Resources

Rank the following neutral ground-state elements in order of increasing atomic radius: P\text{P} (Z=15Z = 15), Cl\text{Cl} (Z=17Z = 17), Na\text{Na} (Z=11Z = 11), and Mg\text{Mg} (Z=12Z = 12). Justify the ranking using effective nuclear charge (ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}) and principal quantum shells.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Cl<P<Mg<Na\text{Cl} < \text{P} < \text{Mg} < \text{Na}

Steps

01

Identify the Principal Quantum Shell and Electron Configurations

All four elements belong to Period 3 of the periodic table:

  • Na\ce{Na} (Z=11Z = 11): [Ne] 3s1[\ce{Ne}]\, 3s^1
  • Mg\ce{Mg} (Z=12Z = 12): [Ne] 3s2[\ce{Ne}]\, 3s^2
  • P\ce{P} (Z=15Z = 15): [Ne] 3s2 3p3[\ce{Ne}]\, 3s^2\, 3p^3
  • Cl\ce{Cl} (Z=17Z = 17): [Ne] 3s2 3p5[\ce{Ne}]\, 3s^2\, 3p^5

Because all four elements are in Period 3, their valence electrons occupy the same principal quantum shell (n=3n = 3), and they all share the same number of inner-shell core electrons (1010 core electrons from the neon core, [Ne][\ce{Ne}]).


02

Compare Effective Nuclear Charge (ZeffZ_{\text{eff}})

Effective nuclear charge (ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}) is the net positive charge experienced by an electron in a polyelectronic atom: Zeff=Z−SZ_{\text{eff}} = Z - S where ZZ is the atomic number (nuclear charge) and SS is the screening or shielding constant provided primarily by core electrons.

  • Across a period from left to right, each step adds one proton to the nucleus and one electron to the outermost valence shell (n=3n = 3).
  • Electrons in the same principal energy level do not shield each other effectively from the nucleus.
  • Because the core shielding remains approximately constant while the nuclear charge ZZ increases from 1111 to 1717, ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} increases steadily across the period: Zeff(Na)<Zeff(Mg)<Zeff(P)<Zeff(Cl)Z_{\text{eff}}(\ce{Na}) < Z_{\text{eff}}(\ce{Mg}) < Z_{\text{eff}}(\ce{P}) < Z_{\text{eff}}(\ce{Cl})

03

Relate ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} to Atomic Radius

  • A greater effective nuclear charge exerts a stronger electrostatic attraction on the valence electrons, pulling them closer to the nucleus and compressing the electron cloud.
  • Consequently, across Period 3, atomic radius decreases as atomic number increases: Na>Mg>P>Cl\ce{Na} > \ce{Mg} > \ce{P} > \ce{Cl}
  • Arranging the elements in order of increasing atomic radius (from smallest to largest): Cl<P<Mg<Na\ce{Cl} < \ce{P} < \ce{Mg} < \ce{Na}

Common Pitfall: Watch the direction of the inequality signs. "Increasing order" requires starting with the smallest radius (Cl\ce{Cl}) and ending with the largest (Na\ce{Na}).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student believes that having more protons and electrons always makes an atom larger, incorrectly concluding that atomic radius increases across a period.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    All elements have valence electrons in n=3n = 3. ⟹\Longrightarrow Number of protons: Na\text{Na} (1111), Mg\text{Mg} (1212), P\text{P} (1515), Cl\text{Cl} (1717).

  2. Step 2

    More protons and electrons add more bulk to the atom. ⟹\Longrightarrow Atomic radius increases as ZZ increases.

    Correct

    As ZZ increases across Period 3 with constant core shielding (S≈10S \approx 10), Zeff=Z−SZ_{\text{eff}} = Z - S increases: Zeff(Na)<Zeff(Mg)<Zeff(P)<Zeff(Cl)Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Na}) < Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Mg}) < Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{P}) < Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Cl}). A higher ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} draws the valence shell closer, so atomic radius decreases as ZZ increases across a period.

    You treated an increase in subatomic particles as adding geometric bulk. Within the same principal energy level (n=3n = 3), added valence electrons do not effectively shield each other. The increasing positive nuclear charge exerts a stronger electrostatic pull on the outer electrons, compressing the electron cloud and decreasing atomic radius across the period.

  3. Step 3

    Increasing atomic radius: Na<Mg<P<Cl\text{Na} < \text{Mg} < \text{P} < \text{Cl}

    Correct

    Increasing atomic radius: Cl<P<Mg<Na\text{Cl} < \text{P} < \text{Mg} < \text{Na}

    Your ranking is inverted as a direct result of the reversed periodic trend in Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that all four elements have valence electrons in the n=3n = 3 principal quantum shell.

