Resources
Strict application of the Aufbau principle predicts that chromium () and copper () should have ground-state valence configurations of and , respectively. (a) Provide the actual experimental ground-state electron configurations for neutral and . (b) Explain the energetic driving force behind these anomalous configurations in terms of electron-electron repulsion and exchange energy. (c) Predict whether tungsten (, directly below and ) exhibits a similar anomalous ground-state valence configuration.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) : ; : ; (b) Enhanced quantum mechanical exchange energy associated with exactly half-filled () and fully filled () subshells, combined with reduced Coulombic pairing energy in , offsets the small promotion energy; (c) No; tungsten adopts the standard Aufbau configuration due to relativistic stabilization of the orbital and a larger energy separation.
Steps
Experimental Ground-State Electron Configurations for and
The standard Aufbau prediction fills the subshell completely before placing electrons into the subshell:
- Predicted for ():
- Predicted for ():
Experimentally, one electron from the orbital is promoted to the orbital to achieve half-filled and fully filled -subshell configurations:
- Chromium ():
- Copper ():
Energetic Driving Force (Exchange Energy and Repulsion)
The transition from to involves an energetic competition:
- Promotion Energy: Promoting an electron from to requires an input of energy because the orbital lies slightly higher in energy than the orbital in neutral free atoms. However, the energy difference is exceptionally small.
-
Exchange Energy (): Quantum mechanical exchange energy is a stabilizing energy released when electrons with identical spins (parallel spins) occupy degenerate orbitals. The stabilization energy is proportional to the number of possible unique pairs of parallel spins, calculated by: where is the number of electrons with parallel spin.
- For , shifting from ( parallel spins in , yielding exchange interactions) to ( parallel spins across and , yielding exchange interactions within the subshell alone) drastically increases the exchange stabilization.
-
Coulombic Pairing Energy (): In the predicted configuration, two electrons are forced into the same spatial orbital, incurring mutual Coulombic repulsion (pairing energy). Moving one electron to an empty orbital relieves this repulsion.
- For , moving an electron to form the closed shell maximizes nuclear screening and symmetry, while eliminating the repulsive pairing in the orbital.
Because the gain in exchange stabilization and the reduction in pairing repulsion together exceed the small promotion energy, the anomalous configurations and represent the true thermodynamic ground states.
Configuration of Tungsten (, )
Although molybdenum (, directly below ) exhibits the anomalous configuration, tungsten () does not follow this pattern.
- Tungsten adopts the standard Aufbau configuration:
Reasoning: In the th period, heavy elements with large nuclear charge () experience pronounced relativistic effects. Inner electrons move at speeds approaching the speed of light, increasing their relativistic mass. This causes the orbitals (including ) to contract spatially and become significantly lower in energy (stabilized). Consequently, the energy gap between the and orbitals widens, making the promotion of a electron to the orbital energetically unfavorable compared to maintaining the paired configuration.
Typical errors
01 The student assumes periodic group trends always hold and mistakenly predicts tungsten adopts the anomalous configuration like chromium and molybdenum.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
Promoting an electron to d maximizes exchange stabilization from parallel spins in half-filled and filled subshells and reduces Coulomb repulsion.
- Step 3
Yes, tungsten is in the same group as Cr and Mo, so it adopts the similar anomalous configuration to achieve a half-filled 5d subshell.
CorrectNo, tungsten adopts the standard Aufbau configuration because relativistic contraction significantly stabilizes the orbital, increasing the energy gap.
You assumed group-level uniformity down Group 6, but heavy elements such as tungsten () experience strong relativistic stabilization of the orbital, which widens the gap and disfavors promoting an electron to .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the anomalous and configurations for and .
You correctly explained the roles of exchange energy and reduced Coulombic repulsion in stabilizing these configurations.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou predicted that tungsten forms an anomalous configuration based strictly on its placement below chromium and molybdenum.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisOver-reliance on vertical periodic group trends without accounting for relativistic effects in heavy period 6 elements, which lower the energy of orbitals and widen the gap.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Relativistic Orbital Contraction in Heavy Elements
For heavy elements (), high nuclear charges cause inner electrons to move at relativistic speeds, contracting and significantly stabilizing all orbitals (including ).
