Resources
Consider the polyatomic ion bromine trifluoride (). Determine the molecular geometry and explicitly evaluate the ideal vs. observed equatorial-axial bond angle . State whether the observed angle is greater than, equal to, or less than the ideal unperturbed angle, and specify the direction of distortion.
Answer and steps
Final answer
Molecular geometry: T-shaped ( derived from trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry with two equatorial lone pairs); the ideal angle of is compressed to approximately (less than ) due to lone pair-bonding pair repulsion pushing the axial bonds away from the equatorial plane.
Steps
Count Valence Electrons and Electron Domains
To apply Valence Shell Electron Pair Repulsion (VSEPR) theory, first determine the number of electron domains around the central bromine () atom:
- Bromine is a halogen (Group 17) with valence electrons.
- Each of the three fluorine () atoms shares electron to form a single covalent bond, consuming of bromine's valence electrons.
- The remaining valence electrons on bromine form lone pairs (non-bonding electron pairs).
Thus, the central atom has:
This corresponds to the generic VSEPR formula , giving a trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain (steric) geometry.
Determine Lone Pair Placement and Molecular Geometry
In a trigonal bipyramidal arrangement, equatorial sites have bond angles of with each other, whereas axial sites are at to equatorial positions.
- Lone pairs occupy more space than bonding pairs, so they experience significant repulsion at angles.
- Placing both lone pairs in the equatorial positions minimizes severe lone pair–lone pair () and lone pair–bonding pair () repulsions.
With equatorial positions occupied by lone pairs, the remaining atoms occupy equatorial position and axial positions. Ignoring the non-bonding electron pairs to describe the positions of the atomic nuclei gives a T-shaped molecular geometry.
Compare Ideal vs. Observed Bond Angles and Identify Distortion
- Ideal Angle: In a perfect, unperturbed trigonal bipyramid, the angle between an axial bond and an equatorial bond () is exactly .
- Repulsive Hierarchy: According to VSEPR theory, electron repulsion decreases in the order:
- Direction of Distortion: The two equatorial lone pairs exert stronger repulsion on the two axial bonding pairs than the equatorial bond does. This pushes both axial bonds away from the lone pairs and bends them inward toward the equatorial fluorine atom.
- Observed Angle: Consequently, the observed is less than the ideal (compressed to approximately ). Similarly, the axial-axial angle is compressed from the ideal to approximately .
Typical errors
01 The student confuses molecular geometry with electron-pair geometry by ignoring lone pairs, concluding the molecule is trigonal planar.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Valence electrons ⟹ Central has single bonds to
- Step 2
electron domains around central atom
CorrectYou counted only the bonding pairs and missed the non-bonding valence electrons on bromine. Of the total electrons, are used in the three bonds and complete the octets of the three fluorine atoms (). The remaining electrons must be placed on the central bromine atom as lone pairs, giving a total of electron domains.
- Step 3
Molecular geometry is trigonal planar
CorrectMolecular geometry is T-shaped (derived from )
Because you found electron domains instead of , you assigned a trigonal planar geometry. With electron domains ( bonding pairs and equatorial lone pairs), the molecular geometry is T-shaped.
- Step 4
Ideal angle is ⟹ Observed angle is equal to ideal angle with no distortion
CorrectIdeal is ; observed angle is less than (approximately ) due to lone pair-bonding pair repulsion
In the correct trigonal bipyramidal framework, the ideal axial-equatorial angle is . The two equatorial lone pairs exert greater repulsion on the axial bonding pairs than the equatorial bond does, compressing the observed angle to less than .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly counted the total valence electron budget for the molecule as electrons.
You correctly identified that the central bromine atom forms single bonds with fluorine atoms.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou equated the number of peripheral bonded atoms directly to the steric number without allocating the remaining valence electrons to the central atom as lone pairs.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Complete the Lewis Electron Accounting
Remaining electrons after terminal atom octets are satisfied must be placed as lone pairs on the central atom: .
Always subtract used bonding and terminal non-bonding electrons from the total valence count before determining the steric number.
- Distinguish Steric Number from Coordination Number
Steric Number = .
Do not assume the number of attached atoms equals the number of electron domains; always inspect whether the central atom accommodates an expanded or complete octet with lone pairs.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationTotal valence electrons .
Electrons assigned to three single bonds: .
Electrons assigned to complete octets of three terminal fluorine atoms: .
Remaining electrons placed on central bromine atom: electrons, which equals lone pairs.
Steric number electron domains (trigonal bipyramidal electron-pair geometry, ).
Placing both lone pairs in equatorial positions minimizes repulsions, producing a T-shaped molecular geometry.
The ideal unperturbed angle is . Strong lone pair-bonding pair () repulsions push the axial bonds inward toward the equatorial fluorine, making the observed angle less than (approximately ).
Molecular geometry: T-shaped; ideal ; observed angle is less than (compressed inward toward the equatorial bond).
