Resources
A closed, rigid reaction vessel contains an initial equimolar mixture of hydrogen gas, , and oxygen gas, , at and a total pressure of . (a) Classify this initial gaseous system as an element, a compound, or a mixture (specifying homogeneous or heterogeneous). (b) An electrical spark is introduced, triggering the synthesis reaction , which proceeds to completion. The container is then cooled back to the original temperature of , where the vapor pressure of liquid water is . Identify the limiting reactant, calculate the final partial pressure of the unreacted gas remaining, and classify the final multi-phase system inside the vessel as an element, compound, or mixture.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) The initial system is a homogeneous mixture (a gas mixture of two diatomic elements). (b) is the limiting reactant (requiring of per of ). If initially, all of reacts with of , leaving of unreacted . The final system contains unreacted gaseous oxygen, liquid water, and water vapor; therefore, the final multi-phase system is a heterogeneous mixture containing an element () and a compound ().
Steps
Part (a): Classification of the Initial System
-
Definitions:
- An element is a pure substance made of only one type of atom (e.g., or ).
- A compound is a pure substance composed of two or more different elements chemically bonded in a fixed ratio (e.g., ).
- A mixture consists of two or more distinct substances physically combined without chemical bonding.
- A homogeneous mixture has a uniform composition throughout (a single phase).
- A heterogeneous mixture has non-uniform composition or distinct visible phases.
-
Analysis:
- The initial system contains two distinct diatomic elements, and , which are not chemically bonded to each other.
- All gases mix completely at the molecular level, forming a single gaseous phase.
- Therefore, the initial system is a homogeneous mixture (a solution of gases).
Part (b): Limiting Reactant, Partial Pressure, and Final System Classification
-
Initial Partial Pressures:
- For an equimolar mixture in a closed, rigid vessel at constant volume () and temperature (), the mole fraction of each gas is .
- By Dalton's law of partial pressures:
-
Identifying the Limiting Reactant:
- The balanced chemical equation is:
- The stoichiometric mole ratio is . By the ideal gas law ( at constant and ), complete consumption of of would require:
- Since only of is present, is the limiting reactant, and is in excess.
-
Final Partial Pressure of Unreacted Gas:
- All of reacts:
- The corresponding amount of consumed is:
- The final partial pressure of unreacted is:
-
Classification of the Final System:
- At , the product water condenses into a liquid phase (), establishing an equilibrium with its vapor ( at ).
- The gas phase contains unreacted and , while liquid water forms a separate phase at the bottom.
- Because the system contains multiple phases (liquid and gas) and multiple chemical substances—an element () and a compound ()—the final system is a heterogeneous mixture.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the stoichiometric coefficient with the amount of reactant consumed, concluding that O2 is limiting because 1 mole is smaller than 2 moles.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Homogeneous mixture because gases mix completely into one uniform phase.
- Step 2
, so and .
- Step 3
Comparing coefficients, has a coefficient of while has , so is limiting.
Correctis the limiting reactant because the reaction requires for every , meaning is consumed twice as fast.
You chose the limiting reactant by looking for the smaller stoichiometric coefficient alone. A reactant with a larger coefficient is consumed at a faster rate; since both gases start with equal partial pressures ( each), the ratio means runs out first.
- Step 4
All of reacts, requiring of .
Correctis completely consumed (), consuming , leaving .
Your calculation followed from misidentifying the limiting reactant in the previous step. Notice that obtaining a negative partial pressure () is a clear warning sign that the other reactant must be limiting.
- Step 5
Final system is a heterogeneous mixture of liquid water, vapor, and excess gas.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly classified the initial equimolar gas system as a homogeneous mixture.
You correctly calculated the initial partial pressures of and using Dalton's law.
You correctly recognized that the presence of liquid water along with gases constitutes a heterogeneous mixture.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the stoichiometric coefficient as a direct indicator of which reactant limits the reaction, rather than calculating the ratio of available amount to stoichiometric coefficient ( or ).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Limiting Reactant Identification
The limiting reactant is the one that gives the smallest ratio of available moles (or partial pressure) to stoichiometric coefficient: .
Divide each reactant's available partial pressure by its balanced coefficient: and . The smaller value designates as limiting.
- Sanity Check for Physical Quantities
Partial pressures and mole quantities of remaining reactants must always be greater than or equal to zero.
If your subtraction produces a negative quantity of remaining reactant, pause and reverse your choice of limiting reactant.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the reaction extent ratios: for , ; for , .
Because , is completely consumed and is the limiting reactant.
Calculate the pressure of consumed: .
Find the final partial pressure of unreacted oxygen: .
(a) Homogeneous mixture. (b) Limiting reactant: ; final partial pressure of unreacted gas: ; final system classification: heterogeneous mixture.
