Resources

Consider the simplest stable isotope of hydrogen, protium (11H^{1}_{1}\text{H}), and its monopositive cation, the hydron (11H+^{1}_{1}\text{H}^{+}). (a) State the exact count of protons, neutrons, and electrons in a neutral 11H^{1}_{1}\text{H} atom. (b) Identify the critical threshold boundary regarding subatomic composition when 11H^{1}_{1}\text{H} is fully ionized to 11H+^{1}_{1}\text{H}^{+}, specifying which subatomic particles remain in the resulting ion.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Protons: 11, Neutrons: 00, Electrons: 11; (b) Upon complete ionization to 11H+^{1}_{1}\text{H}^{+}, it loses its sole electron, leaving exactly 11 proton, 00 neutrons, and 00 electrons (a bare proton nucleus).

Steps

Part (a): Subatomic Particles in Neutral Protium (11H^{1}_{1}\ce{H})

For any nuclide represented by the standard isotopic notation ZAX^{A}_{Z}\ce{X}:

  • The atomic number (ZZ) is the subscript, which defines the number of protons in the nucleus: Protons=Z=1\text{Protons} = Z = 1
  • The mass number (AA) is the superscript, which represents the total number of nucleons (protons plus neutrons): Neutrons=A−Z=1−1=0\text{Neutrons} = A - Z = 1 - 1 = 0
  • In an electrically neutral atom, the positive charge of the protons must be balanced by an equal number of negatively charged electrons: Electrons=Protons=1\text{Electrons} = \text{Protons} = 1

Therefore, a neutral 11H^{1}_{1}\ce{H} atom contains 11 proton, 00 neutrons, and 11 electron.


Part (b): Subatomic Composition of the Cation (11H+^{1}_{1}\ce{H}^+)

Ionization involves the removal of valence electrons without altering the nucleus:

  • Ionization Process: When neutral 11H^{1}_{1}\ce{H} is ionized to form the monopositive cation 11H+^{1}_{1}\ce{H}^+, it loses its single electron: X11X2121H→X11X2121HX++eX−\ce{^{1}_{1}H -> ^{1}_{1}H+ + e-}
  • Threshold Boundary & Remaining Particles:
    • Because protium possesses only one electron and no neutrons, the loss of that lone electron removes its entire extranuclear electron shell.
    • The resulting ion, 11H+^{1}_{1}\ce{H}^+, contains 11 proton, 00 neutrons, and 00 electrons.

Thus, the ion 11H+^{1}_{1}\ce{H}^+ represents a unique threshold in chemistry: it is stripped of all surrounding electrons, reducing the atom entirely to a bare proton nucleus.

Common Pitfall: Do not confuse mass number with neutron count. A mass number of 11 means the total nucleon count is 11. Because one proton is already present, the number of neutrons is 1−1=01 - 1 = 0, not 11.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student assumes every atom must contain at least one neutron and mistakenly calculates neutrons as equal to the mass number.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Protons=1\text{Protons} = 1, Neutrons=1\text{Neutrons} = 1, Electrons=1\text{Electrons} = 1

    Correct

    Protons=1\text{Protons} = 1, Neutrons=0\text{Neutrons} = 0, Electrons=1\text{Electrons} = 1

    In standard nuclide notation ZAX^{A}_{Z}\text{X}, the mass number is A=1A = 1 and the atomic number is Z=1Z = 1. The number of neutrons is given by N=A−Z=1−1=0N = A - Z = 1 - 1 = 0, so protium has 00 neutrons.

  2. Step 2

    Ionization removes 1 electron  ⟹  Particles remaining: 1 proton and 1 neutron\text{Ionization removes 1 electron} \implies \text{Particles remaining: 1 proton and 1 neutron}

    Correct

    Ionization removes 1 electron  ⟹  Particles remaining: 1 proton (0 neutrons, 0 electrons)\text{Ionization removes 1 electron} \implies \text{Particles remaining: 1 proton (0 neutrons, 0 electrons)}

    You correctly recognized that forming a +1+1 cation removes 11 electron. However, because protium has no neutrons, the resulting 11H+^{1}_{1}\text{H}^{+} ion consists solely of 11 bare proton.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that atomic number Z=1Z = 1 gives 11 proton.

You correctly matched the electron count to the proton count for a neutral atom.

You correctly deduced that ionization to a monopositive cation removes 11 electron.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Mass number confused with neutron count

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the mass number (A=1A = 1) as the neutron count itself, rather than recognizing that mass number represents the sum of protons and neutrons (A=Z+NA = Z + N).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Neutron Formula
  • For any nuclide ZAX^{A}_{Z}\text{X}, the neutron count is N=A−ZN = A - Z, not N=AN = A.