Before predicting anomalous -block configurations in period 6, check whether relativistic stabilization of the orbital widens the energy gap enough to favor the standard Aufbau configuration.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationEvaluate the valence orbital energies for tungsten () in period 6.
Recognize that relativistic contraction stabilizes the orbital, lowering its energy and increasing the energy gap compared to the and gaps.
Because the promotion energy from to exceeds the potential exchange energy gained from a half-filled subshell, tungsten does not promote an electron.
Conclude that tungsten adopts the normal Aufbau ground-state configuration: .
No; tungsten adopts the standard Aufbau configuration .
02 The student confuses the experimental ground state with the Aufbau-predicted configuration for copper and writes 4s² 3d⁹.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
,
Correct,
You correctly gave the ground-state configuration of chromium, but copper also forms an anomalous ground state by promoting one electron to complete the subshell as .
- Step 2
is stabilized by a half-filled shell which maximizes exchange energy among parallel spins, while retains because is almost filled.
CorrectIn both atoms, promoting a electron to requires minimal promotion energy. For , maximizes stabilizing exchange energy among parallel spins. For , forms a closed subshell with maximum exchange pairs and relieves Coulombic pairing repulsion in the orbital.
You correctly explained that exchange energy stabilizes the half-filled subshell in chromium. However, copper does not retain ; promoting an electron to form a completely filled subshell provides significant exchange stabilization and relieves Coulombic pairing repulsion in the orbital.
- Step 3
No, tungsten follows the normal Aufbau configuration .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly wrote the anomalous ground-state electron configuration for chromium.
You clearly explained that quantum mechanical exchange energy stabilizes the half-filled subshell in chromium.
You accurately identified that tungsten retains its paired configuration rather than adopting an anomalous valence state.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou recognized that half-filled subshells provide special stability through exchange energy, but you did not extend the same thermodynamic driving force (exchange stabilization plus relief of -electron Coulombic pairing repulsion) to fully filled subshells ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identify $d^4$ and $d^9$ Anomalies
In the first transition series, both and standard Aufbau predictions promote one electron to yield and .
Whenever you encounter a neutral atom ending in (like ) or (like ), promote one electron into the subshell.
- Energetic Driving Force for $d^{10}$
A completely filled subshell maximizes exchange energy and symmetric charge distribution while relieving pairing repulsion, overcoming the small promotion energy.
Explain stability in copper using both the gain in exchange stabilization from filling the subshell and the reduction in Coulombic repulsion from unpairing the electrons.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecall that the exceptional stability in transition metal ground states applies to both half-filled () and fully filled () subshells.
Write the configuration of neutral copper () by promoting one electron from to : .
State the energetic driving force: the combined stabilization from achieving a closed subshell (maximizing exchange pairs) and eliminating Coulombic pairing repulsion in exceeds the small promotion energy.
(a) ; ; (b) Achieving half-filled () and fully filled () subshells maximizes quantum exchange energy and relieves Coulombic pairing repulsion in the orbital, exceeding the small promotion energy; (c) No, tungsten adopts due to relativistic stabilization of the orbital.
Lock it in
What physical phenomenon causes orbitals in heavy elements () to be unusually low in energy?
Relativistic contraction: high effective nuclear velocity increases electron mass, contracting orbitals and strongly stabilizing them.
Similar question
Molybdenum (, ) lies directly below chromium (, ). Write its experimental ground-state electron configuration and state whether it follows the anomalous pattern.
Answer
. Yes, like chromium, the energy gap is small enough that exchange stabilization of a half-filled subshell favors promoting one electron.
Group 10 consists of (), (), and (). Their valence configurations are , , and . Explain why retains an electron in instead of adopting like .
Answer
Relativistic stabilization lowers the energy of the orbital in , widening the energy gap. While promotes both electrons to maximize closure, fully depopulating the stabilized orbital in is energetically unfavorable, leaving it as .
Consider gold (, , Group 11). Despite strong relativistic stabilization of the orbital, gold adopts an anomalous valence configuration rather than . Explain why promotion occurs in but fails to occur in ().
Answer
In gold, achieving a completely closed subshell provides immense stabilization through complete spherical symmetry, total reduction of -hole repulsion, and high effective nuclear charge screening across all ten electrons. In tungsten, forming a half-filled subshell only provides exchange stabilization, which is insufficient to overcome the large relativistic promotion cost from the stabilized orbital.