Resources
Consider the molecule sulfur tetrafluoride (), which has a nonzero net molecular dipole moment. Rather than evaluating whether the molecule is polar or nonpolar overall, determine: (a) the total valence electron count and the steric number of the central sulfur atom; (b) the preferred VSEPR electron-domain and molecular geometries; (c) the specific site (equatorial vs. axial) occupied by the nonbonding lone pair along with the thermodynamic rationale minimizing repulsive interactions; and (d) the direction along which the resultant net dipole moment vector points (relative to the equatorial and axial planes).
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Valence electrons ; steric number of (four single bonds and one lone pair, hybridization). (b) Electron-domain geometry is trigonal bipyramidal; molecular geometry is seesaw (disphenoidal, symmetry). (c) The lone pair occupies an equatorial position because equatorial placement results in only two high-energy lone pair-bonding pair (lp-bp) repulsions, whereas axial placement would incur three unfavorable lp-bp repulsions. (d) The net molecular dipole moment lies entirely in the equatorial plane, bisecting the equatorial bond angle and directed away from the equatorial lone pair toward the electronegative fluorine atoms.
Steps
Part (a): Valence Electron Count and Steric Number
-
Calculate the Total Valence Electrons:
- Sulfur () is in Group 16: .
- Fluorine () is in Group 17: .
-
Determine the Electron Distribution and Steric Number:
- Form four single bonds, which uses .
- Complete the octets of the four peripheral fluorine atoms: .
- The remaining electrons are placed on the central sulfur atom:
- The central sulfur atom has bonding pairs and nonbonding lone pair, yielding a steric number of:
- A steric number of corresponds to hybridization.
Part (b): VSEPR Electron-Domain and Molecular Geometries
- Electron-Domain Geometry: Five electron domains around a central atom adopt a trigonal bipyramidal arrangement to maximize separation.
- Molecular Geometry: Taking into account only the positions of the atomic nuclei with one lone pair present ( designation), the molecular shape is described as seesaw (or disphenoidal, possessing point group symmetry).
Part (c): Site Preference for the Lone Pair (Equatorial vs. Axial)
In VSEPR theory, electron-pair repulsions decrease in the order: Repulsive interactions between domains at angles dominate molecular stability, while interactions at or are negligible by comparison.
- Axial Placement: If the lone pair is placed in an axial position, it forms angles with all three equatorial bonding pairs, resulting in three severe repulsions.
- Equatorial Placement: If the lone pair is placed in an equatorial position, it forms angles with only the two axial bonding pairs (and with the two remaining equatorial pairs), resulting in only two severe repulsions.
Because two repulsions are thermodynamically much more favorable than three, the lone pair occupies an equatorial site.
Part (d): Direction of the Net Dipole Moment Vector ()
-
Axial Dipole Component:
- Due to lone-pair repulsion, the axial bonds bend slightly away from the equatorial lone pair, creating an axial angle of approximately rather than .
- By symmetry, the vertical components of the two axial bond dipoles are equal in magnitude and point in opposite directions, canceling each other out completely along the axial direction.
-
Equatorial Dipole Component:
- The two equatorial bonds are polar ( toward ) and form an angle of approximately (compressed from ).
- Their individual bond dipole vectors combine symmetrically within the equatorial plane.
-
Resultant Net Dipole:
- The net dipole moment lies entirely in the equatorial plane, bisecting the equatorial bond angle.
- It points away from the equatorial sulfur lone pair toward the electronegative equatorial fluorine atoms.
Typical errors
01 The student places the lone pair in an axial position rather than equatorial, incorrectly assuming axial placement leaves the lone pair with more spatial room.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
The lone pair occupies an equatorial site because an equatorial lone pair experiences only two unfavorable lp-bp repulsions, whereas an axial lone pair experiences three lp-bp repulsions.