You correctly listed the atomic numbers and proton counts for sodium, magnesium, phosphorus, and chlorine.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted periodic trend for atomic radius across a period

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating macroscopic mass/particle count with atomic size. Across a period, added electrons enter the same principal quantum shell and experience poor mutual shielding, so the steadily increasing nuclear charge raises ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} and pulls the valence cloud inward rather than making the atom larger.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Constant Core Shielding Across a Period
  • Across a single period, all elements share the same noble-gas core, so shielding (SS) remains roughly constant while nuclear charge (ZZ) increases.

  • Calculate Zeff≈Z−ScoreZ_{\text{eff}} \approx Z - S_{\text{core}} to verify that effective nuclear charge increases steadily from left to right.

Electrostatic Contraction of the Electron Cloud
  • A greater ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} pulls outer-shell electrons closer to the nucleus, reducing atomic radius across a period.

  • Associate higher ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} within the same shell with a smaller atomic radius, reversing the intuitive assumption that more particles mean a larger atom.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that all four elements have 1010 inner core electrons ([Ne][\text{Ne}]), so shielding S≈10S \approx 10.

  2. Calculate relative effective nuclear charges: Zeff(Na)≈11−10=+1Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Na}) \approx 11 - 10 = +1, Zeff(Mg)≈12−10=+2Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Mg}) \approx 12 - 10 = +2, Zeff(P)≈15−10=+5Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{P}) \approx 15 - 10 = +5, and Zeff(Cl)≈17−10=+7Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Cl}) \approx 17 - 10 = +7.

  3. Because a higher ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} pulls the n=3n = 3 shell closer to the nucleus, atomic radius decreases from left to right: Na>Mg>P>Cl\text{Na} > \text{Mg} > \text{P} > \text{Cl}.

  4. Arrange from smallest to largest to satisfy 'increasing order': Cl<P<Mg<Na\text{Cl} < \text{P} < \text{Mg} < \text{Na}.

Final answer

Cl<P<Mg<Na\text{Cl} < \text{P} < \text{Mg} < \text{Na}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how effective nuclear charge (Zeff=Z−SZ_{\text{eff}} = Z - S) explains periodic trends across a period.

  • Practice distinguishing between down-a-group trends (where principal quantum shell nn dominates) and across-a-period trends (where ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} dominates).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student correctly determines that atomic radius decreases across the period but writes the ranking in decreasing order instead of increasing order.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Elements are all in Period 3 with valence electrons in n=3n = 3.

  2. Step 2

    ZZ increases from Na\text{Na} (11) to Cl\text{Cl} (17), so ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} increases across the period.   ⟹  \implies Higher ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} pulls the outer electrons tighter, making the radius smaller.

  3. Step 3

    Increasing atomic radius: Na>Mg>P>Cl\text{Na} > \text{Mg} > \text{P} > \text{Cl}

    Correct

    Cl<P<Mg<Na\text{Cl} < \text{P} < \text{Mg} < \text{Na}

    You arranged the elements from largest radius to smallest radius using greater-than signs, which represents decreasing order rather than increasing order.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that all given elements share the n=3n = 3 valence shell in Period 3.

You clearly explained that effective nuclear charge (ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}) increases from sodium to chlorine.

You correctly deduced that a higher ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} draws valence electrons closer to the nucleus and decreases atomic radius.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
reversal_of_order

You wrote the ranking in decreasing order instead of increasing order.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Your underlying chemical reasoning was completely sound, but you wrote the final sequence starting with the element that has the largest radius (Na\text{Na}) and used greater-than signs (>>), inadvertently producing a decreasing order instead of an increasing order (smallest to largest, with << signs).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Ordering Direction Check
  • 'Increasing order' always means starting from the smallest value and ending at the largest value: smallest<⋯<largest\text{smallest} < \dots < \text{largest}.

  • Before finalizing your answer, verify whether the prompt requests 'increasing' (use <<) or 'decreasing' (use >>).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that 'increasing atomic radius' requires starting with the smallest atom and ending with the largest atom.

  2. From your deduction, Cl\text{Cl} has the highest ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} and smallest radius, while Na\text{Na} has the lowest ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} and largest radius.

  3. Write the elements from smallest to largest using less-than signs: Cl<P<Mg<Na\text{Cl} < \text{P} < \text{Mg} < \text{Na}.

Final answer

Cl<P<Mg<Na\text{Cl} < \text{P} < \text{Mg} < \text{Na}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always double-check prompt keywords: underline 'increasing' (smallest to largest, <<) or 'decreasing' (largest to smallest, >>).

  • Practice writing inequality chains left-to-right from smallest to largest whenever asked for increasing order.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student confuses effective nuclear charge with electron-electron repulsion in the valence shell, believing adding electrons increases repulsion and thus expands the atom across the period.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    All four elements have valence electrons in shell n=3n = 3.   ⟹  \implies From Na\text{Na} to Cl\text{Cl}, valence electrons increase from 11 to 77.

  2. Step 2

    More valence electrons cause greater electron repulsion, pushing the shell outward.

