Resources

A chemist investigates an open-chain aliphatic hydrocarbon having exactly 55 carbon atoms. The degree of unsaturation (Index of Hydrogen Deficiency, IHD\text{IHD}) is evaluated using the formula IHD=2C+2−H2\text{IHD} = \frac{2\text{C} + 2 - \text{H}}{2}. Identify the exact number of hydrogen atoms corresponding to the threshold boundary where the compound transitions among the aliphatic classifications: (a) IHD=0\text{IHD} = 0, (b) IHD=1\text{IHD} = 1, and (c) IHD=2\text{IHD} = 2. Specify whether each threshold boundary represents an alkane, an alkene, or an alkyne (assuming only carbon-carbon multiple bonds and no rings).

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) H=12\text{H} = 12 atoms (IHD=0\text{IHD} = 0), alkane; (b) H=10\text{H} = 10 atoms (IHD=1\text{IHD} = 1), alkene (one C=C\text{C}=\text{C} double bond); (c) H=8\text{H} = 8 atoms (IHD=2\text{IHD} = 2), alkyne (one C≡C\text{C}\equiv\text{C} triple bond) or alkadiene.

Steps

Understanding the Index of Hydrogen Deficiency (IHD\text{IHD})

The degree of unsaturation, or Index of Hydrogen Deficiency (IHD\text{IHD}), measures the total number of rings and π\pi bonds in a molecule. For a neutral hydrocarbon containing C\text{C} carbon atoms and H\text{H} hydrogen atoms:

IHD=2C+2−H2\text{IHD} = \frac{2\text{C} + 2 - \text{H}}{2}

Rearranging this formula to solve for the number of hydrogen atoms (H\text{H}) gives:

2⋅IHD=2C+2−H  ⟹  H=2C+2−2(IHD)2 \cdot \text{IHD} = 2\text{C} + 2 - \text{H} \implies \text{H} = 2\text{C} + 2 - 2(\text{IHD})

Given that the hydrocarbon has exactly 55 carbon atoms (C=5\text{C} = 5):

H=2(5)+2−2(IHD)=12−2(IHD)\text{H} = 2(5) + 2 - 2(\text{IHD}) = 12 - 2(\text{IHD})

Since the compound is restricted to an open-chain structure (acyclic, meaning 00 rings), all degrees of unsaturation arise solely from carbon–carbon multiple bonds (π\pi bonds).


Step-by-Step Evaluation for Each Threshold

  1. Threshold (a): IHD=0\text{IHD} = 0

    • Calculation: H=12−2(0)=12\text{H} = 12 - 2(0) = 12
    • Molecular Formula: CX5HX12\ce{C5H12} (general formula CXnHX2n+2\ce{C_nH_{2n+2}})
    • Classification: An IHD\text{IHD} of 00 indicates no π\pi bonds and no rings; every carbon atom is fully saturated with single bonds. Thus, it represents an alkane (pentane).
  2. Threshold (b): IHD=1\text{IHD} = 1

    • Calculation: H=12−2(1)=10\text{H} = 12 - 2(1) = 10
    • Molecular Formula: CX5HX10\ce{C5H10} (general formula CXnHX2n\ce{C_nH_{2n}})
    • Classification: An IHD\text{IHD} of 11 corresponds to one degree of unsaturation, which in an acyclic hydrocarbon means exactly one π\pi bond (one C=C\ce{C=C} double bond). Thus, it represents an alkene (pentene).
  3. Threshold (c): IHD=2\text{IHD} = 2

    • Calculation: H=12−2(2)=8\text{H} = 12 - 2(2) = 8
    • Molecular Formula: CX5HX8\ce{C5H8} (general formula CXnHX2n−2\ce{C_nH_{2n-2}})
    • Classification: An IHD\text{IHD} of 22 corresponds to two degrees of unsaturation. In an acyclic hydrocarbon, two π\pi bonds can be arranged as either one C≡C\ce{C\equiv C} triple bond (an alkyne, such as pentyne) or two separate C=C\ce{C=C} double bonds (an alkadiene, such as pentadiene).