In a trigonal bipyramid, repulsions at dominate over repulsions at or . Placing the lone pair in an axial position creates three severe lone pair-bonding pair repulsions with the three equatorial bonds. Placing the lone pair in an equatorial position creates only two repulsions (with the two axial bonds), making equatorial placement thermodynamically preferred.
- Step 4Correct
The net dipole moment lies in the equatorial plane, bisecting the equatorial bond angle and pointing away from the lone pair toward the equatorial fluorine atoms.
Because the lone pair actually occupies an equatorial site, the two axial bond dipoles cancel each other along the vertical axis by symmetry, and the net molecular dipole moment vector points entirely within the equatorial plane away from the lone pair.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou calculated the total number of valence electrons accurately.
You correctly found the steric number and identified the electron-domain geometry.
You correctly named the seesaw molecular geometry.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou evaluated spatial crowding based on general visual intuition rather than minimizing the number of high-energy lone pair-bonding pair repulsions.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Count $90^\circ$ interactions first
In VSEPR theory, repulsive forces decrease sharply with angle: interactions at dominate stability, while interactions at or are negligible by comparison.
Always compare competing geometric sites by counting how many lone pair-bonding pair (and lone pair-lone pair) contacts each site produces.
- Equatorial preference for steric number 5
For a steric number of 5, an axial lone pair produces three interactions, whereas an equatorial lone pair produces only two interactions.
In trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry, always place nonbonding lone pairs into equatorial positions first.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompare the repulsions for both sites: axial placement gives three lp-bp repulsions (with all three equatorial bonds); equatorial placement gives two lp-bp repulsions (with the two axial bonds) and two interactions.
Select the equatorial site because minimizing repulsions governs stability.
Analyze dipole cancellation: the two axial bond dipoles point in opposite directions and cancel vertically.
Sum the remaining bond dipoles: the two equatorial bond dipoles combine to give a resultant vector lying in the equatorial plane, bisecting the equatorial bond angle.
The lone pair occupies an equatorial site to minimize repulsions (2 vs. 3), and the resultant net dipole moment vector lies entirely in the equatorial plane pointing away from the lone pair.
02 The student ignores the lone pair when determining the steric number and geometry, treating SF4 as a simple tetrahedral molecule.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
;
You correctly determined that there are valence electrons. However, forming single bonds and completing the octets of fluorine atoms accounts for electrons, leaving electrons ( lone pair) on the central sulfur atom, giving a steric number of .
- Step 2Correct
Because your steric number was , you assigned tetrahedral geometry. With the correct steric number of and one lone pair (an system), the electron-domain geometry is trigonal bipyramidal and the molecular geometry is seesaw.
- Step 3Correct
In a trigonal bipyramidal arrangement, equatorial and axial positions are not equivalent. The lone pair prefers an equatorial site because it experiences only two severe lone pair-bonding pair repulsions compared to three if placed axially.
- Step 4Correct
Because the seesaw molecule is asymmetric ( symmetry), the individual bond dipoles do not cancel. The axial dipoles cancel vertically, leaving a net dipole vector pointing along the equatorial bisector away from the lone pair.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly counted the total number of valence electrons for as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou equated the steric number directly to the number of bonded atoms without distributing the remaining valence electrons to the central atom.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou overlooked checking for an expanded octet on the central period-3 sulfur atom after satisfying the peripheral fluorine octets, missing the nonbonding electron pair.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Account for all valence electrons
Place any surplus electrons directly onto the central atom as lone pairs before finding the steric number.
- Define steric number comprehensively
Always add both bonding domains and nonbonding lone pairs to determine the VSEPR electron-domain geometry.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSubtract bonding and terminal-atom valence electrons from the total: on .
Determine steric number: domains trigonal bipyramidal electron geometry.
Identify molecular shape for : one lone pair yields a seesaw molecular geometry.
Compare repulsions: an equatorial lone pair experiences two repulsions, whereas an axial lone pair experiences three repulsions, making equatorial placement thermodynamically favored.
