Resources
An aqueous solution of acetic acid reaches dynamic equilibrium: , with at . A sample of has an initial hydronium concentration of and a percent ionization of . Exactly of this solution is diluted by adding of pure deionized water, producing a solution. (a) By evaluating the reaction quotient immediately upon dilution, explain why dilution causes the percent ionization to increase despite decreasing . (b) Calculate the new equilibrium percent ionization () of the diluted acetic acid solution.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Dilution reduces the concentrations of all solute species by a factor of , which makes ; thus, the system shifts right toward ions, increasing the fraction of ionized molecules even though absolute decreases; (b) Percent ionization .
Steps
Part (a): Evaluating and Explaining the Shift upon Dilution
- Determine concentrations immediately following dilution: The total volume increases from to , which is a -fold dilution factor: Immediately upon mixing, before any chemical reaction occurs, the concentration of each aqueous species drops by a factor of :
- Evaluate the reaction quotient : Substitute these instantaneous non-equilibrium concentrations into the reaction quotient expression:
-
Apply Le Châtelier's principle:
- Because , the system is no longer at equilibrium and must shift in the forward direction (to the right) to produce more ions and restore equilibrium.
- This forward shift forces a larger fraction of the remaining non-ionized molecules to dissociate into ions.
- Consequently, the percent ionization increases (from to a higher percentage), even though the absolute molar concentration is lower than in the original solution due to the -fold expansion in volume.
Part (b): Calculating the New Equilibrium Percent Ionization
-
Set up the equilibrium table for the diluted solution: For the ionization reaction:
- Initial: , ,
- Change: , ,
- Equilibrium: , ,
- Formulate the equilibrium constant expression:
-
Solve for : Rearrange into standard quadratic form:
Applying the quadratic formula :
(Note: Relying on the approximation gives , which exceeds and introduces noticeable error; using the quadratic formula is necessary for accuracy).
- Calculate percent ionization ():
Typical errors
01 The student forgets that percent ionization increases upon dilution and instead assumes that percent ionization is directly proportional to hydronium ion concentration, concluding that dilution must decrease percent ionization.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
= = 10 [_3^+] = 1.33 10^{-4}, [_3^-] = 1.33 10^{-4}, [3] = 0.0100 Q_c = = 1.77 10^{-6}
- Step 2
[_3^+][_3^+]
CorrectQ_c = 1.80 10^{-6} < K_a \ (1.80 10^{-5}) [3^+].
Comparing to reveals that , meaning the equilibrium shifts to the right to produce more ions. Percent ionization is the ratio ; even though absolute decreases, the total acid concentration decreases by a larger factor of , which causes the ionization fraction to increase.
- Step 3
K_a = = 1.80 10^{-5} x = 4.24 10^{-4} 2 = 100% = 4.24%
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the dilution factor and instantaneous concentrations following dilution.
You correctly evaluated the reaction quotient .
You successfully set up the equilibrium expression and percent ionization formula in part (b).
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeWHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou evaluated percent ionization solely by looking at the change in absolute rather than using Le Châtelier's principle () and the definition of percent ionization as a fraction of initial acid concentration, .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Compare $Q_c$ to $K_a$ to Predict the Direction of Shift
If , the forward reaction is favored and the equilibrium shifts to the right toward products.
Compare your calculated () with the given (). Because , conclude that the reaction shifts toward products (ions).
- Distinguish Concentration from Percent Ionization
.
Recognize that dilution reduces the denominator () by a factor of , while the rightward shift partially replenishes , causing the overall ratio to increase.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompare the reaction quotient to : .
Conclude that the reaction must shift right (forward) to produce more and until .
Explain that this forward shift causes a larger fraction of molecules to ionize, raising the percent ionization even though is lower than before dilution.
(a) Dilution decreases all solute concentrations by a factor of , yielding . The system shifts right, forcing a higher percentage of acid molecules to ionize. (b) (or using the small- approximation).
02 The student calculates percent ionization relative to the undiluted initial acid concentration of 0.100 M instead of the new total diluted concentration of 0.0100 M.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
, so the reaction shifts right toward products, increasing percent ionization.
