Resources
Consider the hypothetical assignment of electrons into a set of three degenerate orbitals. Determine whether assigning two pairs of electrons with anti-parallel spins into two orbitals while leaving the third orbital completely empty (configuration: ) violates the Pauli exclusion principle, Hund's rule, or both. Identify which fundamental physical condition represents the threshold boundary where Hund's rule dictates single occupancy over pairing.
Answer and steps
Final answer
The configuration violates Hund's rule only; it does not violate the Pauli exclusion principle because no individual orbital contains more than two electrons or two electrons with identical quantum numbers. The physical threshold boundary is governed by the electron-electron Coulomb repulsion energy (pairing energy, ) versus the orbital energy splitting (): for degenerate orbitals where , the pairing energy is strictly greater than zero (), so electrons must occupy separate degenerate orbitals with parallel spins to minimize interelectronic repulsion and maximize exchange energy until all degenerate orbitals are singly filled.
Steps
Evaluation of the Pauli Exclusion Principle
The Pauli exclusion principle states that no two electrons in an atom can have the identical set of four quantum numbers . Within any single spatial atomic orbital (defined by ):
- A maximum of two electrons can occupy the orbital.
- If two electrons share an orbital, they must have opposite (anti-parallel) spin projections: and .
In the proposed configuration:
- The first orbital contains two electrons with opposite spins ( and ).
- The second orbital contains two electrons with opposite spins ( and ).
- The third orbital is empty.
Because no single orbital exceeds two electrons and no orbital contains electrons with identical spins, the Pauli exclusion principle is not violated.
Evaluation of Hund's Rule
Hund's rule of maximum multiplicity states that for a set of degenerate orbitals (orbitals having equal energy), the lowest-energy configuration maximizes the total spin quantum number . Consequently:
- Electrons occupy degenerate orbitals singly with parallel spins before any orbital is doubly occupied.
For a system in three degenerate orbitals:
- Ground-state configuration: , yielding two unpaired electrons with parallel spins ().
- Proposed configuration: , yielding zero unpaired electrons () and leaving one degenerate orbital completely vacant while pairing electrons prematurely.
Because electrons are paired before all degenerate orbitals are singly occupied, Hund's rule is violated.
Physical Threshold Boundary: Pairing Energy vs. Orbital Splitting
The energetic choice between single occupancy and pairing is governed by the competition between two quantities:
- Orbital energy splitting (): The difference in potential energy between available orbitals.
- Pairing energy (): The energy penalty required to place two electrons into the same spatial orbital, which arises from electrostatic Coulomb repulsion and the loss of stabilizing quantum-mechanical exchange energy.
The general occupancy condition is:
- If , electrons occupy separate orbitals with parallel spins to minimize repulsion and maximize exchange stabilization.
- If , electrons pair up in the lower-energy orbital because the energy cost of promotion () exceeds the pairing penalty ().
For completely degenerate orbitals, the energy splitting is zero:
Because the pairing energy is strictly positive () due to interelectronic Coulomb repulsion, the condition always holds. Therefore, the boundary threshold dictates that single occupancy with parallel spins is mandatory until every degenerate orbital contains one electron.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the Pauli exclusion principle with Hund's rule, believing that any premature pairing or leaving an empty degenerate orbital violates the Pauli exclusion principle.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Pauli exclusion principle requires orbitals to be filled with parallel spins first.
CorrectThe Pauli exclusion principle requires that no two electrons share the same four quantum numbers, which limits each orbital to a maximum of two electrons with opposing spins ().
You conflated the Pauli exclusion principle with Hund's rule. Filling degenerate orbitals singly with parallel spins before pairing is governed by Hund's rule, not the Pauli exclusion principle.
- Step 2
Leaving an empty p orbital while pairing violates both Pauli exclusion principle and Hund's rule.
CorrectThe configuration violates Hund's rule only.
Because each occupied orbital contains at most two electrons with anti-parallel spins, the Pauli exclusion principle is fully satisfied. The premature pairing and empty degenerate orbital violate only Hund's rule of maximum multiplicity.
- Step 3
Threshold condition: pairing energy .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that Hund's rule is violated by the proposed electron arrangement.
You identified pairing energy () as the fundamental physical threshold favoring single occupancy.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the scope of the Pauli exclusion principle with Hund's rule, attributing spin alignment across different degenerate orbitals to Pauli's principle rather than restricting Pauli's principle to single-orbital electron capacity and spin pairing.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Pauli Exclusion Principle Scope
The Pauli exclusion principle applies strictly within each individual spatial orbital: a maximum of electrons per orbital, which must have opposite spins ( and ).