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

  • Forgetting that rings also contribute to IHD\text{IHD}: A value of IHD=1\text{IHD} = 1 could represent a cycloalkane (e.g., cyclopentane), but the problem explicitly restricts the molecule to an open-chain (aliphatic/acyclic) structure.
  • Assuming IHD=2\text{IHD} = 2 exclusively indicates a triple bond: Two degrees of unsaturation can arise from a single triple bond (two π\pi bonds) or two separate double bonds (one π\pi bond each). Both fulfill the open-chain criteria.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misarranges the formula as H = 2C + 2 - IHD instead of 2C + 2 - 2(IHD), underestimating the loss of two hydrogens per degree of unsaturation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    H=2(5)+2−0=12  ⟹  12 hydrogen atoms, alkane\text{H} = 2(5) + 2 - 0 = 12 \implies 12\text{ hydrogen atoms, alkane}

  2. Step 2

    H=2(5)+2−1=11  ⟹  11 hydrogen atoms, alkene\text{H} = 2(5) + 2 - 1 = 11 \implies 11\text{ hydrogen atoms, alkene}

    Correct

    H=2(5)+2−2(1)=10  ⟹  10 hydrogen atoms, alkene\text{H} = 2(5) + 2 - 2(1) = 10 \implies 10\text{ hydrogen atoms, alkene}

    You subtracted 11 instead of multiplying the IHD\text{IHD} value by 22. Each degree of unsaturation corresponds to a pair of hydrogen atoms (2 H2\text{ H}), yielding H=12−2(1)=10\text{H} = 12 - 2(1) = 10.

  3. Step 3

    H=2(5)+2−2=10  ⟹  10 hydrogen atoms, alkyne\text{H} = 2(5) + 2 - 2 = 10 \implies 10\text{ hydrogen atoms, alkyne}

    Correct

    H=2(5)+2−2(2)=8  ⟹  8 hydrogen atoms, alkyne\text{H} = 2(5) + 2 - 2(2) = 8 \implies 8\text{ hydrogen atoms, alkyne}

    You subtracted 22 instead of 2(IHD)=2(2)=42(\text{IHD}) = 2(2) = 4. With two degrees of unsaturation, four hydrogens are missing relative to the saturated alkane, giving H=12−4=8\text{H} = 12 - 4 = 8.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly associated IHD=0\text{IHD} = 0 with an alkane, IHD=1\text{IHD} = 1 with an alkene, and IHD=2\text{IHD} = 2 with an alkyne.

You correctly evaluated the fully saturated hydrogen baseline as 2(5)+2=122(5) + 2 = 12.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula rearrangement error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You rearranged IHD=2C+2−H2\text{IHD} = \frac{2\text{C} + 2 - \text{H}}{2} into H=2C+2−IHD\text{H} = 2\text{C} + 2 - \text{IHD} instead of multiplying both sides by 22 to get H=2C+2−2(IHD)\text{H} = 2\text{C} + 2 - 2(\text{IHD}). Because each degree of unsaturation represents the loss of a pair of hydrogen atoms, you subtracted single hydrogens instead of pairs.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Clear the denominator first
  • When isolating H\text{H} from IHD=2C+2−H2\text{IHD} = \frac{2\text{C} + 2 - \text{H}}{2}, multiply both sides by 22 to obtain 2(IHD)=2C+2−H2(\text{IHD}) = 2\text{C} + 2 - \text{H}.

  • Rearrange to solve for H\text{H} as H=(2C+2)−2(IHD)\text{H} = (2\text{C} + 2) - 2(\text{IHD}) before substituting numerical values.

Check parity of neutral hydrocarbons
  • Any stable neutral hydrocarbon without radicals must contain an even number of hydrogen atoms.

  • Verify that your calculated hydrogen count is always an even number; getting an odd count like 1111 signals an algebraic error.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Multiply both sides of the definition by 22: 2(IHD)=2C+2−H2(\text{IHD}) = 2\text{C} + 2 - \text{H}.

