Resources
Consider the electrolysis of a dilute neutral aqueous sodium chloride solution, , at (, , ). The relevant standard reduction potentials are: In the asymptotic limit of infinite dilution (or very low solute concentration without kinetic overpotentials), determine: (a) which species is preferentially reduced at the cathode, (b) which species is thermodynamically favored to be oxidized at the anode, and (c) the minimum external theoretical decomposition voltage () required to drive water electrolysis at standard conditions ( for water splitting).
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) is reduced to at the cathode; (b) is oxidized to at the anode; (c) Minimum theoretical decomposition potential .
Steps
Cathode Reaction (Reduction)
At the cathode, reduction takes place. The two competing reduction half-reactions in neutral aqueous solution are:
- Reduction of sodium ions:
- Reduction of water:
The species with the more positive (less negative) reduction potential is reduced preferentially because it has a greater thermodynamic tendency to gain electrons:
Therefore, is preferentially reduced to at the cathode.
Anode Reaction (Oxidation)
At the anode, oxidation takes place. The competing oxidation half-reactions are:
- Oxidation of chloride ions:
- Oxidation of water:
The half-reaction with the more positive (less negative) oxidation potential (corresponding to the lower standard reduction potential) is thermodynamically favored to lose electrons:
Therefore, is thermodynamically favored to be oxidized to at the anode.
Pitfall to Avoid: In industrial electrolysis of concentrated (brine), forms instead of due to the high kinetic overpotential required to evolve . However, in very dilute solution where kinetic overpotentials are neglected, thermodynamic prediction governs and water oxidation predominates.
Minimum Theoretical External Decomposition Voltage
The overall thermodynamic cell potential () for the electrolysis of water at is given by:
Because , the reaction is non-spontaneous. The minimum theoretical external voltage () required to drive the reaction is:
Thus, the minimum theoretical decomposition potential is .
Typical errors
01 The student confuses cathode reduction with metal cation reduction by assuming Na⁺ is always discharged at the cathode in NaCl electrolysis.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Cathode attracts cations: is preferentially reduced at the cathode.
CorrectAt the cathode, compare with . Because , is preferentially reduced to .
Although cations migrate toward the cathode, water is present in aqueous solution and has a significantly higher (less negative) reduction potential ( vs. ). Thermodynamically, water is reduced far more easily than sodium ions.
- Step 2
Anode oxidation: compare and Water has the lower reduction potential, so is oxidized to .
- Step 3
Minimum decomposition voltage
CorrectYour formula and calculation method were logical, but the numerical result was affected by using the reduction potential of () rather than the potential for water reduction (). With water reacting at both electrodes, the minimum decomposition voltage is .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly remembered that oxidation occurs at the anode and reduction occurs at the cathode.
You correctly deduced that the species with the lower reduction potential is more readily oxidized at the anode.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that because cations migrate to the cathode, the solute cation must be the species reduced, overlooking that water molecules also compete for reduction and are much easier to reduce than active Group 1 metal cations.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Aqueous Electrolysis Reduction Competition
At the cathode, the species with the more positive (or less negative) reduction potential is reduced preferentially.
Always compare the reduction potential of the dissolved cation with the reduction potential of water before deciding the cathode product.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompare the reduction potentials at the cathode: vs. . Because , water is reduced to at the cathode.
At the anode, water is oxidized to because its potential () is lower than that of chloride ().
Calculate the net cell potential for water electrolysis: .
The minimum external potential required to drive the reaction is .
(a) is reduced to ; (b) is oxidized to ; (c) Minimum theoretical decomposition voltage is .
02 The student relies on laboratory experience with brine electrolysis where Cl₂ forms due to overpotential, ignoring the thermodynamic data and problem instruction stating no kinetic overpotentials.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
At the cathode, water reduction () is more positive than () is preferentially reduced.
- Step 2
Anode discharges chloride ions in solution to form chlorine gas is thermodynamically favored to be oxidized at the anode.
