Resources

An electric conductivity cell uses two platinum electrodes connected to a light bulb and an external DC voltage source. Two test beakers are examined: Beaker 1 contains pure solid crystalline potassium bromide (KBr(s)\text{KBr}(s)) at 20 ∘C20\,^\circ\text{C}. Beaker 2 contains molten potassium bromide (KBr(l)\text{KBr}(l)) heated to 750 ∘C750\,^\circ\text{C} (melting point of KBr=734 ∘C\text{KBr} = 734\,^\circ\text{C}). (a) Predict the conductivity state (conducts vs. non-conducting insulator) of each beaker. (b) Explain the microscopic physical reason for the difference, explicitly contrasting electronic conduction in metals with ionic conduction in crystal lattices.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Beaker 1 (KBr(s)\text{KBr}(s)) is a non-conducting insulator; Beaker 2 (KBr(l)\text{KBr}(l)) is an excellent electrical conductor. (b) In crystalline KBr(s)\text{KBr}(s), K+\text{K}^+ and Br−\text{Br}^- ions are locked in rigid lattice positions with zero mobile charge carriers (valence electrons are localized in filled ionic shells, unlike delocalized metallic electron seas). Upon melting into KBr(l)\text{KBr}(l), thermal energy overcomes the electrostatic lattice energy, freeing mobile hydrated/molten K+\text{K}^+ cations and Br−\text{Br}^- anions to migrate toward the cathode and anode under an applied electric field.

Steps

01

Solid Potassium Bromide (KBr(s)\ce{KBr}(s))

Part (a): Predicting Conductivity State

For an electrical current to flow through a substance, two conditions must be met:

  1. There must be charged particles present.
  2. These charged particles must be free to move (mobile charge carriers).
  • Beaker 1 (KBr(s)\ce{KBr}(s) at 20 ∘C20\,^\circ\text{C}): Non-conducting insulator. The light bulb remains unlit.
  • Beaker 2 (KBr(l)\ce{KBr}(l) at 750 ∘C750\,^\circ\text{C}): Electrical conductor. The light bulb glows brightly.

Part (b): Microscopic Physical Mechanism

  • Lattice Structure: Solid potassium bromide forms a three-dimensional ionic giant crystal lattice held together by strong, nondirectional electrostatic attractions between alternating KX+\ce{K+} cations and BrX−\ce{Br-} anions.
  • Immobile Ions: Because the electrostatic forces within the lattice are extremely strong, each ion is fixed in place and can only vibrate around its equilibrium position.
  • Absence of Free Electrons: Unlike metals, which possess a "sea of delocalized electrons" capable of moving freely under an electric potential difference (electronic conduction), ionic compounds have their valence electrons tightly localized in stable, filled-shell noble-gas configurations (KX+\ce{K+} has the argon configuration [Ar][\ce{Ar}], and BrX−\ce{Br-} has the krypton configuration [Kr][\ce{Kr}]). With neither mobile ions nor free electrons, solid KBr\ce{KBr} acts as an electrical insulator.
02

Molten Potassium Bromide (KBr(l)\ce{KBr}(l))

  • Overcoming Lattice Energy: When heated to 750 ∘C750\,^\circ\text{C} (above its melting point of 734 ∘C734\,^\circ\text{C}), the thermal energy supplied overcomes the electrostatic lattice energy that binds the crystal together.
  • Ionic Mobility: The rigid lattice breaks down into a fluid containing dissociated, mobile KX+\ce{K+} cations and BrX−\ce{Br-} anions.
  • Current Carriage: Under an applied external DC electric field:
    • Positively charged potassium cations (KX+\ce{K+}) migrate toward the negative electrode (cathode).
    • Negatively charged bromide anions (BrX−\ce{Br-}) migrate toward the positive electrode (anode).

This net directional movement of ions constitutes an ionic current, completing the electric circuit and allowing the molten salt to conduct electricity efficiently.


Common Pitfall to Avoid

  • Confusing Electronic and Ionic Conduction: Do not state that electrons flow through the molten salt. In ionic conductors (electrolytes/melts), the charge carriers are ions, not free electrons. Electron transfer occurs only at the electrode interfaces via redox reactions, while physical migration of KX+\ce{K+} and BrX−\ce{Br-} carries the charge through the liquid bulk.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student incorrectly assumes that electrical conduction always requires free electrons, concluding that molten salts must conduct by releasing delocalized electrons rather than mobile ions.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Beaker 1: Non-conducting insulator   ⟹  \implies Beaker 2: Conducts

  2. Step 2

    In solid KBr\ce{KBr}, electrons are tightly bound in bonds and cannot move, so it does not conduct.

    Correct

    In solid KBr\ce{KBr}, KX+\ce{K+} cations and BrX−\ce{Br-} anions are locked in fixed positions within a rigid ionic crystal lattice and cannot migrate, and electrons are tightly localized in filled valence shells.

