Resources

A high-precision vacuum chamber holds a pure sample of iodine (I2\text{I}_2). The phase diagram of iodine features a triple point at Tt=113.7∘CT_t = 113.7^\circ\text{C} and an equilibrium pressure of Pt=91.6 TorrP_t = 91.6\text{ Torr}. An operator sets the chamber pressure to P=1.200×104 PaP = 1.200 \times 10^4\text{ Pa} and the chamber temperature to T=368.15 KT = 368.15\text{ K}. Given the standard conversions 1 atm=101325 Pa=760.0 Torr1\text{ atm} = 101325\text{ Pa} = 760.0\text{ Torr}: (a) Convert both PtP_t and the chamber pressure PP into bars (1 bar=105 Pa1\text{ bar} = 10^5\text{ Pa}), and convert TtT_t and TT into Kelvin. (b) Determine whether heating this sample isobarically at P=1.200×104 PaP = 1.200 \times 10^4\text{ Pa} from 368.15 K368.15\text{ K} will result in direct sublimation into vapor or melting into liquid before vaporization.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Pt=0.1221 barP_t = 0.1221\text{ bar}, P=0.1200 barP = 0.1200\text{ bar}, Tt=386.85 KT_t = 386.85\text{ K}, T=368.15 KT = 368.15\text{ K}; (b) The sample undergoes direct sublimation into vapor without forming a liquid phase.

Steps

Part (a): Unit Conversions

  1. Triple Point Pressure (PtP_t) to bar: First, convert Torr to Pascals using the conversion factor 1 atm=101325 Pa=760.0 Torr1\text{ atm} = 101325\text{ Pa} = 760.0\text{ Torr}: Pt=91.6 Torr×101325 Pa760.0 Torr≈1.2212×104 PaP_t = 91.6\text{ Torr} \times \frac{101325\text{ Pa}}{760.0\text{ Torr}} \approx 1.2212 \times 10^4\text{ Pa} Next, convert Pascals to bars using 1 bar=105 Pa1\text{ bar} = 10^5\text{ Pa}: Pt=1.2212×104 Pa105 Pa/bar≈0.1221 barP_t = \frac{1.2212 \times 10^4\text{ Pa}}{10^5\text{ Pa/bar}} \approx 0.1221\text{ bar}
  2. Chamber Pressure (PP) to bar: P=1.200×104 Pa105 Pa/bar=0.1200 barP = \frac{1.200 \times 10^4\text{ Pa}}{10^5\text{ Pa/bar}} = 0.1200\text{ bar}
  3. Temperatures to Kelvin: Convert the triple point temperature TtT_t using T(K)=T(∘C)+273.15T(\text{K}) = T(^\circ\text{C}) + 273.15: Tt=113.7+273.15=386.85 KT_t = 113.7 + 273.15 = 386.85\text{ K} The chamber temperature is already provided in Kelvin: T=368.15 KT = 368.15\text{ K}

Part (b): Phase Transition Analysis

  1. Initial Phase of the Sample:

    • The triple point temperature is Tt=386.85 KT_t = 386.85\text{ K}, and the chamber temperature is T=368.15 KT = 368.15\text{ K}.
    • Since T<TtT < T_t and P<PtP < P_t, the initial state of the sample lies in the solid region of the phase diagram.
  2. Effect of Isobaric Heating:

    • A phase diagram represents the boundary lines between solid, liquid, and gas phases. The triple point defines the lowest pressure at which the liquid phase can exist in stable equilibrium.
    • Comparing the pressures: P=0.1200 bar<Pt=0.1221 barP = 0.1200\text{ bar} < P_t = 0.1221\text{ bar}
    • Because the chamber pressure PP is strictly below the triple point pressure PtP_t, any horizontal (isobaric) heating path moves from the solid phase directly across the sublimation curve into the gas phase.
    • Therefore, the sample undergoes direct sublimation into vapor without forming an intermediate liquid phase.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student compares the operating temperature to the triple point temperature instead of comparing chamber pressure to the triple point pressure to determine the phase transition sequence, concluding it will melt.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Pt=91.6×(101325760.0)/105=0.1221 bar  ⟹  P=1.200×104105=0.1200 bar  ⟹  Tt=113.7+273.15=386.85 K  ⟹  T=368.15 KP_t = 91.6 \times \left(\frac{101325}{760.0}\right)/10^5 = 0.1221\text{ bar} \implies P = 1.200 \times \frac{10^4}{10^5} = 0.1200\text{ bar} \implies T_t = 113.7 + 273.15 = 386.85\text{ K} \implies T = 368.15\text{ K}

  2. Step 2

    T=368.15 KT = 368.15\text{ K} is below the triple point temperature Tt=386.85 KT_t = 386.85\text{ K}. As the temperature increases past 386.85 K386.85\text{ K}, it will melt into liquid before vaporizing.

    Correct

    P=0.1200 bar<Pt=0.1221 bar  ⟹  P = 0.1200\text{ bar} < P_t = 0.1221\text{ bar} \implies direct sublimation into vapor without forming a liquid phase.

