Resources

A chemistry student attempts to calculate the pH\text{pH} of a solution prepared with 0.200 M NH4Cl0.200\text{ M } \text{NH}_4\text{Cl} (Ka=5.56×10−10K_a = 5.56 \times 10^{-10}) and 0.100 M NH30.100\text{ M } \text{NH}_3. The student mistakenly applies the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation using the ratio [conjugate acid][conjugate base]\frac{[\text{conjugate acid}]}{[\text{conjugate base}]} instead of the standard convention [conjugate base][conjugate acid]\frac{[\text{conjugate base}]}{[\text{conjugate acid}]}. Calculate: (a) the correct equilibrium pH\text{pH} of the buffer solution at 25∘C25^\circ\text{C}, and (b) the erroneous pH\text{pH} value resulting from this convention inversion trap.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Correct pH=8.954\text{Correct pH} = 8.954; (b) Erroneous pH=9.556\text{Erroneous pH} = 9.556

Steps

Part (a): Correct Equilibrium pH\text{pH}

  1. Identify the Buffer Components and Equilibrium Constant The buffer consists of a weak acid and its conjugate base:

    • Weak conjugate acid: NHX4X+\ce{NH4+}, with [NHX4X+]=0.200 M[\ce{NH4+}] = 0.200\text{ M}
    • Weak conjugate base: NHX3\ce{NH3}, with [NHX3]=0.100 M[\ce{NH3}] = 0.100\text{ M}
    • Acid dissociation constant: Ka=5.56×10−10K_a = 5.56 \times 10^{-10}
  2. Calculate pKa\text{p}K_a pKa=−log⁡10(Ka)=−log⁡10(5.56×10−10)≈9.255\text{p}K_a = -\log_{10}(K_a) = -\log_{10}(5.56 \times 10^{-10}) \approx 9.255
  3. Apply the Standard Henderson-Hasselbalch Equation The correct equation relates pH\text{pH} to pKa\text{p}K_a using the ratio of conjugate base to conjugate acid: pH=pKa+log⁡10([base][acid])\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a + \log_{10}\left(\frac{[\text{base}]}{[\text{acid}]}\right)

    Substitute the given concentrations into the formula: pH=9.255+log⁡10(0.1000.200)\text{pH} = 9.255 + \log_{10}\left(\frac{0.100}{0.200}\right) pH=9.255+log⁡10(0.500)=9.255−0.301=8.954\text{pH} = 9.255 + \log_{10}(0.500) = 9.255 - 0.301 = 8.954

    Physical check: Because the acidic component is present in higher concentration than the basic component ([NHX4X+]>[NHX3][\ce{NH4+}] > [\ce{NH3}]), the solution pH\text{pH} must be lower than the pKa\text{p}K_a (8.954<9.2558.954 < 9.255), confirming the result is chemically reasonable.


Part (b): Erroneous pH\text{pH} from Ratio Inversion

  1. Identify the Common Trap A frequent error is inverting the concentration ratio by placing the acid in the numerator: pHerr=pKa+log⁡10([acid][base])\text{pH}_{\text{err}} = \text{p}K_a + \log_{10}\left(\frac{[\text{acid}]}{[\text{base}]}\right)
  2. Calculate the Resulting Value pHerr=9.255+log⁡10(0.2000.100)\text{pH}_{\text{err}} = 9.255 + \log_{10}\left(\frac{0.200}{0.100}\right) pHerr=9.255+log⁡10(2.00)=9.255+0.301=9.556\text{pH}_{\text{err}} = 9.255 + \log_{10}(2.00) = 9.255 + 0.301 = 9.556