Check each orbital individually; if no single orbital contains more than two electrons or identical spins, the Pauli exclusion principle is obeyed.
- Hund's Rule Scope
Hund's rule dictates how electrons distribute across multiple degenerate orbitals: occupy singly with parallel spins first to maximize exchange energy and minimize Coulomb repulsion.
Check across all degenerate orbitals; if an orbital is empty while another degenerate orbital contains paired electrons, Hund's rule is violated.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationState the Pauli exclusion principle: no two electrons can have identical sets of quantum numbers , meaning each spatial orbital holds at most two electrons with opposite spins.
Evaluate the configuration against Pauli: each occupied orbital has two electrons with opposite spins, so it obeys the Pauli exclusion principle.
Evaluate against Hund's rule: degenerate orbitals must be singly occupied with parallel spins before pairing occurs. Since one orbital is empty while others are doubly occupied, it violates Hund's rule.
The configuration violates Hund's rule only; the threshold boundary is governed by pairing energy relative to degenerate orbital splitting .
02 The student mistakenly believes that Hund's rule only dictates spin alignment (multiplicity) within occupied orbitals rather than requiring maximum single occupancy across degenerate orbitals, concluding neither rule is violated.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Each orbital has at most two electrons with opposite spins, so Pauli exclusion principle is obeyed.
- Step 2
Because each pair has net spin zero and opposite spins, Hund's rule is not violated. Neither rule is violated.
CorrectHund's rule is violated because electrons must singly occupy all degenerate orbitals with parallel spins to maximize total spin (, configuration ) before pairing ().
Hund's rule requires maximizing total spin multiplicity () by filling degenerate orbitals singly with parallel spins first. Prematurely pairing electrons into two orbitals leaves one degenerate orbital completely empty and gives instead of the ground-state .
- Step 3
Threshold condition: pairing energy equals orbital energy gap .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly analyzed the spin states within individual orbitals to evaluate the Pauli exclusion principle.
You identified that the pairing energy versus orbital energy gap () defines the threshold for electron pairing.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated Hund's rule as an orbital-level spin neutrality rule rather than a degenerate-subshell rule that maximizes total spin multiplicity () across all equal-energy orbitals.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Hund's Rule of Maximum Multiplicity
For degenerate orbitals, the ground state maximizes total spin ; electrons fill orbitals singly with parallel spins before pairing.
Count all unpaired electrons and maximize the number of parallel spins across all degenerate orbitals before adding a second electron to any orbital.
- Degenerate Orbital Threshold Condition
Electrons pair only if the energy gap to an empty orbital exceeds the pairing energy penalty: .
Note that for degenerate orbitals, ; because Coulombic pairing energy , the condition is always met, forbidding premature pairing.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationEvaluate the total spin of the proposed configuration : .
Determine the ground-state configuration for electrons in three degenerate orbitals by applying Hund's rule: , which gives .
Compare the two configurations: because and a degenerate orbital was left vacant while electrons paired prematurely, Hund's rule is violated.
The configuration violates Hund's rule only; it does not violate the Pauli exclusion principle. The threshold boundary is , which for degenerate orbitals () always yields , enforcing single occupancy.
Lock it in
What physical constraint does the Pauli exclusion principle impose on a single spatial orbital?
A maximum of two electrons with opposing spins ( and ). Memory cue: Pauli governs maximum capacity per orbital.
Similar question
For a set of degenerate orbitals containing electrons, identify which principle is violated by the configuration: .
Answer
Violates the Pauli exclusion principle (and consequently Hund's rule). Key step: The first orbital contains two electrons with parallel spins ( for both), which directly violates the Pauli exclusion principle.
Determine whether the carbon ground-state excited configuration represents a valid excited state that obeys the Pauli exclusion principle.
Answer
Yes, it is an allowed excited state that obeys the Pauli exclusion principle but violates Hund's rule. Key step: The orbital has two paired anti-parallel electrons (), satisfying Pauli; it is an excited state because pairing costs Coulomb repulsion energy .
In an octahedral coordination complex with orbital splitting parameter and mean pairing energy , under what exact energetic condition does a ion adopt a low-spin configuration instead of high-spin ?
Answer
. Key step: When the crystal field splitting energy exceeds the pairing energy penalty , the energetic cost of promoting an electron to the higher level is greater than the pairing cost, favoring pairing in the lower set.