Resources

An unknown anhydrous group 2 metal carbonate, MCO3(s)\text{MCO}_3(s), undergoes thermal decomposition upon strong heating to yield a solid metal oxide, MO(s)\text{MO}(s), and carbon dioxide gas, CO2(g)\text{CO}_2(g). When a 4.935 g4.935\,\text{g} sample of MCO3(s)\text{MCO}_3(s) is completely decomposed, it yields 1.468 g1.468\,\text{g} of CO2(g)\text{CO}_2(g). Predict the balanced decomposition equation, deduce the molar mass of the metal M\text{M}, and identify the chemical formula of the original reactant.

Answer and steps

Final answer

MCO3(s)→MO(s)+CO2(g)\text{MCO}_3(s) \rightarrow \text{MO}(s) + \text{CO}_2(g); Molar mass of M=87.6 g/mol\text{M} = 87.6\,\text{g/mol}; Original reactant is SrCO3\text{SrCO}_3

Steps

01

Write the balanced chemical equation

Group 2 metal carbonates decompose upon heating into the solid metal oxide and gaseous carbon dioxide in a 1:11:1 stoichiometric ratio:

MCOX3(s)→MO(s)+COX2(g)\ce{MCO3(s) -> MO(s) + CO2(g)}

02

Determine the moles of COX2\ce{CO2} produced

Using the standard molar mass of carbon dioxide, M(COX2)=12.011+2(16.00)=44.01 g/molM(\ce{CO2}) = 12.011 + 2(16.00) = 44.01\text{ g/mol}:

n(COX2)=m(COX2)M(COX2)=1.468 g44.01 g/mol≈0.03336 moln(\ce{CO2}) = \frac{m(\ce{CO2})}{M(\ce{CO2})} = \frac{1.468\text{ g}}{44.01\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.03336\text{ mol}

03

Calculate the molar mass of the carbonate MCOX3\ce{MCO3}

From the balanced equation, 1 mol1\text{ mol} of MCOX3\ce{MCO3} produces 1 mol1\text{ mol} of COX2\ce{CO2}. Therefore:

n(MCOX3)=n(COX2)≈0.03336 moln(\ce{MCO3}) = n(\ce{CO2}) \approx 0.03336\text{ mol}

The molar mass of MCOX3\ce{MCO3} is the initial mass of the sample divided by the number of moles:

M(MCOX3)=m(MCOX3)n(MCOX3)=4.935 g0.03336 mol≈147.9 g/molM(\ce{MCO3}) = \frac{m(\ce{MCO3})}{n(\ce{MCO3})} = \frac{4.935\text{ g}}{0.03336\text{ mol}} \approx 147.9\text{ g/mol}

04

Deduce the molar mass and identity of the metal M\ce{M}

The formula mass of MCOX3\ce{MCO3} consists of the metal M\text{M} and the carbonate group COX3\ce{CO3}:

M(COX3)=12.011+3(16.00)=60.01 g/molM(\ce{CO3}) = 12.011 + 3(16.00) = 60.01\text{ g/mol}

Subtracting the carbonate group from the total molar mass:

M(M)=M(MCOX3)−M(COX3)=147.9 g/mol−60.01 g/mol≈87.6 g/molM(\text{M}) = M(\ce{MCO3}) - M(\ce{CO3}) = 147.9\text{ g/mol} - 60.01\text{ g/mol} \approx 87.6\text{ g/mol}

Common Pitfall: Be careful not to subtract the molar mass of COX2\ce{CO2} instead of the carbonate ion COX3X2−\ce{CO3^2-}. The metal carbonate contains three oxygen atoms, not two.

Looking at Group 2 of the periodic table:

  • Magnesium (Mg\ce{Mg}): 24.31 g/mol24.31\text{ g/mol}
  • Calcium (Ca\ce{Ca}): 40.08 g/mol40.08\text{ g/mol}
  • Strontium (Sr\ce{Sr}): 87.62 g/mol87.62\text{ g/mol}
  • Barium (Ba\ce{Ba}): 137.33 g/mol137.33\text{ g/mol}

The atomic mass of 87.6 g/mol87.6\text{ g/mol} corresponds to strontium (Sr\ce{Sr}). Therefore, the original reactant is strontium carbonate, SrCOX3\ce{SrCO3}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to subtract the molar mass of the carbonate group from the molar mass of the compound, equating the molar mass of MCO3 directly to the metal M and incorrectly identifying the metal as barium.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    MCOX3(s)→MO(s)+COX2(g)\ce{MCO3(s) -> MO(s) + CO2(g)}