    While electrons are indeed localized in noble gas electron shells, the primary physical reason solid ionic salts do not conduct electricity is that the ions themselves are held rigidly in the crystal lattice and cannot migrate to carry charge.

  3. Step 3

    When heated above 734 ∘C734\,^\circ\text{C}, thermal energy frees valence electrons from the ions into a sea of electrons, conducting electricity like a metal rather than moving ions.

    Correct

    Melting overcomes the lattice energy, allowing KX+\ce{K+} cations and BrX−\ce{Br-} anions to move freely; under an applied potential, mobile ions migrate toward oppositely charged electrodes (ionic conduction).

    Melting an ionic solid does not delocalize valence electrons or form a metallic electron sea. Instead, thermal energy overcomes the electrostatic lattice attractions, allowing KX+\ce{K+} cations and BrX−\ce{Br-} anions to physically move through the liquid and carry the electric current.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that solid KBr\ce{KBr} acts as an insulator and molten KBr\ce{KBr} conducts electricity.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing ionic conduction with electronic/metallic conduction

No

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that all electrical conduction requires a 'sea of electrons' as found in metals, not realizing that liquid electrolytes and molten salts conduct via the physical migration of mobile cations and anions.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify the Charge Carrier
  • Electrical conductivity requires mobile charge carriers, which can be either delocalized electrons (in metals/graphite) or mobile ions (in molten salts/aqueous solutions).

  • Determine whether the substance is a metal or an ionic compound before identifying the charge carrier.

Phase Change in Ionic Solids
  • Melting an ionic compound disrupts the rigid lattice into freely moving ions; it does not ionize the substance into free electrons.

  • Explain conduction in molten ionic compounds by describing the migration of cations toward the cathode and anions toward the anode.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State that in solid KBr\ce{KBr}, the KX+\ce{K+} and BrX−\ce{Br-} ions are rigidly fixed in place within the crystal lattice, meaning there are no mobile charge carriers.

  2. Explain that heating KBr\ce{KBr} past its melting point (734 ∘C734\,^\circ\text{C}) supplies sufficient thermal energy to break down the rigid lattice structure.

  3. Specify that the charge carriers in molten KBr\ce{KBr} are mobile KX+\ce{K+} cations and BrX−\ce{Br-} anions, which migrate toward the oppositely charged electrodes (ionic conduction), distinct from the delocalized electron sea in metals.

Final answer

(a) Beaker 1 is a non-conducting insulator; Beaker 2 conducts electricity. (b) In solid KBr\ce{KBr}, KX+\ce{K+} and BrX−\ce{Br-} ions are locked in a rigid ionic lattice with no mobile charge carriers. Upon melting, the lattice breaks down into freely moving KX+\ce{K+} cations and BrX−\ce{Br-} anions that migrate toward the electrodes under an electric field (ionic conduction), unlike metals which conduct via delocalized electrons.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinct mechanisms of electronic conduction (free electrons in metals) versus ionic conduction (free ions in liquids/solutions).

  • Practice describing the structure of molten salts as dissociated, mobile cations and anions rather than neutral atoms in an electron sea.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student believes that since potassium is an alkali metal, solid KBr possesses metallic conductivity properties, predicting solid KBr conducts electricity.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Beaker 1: Conducts  ⟹  Beaker 2: Conducts\text{Beaker 1: Conducts} \implies \text{Beaker 2: Conducts}

    Correct

    Beaker 1: Non-conducting insulator;Beaker 2: Electrical conductor\text{Beaker 1: Non-conducting insulator}; \text{Beaker 2: Electrical conductor}

    You correctly identified that molten KBr\text{KBr} conducts, but solid crystalline KBr\text{KBr} cannot conduct electricity because its ions are locked in fixed positions within the crystal lattice.

  2. Step 2

    Because potassium is a metal, KBr contains metallic bonds that allow electrons to conduct even in the solid state.  ⟹  In both solid and liquid states, the metallic potassium component provides conduction via free electrons, contrasting with non-metal lattices.\text{Because potassium is a metal, KBr contains metallic bonds that allow electrons to conduct even in the solid state.} \implies \text{In both solid and liquid states, the metallic potassium component provides conduction via free electrons, contrasting with non-metal lattices.}

    Correct

    KBr forms an ionic giant lattice between K+ and Br−. In the solid, ions are fixed with no mobile charge carriers (electrons are localized in filled valence shells). Upon melting, the lattice breaks down and thermal energy frees mobile K+ cations and Br− anions to carry electric current.\text{KBr forms an ionic giant lattice between K}^+ \text{ and Br}^- \text{. In the solid, ions are fixed with no mobile charge carriers (electrons are localized in filled valence shells). Upon melting, the lattice breaks down and thermal energy frees mobile K}^+ \text{ cations and Br}^- \text{ anions to carry electric current.}

