Resources
A student claims: 'Diluting an aqueous solution of any electrolyte always decreases the concentration of all individual chemical species, and therefore adding pure water to a weak electrolyte solution must decrease the total fraction of acid molecules that ionize.' Test this intuition by considering an aqueous solution of the weak electrolyte hypochlorous acid (, ) prepared at two concentrations: (1) and (2) (a 100-fold dilution). (a) Calculate the equilibrium hydronium concentration and percent ionization for both solutions. (b) Explain mathematically and via Le Chatelier's principle why the percent ionization increases upon dilution despite the decrease in .
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) For : , percent ionization = . For : , percent ionization = . (b) Although decreases by a factor of 10, the percent ionization increases by a factor of 10. Diluting by a factor of decreases the reaction quotient to , which drives the dissociation equilibrium to the right to produce more ions per mole of acid.
Steps
For :
Part (a): Equilibrium Concentrations and Percent Ionization
Hypochlorous acid () is a weak monoprotic acid that ionizes in water according to the equilibrium: The acid dissociation constant expression is: Let . At equilibrium, , where is the initial concentration of . Because is very small, we can apply the approximation : The percent ionization is defined as:
- Equilibrium hydronium concentration:
- Percent ionization:
The rule is valid since .
For (-fold dilution):
- Equilibrium hydronium concentration:
- Percent ionization:
Part (b): Mathematical and Le Chatelier's Principle Explanation
Mathematical Explanation (Ostwald's Dilution Law)
Using the approximate relation :
- The hydronium concentration scales with . When decreases by a factor of , decreases by a factor of .
- The percent ionization is inversely proportional to . When is reduced by a factor of , increases by a factor of (from to ).
Le Chatelier's Principle via Reaction Quotient ()
Suppose the solution at equilibrium is diluted by adding water such that the volume increases by a factor of (decreasing all molar concentrations instantaneously by a factor of ):
Since , it follows that .
To re-establish equilibrium (), the system must shift to the right (toward the side with more dissolved solute particles). Consequently, additional molecules dissociate, increasing the total fraction (percent) of acid ionized, directly disproving the student's intuition.
Typical errors
01 The student miscalculates percent ionization by multiplying [H3O+] by the initial acid concentration instead of dividing by it.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You multiplied by the initial concentration instead of dividing by it. Percent ionization represents the fraction of initial acid molecules that have ionized: .
- Step 3
- Step 4Correct
You repeated the formula mistake by multiplying instead of dividing: .
- Step 5
"Since , decreasing decreases proportionally. Dilution lowers all concentrations, so the reaction cannot produce a higher percentage of ions."
CorrectMathematically, , which is inversely proportional to , meaning dilution increases . By Le Chatelier's principle, diluting by a factor reduces , driving equilibrium toward the side with more aqueous ions.
Because of the inverted definition of , your conclusion was reversed. Percent ionization increases upon dilution because , shifting the system toward producing more dissociated ions per mole of acid.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly set up the equilibrium expression using the small- approximation.
You calculated accurate equilibrium hydronium concentrations for both concentrations.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou used multiplication rather than division in the percent ionization formula.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated the total amount of ions produced with the fractional percentage of acid molecules ionized, misremembering the part-over-whole definition of percent ionization.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Definition of Percent Ionization
Percent ionization is a percentage (part over whole): .
Always verify that your formula divides the ionized amount by the initial concentration so that units cancel into a dimensionless fraction before multiplying by .
- Ostwald's Dilution Law
For a weak acid with small , .
Recognize that as concentration decreases, percent ionization must increase, even though the absolute concentration decreases.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate .
Calculate .
Notice that , so diluting -fold increases the ionization percentage tenfold.
Explain via Le Chatelier's principle: Diluting increases volume, making . The system shifts right to produce more total particles, increasing the fraction of ionized molecules.
(a) For : , . For : , . (b) Percent ionization is , which is inversely proportional to ; diluting by a factor drops , shifting the equilibrium right toward more dissolved ions.
02 The student confuses the direction of shift under Le Chatelier's principle, arguing that adding water shifts the equilibrium left because water is a solvent or reactant.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
, and ,
- Step 2
Mathematically, , so as decreases, increases.
- Step 3
By Le Chatelier's principle, adding water increases the reactant side, so the reaction shifts right to consume water, but because water concentration is constant, dilution decreases product concentrations equally, shifting the reaction to the left where there are fewer ions.
CorrectDilution decreases all aqueous concentrations by factor . Since there are two dissolved product ions ( and ) and only one dissolved reactant molecule (), . By Le Chatelier's principle, the system shifts right toward the side with more dissolved solute particles to counteract the dilution.