  2. Step 2

    m(COX2)=1.468 g  ⟹  M(COX2)=44.01 g/mol  ⟹  n(COX2)=1.46844.01=0.03336 molm(\ce{CO2}) = 1.468\text{ g} \implies M(\ce{CO2}) = 44.01\text{ g/mol} \implies n(\ce{CO2}) = \frac{1.468}{44.01} = 0.03336\text{ mol}

  3. Step 3

    n(MCOX3)=0.03336 moln(\ce{MCO3}) = 0.03336\text{ mol}

  4. Step 4

    M(M)=4.9350.03336=147.9 g/mol≈137.3 g/mol (Ba)M(\text{M}) = \frac{4.935}{0.03336} = 147.9\text{ g/mol} \approx 137.3\text{ g/mol (Ba)}

    Correct

    M(MCOX3)=4.935 g0.03336 mol=147.9 g/mol  ⟹  M(M)=M(MCOX3)−M(COX3)=147.9−60.01=87.9 g/mol≈87.6 g/mol (Sr)M(\ce{MCO3}) = \frac{4.935\text{ g}}{0.03336\text{ mol}} = 147.9\text{ g/mol} \implies M(\text{M}) = M(\ce{MCO3}) - M(\ce{CO3}) = 147.9 - 60.01 = 87.9\text{ g/mol} \approx 87.6\text{ g/mol (Sr)}

    Dividing the initial mass 4.935 g4.935\text{ g} by 0.03336 mol0.03336\text{ mol} gives the molar mass of the entire compound MCOX3\ce{MCO3}, not the metal M\text{M} alone. You must subtract the carbonate anion's molar mass (M(COX3)≈60.01 g/molM(\ce{CO3}) \approx 60.01\text{ g/mol}) to find M(M)M(\text{M}).

  5. Step 5

    BaCOX3\ce{BaCO3}

    Correct

    SrCOX3\ce{SrCO3}

    Because the metal's molar mass was calculated as 147.9 g/mol147.9\text{ g/mol} instead of 87.9 g/mol87.9\text{ g/mol}, you selected barium instead of strontium.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You wrote the balanced thermal decomposition equation correctly.

You correctly converted the measured mass of carbon dioxide into moles.

You used the correct 1:11:1 stoichiometric ratio to find the moles of the reactant metal carbonate.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula mass vs. atomic mass confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the total molar mass of the compound MCO3 as the atomic mass of the metal M, forgetting that the carbonate group (one carbon and three oxygens) accounts for 60.01 g/mol of the total formula mass.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Compound Mass Breakdown
  • For any binary or polyatomic ionic compound MxYy\ce{M}_x\ce{Y}_y, M(compound)=x⋅M(M)+y⋅M(Y)M(\text{compound}) = x \cdot M(\text{M}) + y \cdot M(\text{Y}).

  • Always isolate M(M)M(\text{M}) by subtracting the mass of the known anion polyatomic group from the total calculated compound molar mass.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the molar mass of the carbonate group: M(COX3)=12.011+3(16.00)=60.01 g/molM(\ce{CO3}) = 12.011 + 3(16.00) = 60.01\text{ g/mol}.

  2. Subtract the carbonate group from the total molar mass: M(M)=147.9 g/mol−60.01 g/mol=87.9 g/molM(\text{M}) = 147.9\text{ g/mol} - 60.01\text{ g/mol} = 87.9\text{ g/mol}.

  3. Compare 87.9 g/mol87.9\text{ g/mol} to Group 2 atomic masses: magnesium is 24.31 g/mol24.31\text{ g/mol}, calcium is 40.08 g/mol40.08\text{ g/mol}, strontium is 87.62 g/mol87.62\text{ g/mol}, and barium is 137.33 g/mol137.33\text{ g/mol}. The value matches strontium (Sr\ce{Sr}).

Final answer

MCOX3(s)→MO(s)+COX2(g)\ce{MCO3(s) -> MO(s) + CO2(g)}; Molar mass of M=87.6 g/mol\text{M} = 87.6\text{ g/mol}; Original reactant is SrCOX3\ce{SrCO3}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice breaking down formula mass expressions into metal and nonmetal/polyatomic ion components before solving for unknown elements.