    To determine whether a substance melts or sublimes upon isobaric heating, compare the constant operating pressure PP to the triple point pressure PtP_t. The liquid phase cannot exist at equilibrium below PtP_t. Because P=0.1200 bar<0.1221 barP = 0.1200\text{ bar} < 0.1221\text{ bar}, heating moves the sample directly across the sublimation curve from solid to vapor.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accurately converted all pressure values into bars and temperature values into Kelvin.

You correctly recognized that the initial state is at a temperature lower than the triple point temperature.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Pressure vs. Triple Point Misinterpretation

You evaluated whether melting occurs by checking if the temperature crosses TtT_t, without checking whether the constant pressure allows a liquid phase to exist.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

A stable liquid phase only exists at pressures greater than or equal to the triple point pressure (P≥PtP \ge P_t). In an isobaric heating process (a horizontal path on a P-TP\text{-}T diagram), the pressure determines the sequence of phase transitions: if P<PtP < P_t, the path passes exclusively from solid to gas (sublimation), never intersecting the liquid region.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Criterion for Liquid Existence
  • A stable liquid phase requires P≥PtP \ge P_t.

  • Compare the system pressure PP directly to the triple point pressure PtP_t before tracing temperature changes.

Isobaric Path on Phase Diagrams
  • Heating at constant pressure corresponds to moving horizontally from left to right on a P-TP\text{-}T diagram.

  • Draw a horizontal line at P=0.1200 barP = 0.1200\text{ bar}; observe that it lies entirely below the triple point and crosses only the solid-gas boundary.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare the constant chamber pressure to the triple point pressure: P=0.1200 barP = 0.1200\text{ bar} and Pt=0.1221 barP_t = 0.1221\text{ bar}, so P<PtP < P_t.

  2. On a P-TP\text{-}T phase diagram, a horizontal path at P<PtP < P_t moves from the solid region directly into the vapor region across the sublimation curve.

  3. Conclude that no liquid forms at any temperature under this pressure.

Final answer

The sample undergoes direct sublimation into vapor without forming a liquid phase.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how horizontal (isobaric) lines behave above versus below the triple point on a P-TP\text{-}T phase diagram.

  • Practice identifying whether a substance sublimes or melts by always comparing operating pressure PP to triple point pressure PtP_t first.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student rounds 101325 Pa / 760 Torr incorrectly as 100000 / 760, resulting in an underestimated triple point pressure below the chamber pressure and concluding it melts.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Pt=91.6×100000760.0/105=0.1192 barP_t = 91.6 \times \frac{100000}{760.0} / 10^5 = 0.1192\text{ bar}

    Correct

    Pt=91.6 Torr×101325 Pa760.0 Torr×1 bar105 Pa≈0.1221 barP_t = 91.6\text{ Torr} \times \frac{101325\text{ Pa}}{760.0\text{ Torr}} \times \frac{1\text{ bar}}{10^5\text{ Pa}} \approx 0.1221\text{ bar}

    You used 100000 Pa100000\text{ Pa} for 1 atm1\text{ atm} instead of the given conversion factor 1 atm=101325 Pa1\text{ atm} = 101325\text{ Pa}. This underestimation yielded 0.1192 bar0.1192\text{ bar} instead of 0.1221 bar0.1221\text{ bar}.

  2. Step 2

    P=1.200×104105=0.1200 bar  ⟹  Tt=113.7+273.15=386.85 K  ⟹  T=368.15 KP = \frac{1.200 \times 10^4}{10^5} = 0.1200\text{ bar} \implies T_t = 113.7 + 273.15 = 386.85\text{ K} \implies T = 368.15\text{ K}

  3. Step 3

    P=0.1200 barP = 0.1200\text{ bar} is greater than Pt=0.1192 barP_t = 0.1192\text{ bar}. Because the pressure is above the triple point pressure, heating will cause the solid to melt into liquid before vaporization.

    Correct

    Because P=0.1200 bar<Pt=0.1221 barP = 0.1200\text{ bar} < P_t = 0.1221\text{ bar}, the pressure lies below the triple point; isobaric heating causes direct sublimation into vapor without forming a liquid phase.

    Your reasoning that a pressure above the triple point causes melting is conceptually correct, but because of the conversion error in Step 1, you compared against an incorrect pressure.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You converted the chamber pressure from Pascals to bars accurately.

You correctly calculated the triple point temperature in Kelvin using the standard offset.