  2. Rearrange to isolate H\text{H}: H=2C+2−2(IHD)\text{H} = 2\text{C} + 2 - 2(\text{IHD}).

  3. Substitute C=5\text{C} = 5 and IHD=1\text{IHD} = 1: H=2(5)+2−2(1)=10\text{H} = 2(5) + 2 - 2(1) = 10, giving CX5HX10\ce{C5H10} (alkene).

  4. Substitute C=5\text{C} = 5 and IHD=2\text{IHD} = 2: H=2(5)+2−2(2)=8\text{H} = 2(5) + 2 - 2(2) = 8, giving CX5HX8\ce{C5H8} (alkyne or alkadiene).

Final answer

(a) H=12\text{H} = 12 atoms, alkane; (b) H=10\text{H} = 10 atoms, alkene; (c) H=8\text{H} = 8 atoms, alkyne (or alkadiene).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice isolating variables from fractional definitions before plugging in numbers.

  • Remember that each degree of unsaturation (each ring or π\pi bond) always removes two hydrogen atoms relative to an alkane.

  • Use the even-hydrogen parity check on neutral hydrocarbon formulas to catch single-hydrogen algebraic slips.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the hydrocarbon family names, reversing the designations of alkene and alkyne for IHD = 1 and IHD = 2.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    0=(12−H)/2  ⟹  H=120 = (12 - \text{H})/2 \implies \text{H} = 12, 12 hydrogen atoms, alkane

  2. Step 2

    1=(12−H)/2  ⟹  H=101 = (12 - \text{H})/2 \implies \text{H} = 10, 10 hydrogen atoms, alkyne

    Correct

    H=10\text{H} = 10, alkene

    You calculated the hydrogen count H=10\text{H} = 10 accurately, but an open-chain hydrocarbon with IHD=1\text{IHD} = 1 has one π\pi bond (a C=C\ce{C=C} double bond), which defines an alkene rather than an alkyne.

  3. Step 3

    2=(12−H)/2  ⟹  H=82 = (12 - \text{H})/2 \implies \text{H} = 8, 8 hydrogen atoms, alkene

    Correct

    H=8\text{H} = 8, alkyne (or alkadiene)

    You calculated H=8\text{H} = 8 accurately, but IHD=2\text{IHD} = 2 corresponds to two degrees of unsaturation (two π\pi bonds), which forms an alkyne (with one C≡C\ce{C#C} triple bond) or an alkadiene.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the Index of Hydrogen Deficiency equation IHD=2C+2−H2\text{IHD} = \frac{2\text{C} + 2 - \text{H}}{2} with C=5\text{C} = 5.

You solved for the correct hydrogen atom count in all three cases: 1212, 1010, and 88.

You accurately identified that IHD=0\text{IHD} = 0 corresponds to a saturated alkane.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Nomenclature / Functional Group Confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You swapped the names of alkenes and alkynes, associating one degree of unsaturation (a double bond) with an alkyne and two degrees of unsaturation (a triple bond) with an alkene.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Recall the Alk- Suffixes in Alphabetical Order
  • Alkane (−ane-ane, 0 π\pi bonds, single) →\rightarrow Alkene (−ene-ene, 1 π\pi bond, double) →\rightarrow Alkyne (−yne-yne, 2 π\pi bonds, triple).

  • Associate each increasing step in bond order and IHD with the alphabetical progression of suffixes: A (single, IHD=0\text{IHD}=0), E (double, IHD=1\text{IHD}=1), Y (triple, IHD=2\text{IHD}=2).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. For IHD=1\text{IHD} = 1: One degree of unsaturation in an acyclic hydrocarbon corresponds to one C=C\ce{C=C} double bond, which is an alkene (formula CXnHX2n\ce{C_nH_{2n}}).

  2. For IHD=2\text{IHD} = 2: Two degrees of unsaturation correspond to two π\pi bonds, which can be arranged as a C≡C\ce{C#C} triple bond (an alkyne, formula CXnHX2n−2\ce{C_nH_{2n-2}}) or two double bonds (an alkadiene).

