Resources
A student measures the electrical resistivity of a copper alloy wire across temperature. At reference temperature , the wire has resistivity and temperature coefficient of resistivity . (a) Calculate the electrical resistivity when the wire is cooled in liquid nitrogen to using the linear relation . (b) In evaluating why pure metals show positive temperature coefficients () while intrinsic semiconductors show negative coefficients (), explain the physical meaning of the sign of in terms of charge carrier density versus lattice vibration (phonon) scattering.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; (b) For metals, carrier density is constant; higher temperature increases lattice thermal vibrations (phonons), reducing relaxation time and increasing scattering, so . For intrinsic semiconductors, thermal excitation exponentially increases carrier density , dominating over scattering, so .
Steps
Part (a): Calculating Resistivity at Low Temperature
-
Identify the Given Values and Linear Model:
- Reference temperature:
- Reference resistivity:
- Temperature coefficient of resistivity:
- Final temperature:
The linear temperature dependence of resistivity is given by:
- Calculate the Temperature Difference:
- Compute the Bracketed Scaling Factor:
-
Calculate :
(Common Pitfall: Ensure the sign of is negative when cooling below the reference temperature; subtracting from rather than is a frequent algebraic mistake).
Part (b): Physical Origin of the Sign of
Electrical resistivity can be understood microscopically via the Drude model: where is electron mass, is elementary charge, is charge carrier concentration (carrier density), and is the mean relaxation time between scattering events.
- Metals (, ): In metallic bonding, valence electrons form a delocalized "sea of electrons." The carrier density is essentially fixed and independent of temperature. As temperature increases, the positive metal ion cores in the crystal lattice vibrate with greater amplitude (increased lattice thermal vibrations, or phonons). This increases the scattering probability of conducting electrons, shortening the mean free time . Because is constant and decreases, resistivity increases with temperature:
- Intrinsic Semiconductors (, ): At low temperatures, electrons are bound within the valence band. Increasing temperature thermally excites electrons across the band gap into the conduction band, causing the carrier density to increase exponentially (). Although lattice vibrations also increase (reducing ), the exponential increase in carrier density strongly dominates over the decrease in . As a result, resistivity drops substantially as temperature rises:
Typical errors
01 The student calculates ΔT as T₀ - T₁ instead of T₁ - T₀, resulting in an erroneous temperature increase and higher resistivity upon cooling.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You reversed the initial and final temperatures when calculating the change in temperature. The change is defined as final minus initial (). Cooling down to liquid nitrogen temperatures must yield a negative .
- Step 2Correct
Your arithmetic and substitution steps followed your formula correctly, but the result was affected by the positive sign error from Step 1.
- Step 3
In metals, carrier density is constant and lattice vibration scattering increases with temperature, so resistivity increases and . In intrinsic semiconductors, thermal generation of charge carriers increases carrier density, which dominates over scattering, so .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly articulated the microscopic roles of carrier density and lattice vibration scattering across metals and intrinsic semiconductors.
You correctly recalled and algebraically applied the linear temperature relation .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou subtracted the final temperature from the reference temperature rather than computing .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou overlooked the standard definition of change as , or set up the subtraction to keep positive without considering that cooling requires a negative change in temperature.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Temperature change sign check
is always defined as (). When cooling, .
Always write out explicitly before substituting negative temperatures.
- Physical plausibility check for metals
Because metals have positive temperature coefficients (), cooling must decrease electrical resistivity ().
Verify after computing whether cooling produced a resistivity value lower than the room-temperature value.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the correct temperature difference: .
Substitute into the linear equation: .
Evaluate the bracketed term: .
Multiply to find : .
(a) ; (b) For metals, is constant and phonon scattering increases with , so . For semiconductors, carrier generation dominates over scattering, so .
02 The student confuses the physical mechanism of semiconductors with metals, claiming that semiconductor resistivity decreases because lattice vibrations freeze out rather than because carrier density increases.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
For metals, because carrier density is fixed and increased phonon scattering impedes electron flow as temperature rises.
- Step 3
For semiconductors, because rising temperature reduces lattice vibrations and allows electrons to move more freely, while carrier density stays unchanged.
CorrectIn intrinsic semiconductors, thermal excitation promotes electrons across the band gap into the conduction band, causing carrier density to increase exponentially; this increase dominates over higher phonon scattering, so .
Lattice vibrations increase with temperature in all solid lattices. Semiconductor resistivity decreases with temperature because thermal excitation across the band gap exponentially boosts the free carrier concentration , which far outweighs the opposing effect of increased phonon scattering.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou calculated the temperature change and final resistivity accurately with correct signs and units in part (a).
You correctly attributed the positive temperature coefficient in metals to increased phonon scattering at fixed carrier density.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that charge carrier density in intrinsic semiconductors remains fixed with temperature and that thermal energy reduces lattice vibrations, whereas thermal energy actually increases lattice vibrations in all solids while exponentially generating free carriers across the band gap.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Universal Effect of Temperature on Lattice Vibrations
In every crystalline solid, increasing temperature increases thermal energy () and lattice vibration amplitude (phonon population); lattice vibrations never decrease with rising temperature.
Always treat lattice phonon scattering as increasing with temperature regardless of whether the material is a metal, semiconductor, or insulator.
- Carrier Density Contrast (Drude Framework: $\rho = \frac{m_e}{n e^2 \tau}$)
For metals, valence electrons are already delocalized (), so scattering dictates . For intrinsic semiconductors, electrons must be thermally excited across the band gap (), so exponential carrier growth dominates over scattering and drives .
When explaining temperature coefficients, contrast constant carrier density in metals with exponentially activated carrier density in semiconductors.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationExpress electrical conductivity and resistivity via the Drude relation: .
Note that for all solids, higher temperature increases lattice vibrations (phonons), which shortens relaxation time and tends to increase resistivity.
Recognize that in an intrinsic semiconductor, valence electrons are bound at low temperatures. Thermal energy promotes electrons across the band gap into the conduction band.
Conclude that because the carrier concentration increases exponentially with temperature (), the dramatic rise in overwhelms the decrease in , producing .
(a) ; (b) In metals, is constant while phonon scattering increases with temperature, so . In intrinsic semiconductors, thermal excitation exponentially increases carrier density , overcoming increased phonon scattering so that .
Lock it in
How is the temperature change formally defined in the linear resistivity formula ?
. Cooling always yields a negative .
Similar question
An aluminum wire has a resistivity of at and a temperature coefficient . Calculate its resistivity when cooled in dry ice to .
Answer
. Then .
A platinum resistance thermometer has a resistance of at with . When placed in a cold bath, its resistance drops to . Determine the temperature of the bath.
Answer
Using , .
Explain why cooling a heavily doped n-type semiconductor down from room temperature might initially cause its resistivity to decrease slightly before eventually increasing sharply at extremely low temperatures.
Answer
Between moderate and low temperatures, carrier density remains constant (exhaustion/freeze-out has not yet occurred), so reduced lattice phonon scattering decreases resistivity. At extremely low cryogenic temperatures, carrier freeze-out occurs where thermal energy cannot ionize donor atoms, causing to plummet exponentially and driving resistivity sharply up.