- Step 3
- Step 4Correct
You placed the pre-dilution concentration () in the denominator instead of the actual initial concentration of the diluted solution (). This produced , which mistakenly indicates a decrease from the original and contradicts your correct conclusion in part (a).
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou determined the -fold dilution factor and calculated the instantaneous post-dilution concentrations accurately.
You evaluated and correctly explained the rightward shift using Le Châtelier's principle.
You set up the equilibrium expression for the diluted acid and accurately solved for .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeDividing by the undiluted instead of the new diluted in the percent ionization formula.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou associated percent ionization with the very first concentration given in the problem statement rather than the initial formal concentration of the specific equilibrium solution being analyzed.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Reference State for Percent Ionization
.
Always identify which solution's equilibrium is being calculated and use that solution's initial un-ionized acid concentration in the denominator.
- Consistency with Qualitative Le Châtelier Predictions
Diluting a weak acid shifts equilibrium toward the side with more aqueous ions (Ostwald's dilution law), meaning percent ionization must strictly increase.
Check your final numerical percent ionization against your part (a) prediction: because , must be greater than .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecall the definition of percent ionization for the diluted solution: .
Substitute the equilibrium concentration (or from the approximation) and the diluted initial concentration :
(or ).
4.15%
03 The student miscalculates Qc by failing to dilute the numerator ion concentrations by the factor of 10, resulting in Qc > Ka and an erroneous shift to the left.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
Immediately upon -fold dilution, all solute concentrations decrease by a factor of : and , giving .
Diluting the total volume from to expands the solution volume tenfold for every dissolved species. Both and decrease to immediately upon mixing.
- Step 2Correct
Because , the system shifts forward (to the right) to restore equilibrium, forcing more acid molecules to dissociate and thereby increasing the percent ionization.
Your conclusion followed logically from your calculated value of , but because the correct reaction quotient satisfies , the system actually shifts right toward the side with more aqueous ions.
- Step 3
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized how to calculate percent ionization from the equilibrium hydronium concentration.
You correctly set up the expression to solve for the equilibrium ion concentration in the diluted solution.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou assumed only the non-ionized acid was diluted while keeping the products at their pre-dilution concentrations.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou overlooked that physical dilution increases the total volume of the solution, which immediately lowers the molar concentration of every solute species present, both reactants and products.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Universal Dilution Rule
Adding solvent decreases the molarity of all dissolved aqueous solutes by the exact same dilution factor: .
Always apply the volume expansion factor to every aqueous product and reactant before writing .
- Reaction Quotient under Dilution
For a dissociation reaction , diluting by factor scales the numerator by and denominator by , so .
Check that dilution always drives a dissociation equilibrium toward the side with more aqueous particles.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFind the dilution factor: .
Scale all instantaneous concentrations: , , .
Compute the reaction quotient: .
Compare with : Since , the reaction shifts right, increasing the percent ionization.
(a) , so the system shifts right, increasing percent ionization; (b) (or by approximation).
Lock it in
How does diluting a weak acid solution with water affect its reaction quotient relative to ?
becomes less than because the product concentrations in the numerator are both diluted while the denominator has only one solute term, so drops by the dilution factor.
Similar question
A solution of formic acid (, ) is diluted by a factor of . Calculate immediately upon dilution and state the direction the equilibrium must shift to re-establish equilibrium.
Answer
Immediately upon dilution, each species concentration drops to of its equilibrium value: . Since , the equilibrium shifts to the right (forward direction).
A solution of hydrocyanic acid (, ) has a percent ionization of . Calculate the new percent ionization when the solution is diluted to .
Answer
Using , for , . Then , which is higher than the original .
Explain, using Le Châtelier's principle and the reaction quotient expression, whether adding water to a saturated solution of calcium fluoride () in contact with excess solid will dissolve more solid or precipitate solid.
Answer
Diluting the solution lowers both and , causing to drop below . Because , the system shifts in the forward direction (to the right), causing more solid to dissolve until equilibrium is restored.