    Pitfall Note: Inverting the logarithmic ratio changes the sign of the logarithmic term (log⁡(a/b)=−log⁡(b/a)\log(a/b) = -\log(b/a)). When [acid]>[base][\text{acid}] > [\text{base}], the inverted formula incorrectly predicts a pH>pKa\text{pH} > \text{p}K_a, erroneously suggesting a more basic solution.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student subtracts the log term instead of adding it in the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation, incorrectly yielding a pH of 9.56 for part (a) and 8.95 for part (b).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    pKa=−log⁡(5.56×10−10)=9.255\text{p}K_a = -\log(5.56 \times 10^{-10}) = 9.255

  2. Step 2

    pH=pKa−log⁡([NH3]/[NH4+])  ⟹  pH=9.255−log⁡(0.100/0.200)=9.255−(−0.301)=9.56\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a - \log([\text{NH}_3]/[\text{NH}_4^+]) \implies \text{pH} = 9.255 - \log(0.100/0.200) = 9.255 - (-0.301) = 9.56

    Correct

    pH=pKa+log⁡([NH3][NH4+])=9.255+log⁡(0.500)=9.255−0.301=8.954\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a + \log\left(\frac{[\text{NH}_3]}{[\text{NH}_4^+]}\right) = 9.255 + \log(0.500) = 9.255 - 0.301 = 8.954

    The standard Henderson-Hasselbalch formula adds the logarithmic ratio of base to acid: pH=pKa+log⁡([base]/[acid])\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a + \log([\text{base}]/[\text{acid}]). By subtracting this term, you obtained a pH\text{pH} higher than pKa\text{p}K_a, even though the buffer has more acid (0.200 M0.200\text{ M}) than base (0.100 M0.100\text{ M}).

  3. Step 3

    pHerroneous=pKa−log⁡([NH4+][NH3])  ⟹  pHerroneous=9.255−log⁡(0.2000.100)=9.255−0.301=8.95\text{pH}_{\text{erroneous}} = \text{p}K_a - \log\left(\frac{[\text{NH}_4^+]}{[\text{NH}_3]}\right) \implies \text{pH}_{\text{erroneous}} = 9.255 - \log\left(\frac{0.200}{0.100}\right) = 9.255 - 0.301 = 8.95

    Correct

    pHerroneous=pKa+log⁡([NH4+][NH3])=9.255+log⁡(2.00)=9.255+0.301=9.556\text{pH}_{\text{erroneous}} = \text{p}K_a + \log\left(\frac{[\text{NH}_4^+]}{[\text{NH}_3]}\right) = 9.255 + \log(2.00) = 9.255 + 0.301 = 9.556

    The question specifies that the error is inverting the concentration ratio inside the standard formula: pKa+log⁡([acid]/[base])\text{p}K_a + \log([\text{acid}]/[\text{base}]). Because you also used a minus sign in front of the logarithm, you inadvertently cancelled out the inversion, yielding 8.958.95 instead of 9.5569.556.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified NHX4X+\ce{NH4+} as the conjugate acid and NHX3\ce{NH3} as the conjugate base.

You accurately computed the pKa\text{p}K_a value from KaK_a.

You handled the logarithmic arithmetic consistently.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula Sign Error

You wrote a minus sign before the log⁡([base]/[acid])\log([\text{base}]/[\text{acid}]) term instead of a plus sign.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the two equivalent forms of the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation: the standard form uses a plus sign with base over acid, pH=pKa+log⁡([base]/[acid])\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a + \log([\text{base}]/[\text{acid}]), while a minus sign only applies if the ratio is inverted, pH=pKa−log⁡([acid]/[base])\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a - \log([\text{acid}]/[\text{base}]).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Standard Henderson-Hasselbalch Sign
  • pH=pKa+log⁡([conjugate base][conjugate acid])\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a + \log\left(\frac{[\text{conjugate base}]}{[\text{conjugate acid}]}\right)

  • Always write a plus sign before log⁡\log when placing the base in the numerator.

Chemical Reasonableness Check
  • If [acid]>[base][\text{acid}] > [\text{base}], then pH<pKa\text{pH} < \text{p}K_a. If [base]>[acid][\text{base}] > [\text{acid}], then pH>pKa\text{pH} > \text{p}K_a.