Final answer

(a) H=12\text{H} = 12 atoms, alkane; (b) H=10\text{H} = 10 atoms, alkene; (c) H=8\text{H} = 8 atoms, alkyne (or alkadiene)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice matching the suffixes -ane, -ene, and -yne to the number of π\pi bonds.

  • Review general formulas for acyclic hydrocarbons: CXnHX2n+2\ce{C_nH_{2n+2}} for alkanes, CXnHX2n\ce{C_nH_{2n}} for alkenes, and CXnHX2n−2\ce{C_nH_{2n-2}} for alkynes.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student omits the '+ 2' saturated alkane offset in the formula, calculating from 2C - H instead of 2C + 2 - H.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    0=2(5)−H2  ⟹  10−H=0  ⟹  H=100 = \frac{2(5) - \text{H}}{2} \implies 10 - \text{H} = 0 \implies \text{H} = 10, 10 hydrogen atoms, alkane10\text{ hydrogen atoms, alkane}

    Correct

    IHD=2C+2−H2  ⟹  0=2(5)+2−H2  ⟹  12−H=0  ⟹  H=12\text{IHD} = \frac{2\text{C} + 2 - \text{H}}{2} \implies 0 = \frac{2(5) + 2 - \text{H}}{2} \implies 12 - \text{H} = 0 \implies \text{H} = 12, alkane

    You omitted the +2+2 in the numerator of the IHD\text{IHD} formula. A fully saturated 55-carbon alkane follows CXnHX2n+2\ce{C_nH_{2n+2}}, giving 2(5)+2=122(5) + 2 = 12 hydrogen atoms, not 1010.

  2. Step 2

    1=10−H2  ⟹  10−H=2  ⟹  H=81 = \frac{10 - \text{H}}{2} \implies 10 - \text{H} = 2 \implies \text{H} = 8, 8 hydrogen atoms, alkene8\text{ hydrogen atoms, alkene}

    Correct

    1=12−H2  ⟹  12−H=2  ⟹  H=101 = \frac{12 - \text{H}}{2} \implies 12 - \text{H} = 2 \implies \text{H} = 10, alkene

    Your algebraic rearrangement was executed correctly, but this step carries forward the missing +2+2 term from Step 1. A 55-carbon mono-alkene has 1010 hydrogen atoms (CX5HX10\ce{C5H10}).

  3. Step 3

    2=10−H2  ⟹  10−H=4  ⟹  H=62 = \frac{10 - \text{H}}{2} \implies 10 - \text{H} = 4 \implies \text{H} = 6, 6 hydrogen atoms, alkyne6\text{ hydrogen atoms, alkyne}

    Correct

    2=12−H2  ⟹  12−H=4  ⟹  H=82 = \frac{12 - \text{H}}{2} \implies 12 - \text{H} = 4 \implies \text{H} = 8, alkyne (or alkadiene)

    Your algebra and classification are consistent, but the hydrogen count is affected by using 1010 instead of 1212 as the saturated maximum. For IHD=2\text{IHD} = 2, H=12−4=8\text{H} = 12 - 4 = 8.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly associated each index value with its functional class: IHD=0\text{IHD} = 0 is an alkane, IHD=1\text{IHD} = 1 is an alkene, and IHD=2\text{IHD} = 2 is an alkyne.

You performed the algebraic rearrangements and linear solving accurately from your written formulas.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula omission error

You dropped the +2+ 2 constant when setting up the Index of Hydrogen Deficiency formula.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the reference baseline of saturation as 2C2\text{C} rather than 2C+22\text{C} + 2, forgetting that an open-chain saturated alkane requires two terminal capping hydrogen atoms.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Saturated Baseline Check
  • Every open-chain alkane has the formula CXnHX2n+2\ce{C_nH_{2n+2}}. The extra 22 hydrogens cap the two chain ends.

