Resources
Based on the general trend that atomic radius increases down a group due to the addition of principal quantum shells, a student expects the atomic radius of hafnium (, , Period 6) to be substantially larger than that of zirconium (, , Period 5). In reality, their metallic radii are nearly identical (, ). Name the specific phenomenon that causes this counter-intuitive result and identify the subshell whose poor shielding ability is directly responsible.
Answer and steps
Final answer
Phenomenon: Lanthanide contraction; Subshell: subshell
Steps
General Down-a-Group Trend
Down any group in the periodic table, each successive period introduces a new principal quantum shell (a higher principal quantum number ). This increased distance of valence electrons from the nucleus normally causes the atomic radius to increase significantly from Period 5 to Period 6.
Based on this trend alone, hafnium (, ) is expected to be substantially larger than zirconium (, ).
The Intervening Subshell and Shielding
Between lanthanum () and hafnium () lie the 14 lanthanide elements (cerium, , through lutetium, ). Across this series, electrons are added to the inner subshell:
Due to their diffuse spatial distribution and poor penetration toward the nucleus, -orbital electrons provide very ineffective shielding (screening) against the positive charge of the nucleus.
The shielding ability of subshells follows the order:
Effective Nuclear Charge and the Phenomenon
Because the added electrons shield poorly, the effective nuclear charge () experienced by the outer electrons increases steadily as the nuclear charge increases by protons across the series.
This marked increase in pulls all electron shells closer to the nucleus, resulting in a steady decrease in atomic and ionic radii known as the lanthanide contraction.
Conclusion
By the time the subshell is completely filled at hafnium (), the cumulative shrinkage caused by the lanthanide contraction almost perfectly cancels out the expected size expansion from adding the principal shell. Consequently:
- Phenomenon: Lanthanide contraction
- Subshell: subshell (or )
Typical errors
01 The student misidentifies the subshell being filled across the lanthanide series as 5d rather than 4f.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Lanthanide contraction
- Step 2
subshell
Correctsubshell
The elements preceding hafnium (, ) across the lanthanide series involve filling the inner subshell, not the subshell. It is the poor shielding of these added electrons that causes the contraction.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly named the lanthanide contraction as the underlying cause for the nearly identical radii of zirconium and hafnium.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the transition metal subshell being filled in the main block with the inner transition subshell filled across the lanthanide series in Period 6.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Locate the Intervening Block
In Period , the inner transition elements fill the subshell, while the main transition metals fill the subshell.
For Period 6 (), determine the inner -block subshell by evaluating , which corresponds to the subshell.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the atomic numbers intervening between () and ().
Note that elements through fill the orbitals.
Recognize that diffuse -orbitals have the poorest shielding ability ().
Phenomenon: Lanthanide contraction; Subshell: subshell
02 The student confuses the period-6 phenomenon with the d-block contraction (scandide contraction) caused by poor 3d shielding.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
d-block contraction
CorrectLanthanide contraction
You named the -block contraction, which occurs after filling the series (notably making gallium smaller than expected relative to aluminum). The contraction that occurs between zirconium () and hafnium () across Period 6 is called the lanthanide contraction.
- Step 2
3d subshell
Correctsubshell
You identified the subshell, but the elements inserted directly before hafnium are the lanthanides (cerium through lutetium), where electrons fill the inner subshell.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that poor shielding by an intervening inner subshell causes an unexpected contraction in atomic radius.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo, this is a conceptual mix-up between Period 4 -block shielding and Period 6 -block shielding.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the -block (scandide) contraction that follows the series in Period 4 with the lanthanide contraction that follows the series across the 6th period.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Locate the Intervening Elements
Between () and (), lanthanide elements ( to ) fill the subshell.
Check atomic numbers on the periodic table to verify which subshell fills between the two compared elements.
- Subshell Shielding Hierarchy
The shielding efficiency follows the order . Both and orbitals shield poorly, but electrons are responsible for the lanthanide series contraction.
Associate the subshell with Period 4/13 trends (e.g., vs. ) and the subshell with Period 5 vs. Period 6 transition metal pairs.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationNote that zirconium has in Period 5, while hafnium has in Period 6.
Observe that between lanthanum () and hafnium (), electrons are added to the inner subshell ().
Because electrons have poor penetration and shield the nucleus very poorly, the effective nuclear charge () increases substantially across the lanthanides, pulling the outer shells inward.
This shrinkage is specifically termed the lanthanide contraction.
Phenomenon: Lanthanide contraction; Subshell: subshell
03 The student confuses the principal quantum number of the f-subshell being filled, identifying it as 5f instead of 4f.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Lanthanide contraction
- Step 2
5f subshell
Correctsubshell
The elements preceding hafnium in Period 6 are the lanthanides, which fill the subshell, not the subshell (which is filled in Period 7 by the actinides).
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the lanthanide contraction as the phenomenon responsible for the similarity in metallic radii between zirconium and hafnium.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the principal quantum number of the subshell filled in Period 6, writing rather than using the rule, which gives for Period 6 ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Determine the Principal Quantum Number for f-Subshells
For elements in period , the inner subshell being filled has a principal quantum number of .
Check the period number of the element: for Period 6 (), the filling subshell is ; the subshell is filled in Period 7.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecall that hafnium (, ) is in Period 6 ().
Apply the Aufbau principle: the orbitals filled during Period 6 correspond to .
State the correct subshell as .
Phenomenon: Lanthanide contraction; Subshell: subshell
Lock it in
Which subshell is filled across the lanthanide series in Period 6 of the periodic table?
The subshell. Inner transition metals fill the orbital, so for Period 6 (), .
Similar question
Molybdenum (, Period 5, Group 6) and tungsten (, Period 6, Group 6) have nearly identical atomic radii ( and ). State the cause of this similarity and write the filled inner subshell responsible.
Answer
Lanthanide contraction; filled subshell (). The intervening electrons shield the increasing nuclear charge poorly, contracting the valence orbitals of tungsten.
Compare the first ionization energy of zirconium (, ) and hafnium (, ). Normally, ionization energy decreases down a group. Predict whether will have a lower or higher first ionization energy than , and explain why using effective nuclear charge ().
Answer
has a higher first ionization energy () than (). Due to the lanthanide contraction, the poorly shielding electrons allow to increase substantially, holding the valence electrons more tightly despite the higher principal quantum level.
In Period 7, elements (thorium) through (lawrencium) form the actinide series. Name the analogous contraction phenomenon occurring here and identify the specific subshell whose poor shielding causes it.
Answer
Actinide contraction; subshell. Across Period 7 (), electrons enter the subshell, which shields the nuclear charge even less effectively than electrons.