Diluting an aqueous equilibrium shifts the position toward the side with a greater number of dissolved particles (moles of aqueous ions). Because dissociation produces two aqueous ions from one weak acid molecule, adding water lowers relative to (), driving the shift to the right, not to the left.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the hydronium ion concentration and percent ionization for both concentrations.
You successfully related percent ionization inversely to the square root of concentration using Ostwald's dilution law.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou misunderstood how dilution shifts an aqueous equilibrium, mistakenly concluding that a decrease in concentration shifts the system toward the side with fewer particles rather than toward the side with more dissolved solute particles.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Count Dissolved Particles
Water as a pure liquid solvent does not change its activity in dilute solutions; only dissolved solute species appear in and .
Count the number of moles of dissolved solute particles on the reactant side versus the product side: (1 aqueous particle 2 aqueous particles).
- Evaluate $Q$ vs $K$
Diluting by a volume factor reduces each aqueous molarity by , giving .
Because , the forward reaction is favored, shifting the equilibrium to the right to produce more ions.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the net reaction involving aqueous species: .
Identify the number of aqueous solute species: 1 aqueous reactant () versus 2 aqueous products ( and ). Water is the liquid solvent and its activity remains essentially 1.
Evaluate the reaction quotient upon dilution by a factor of : . Since , .
Apply Le Chatelier's principle: to restore equilibrium, the system shifts to the right (the side with more aqueous ions), causing more to dissociate and increasing the percent ionization.
Dilution decreases below (), causing the system to shift to the right toward the side with more dissolved ions, thereby increasing the fraction of acid that ionizes.
03 The student forgets to take the square root when solving for x from x² = Ka × C, leading to an incorrect [H3O+] and percent ionization.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You isolated as if the numerator were rather than . Because , you must take the square root of the product to find .
- Step 2Correct
You correctly applied the definition of percent ionization , but the numerical result was affected by the earlier missing square root.
- Step 3Correct
You repeated the same algebraic omission of the square root when solving for in the diluted solution.
- Step 4
Mathematically, , which is constant regardless of dilution. By Le Chatelier's principle, dilution decreases all concentrations equally, so percent ionization remains unchanged.
CorrectMathematically, , so is inversely proportional to and increases upon dilution. By Le Chatelier's principle, dilution by volume factor sets , shifting the equilibrium toward the products (more dissociated particles).
Because of your algebraic error, you concluded that equals a constant. In reality, dilution by factor lowers the concentrations of two product ions in the numerator while lowering only one reactant in the denominator, making and driving forward dissociation.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the equilibrium expression using the small- approximation.
You used the correct definition for percent ionization, , and substituted your calculated values consistently.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou equated directly to instead of taking the square root of .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the quadratic term in the numerator of as a linear term , forgetting that solving for hydronium ion concentration from weak acid dissociation requires taking the square root: .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Solving for $x$ from $K_a = \frac{x^2}{C}$
For a monoprotic weak acid with negligible dissociation, .
Always verify units and powers: if you have , write out explicitly before computing.
- Ostwald's Dilution Law
Percent ionization satisfies .
Recognize that as initial concentration decreases, percent ionization must increase, even though decreases.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFor : .
Compute .
For : .
Compute .
Explain part (b): Mathematically, , which scales inversely with . Conceptually, diluting by factor yields , shifting equilibrium to the right to produce more total ions.
(a) : , ; : , . (b) Percent ionization increases by a factor of 10 because , and dilution causes , shifting equilibrium to the side with more aqueous ions.
Lock it in
What is the mathematical definition of percent ionization () for a weak monoprotic acid of initial concentration ?
. Memory cue: Percent is always 'part over whole' times .
Similar question
A solution of nitrous acid (, ) reaches equilibrium. Calculate its equilibrium and percent ionization.
Answer
, percent ionization = . Steps: Using the quadratic formula (since ionization exceeds ), . Then .
A weak base has . Solution 1 is prepared at and Solution 2 is prepared at . Using the small- approximation, calculate the ratio of the percent ionization of Solution 2 to Solution 1 ().
Answer
Ratio . Steps: . Therefore, .
A solution containing hydrocyanic acid (, ) is diluted with water until its volume increases by a factor of . Calculate the percent ionization before and after dilution, and write the reaction quotient expression immediately after adding water to show why equilibrium shifts to the right.
Answer
; ; . Steps: Initially, . Diluting 4-fold gives , . Immediately upon dilution, each species concentration drops to , so . Because , the system shifts right to produce more ions.