  • Always write IHD=(2C+2)−H2\text{IHD} = \frac{(2\text{C} + 2) - \text{H}}{2}, where 2C+22\text{C} + 2 represents the maximum possible hydrogens.

Sanity Check with Pentane
  • For n=5n = 5, saturated pentane is CX5HX12\ce{C5H12}.

  • Before proceeding to unsaturation, confirm that when IHD=0\text{IHD} = 0, H\text{H} equals 2(5)+2=122(5) + 2 = 12.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the full formula: IHD=2C+2−H2\text{IHD} = \frac{2\text{C} + 2 - \text{H}}{2}. With C=5\text{C} = 5, this simplifies to IHD=12−H2\text{IHD} = \frac{12 - \text{H}}{2}, or H=12−2(IHD)\text{H} = 12 - 2(\text{IHD}).

  2. For (a) IHD=0\text{IHD} = 0: H=12−2(0)=12\text{H} = 12 - 2(0) = 12 atoms   ⟹  \implies alkane.

  3. For (b) IHD=1\text{IHD} = 1: H=12−2(1)=10\text{H} = 12 - 2(1) = 10 atoms   ⟹  \implies alkene.

  4. For (c) IHD=2\text{IHD} = 2: H=12−2(2)=8\text{H} = 12 - 2(2) = 8 atoms   ⟹  \implies alkyne (or alkadiene).

Final answer

(a) H=12\text{H} = 12, alkane; (b) H=10\text{H} = 10, alkene; (c) H=8\text{H} = 8, alkyne

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the general alkane formula CXnHX2n+2\ce{C_nH_{2n+2}} as the standard anchor for degree of unsaturation calculations.

  • Review how each degree of unsaturation reduces the hydrogen count by exactly 22 relative to the saturated alkane reference.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

An open-chain aliphatic hydrocarbon has 44 carbon atoms. Calculate the exact number of hydrogen atoms when (a) IHD=1\text{IHD} = 1 and (b) IHD=2\text{IHD} = 2, and state the classification of each.

Answer

(a) H=2(4)+2−2(1)=8\text{H} = 2(4) + 2 - 2(1) = 8 atoms, alkene; (b) H=2(4)+2−2(2)=6\text{H} = 2(4) + 2 - 2(2) = 6 atoms, alkyne (or alkadiene).

02

A chemist identifies an aliphatic acyclic hydrocarbon with the formula CX7HX10\ce{C7H10}. Determine its Index of Hydrogen Deficiency (IHD\text{IHD}) and describe two different combinations of carbon–carbon multiple bonds that this molecule could possess.

Answer

IHD=2(7)+2−102=62=3\text{IHD} = \frac{2(7) + 2 - 10}{2} = \frac{6}{2} = 3. Because the molecule is acyclic, it contains 3 π3\ \pi bonds. Possible combinations include: (1) one triple bond and one double bond, (2) three double bonds, or (3) two cumulated/conjugated triple bonds aren't needed, but two double bonds and one triple bond or one triple plus one double both provide 3 π3\ \pi bonds.

03

A branched acyclic hydrocarbon has the formula CXn HX2n−4\ce{C_n H_{2n - 4}}. Express its IHD\text{IHD} in terms of this formula, and determine the minimum number of carbon atoms nn needed for this molecule to contain two carbon-carbon triple bonds.

Answer

IHD=2n+2−(2n−4)2=62=3\text{IHD} = \frac{2n + 2 - (2n - 4)}{2} = \frac{6}{2} = 3. However, two carbon-carbon triple bonds require 2×2=4 π2 \times 2 = 4\ \pi bonds (which corresponds to IHD=4\text{IHD} = 4, general formula CXn HX2n−6\ce{C_n H_{2n-6}}). For an acyclic hydrocarbon with exactly two triple bonds, each triple bond requires at least 2 carbons, so the absolute minimum carbon chain is n=4n = 4 (diacetylene, CX4HX2\ce{C4H2}, which has IHD=4\text{IHD} = 4).

Loading workspace…