CorrectAt the anode: (or ), so is thermodynamically favored to be oxidized to .
At the anode, the species with the more positive oxidation potential (or lower reduction potential) is oxidized first. Since , water oxidation is thermodynamically favored over chloride oxidation. In concentrated brine, forms due to kinetic overpotential for oxygen evolution, but the question explicitly asked for the thermodynamic preference without kinetic overpotentials.
- Step 3
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the species with the more positive reduction potential is preferentially reduced at the cathode.
You arrived at the correct minimum external theoretical decomposition voltage of .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou recalled that chloride ions discharge to give chlorine gas in standard laboratory or industrial electrolysis of salt water, overlooking that this outcome is driven by kinetic overpotential rather than thermodynamics.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing thermodynamic favorability with kinetic overpotential phenomena in competitive anode oxidation.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Thermodynamic Favorability at the Anode
At the anode, oxidation occurs. Thermodynamically, the reaction with the most positive oxidation potential (or least positive standard reduction potential ) occurs first.
Always compare for all competing species at the anode before considering any kinetic overpotential effects.
- Reading Explicit Question Constraints
When a problem specifies 'thermodynamically favored' or 'without kinetic overpotentials,' predictions must rely strictly on potential values rather than empirical laboratory outcomes like brine electrolysis.
Check whether the question prompts for thermodynamic preference or experimental/kinetic product distribution.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the competing oxidation half-reactions at the anode: with , and with at .
Compare their thermodynamic oxidation tendencies: because , water requires a less positive anode potential to lose electrons than chloride ions.
Conclude that is thermodynamically favored to be oxidized at the anode to produce .
(a) is reduced to ; (b) is oxidized to ; (c) .
03 The student calculates the standard decomposition voltage by subtracting the two water potentials without accounting for the proper pH/half-reaction pairing, combining standard basic reduction with standard acidic oxidation incorrectly as -0.83 V - 1.23 V = -2.06 V.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
You paired the standard reduction potential of water under basic conditions (, ) with the standard reduction potential under acidic conditions (, ). Both half-reactions in the same cell must be evaluated at the same .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly selected the species reduced at the cathode by comparing the reduction potentials of water and sodium ions.
You correctly selected the species oxidized at the anode by comparing the potentials of water and chloride ions.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou combined standard reduction potentials defined at two different pH extremes (pH 14 and pH 0) rather than evaluating both half-cell potentials at the same solution pH (pH 7.00, or a uniform standard state), which artificially added the free energy of water self-ionization.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Evaluate Half-Reactions at Uniform pH
Both electrode half-reactions in an electrochemical cell must be evaluated at the same using .
Always check that the potentials used for the anode and cathode correspond to the same solution conditions (here, , where and ).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the thermodynamic cell potential at : .
Determine the minimum external theoretical decomposition voltage: .
Lock it in
In aqueous electrolysis, when does water get reduced at the cathode instead of the dissolved metal cation?
Water is reduced whenever , which is true for all active metals (alkali, alkaline earth, and ).
Similar question
A dilute aqueous solution of potassium sulfate, , is electrolyzed using inert platinum electrodes. Identify the predominant chemical species reduced at the cathode and oxidized at the anode.
Answer
Cathode: is reduced to because . Anode: is oxidized to because sulfate ( with ) is much harder to oxidize than water ().
An aqueous solution containing is electrolyzed. Given and at neutral pH, determine which species is discharged at the cathode and state the expected observation.
Answer
Discharged species: . Because , copper(II) ions are preferentially reduced over water: . Observation: A reddish-brown metallic coating of copper deposits on the cathode.
Molten and dilute aqueous are both electrolyzed using inert electrodes. Explain why metallic sodium is produced from molten but hydrogen gas is produced from aqueous , citing thermodynamic competition.
Answer
In molten , no water is present, leaving as the only reducible species, so it must be reduced to . In aqueous , water is present and acts as a competing electron acceptor. Because is significantly more positive than , reduction of water to is thermodynamically favored over reduction of .