  • When finding an unknown metal in a salt, always check whether your computed molar mass belongs to the cation alone or the entire ionic formula unit.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student uses the mass of the solid sample as the mass of the metal oxide rather than the metal carbonate when setting up the mole relationship, leading to an incorrect molar mass of M.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    MCOX3(s)→MO(s)+COX2(g)\ce{MCO3(s) -> MO(s) + CO2(g)}

  2. Step 2

    n(COX2)=1.468 g44.01 g/mol=0.03336 moln(\ce{CO2}) = \frac{1.468\text{ g}}{44.01\text{ g/mol}} = 0.03336\text{ mol}

  3. Step 3

    n(MO)=0.03336 moln(\ce{MO}) = 0.03336\text{ mol}

  4. Step 4

    M(MO)=4.935 g0.03336 mol=147.9 g/molM(\ce{MO}) = \frac{4.935\text{ g}}{0.03336\text{ mol}} = 147.9\text{ g/mol}

    Correct

    M(MCOX3)=m(MCOX3)n(MCOX3)=4.935 g0.03336 mol=147.9 g/molM(\ce{MCO3}) = \frac{m(\ce{MCO3})}{n(\ce{MCO3})} = \frac{4.935\text{ g}}{0.03336\text{ mol}} = 147.9\text{ g/mol}

    The given mass of 4.935 g4.935\text{ g} belongs to the starting reactant MCOX3\ce{MCO3}, not to the solid product MO\ce{MO}. Therefore, dividing 4.935 g4.935\text{ g} by 0.03336 mol0.03336\text{ mol} gives the molar mass of MCOX3\ce{MCO3}, not MO\ce{MO}.

  5. Step 5

    M(M)=147.9−16.00=131.9 g/mol≈137.3 g/mol (Ba)M(\text{M}) = 147.9 - 16.00 = 131.9\text{ g/mol} \approx 137.3\text{ g/mol (Ba)}

    Correct

    M(M)=M(MCOX3)−M(COX3X2−)=147.9 g/mol−60.01 g/mol=87.9 g/mol≈87.6 g/mol (Sr)M(\text{M}) = M(\ce{MCO3}) - M(\ce{CO3^2-}) = 147.9\text{ g/mol} - 60.01\text{ g/mol} = 87.9\text{ g/mol} \approx 87.6\text{ g/mol (Sr)}

    Because you treated 147.9 g/mol147.9\text{ g/mol} as the molar mass of MO\ce{MO}, you subtracted only the mass of one oxygen atom (16.00 g/mol16.00\text{ g/mol}) rather than the mass of the carbonate group (60.01 g/mol60.01\text{ g/mol}).

  6. Step 6

    BaCOX3\ce{BaCO3}

    Correct

    SrCOX3\ce{SrCO3}

    Propagating the calculated molar mass identified barium instead of strontium.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You wrote the correct balanced chemical equation for the decomposition reaction.

You accurately calculated the moles of evolved COX2\ce{CO2} from its mass and molar mass.

You recognized the 1:11:1 stoichiometric relationship between the reaction species.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sample identity mismatch in molar mass calculation

You labeled the starting sample mass 4.935 g4.935\text{ g} as MO\ce{MO} instead of MCOX3\ce{MCO3}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the mass of the initial reactant with that of the solid residue led to subtracting the molar mass of an oxygen atom instead of the carbonate group.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Pair Mass with the Correct Chemical Species
  • M(X)=m(X)n(X)M(X) = \frac{m(X)}{n(X)} requires the mass and mole quantities to describe the exact same chemical substance XX.

  • Always write down the full chemical formula next to any mass given in the problem statement before calculating molar mass.

Use Conservation of Mass for Residues
  • If you wish to work with the solid residue MO\ce{MO}, find its mass first: m(MO)=m(MCOX3)−m(COX2)m(\ce{MO}) = m(\ce{MCO3}) - m(\ce{CO2}).

  • Check whether the stated mass refers to the sample before heating (carbonate) or after heating (oxide).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify that 4.935 g4.935\text{ g} is the mass of MCOX3\ce{MCO3}: M(MCOX3)=4.935 g0.03336 mol≈147.93 g/molM(\ce{MCO3}) = \frac{4.935\text{ g}}{0.03336\text{ mol}} \approx 147.93\text{ g/mol}.

  2. Subtract the molar mass of the carbonate group (COX3X2−\ce{CO3^2-}): M(M)=147.93 g/mol−[12.01+3(16.00)] g/mol=147.93 g/mol−60.01 g/mol=87.92 g/mol≈87.6 g/molM(\text{M}) = 147.93\text{ g/mol} - [12.01 + 3(16.00)]\text{ g/mol} = 147.93\text{ g/mol} - 60.01\text{ g/mol} = 87.92\text{ g/mol} \approx 87.6\text{ g/mol}.