    Correct

    Zeff=Z−SZ_{\text{eff}} = Z - S. As nuclear charge ZZ increases from 1111 to 1717 while core shielding SS remains constant, ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} increases across the period and pulls the valence shell closer to the nucleus.

    Electrons in the same principal energy level shield each other very poorly. Across Period 3, adding protons to the nucleus increases ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}, exerting a stronger electrostatic pull on the n=3n = 3 shell and shrinking the atomic radius.

  3. Step 3

    Increasing atomic radius: Na<Mg<P<Cl\text{Na} < \text{Mg} < \text{P} < \text{Cl}

    Correct

    Increasing atomic radius: Cl<P<Mg<Na\text{Cl} < \text{P} < \text{Mg} < \text{Na}

    Because your physical rationale was inverted in Step 2, your final ranking is completely reversed. Chlorine has the highest ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} and smallest radius, while sodium has the lowest ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} and largest radius.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that all four elements reside in Period 3 with their outermost electrons in the n=3n = 3 shell.

You accurately identified the valence electron counts increasing from sodium to chlorine.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
confusing electron repulsion with effective nuclear charge

You assumed adding valence electrons expands the shell due to repulsion, overlooking the increasing nuclear charge.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You overlooked the dominant role of effective nuclear charge (Zeff=Z−SZ_{\text{eff}} = Z - S) across a period. Because core shielding remains constant across a single row, the addition of protons outcompetes same-shell electron repulsions, drawing the outer shell inward.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Effective Nuclear Charge Across a Period
  • Across a period, nuclear charge ZZ increases while inner-shell core shielding SS stays constant, so ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} increases and contracts the valence shell.

  • Always evaluate ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} before considering valence electron repulsions when moving across a period.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the effective nuclear charge trend across Period 3: core electrons S≈10S \approx 10, while ZZ increases from 1111 (Na\text{Na}) to 1212 (Mg\text{Mg}) to 1515 (P\text{P}) to 1717 (Cl\text{Cl}).

  2. Since Zeff=Z−SZ_{\text{eff}} = Z - S, effective nuclear charge increases: Zeff(Na)<Zeff(Mg)<Zeff(P)<Zeff(Cl)Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Na}) < Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Mg}) < Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{P}) < Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Cl}).

  3. A higher ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} exerts a stronger electrostatic attraction on the n=3n = 3 valence electrons, drawing them closer to the nucleus.

  4. Therefore, atomic radius decreases across the period: Na>Mg>P>Cl\text{Na} > \text{Mg} > \text{P} > \text{Cl}.

Final answer

Cl<P<Mg<Na\text{Cl} < \text{P} < \text{Mg} < \text{Na}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the formula Zeff≈Z−SZ_{\text{eff}} \approx Z - S and verify why same-shell electrons do not provide significant shielding.

  • Practice ranking atoms across Period 2 and Period 3 by explicitly writing down ZZ and ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} first.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Rank the elements Al\text{Al} (Z=13Z = 13), S\text{S} (Z=16Z = 16), and Ar\text{Ar} (Z=18Z = 18) in order of increasing atomic radius, and justify your answer using ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}.

Answer

Ar<S<Al\text{Ar} < \text{S} < \text{Al}. All three elements have valence electrons in n=3n = 3 with 1010 core electrons. As ZZ increases from 1313 to 1818, ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} increases from roughly +3+3 to +8+8, drawing the valence shell closer to the nucleus and decreasing atomic radius across the period.

02

Explain why K\text{K} (Z=19Z = 19) has a significantly larger atomic radius than Cl\text{Cl} (Z=17Z = 17), whereas Cl\text{Cl} is smaller than Na\text{Na} (Z=11Z = 11).

Answer

K\text{K} has its outermost valence electron in a new, higher principal energy level (n=4n = 4), placing it much farther from the nucleus despite a higher nuclear charge. In contrast, Na\text{Na} and Cl\text{Cl} share the same valence shell (n=3n = 3), where the much higher ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} of chlorine (+7+7 vs. +1+1) contracts its electron cloud compared to sodium.

03

Consider the isoelectronic series O2−\text{O}^{2-}, F−\text{F}^-, Na+\text{Na}^+, and Mg2+\text{Mg}^{2+}, each having 1010 electrons (1s2 2s2 2p61s^2\,2s^2\,2p^6). Rank these species in order of increasing ionic radius and justify using nuclear charge ZZ.

Answer

Mg2+<Na+<F−<O2−\text{Mg}^{2+} < \text{Na}^+ < \text{F}^- < \text{O}^{2-}. Because all four ions have identical electron configurations and identical shielding, the ion with the greatest nuclear charge (Z=12Z = 12 for Mg2+\text{Mg}^{2+}) exerts the strongest attraction on the n=2n = 2 electrons, contracting the ionic radius the most. Conversely, O2−\text{O}^{2-} has only 88 protons for 1010 electrons, resulting in the weakest hold and the largest radius.

Loading workspace…