02 The student applies a 1:1 mole ratio instead of the balanced reaction stoichiometry (2:1), concluding that both reactants are completely consumed with no unreacted gas remaining.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Homogeneous mixture of two gases.
- Step 2
and initially.
- Step 3
Assuming reactants react in an equal 1:1 ratio, neither is limiting as both react completely.
Correctis the limiting reactant because react with .
You used an assumed stoichiometric ratio instead of the balanced equation . Because of requires of , hydrogen runs out first and is the limiting reactant.
- Step 4
Final partial pressure of unreacted gas =
CorrectBecause you concluded that both reactants were fully consumed, you found of remaining gas. With limiting, of consumes of , leaving of unreacted .
- Step 5
Final system contains only pure water in liquid and gas phases, so it is a compound.
CorrectHeterogeneous mixture (containing unreacted gaseous , liquid , and vapor).
Because unreacted remains alongside liquid water and water vapor, the container holds multiple chemical substances across multiple phases, making it a heterogeneous mixture.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly classified the initial two-gas system as a homogeneous mixture.
You correctly found the initial partial pressures of and from the total pressure and mole fractions.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that equimolar reactants react in a ratio rather than comparing available quantities against the stoichiometric coefficients of the balanced reaction equation ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Read coefficients from the balanced equation
Reactants combine according to their stoichiometric coefficients, not necessarily in a ratio.
Always divide each reactant's available moles (or partial pressure) by its stoichiometric coefficient to determine which quantity is smaller and thus limiting.
- Classifying multi-substance, multi-phase systems
A system containing two or more distinct chemical species (e.g., an element and a compound) across different phases is a heterogeneous mixture.
List all chemical substances and physical phases present after reaction completion before classifying the final system.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the stoichiometric requirement: are required for every .
Compare available pressures: , whereas . Since , is limiting.
Calculate unreacted oxygen: , leaving .
Identify final contents: , , and . Because multiple substances exist in different physical phases, the final system is a heterogeneous mixture.
Limiting reactant: ; final partial pressure of unreacted gas: ; classification: heterogeneous mixture.
03 The student adds the vapor pressure of water to the remaining unreacted oxygen gas when calculating the final partial pressure of the unreacted gas.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Homogeneous mixture of and gases.
- Step 2
, is limiting because of requires of .
- Step 3Correct
The prompt asked specifically for the partial pressure of the unreacted gas remaining (). That value is . By adding , you calculated the total pressure of the gas mixture rather than the partial pressure of the unreacted reactant.
- Step 4
Final system contains liquid and gas phases, so it is a heterogeneous mixture.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly classified the initial gas solution as a homogeneous mixture.
You determined the correct initial equimolar partial pressures of each reactant.
You used the stoichiometric mole ratio to correctly identify hydrogen as the limiting reactant.
You correctly determined that of oxygen gas remains unconsumed.
You properly recognized that the multi-phase product system constitutes a heterogeneous mixture.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou found the correct unreacted oxygen pressure of , but you included the vapor pressure of water to give the total gas pressure instead of reporting the unreacted gas's partial pressure.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisMisinterpreting the quantity requested by the prompt: treating 'partial pressure of the unreacted gas' as 'total pressure of the gas phase above the liquid'.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Partial Pressure vs. Total Pressure
By Dalton's Law, the partial pressure of an individual gas component depends only on its moles: . The vapor pressure of another substance adds to , not to .
When asked for the partial pressure of a specific unreacted gas, report directly without adding vapor pressures of coexisting liquids.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the unreacted gas remaining in the vessel as .
Subtract the reacted pressure from the initial pressure: .
Keep separate from the vapor pressure of water, , because water vapor is a reaction product, not unreacted gas.
(a) Homogeneous mixture. (b) Limiting reactant: ; final partial pressure of unreacted gas: ; final system: heterogeneous mixture.
Lock it in
How do you systematically determine the limiting reactant given initial moles (or pressures) and a balanced equation?
Divide each reactant's initial amount by its stoichiometric coefficient. The reactant with the smallest quotient is limiting.
Similar question
A rigid vessel contains of and of at constant temperature. They react according to to completion. Identify the limiting reactant and calculate the final partial pressure of the unreacted gas.
Answer
is limiting. Dividing initial pressures by coefficients gives for and for . Since , limits the reaction. Consumed . Remaining .
A container holds and . An electrical spark triggers . Identify the limiting reactant, find the moles of excess reactant left over, and classify the final gaseous product mixture as an element, compound, or mixture.
Answer
is limiting because . The reaction consumes , leaving unreacted alongside . Because it contains two different substances in a single phase, the final gas is a homogeneous mixture.
Gaseous ammonia and oxygen react via in a sealed chamber. The initial partial pressures are and . Determine the limiting reactant and the final partial pressure of the excess reactant remaining after reaction completion.
Answer
is limiting. Comparing ratios: vs. . Since , is limiting. Oxygen consumed is . Remaining .