  • Check your calculated pH\text{pH} against pKa\text{p}K_a: with more acid present, the pH\text{pH} must fall below pKa\text{p}K_a.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. For part (a), substitute into the standard equation: pH=9.255+log⁡(0.1000.200)=9.255+(−0.301)=8.954\text{pH} = 9.255 + \log\left(\frac{0.100}{0.200}\right) = 9.255 + (-0.301) = 8.954.

  2. For part (b), apply the question's stated ratio-inversion trap with the standard addition: pHerr=9.255+log⁡(0.2000.100)=9.255+0.301=9.556\text{pH}_{\text{err}} = 9.255 + \log\left(\frac{0.200}{0.100}\right) = 9.255 + 0.301 = 9.556.

Final answer

(a) Correct pH=8.954\text{Correct pH} = 8.954; (b) Erroneous pH=9.556\text{Erroneous pH} = 9.556

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the mnemonic 'Base on top, add the log' to keep the correct sign and quotient paired.

  • Perform a quick qualitative sanity check after calculating: verify whether the buffer should be more acidic or more basic than its pKa\text{p}K_a.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses Ka with Kb and calculates pOH instead of pH, leading to an incorrect pH of 5.05 for part (a) and 4.44 for part (b).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    pKa=−log⁡(5.56×10−10)=9.255\text{p}K_a = -\log(5.56 \times 10^{-10}) = 9.255

  2. Step 2

    pOH=9.255+log⁡(0.1000.200)=9.255−0.301=8.95  ⟹  pH=14.00−8.95=5.05\text{pOH} = 9.255 + \log\left(\frac{0.100}{0.200}\right) = 9.255 - 0.301 = 8.95 \implies \text{pH} = 14.00 - 8.95 = 5.05

    Correct

    pH=pKa+log⁡10([NHX3][NHX4X+])=9.255+log⁡10(0.1000.200)=8.954\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a + \log_{10}\left(\frac{[\ce{NH3}]}{[\ce{NH4+}]}\right) = 9.255 + \log_{10}\left(\frac{0.100}{0.200}\right) = 8.954

    You substituted the concentrations correctly, but the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation using pKa\text{p}K_a calculates pH\text{pH} directly, not pOH\text{pOH}. Subtracting your intermediate value from 14.0014.00 turned a basic buffer into an acidic solution.

  3. Step 3

    pOH=9.255+log⁡(0.2000.100)=9.255+0.301=9.56  ⟹  pHerroneous=14.00−9.56=4.44\text{pOH} = 9.255 + \log\left(\frac{0.200}{0.100}\right) = 9.255 + 0.301 = 9.56 \implies \text{pH}_{\text{erroneous}} = 14.00 - 9.56 = 4.44

    Correct

    pHerr=pKa+log⁡10([NHX4X+][NHX3])=9.255+log⁡10(0.2000.100)=9.556\text{pH}_{\text{err}} = \text{p}K_a + \log_{10}\left(\frac{[\ce{NH4+}]}{[\ce{NH3}]}\right) = 9.255 + \log_{10}\left(\frac{0.200}{0.100}\right) = 9.556

    You correctly set up the inverted ratio requested by the problem, but your earlier confusion of pH\text{pH} with pOH\text{pOH} carried forward when you subtracted 9.569.56 from 14.0014.00.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You calculated the correct pKa\text{p}K_a from the given KaK_a.

You evaluated the base-10 logarithmic terms accurately in both parts.