  • Always subtract the atomic number (subscript) from the mass number (superscript) to find the number of neutrons.

Structure of the Hydron ($^{1}_{1}\text{H}^{+}$)
  • Protium (11H^{1}_{1}\text{H}) is unique among stable nuclides because its nucleus contains no neutrons.

  • When 11H^{1}_{1}\text{H} loses its single electron, only the single proton remains, creating a bare nucleus.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Use N=A−Z=1−1=0N = A - Z = 1 - 1 = 0 to find that neutral 11H^{1}_{1}\text{H} has 11 proton, 00 neutrons, and 11 electron.

  2. Remove 11 electron for ionization: 1−1=01 - 1 = 0 electrons remain.

  3. Identify the remaining particles in 11H+^{1}_{1}\text{H}^{+} as exactly 11 proton, 00 neutrons, and 00 electrons.

Final answer

(a) 11 proton, 00 neutrons, 11 electron; (b) Ionization removes the sole electron, leaving only 11 bare proton (00 neutrons, 00 electrons).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice calculating subatomic particles for nuclides where A=2ZA = 2Z vs. A≠2ZA \neq 2Z using N=A−ZN = A - Z.

  • Remember that 11H^{1}_{1}\text{H} is the only stable isotope without any neutrons in its nucleus.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses ionization with nuclear loss and assumes forming a positive ion requires losing a proton rather than an electron.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Protons=1  ⟹  Neutrons=1−1=0  ⟹  Electrons=1\text{Protons} = 1 \implies \text{Neutrons} = 1 - 1 = 0 \implies \text{Electrons} = 1

  2. Step 2

    Positive charge means losing a proton.

    Correct

    Positive charge is formed by losing an electron: X11X2121H→X11X2121HX++eX−\ce{^{1}_{1}H -> ^{1}_{1}H+ + e-}.

    Chemical ionization involves the loss or gain of electrons from the extranuclear shell, never the removal of nuclear protons. Because electrons carry a negative charge (−1-1), losing one electron results in a net +1+1 positive charge.

  3. Step 3

    Particles remaining : 1 electron.

    Correct

    Particles remaining: 11 proton, 00 neutrons, and 00 electrons (a bare proton).

    Because ionization removes the sole electron rather than the proton, the resulting hydron cation (11H+^{1}_{1}\text{H}^{+}) consists entirely of the remaining single proton nucleus.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the numbers of protons, neutrons, and electrons in a neutral protium atom.

You used the relationship A−ZA - Z properly to deduce that protium has zero neutrons.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Ionization mechanism misconception

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated a positive ionic charge with the loss of a positive particle (proton) rather than the removal of a negative charge carrier (electron), reflecting a fundamental confusion between chemical ionization and nuclear transmutation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Subatomic Charge Balance
  • Net charge is given by Charge=(number of protons)−(number of electrons)\text{Charge} = (\text{number of protons}) - (\text{number of electrons}).

  • Always keep the proton count fixed during chemical reactions and adjust the electron count to produce the net ionic charge.

Nature of Ionization
  • Cations form when an atom loses electrons (e−e^{-}); anions form when an atom gains electrons (e−e^{-}).

  • To form a +1+1 cation from a neutral atom, subtract one electron from the extranuclear shell.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that chemical charge changes occur exclusively via electron transfer: X11X2121H→X11X2121HX++eX−\ce{^{1}_{1}H -> ^{1}_{1}H+ + e-}.

  2. Compute the remaining electron count: Electrons=1−1=0\text{Electrons} = 1 - 1 = 0.

  3. Retain the intact nucleus: Protons=1\text{Protons} = 1 and Neutrons=0\text{Neutrons} = 0.

Final answer

(a) Protons: 11, Neutrons: 00, Electrons: 11; (b) Complete ionization removes the single electron, leaving exactly 11 proton, 00 neutrons, and 00 electrons (a bare proton nucleus).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how net ionic charge relates to electron surplus or deficiency using the formula Charge=p−e\text{Charge} = p - e.

  • Practice determining subatomic particle counts for other light cations and anions, such as HeX+\ce{He+}, LiX+\ce{Li+}, and HX−\ce{H-}.