  3. Compare this value to Group 2 metals: strontium (Sr\ce{Sr}) has an atomic mass of 87.62 g/mol87.62\text{ g/mol}.

Final answer

MCOX3(s)→MO(s)+COX2(g)\ce{MCO3(s) -> MO(s) + CO2(g)}; Molar mass of M=87.6 g/mol\text{M} = 87.6\text{ g/mol}; Original reactant is SrCOX3\ce{SrCO3}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review mass conservation in thermal decomposition reactions to keep track of reactant versus product masses.

  • Practice calculating molar masses of unknown salts by explicitly labeling both the numerator and denominator with their chemical formulas.

  • Solve the practice problems below to master working with gaseous mass loss.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student subtracts only the mass of carbon instead of the entire carbonate group when calculating the molar mass of M from MCO3.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    MCOX3(s)→MO(s)+COX2(g)\ce{MCO3(s) -> MO(s) + CO2(g)}

  2. Step 2

    n(COX2)=1.46844.01=0.03336 moln(\ce{CO2}) = \frac{1.468}{44.01} = 0.03336\text{ mol}

  3. Step 3

    n(MCOX3)=0.03336 mol  ⟹  M(MCOX3)=4.9350.03336=147.9 g/moln(\ce{MCO3}) = 0.03336\text{ mol} \implies M(\ce{MCO3}) = \frac{4.935}{0.03336} = 147.9\text{ g/mol}

  4. Step 4

    M(M)=147.9−12.01=135.9 g/mol≈137.3 g/mol (Ba)M(\text{M}) = 147.9 - 12.01 = 135.9\text{ g/mol} \approx 137.3\text{ g/mol (Ba)}

    Correct

    M(M)=M(MCOX3)−M(COX3)=147.9−60.01=87.9 g/mol≈87.6 g/mol (Sr)M(\text{M}) = M(\ce{MCO3}) - M(\ce{CO3}) = 147.9 - 60.01 = 87.9\text{ g/mol} \approx 87.6\text{ g/mol (Sr)}

    You subtracted only the atomic mass of carbon (12.01 g/mol12.01\text{ g/mol}) rather than the entire carbonate radical COX3\ce{CO3} (12.01+3×16.00=60.01 g/mol12.01 + 3 \times 16.00 = 60.01\text{ g/mol}). The three oxygen atoms belong to the carbonate group.

  5. Step 5

    BaCOX3\ce{BaCO3}

    Correct

    SrCOX3\ce{SrCO3}

    Because your calculated metal molar mass was 135.9 g/mol135.9\text{ g/mol} instead of 87.9 g/mol87.9\text{ g/mol}, you selected barium (Ba\ce{Ba}) instead of strontium (Sr\ce{Sr}).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You wrote the correct stoichiometric equation for the decomposition reaction.

You accurately converted the mass of released gas into moles.

You correctly calculated the overall molar mass of the metal carbonate compound.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula mass deduction error

You subtracted only the mass of carbon (12.01 g/mol12.01\text{ g/mol}) from MCOX3\ce{MCO3} instead of the entire carbonate ion (60.01 g/mol60.01\text{ g/mol}).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Incomplete account of polyatomic anion stoichiometry when isolating an unknown cation from a salt formula.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Molar Mass Decomposition of Polyatomic Salts
  • M(MaXb)=a⋅M(M)+b⋅M(X)M(\text{M}_a\text{X}_b) = a \cdot M(\text{M}) + b \cdot M(\text{X})

  • Always write out the constituent parts of the formula mass explicitly: M(MCOX3)=M(M)+M(C)+3⋅M(O)M(\ce{MCO3}) = M(\text{M}) + M(\ce{C}) + 3 \cdot M(\ce{O}) before isolating M(M)M(\text{M}).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the molar mass of the carbonate group: M(COX3)=12.01+3(16.00)=60.01 g/molM(\ce{CO3}) = 12.01 + 3(16.00) = 60.01\text{ g/mol}.

  2. Subtract the entire carbonate group from M(MCOX3)M(\ce{MCO3}): M(M)=147.9 g/mol−60.01 g/mol=87.9 g/molM(\text{M}) = 147.9\text{ g/mol} - 60.01\text{ g/mol} = 87.9\text{ g/mol}.