Evaluate dipole cancellation: axial dipoles cancel along the axial axis, but equatorial bond dipoles combine to give a net dipole moment lying in the equatorial plane directed away from the lone pair.
(a) valence electrons, steric number ; (b) trigonal bipyramidal electron geometry, seesaw molecular geometry; (c) equatorial position, because it minimizes repulsions ( vs. ); (d) lies entirely in the equatorial plane, bisecting the equatorial angle and pointing toward the equatorial fluorines.
03 The student reverses the direction of the net dipole moment by thinking it points along the highly electronegative fluorine atoms rather than toward the lone pair in the equatorial plane.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
- Step 4
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou calculated the correct total valence electron count () and central steric number ().
You assigned both the electron-domain geometry and molecular geometry accurately.
You applied VSEPR repulsion minimization rules to justify placing the lone pair in an equatorial site.
You correctly resolved the vector components to find that the net dipole moment lies in the equatorial plane pointing toward the fluorines.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeREASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Steric Number and Geometry Mapping
Steric number corresponds to a trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry with equatorial () and axial () positions.
Count bonding pairs plus lone pairs on the central atom to find the parent geometry before determining the molecular shape.
- VSEPR Repulsion Hierarchy
Repulsions at govern stability: .
Always place lone pairs in equatorial sites within a trigonal bipyramid to reduce the number of high-energy repulsions from three to two.
- Symmetry and Vector Addition
In seesaw molecules, equal axial dipole components cancel along the axial axis, so any net dipole must lie along the axis in the equatorial plane.
Combine the strongly polar bond dipoles vectorially and verify their resultant direction relative to the molecular symmetry axes.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationConfirm the symmetry axis: The rotational axis lies within the equatorial plane and bisects both the equatorial angle and the lone pair.
Examine axial bond distortion: Repulsion from the equatorial lone pair compresses the axial angle from to approximately .
Add dipole vectors: Both the compressed axial dipoles and the equatorial dipoles contribute components directed away from the lone pair toward the fluorine atoms, reinforcing the net equatorial dipole.
(a) valence electrons, steric number ; (b) trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry, seesaw molecular geometry; (c) equatorial position because it has only two lp-bp repulsions versus three for axial placement; (d) lies entirely in the equatorial plane, bisecting the equatorial bond angle and directed toward the fluorine atoms.
Lock it in
In a trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry (steric number 5), which bond angles dominate the thermodynamic repulsion between electron domains?
Interactions at dominate. Repulsions at and are much weaker and generally negligible in comparison.
Similar question
Chlorine trifluoride () has a steric number of 5 with three single bonds and two nonbonding lone pairs (). Determine the positions of both lone pairs (equatorial vs. axial) and state the resulting molecular geometry.
Answer
Both lone pairs occupy equatorial positions to minimize severe repulsions (resulting in only one lp-lp repulsion and four lp-bp repulsions, compared to six lp-bp repulsions if placed axially). The resulting molecular geometry is T-shaped.
The triiodide ion () features a central iodine atom bonded to two iodine atoms with three nonbonding lone pairs (). (a) Where do the three lone pairs reside? (b) Is polar or nonpolar?
Answer
(a) All three lone pairs occupy the three equatorial positions around the central iodine atom. (b) The two terminal iodine atoms occupy the axial positions at to each other, so their bond dipoles cancel exactly, making nonpolar (net dipole ).
Consider bromine pentafluoride (), which has a steric number of 6 (). (a) Does the single lone pair show an equatorial vs. axial site preference as in ? (b) In which direction does the net molecular dipole moment point?
Answer
(a) No, all six vertices in an octahedral electron-domain geometry are mutually equivalent with angles to four adjacent sites, so any position is thermodynamically equivalent. (b) With one vertex occupied by a lone pair, the molecular geometry is square pyramidal; the equatorial dipoles cancel symmetrically, leaving a net dipole moment pointing along the fourfold rotational axis toward the axial fluorine atom.