You followed the question instructions by inverting the acid-base ratio in part (b).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula output misidentification

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated the ammonia/ammonium buffer system with pOH\text{pOH} simply because ammonia is a weak base, overlooking that the standard Henderson-Hasselbalch equation pH=pKa+log⁡([base]/[acid])\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a + \log([\text{base}]/[\text{acid}]) directly outputs pH\text{pH} whenever pKa\text{p}K_a is used.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Match the constant to the variable
  • When using pKa\text{p}K_a, the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation directly outputs pH=pKa+log⁡([conjugate base]/[conjugate acid])\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a + \log([\text{conjugate base}]/[\text{conjugate acid}]). It outputs pOH\text{pOH} only if you use pKb\text{p}K_b with log⁡([conjugate acid]/[conjugate base])\log([\text{conjugate acid}]/[\text{conjugate base}]).

  • Check the equilibrium constant on the right-hand side before writing the variable on the left: pKa  ⟹  pH\text{p}K_a \implies \text{pH}.

Perform a physical sense-check
  • An equimolar NHX3/NHX4X+\ce{NH3}/\ce{NH4+} buffer has a pH\text{pH} near 9.259.25. Because [NHX4X+][\ce{NH4+}] exceeds [NHX3][\ce{NH3}], the solution must be slightly more acidic than pKa\text{p}K_a, yielding a pH\text{pH} around 8.958.95.

  • Always verify whether an ammonium buffer can reasonably have a strongly acidic pH\text{pH} around 5.055.05.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the standard Henderson-Hasselbalch equation: pH=pKa+log⁡10([NHX3][NHX4X+])\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a + \log_{10}\left(\frac{[\ce{NH3}]}{[\ce{NH4+}]}\right).

  2. Substitute the known values: pH=9.255+log⁡10(0.1000.200)=9.255−0.301=8.954\text{pH} = 9.255 + \log_{10}\left(\frac{0.100}{0.200}\right) = 9.255 - 0.301 = 8.954.

  3. Apply the inverted ratio for part (b): pHerr=9.255+log⁡10(0.2000.100)=9.255+0.301=9.556\text{pH}_{\text{err}} = 9.255 + \log_{10}\left(\frac{0.200}{0.100}\right) = 9.255 + 0.301 = 9.556.

Final answer

(a) Correct pH=8.954\text{Correct pH} = 8.954; (b) Erroneous pH=9.556\text{Erroneous pH} = 9.556

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize that pH=pKa+log⁡([base]/[acid])\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a + \log([\text{base}]/[\text{acid}]) always outputs pH\text{pH}, never pOH\text{pOH}.

  • Practice converting KbK_b to KaK_a via Kw=KaKbK_w = K_a K_b so you can comfortably solve basic buffers in terms of pH\text{pH} directly.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student swaps natural logarithm (ln) for base-10 logarithm (log) in the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation, obtaining a pH of 8.56 for part (a) and 9.95 for part (b).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    pKa=−log⁡(5.56×10−10)=9.255\text{p}K_a = -\log(5.56 \times 10^{-10}) = 9.255

  2. Step 2

    pH=pKa+ln⁡([NH3]/[NH4+])  ⟹  pH=9.255+ln⁡(0.1000.200)=9.255−0.693=8.56\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a + \ln([\text{NH}_3]/[\text{NH}_4^+]) \implies \text{pH} = 9.255 + \ln\left(\frac{0.100}{0.200}\right) = 9.255 - 0.693 = 8.56

    Correct

    pH=pKa+log⁡10([NH3][NH4+])=9.255+log⁡10(0.500)=9.255−0.301=8.954\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a + \log_{10}\left(\frac{[\text{NH}_3]}{[\text{NH}_4^+]}\right) = 9.255 + \log_{10}(0.500) = 9.255 - 0.301 = 8.954

    You substituted the correct species into the ratio, but you evaluated the term using the natural logarithm (ln⁡\ln) instead of the common base-10 logarithm (log⁡10\log_{10}).