You correctly understood that comparing the operating pressure to the triple point pressure determines whether isobaric heating yields melting or sublimation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unit conversion rounding / precision error

You substituted the rounded value 100000 Pa100000\text{ Pa} instead of 101325 Pa101325\text{ Pa} for standard atmospheric pressure.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the bar definition (1 bar=105 Pa=100000 Pa1\text{ bar} = 10^5\text{ Pa} = 100000\text{ Pa}) with the standard atmosphere definition (1 atm=101325 Pa=760.0 Torr1\text{ atm} = 101325\text{ Pa} = 760.0\text{ Torr}) when setting up multi-step pressure unit conversions.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Atmosphere vs. Bar Distinction
  • 1 atm=101325 Pa=760.0 Torr1\text{ atm} = 101325\text{ Pa} = 760.0\text{ Torr}, whereas 1 bar=105 Pa=100000 Pa1\text{ bar} = 10^5\text{ Pa} = 100000\text{ Pa}.

  • Always convert Torr to atmospheres or Pascals using 101325 Pa/760.0 Torr101325\text{ Pa} / 760.0\text{ Torr} before scaling by 105 Pa/bar10^5\text{ Pa/bar}.

Isobaric Heating across the Triple Point
  • Liquid exists only at pressures at or above the triple point pressure (P≥PtP \ge P_t).

  • When P<PtP < P_t, an isobaric heating line moves directly from solid to vapor (sublimation).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert PtP_t accurately: Pt=91.6 Torr×101325 Pa760.0 Torr=1.2212×104 PaP_t = 91.6\text{ Torr} \times \frac{101325\text{ Pa}}{760.0\text{ Torr}} = 1.2212 \times 10^4\text{ Pa}.

  2. Convert PtP_t to bars: Pt=1.2212×104 Pa105 Pa/bar=0.1221 barP_t = \frac{1.2212 \times 10^4\text{ Pa}}{10^5\text{ Pa/bar}} = 0.1221\text{ bar}.

  3. Compare the pressures: P=0.1200 bar<Pt=0.1221 barP = 0.1200\text{ bar} < P_t = 0.1221\text{ bar}.

  4. Deduce phase transition: Because the pressure is strictly below the triple point pressure, the sample undergoes direct sublimation from solid to vapor upon heating.

Final answer

(a) Pt=0.1221 barP_t = 0.1221\text{ bar}, P=0.1200 barP = 0.1200\text{ bar}, Tt=386.85 KT_t = 386.85\text{ K}, T=368.15 KT = 368.15\text{ K}; (b) The sample undergoes direct sublimation into vapor without forming a liquid phase.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Be careful to distinguish 1 atm=101325 Pa1\text{ atm} = 101325\text{ Pa} from 1 bar=100000 Pa1\text{ bar} = 100000\text{ Pa}.

  • Always write out explicit conversion factors with units cancelling to avoid mixing up standard pressure standards.

  • Re-evaluate phase boundaries whenever values lie very close to a reference point.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A sample of water is held in a sealed container at P=4.0 TorrP = 4.0\text{ Torr} and T=−10.0∘CT = -10.0^\circ\text{C}. The triple point of water is at Pt=4.58 TorrP_t = 4.58\text{ Torr} and Tt=0.01∘CT_t = 0.01^\circ\text{C}. If the sample is heated isobarically to 25.0∘C25.0^\circ\text{C}, identify the phase transition that occurs and explain why no liquid forms.

Answer

The sample undergoes direct sublimation into vapor. Because the operating pressure (P=4.0 TorrP = 4.0\text{ Torr}) is below the triple point pressure (Pt=4.58 TorrP_t = 4.58\text{ Torr}), an isobaric heating path lies entirely below the liquid region on the phase diagram and crosses only the sublimation line.

02

Substance X has a triple point at Tt=180 KT_t = 180\text{ K} and Pt=0.50 barP_t = 0.50\text{ bar}. An experimenter prepares two samples of solid X at 100 K100\text{ K}: Sample 1 at P1=0.30 barP_1 = 0.30\text{ bar} and Sample 2 at P2=1.20 barP_2 = 1.20\text{ bar}. Describe the sequence of phase changes for each sample as it is heated isobarically to 300 K300\text{ K}.

Answer

Sample 1 (P1=0.30 bar<PtP_1 = 0.30\text{ bar} < P_t): sublimes directly from solid to gas without forming liquid. Sample 2 (P2=1.20 bar>PtP_2 = 1.20\text{ bar} > P_t): melts from solid to liquid upon crossing the fusion curve, then vaporizes into gas upon crossing the vaporization curve.

03

A chamber contains a substance at P=2.5 barP = 2.5\text{ bar} and T=200 KT = 200\text{ K} in the solid phase. Its triple point is at Pt=1.8 barP_t = 1.8\text{ bar} and Tt=220 KT_t = 220\text{ K}. (a) Does heating at 2.5 bar2.5\text{ bar} lead to melting or sublimation? (b) To achieve direct sublimation upon heating from 200 K200\text{ K}, what adjustment must be made to the chamber pressure?

Answer

(a) It melts into liquid before vaporizing because P=2.5 bar>Pt=1.8 barP = 2.5\text{ bar} > P_t = 1.8\text{ bar}. (b) The chamber pressure must be reduced below the triple point pressure (P<1.8 barP < 1.8\text{ bar}) before heating, ensuring the isobaric path bypasses the liquid phase.

Loading workspace…