02 The student places the two lone pairs in axial positions rather than equatorial positions, incorrectly predicting a trigonal planar geometry with ideal 90° angles.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
In a trigonal bipyramid, electron repulsions at dominate over repulsions at larger angles. An axial lone pair would encounter three interactions, whereas an equatorial lone pair encounters only two interactions. Therefore, both lone pairs must occupy equatorial positions, giving a T-shaped molecular geometry.
- Step 3Correct
Because this step builds on your placement of lone pairs in the axial positions, you predicted no distortion. With the lone pairs placed equatorially, their greater repulsive volume pushes the axial bonds toward the equatorial fluorine atom, compressing to less than (approximately ).
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly counted the bonding and lone pairs on the central bromine atom to obtain a steric number of .
You correctly assigned the trigonal bipyramidal electron-domain geometry.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou prioritized maximizing the lone pair–lone pair separation angle ( axial-axial) while overlooking that repulsions at are much stronger and dominate geometry determination in VSEPR theory. Placing lone pairs in axial positions creates three unfavorable interactions per lone pair, whereas equatorial placement creates only two.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Minimizing $90^\circ$ Repulsions in Trigonal Bipyramidal Geometry
In steric number (trigonal bipyramidal), lone pairs always occupy equatorial positions because equatorial sites have only two adjacent domains at , compared to three at for axial sites.
Whenever you encounter an , , or molecule, place all lone pairs in equatorial sites before evaluating shape and bond angles.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationPlace both lone pairs in equatorial positions to minimize repulsions, leaving axial positions and equatorial position for the three fluorine atoms.
Describe the molecular geometry formed by the nuclei: the resulting shape is T-shaped.
Apply the VSEPR repulsion hierarchy (): the two equatorial lone pairs push the axial bonds away from the equatorial plane toward the equatorial bond.
Conclude that the observed angle is less than the ideal , compressing to approximately .
Molecular geometry: T-shaped; observed (approximately ), distorted toward the equatorial fluorine atom.
03 The student correctly identifies the T-shaped geometry but concludes the bond angle expands because lone pairs push the equatorial bond away.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
The two equatorial lone pairs exert stronger repulsion on the axial bonding pairs than on the equatorial bond, pushing the axial bonds inward toward the equatorial atom. Thus, the observed is less than (approximately ).
The two equatorial lone pairs lie in the equatorial plane at to both axial bonds. Because lone pair–bonding pair () repulsion is stronger than bonding pair–bonding pair () repulsion, the lone pairs push the axial bonds away from the lone pairs and inward toward the equatorial fluorine, compressing the angle to less than .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly counted the valence electron pairs around bromine to find a steric number of .
You correctly recognized that lone pairs occupy equatorial positions in a trigonal bipyramidal framework to minimize repulsions.
You correctly classified the molecular geometry as T-shaped.
You correctly identified the ideal unperturbed equatorial-axial bond angle as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed the equatorial lone pairs push the equatorial bond away from the axial bonds. In reality, the two lone pairs exert their strongest repulsions against the perpendicular axial bonds, pushing both axial bonds inward toward the equatorial bond and compressing to less than .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Evaluating VSEPR Distortion in Trigonal Bipyramidal Systems
In an T-shaped geometry, the two equatorial lone pairs are from the axial bonds and from the equatorial bond. The dominant repulsions push axial bonds toward the equatorial bond.
Check which bonds are at to the lone pairs. The pairs at experience the strongest repulsion and bend away from the lone pairs, closing the angle between the remaining bonds.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationLocate the relative angles: the two equatorial lone pairs are at to each axial bond () and at approximately to the equatorial bond ().
Apply the VSEPR repulsive hierarchy: repulsion is significantly stronger at than at .
Determine the direction of movement: the two lone pairs push both axial bonds away from themselves and inward toward the equatorial bond.
Compare with the ideal angle: this inward bending compresses from to approximately (less than ).
Molecular geometry is T-shaped; the observed is less than the ideal (approximately ) because equatorial lone pairs push the axial bonds inward toward the equatorial fluorine atom.
Lock it in
How do you calculate the number of lone pairs on a central atom from a Lewis electron count?
Subtract all bonding electrons and terminal-atom lone-pair electrons from the total valence electron budget; divide the remaining electrons by .
Similar question
Determine the steric number, molecular geometry, and ideal equatorial-axial bond angle for chlorine trifluoride ().
Answer
Steric number ( bonding pairs lone pairs on ); molecular geometry = T-shaped; ideal (observed angle is compressed to ).
For the triiodide ion (), determine the total number of electron domains around the central iodine atom, the molecular geometry, and the observed bond angle.
Answer
Total valence electrons . Central has single bonds and lone pairs (steric number , ). All lone pairs occupy equatorial positions, giving a linear molecular geometry with an observed bond angle of exactly .
Sulfur tetrafluoride () has fluorine atoms bonded to sulfur. Determine its molecular geometry and state whether the axial-equatorial bond angle is greater than, equal to, or less than the ideal angle of .
Answer
Sulfur has valence electrons: bonding pairs equatorial lone pair (steric number , ). The molecular geometry is seesaw. Because lone pair-bonding pair repulsion exceeds bonding pair-bonding pair repulsion, the observed axial-equatorial angle is compressed to less than (approximately ).