    You treated KBr\text{KBr} as having metallic bonding and free electron conduction because potassium is a metal. A metal bonded to a nonmetal forms an ionic compound with electron transfer, not a metallic bond. In KBr\text{KBr}, electrons are tightly held in filled valence shells, and electrical conduction in the molten state occurs through the physical migration of ions, not free electrons.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized that heating potassium bromide to a molten liquid in Beaker 2 enables electrical conduction.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Misidentifying ionic compounds as metallic conductors

You crossed out the correct prediction that Beaker 1 is non-conducting.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that the presence of a metallic element implies metallic bonding and delocalized free-electron conduction across all states, overlooking that reacting a metal with a nonmetal forms an ionic lattice where electrons are localized into ions and charge transport occurs exclusively via mobile ions.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify Bond Type from Constituent Elements
  • A metal combined with a nonmetal forms an ionic bond via valence electron transfer, producing fixed cations and anions rather than a sea of delocalized electrons.

  • Always check whether both elements are metals (metallic bonding) or a metal plus a nonmetal (ionic bonding) before assuming electron mobility.

Identify the Mobile Charge Carrier
  • Metals conduct via delocalized electrons in both solid and liquid states. Ionic compounds never conduct via free electrons; they conduct only when ions are free to move (molten or aqueous).

  • For ionic compounds, attribute electrical conduction to mobile cations and anions migrating under an electric field, never to free electrons.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Classify KBr\text{KBr} as an ionic compound containing K+\text{K}^+ and Br−\text{Br}^- ions with complete, localized octets.

  2. Deduce that solid KBr(s)\text{KBr}(s) at 20 ∘C20\,^\circ\text{C} is a non-conducting insulator because all ions are locked rigidly in the crystal lattice.

  3. Explain that at 750 ∘C750\,^\circ\text{C}, molten KBr(l)\text{KBr}(l) conducts because thermal energy breaks the lattice, freeing K+\text{K}^+ and Br−\text{Br}^- ions to migrate to the cathode and anode.

Final answer

(a) Beaker 1 is a non-conducting insulator; Beaker 2 is an electrical conductor. (b) Solid KBr\text{KBr} has immobile ions and no free electrons. Molten KBr\text{KBr} conducts electricity through mobile K+\text{K}^+ and Br−\text{Br}^- ions, unlike metals which conduct via delocalized electrons.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between electronic conduction (delocalized electron sea in pure metals) and ionic conduction (mobile ions in molten or dissolved salts).

  • Practice predicting electrical conductivity across the four major crystalline solids: metallic, ionic, covalent network, and molecular.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Explain why solid magnesium chloride (MgClX2\ce{MgCl2}) does not conduct electricity, but aqueous magnesium chloride (MgClX2(aq)\ce{MgCl2}(aq)) conducts electricity readily. Identify the charge carriers in the conducting state.

Answer

In solid MgClX2\ce{MgCl2}, MgX2+\ce{Mg^{2+}} and ClX−\ce{Cl-} ions are held in fixed positions within the crystal lattice and cannot move. When dissolved in water, the lattice dissociates into mobile hydrated MgX2+\ce{Mg^{2+}} cations and ClX−\ce{Cl-} anions, which act as mobile charge carriers to conduct current.

02

A student tests three substances for electrical conductivity: solid copper wire, molten sodium chloride (NaCl(l)\ce{NaCl}(l)), and liquid hexane (CX6HX14(l)\ce{C6H14}(l)). Predict which will conduct electricity, and contrast the type of charge carrier in each conducting substance.

Answer

Copper wire and molten NaCl\ce{NaCl} conduct; liquid hexane does not. In copper wire, charge is carried by delocalized valence electrons (electronic conduction). In molten NaCl\ce{NaCl}, charge is carried by mobile NaX+\ce{Na+} cations and ClX−\ce{Cl-} anions (ionic conduction). Hexane consists of neutral covalent molecules with neither free electrons nor ions.

03

During the electrolysis of molten lead(II) bromide (PbBrX2(l)\ce{PbBr2}(l)), an electric current passes through the liquid between two inert electrodes. Describe the physical movement occurring in the liquid bulk and identify what happens at each electrode interface to sustain the external electron flow.

Answer

In the bulk liquid, mobile PbX2+\ce{Pb^{2+}} cations migrate toward the cathode (negative electrode) and mobile BrX−\ce{Br-} anions migrate toward the anode (positive electrode). At the cathode, PbX2+\ce{Pb^{2+}} gains electrons to form liquid lead (PbX2++2 eX−→Pb\ce{Pb^{2+} + 2e- -> Pb}). At the anode, BrX−\ce{Br-} loses electrons to form bromine vapor (2 BrX−→BrX2+2 eX−\ce{2Br- -> Br2 + 2e-}), transferring electrons back into the external circuit.

Loading workspace…