  • Contrast chemical processes (electron rearrangement) with nuclear reactions (proton or neutron changes).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student confuses a cation with an anion and adds an electron instead of removing one upon ionization.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Protons=1  ⟹  Neutrons=0  ⟹  Electrons=1\text{Protons} = 1 \implies \text{Neutrons} = 0 \implies \text{Electrons} = 1

  2. Step 2

    Ionization to HX+ adds 1 electron.  ⟹  Electrons=1+1=2\text{Ionization to } \ce{H+} \text{ adds } 1 \text{ electron.} \implies \text{Electrons} = 1 + 1 = 2

    Correct

    Ionization to HX+ removes 1 electron: Electrons=1−1=0\text{Ionization to } \ce{H+} \text{ removes } 1 \text{ electron: } \text{Electrons} = 1 - 1 = 0

    A positive charge indicates the loss of negatively charged electrons. Forming a +1+1 cation requires removing 11 electron rather than adding one.

  3. Step 3

    Particles remaining: 1 proton and 2 electrons.\text{Particles remaining: } 1 \text{ proton and } 2 \text{ electrons.}

    Correct

    Particles remaining: 1 proton, 0 neutrons, and 0 electrons (a bare proton nucleus).\text{Particles remaining: } 1 \text{ proton, } 0 \text{ neutrons, and } 0 \text{ electrons (a bare proton nucleus).}

    Because you added an electron instead of removing it, your count of remaining subatomic particles carried over the error from Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that neutral 11H^{1}_{1}\ce{H} has 11 proton, 00 neutrons, and 11 electron.

You recognized that ionization alters the electron count while keeping the nucleus intact.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign inversion in cation charge calculation

You treated the +1+1 charge as an addition of an electron (+1 eX−+1\,\ce{e-}), resulting in 22 electrons instead of 00.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated the positive sign of a cation with adding subatomic particles rather than removing negatively charged electrons. Since electrons carry a negative charge (−1-1), creating a net positive charge requires losing electrons (extcharge=p−e ext{charge} = p - e).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Cation vs. Anion Electron Rule
  • Number of electrons=Z−(charge)\text{Number of electrons} = Z - (\text{charge}). A positive charge subtracts electrons; a negative charge adds electrons.

  • Check the charge sign: if it is positive (+n+n), subtract nn electrons from the neutral count; if negative (−n-n), add nn electrons.

Protium Ionization Threshold
  • A neutral protium atom has only 11 electron. Removing that electron leaves only the nucleus (11 proton).

  • Recognize that complete ionization of 11H^{1}_{1}\ce{H} strips its entire electron shell, leaving an isolated proton with 00 electrons.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall that net charge is given by Charge=protons−electrons\text{Charge} = \text{protons} - \text{electrons}.

  2. For 11HX+^{1}_{1}\ce{H+}, charge=+1\text{charge} = +1, so 1=1−electrons1 = 1 - \text{electrons}, which yields electrons=1−1=0\text{electrons} = 1 - 1 = 0.

  3. State the remaining particles: 11 proton, 00 neutrons, and 00 electrons.

Final answer

(a) Protons: 11, Neutrons: 00, Electrons: 11; (b) Complete ionization removes the single electron, leaving only 11 proton (00 neutrons, 00 electrons), which is a bare proton nucleus.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the relationship between net ionic charge and electron count: charge=p−e\text{charge} = p - e.

  • Practice determining electron counts for both cations (e.g., LiX+\ce{Li+}, MgX2+\ce{Mg^2+}) and anions (e.g., HX−\ce{H-}, ClX−\ce{Cl-}).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Determine the number of protons, neutrons, and electrons in a neutral deuterium atom, 12H^{2}_{1}\text{H}.

Answer

11 proton, 11 neutron, 11 electron. Protons =Z=1= Z = 1; Neutrons =A−Z=2−1=1= A - Z = 2 - 1 = 1; Electrons =Protons=1= \text{Protons} = 1.

02

A helium-4 nucleus undergoes double ionization to form an alpha particle (24He2+^{4}_{2}\text{He}^{2+}). State the count of protons, neutrons, and electrons in this ion.

Answer

22 protons, 22 neutrons, 00 electrons. Protons =Z=2= Z = 2; Neutrons =A−Z=4−2=2= A - Z = 4 - 2 = 2; Electrons =2−2=0= 2 - 2 = 0.

03

An ion has 1010 electrons, a charge of −1-1, and a mass number of 1919. Determine its nuclide symbol in the form ZAX−^{A}_{Z}\text{X}^{-} and its neutron count.

Answer

919F−^{19}_{9}\text{F}^{-} with 1010 neutrons. For a −1-1 ion with 1010 electrons, the proton count is Z=10−1=9Z = 10 - 1 = 9 (Fluorine). Neutrons =A−Z=19−9=10= A - Z = 19 - 9 = 10.

Loading workspace…