element inside the parentheses. Chlorine has an implicit subscript of 11, so each formula unit contains 1×3=31 \times 3 = 3 chlorine atoms, not 11.

  4. Step 4

    5 atoms in chromium(III) hypochlorite compared to 14 atoms in chromium(III) perchlorate5\text{ atoms in chromium(III) hypochlorite compared to } 14\text{ atoms in chromium(III) perchlorate}

    Correct

    7 atoms in chromium(III) hypochlorite compared to 16 atoms in chromium(III) perchlorate7\text{ atoms in chromium(III) hypochlorite compared to } 16\text{ atoms in chromium(III) perchlorate}

    This comparison follows directly from the earlier atom counting error in Step 3.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the +3+3 charge on the chromium ion and the −1-1 charge on each oxoanion.

You used parentheses properly when writing chemical formulas containing multiple polyatomic ions.

You accurately multiplied the oxygen subscript by the outer subscript in the perchlorate formula unit.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Subscript Distribution Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the subscript outside the parentheses as applying only to the oxygen atom rather than distributing it across every atom type inside the parentheses.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Distribute Outer Subscripts to All Elements
  • In a formula containing (AxBy)n(A_x B_y)_n, the number of atoms of element AA is x×nx \times n, and the number of atoms of element BB is y×ny \times n.

  • Always multiply the implied or explicit subscript of each individual element inside the parentheses by the multiplier outside before summing.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Count all atoms in Cr(ClO)X3\ce{Cr(ClO)3}: 1 Cr+(1×3) Cl+(1×3) O=1+3+3=7 atoms1\text{ Cr} + (1 \times 3)\text{ Cl} + (1 \times 3)\text{ O} = 1 + 3 + 3 = 7\text{ atoms}.

  2. Count all atoms in Cr(ClOX4)X3\ce{Cr(ClO4)3}: 1 Cr+(1×3) Cl+(4×3) O=1+3+12=16 atoms1\text{ Cr} + (1 \times 3)\text{ Cl} + (4 \times 3)\text{ O} = 1 + 3 + 12 = 16\text{ atoms}.

Final answer

Chromium(III) hypochlorite contains 77 atoms per formula unit, compared to 1616 atoms in chromium(III) perchlorate.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice expanding parentheses explicitly by writing out each element's count as inner subscript×outer subscript\text{inner subscript} \times \text{outer subscript}.

  • Verify your final atom counts by breaking the polyatomic ion into separate units (for example, three distinct ClOX−\ce{ClO^-} groups give 3 Cl3\text{ Cl} and 3 O3\text{ O}).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Write the neutral chemical formula for cobalt(II) hypochlorite and state the total number of atoms in one formula unit.

Answer

Formula: Co(ClO)2\text{Co}(\text{ClO})_2. One formula unit contains 1 Co+2 Cl+2 O=5 atoms1\text{ Co} + 2\text{ Cl} + 2\text{ O} = 5\text{ atoms}.

02

An ionic compound contains aluminum, Al3+\text{Al}^{3+}, paired with chlorite ions. (a) Write its formula. (b) Calculate the total number of oxygen atoms present in 44 formula units of this compound.

Answer

(a) Chlorite is ClO2−\text{ClO}_2^-, so the neutral formula is Al(ClO2)3\text{Al}(\text{ClO}_2)_3. (b) Each formula unit contains 3×2=63 \times 2 = 6 oxygen atoms; across 44 formula units, there are 4×6=244 \times 6 = 24 oxygen atoms.

03

Compare the formulas and total atom counts of copper(II) perchlorate and copper(II) hypochlorite per single formula unit.

Answer

Copper(II) perchlorate is Cu(ClO4)2\text{Cu}(\text{ClO}_4)_2, containing 1+2(1)+2(4)=11 atoms1 + 2(1) + 2(4) = 11\text{ atoms}. Copper(II) hypochlorite is Cu(ClO)2\text{Cu}(\text{ClO})_2, containing 1+2(1)+2(1)=5 atoms1 + 2(1) + 2(1) = 5\text{ atoms}.

Loading workspace…