  3. Compare 87.9 g/mol87.9\text{ g/mol} with Group 2 atomic masses: Mg=24.31\ce{Mg} = 24.31, Ca=40.08\ce{Ca} = 40.08, Sr=87.62\ce{Sr} = 87.62, Ba=137.33 g/mol\ce{Ba} = 137.33\text{ g/mol}. The value corresponds to strontium (Sr\ce{Sr}).

Final answer

MCOX3(s)→MO(s)+COX2(g)\ce{MCO3(s) -> MO(s) + CO2(g)}; Molar mass of M=87.6 g/mol\text{M} = 87.6\text{ g/mol}; Original reactant is SrCOX3\ce{SrCO3}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the full molecular breakdown of the salt formula before subtracting to ensure all atoms in the polyatomic ion are included.

  • Double-check that the molar mass subtracted for COX3X2−\ce{CO3^2-} is approximately 60.0 g/mol60.0\text{ g/mol}, not 12.0 g/mol12.0\text{ g/mol} or 44.0 g/mol44.0\text{ g/mol}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 2.102 g2.102\text{ g} sample of an unknown anhydrous Group 2 metal carbonate MCOX3\ce{MCO3} decomposes completely to produce 1.097 g1.097\text{ g} of carbon dioxide gas. Deduce the identity of the metal M\text{M}.

Answer

n(COX2)=1.097 g44.01 g/mol=0.02493 moln(\ce{CO2}) = \frac{1.097\text{ g}}{44.01\text{ g/mol}} = 0.02493\text{ mol}. Since n(MCOX3)=n(COX2)n(\ce{MCO3}) = n(\ce{CO2}), M(MCOX3)=2.102 g0.02493 mol=84.32 g/molM(\ce{MCO3}) = \frac{2.102\text{ g}}{0.02493\text{ mol}} = 84.32\text{ g/mol}. Subtracting the carbonate group: M(M)=84.32−60.01=24.31 g/molM(\text{M}) = 84.32 - 60.01 = 24.31\text{ g/mol}. The metal is magnesium (Mg\ce{Mg}).

02

A 3.947 g3.947\text{ g} sample of a Group 2 metal sulfate, MSOX4\ce{MSO4}, is precipitated and found to contain 0.01691 mol0.01691\text{ mol} of the sulfate compound. Determine the atomic mass of metal M\text{M} and identify the metal.

Answer

M(MSOX4)=3.947 g0.01691 mol=233.4 g/molM(\ce{MSO4}) = \frac{3.947\text{ g}}{0.01691\text{ mol}} = 233.4\text{ g/mol}. The sulfate group has molar mass M(SOX4)=32.06+4(16.00)=96.06 g/molM(\ce{SO4}) = 32.06 + 4(16.00) = 96.06\text{ g/mol}. Subtracting gives M(M)=233.4−96.06=137.3 g/molM(\text{M}) = 233.4 - 96.06 = 137.3\text{ g/mol}. The metal is barium (Ba\ce{Ba}).

03

An unknown monovalent alkali metal carbonate, MX2COX3\ce{M2CO3}, is heated with excess hydrochloric acid, liberating 0.880 g0.880\text{ g} of COX2\ce{CO2} gas according to the equation: MX2COX3(s)+2 HCl(aq)→2 MCl(aq)+HX2O(l)+COX2(g)\ce{M2CO3(s) + 2HCl(aq) -> 2MCl(aq) + H2O(l) + CO2(g)}. If the initial sample mass was 2.760 g2.760\text{ g}, determine the identity of the alkali metal M\text{M}.

Answer

n(COX2)=0.880 g44.01 g/mol=0.0200 moln(\ce{CO2}) = \frac{0.880\text{ g}}{44.01\text{ g/mol}} = 0.0200\text{ mol}. From stoichiometry, n(MX2COX3)=0.0200 moln(\ce{M2CO3}) = 0.0200\text{ mol}. Thus, M(MX2COX3)=2.760 g0.0200 mol=138.0 g/molM(\ce{M2CO3}) = \frac{2.760\text{ g}}{0.0200\text{ mol}} = 138.0\text{ g/mol}. The carbonate ion is 60.01 g/mol60.01\text{ g/mol}, so 2×M(M)=138.0−60.01=78.0 g/mol2 \times M(\text{M}) = 138.0 - 60.01 = 78.0\text{ g/mol}, giving M(M)=39.0 g/molM(\text{M}) = 39.0\text{ g/mol}. The metal is potassium (K\ce{K}).

Loading workspace…