  3. Step 3

    pHerroneous=pKa+ln⁡([NH4+]/[NH3])  ⟹  pHerroneous=9.255+ln⁡(0.2000.100)=9.255+0.693=9.95\text{pH}_{\text{erroneous}} = \text{p}K_a + \ln([\text{NH}_4^+]/[\text{NH}_3]) \implies \text{pH}_{\text{erroneous}} = 9.255 + \ln\left(\frac{0.200}{0.100}\right) = 9.255 + 0.693 = 9.95

    Correct

    pHerroneous=pKa+log⁡10([NH4+][NH3])=9.255+log⁡10(2.00)=9.255+0.301=9.556\text{pH}_{\text{erroneous}} = \text{p}K_a + \log_{10}\left(\frac{[\text{NH}_4^+]}{[\text{NH}_3]}\right) = 9.255 + \log_{10}(2.00) = 9.255 + 0.301 = 9.556

    You correctly inverted the concentration ratio to model the error required by part (b), but you again applied the natural logarithm (ln⁡\ln) instead of log⁡10\log_{10}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the pKa\text{p}K_a of ammonium as 9.2559.255 using the base-10 definition of the "p" operator.

You correctly identified the conjugate base (NHX3\ce{NH3}) and conjugate acid (NHX4X+\ce{NH4+}) components.

You set up the inverted ratio correctly as requested for part (b).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Logarithm Base Confusion (ln vs log10)

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You used the natural logarithm function (ln⁡\ln, base ee) instead of the decadic/common logarithm (log⁡10\log_{10}, base 10). Because the "p" scale in chemistry is defined as −log⁡10-\log_{10}, the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation strictly requires the base-10 logarithm.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Logarithm Base in Acid-Base Chemistry
  • The "p" operator represents −log⁡10-\log_{10}. Therefore, the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation is pH=pKa+log⁡10([base][acid])\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a + \log_{10}\left(\frac{[\text{base}]}{[\text{acid}]}\right).

  • Always press log⁡\log (base 10) on your calculator when working with pH\text{pH} and pKa\text{p}K_a, reserving ln⁡\ln for thermodynamic and kinetic formulas such as the Arrhenius equation or ΔG∘=−RTln⁡K\Delta G^\circ = -RT\ln K.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate part (a) using base-10 logarithm: pH=9.255+log⁡10(0.1000.200)=9.255+(−0.301)=8.954\text{pH} = 9.255 + \log_{10}\left(\frac{0.100}{0.200}\right) = 9.255 + (-0.301) = 8.954.

  2. Evaluate part (b) with the inverted ratio using base-10 logarithm: pHerroneous=9.255+log⁡10(0.2000.100)=9.255+0.301=9.556\text{pH}_{\text{erroneous}} = 9.255 + \log_{10}\left(\frac{0.200}{0.100}\right) = 9.255 + 0.301 = 9.556.

Final answer

(a) Correct pH=8.954\text{Correct pH} = 8.954; (b) Erroneous pH=9.556\text{Erroneous pH} = 9.556

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the mathematical derivation of the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation by taking −log⁡10-\log_{10} of both sides of Ka=[HX+][AX−]/[HA]K_a = [\ce{H+}][\ce{A-}]/[\ce{HA}].

  • Practice using the log⁡\log key on your calculator for pH\text{pH} problems to avoid accidentally hitting ln⁡\ln.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A buffer solution is prepared with 0.150 M CHX3COOH0.150\text{ M } \ce{CH3COOH} and 0.300 M CHX3COONa0.300\text{ M } \ce{CH3COONa}. Given Ka(CHX3COOH)=1.80×10−5K_a(\ce{CH3COOH}) = 1.80 \times 10^{-5} (pKa=4.745\text{p}K_a = 4.745), calculate the equilibrium pH\text{pH}.

Answer

pH=5.046\text{pH} = 5.046. Key steps: Identify [base]=0.300 M[\text{base}] = 0.300\text{ M} and [acid]=0.150 M[\text{acid}] = 0.150\text{ M}. Apply pH=4.745+log⁡(0.3000.150)=4.745+log⁡(2.00)=4.745+0.301=5.046\text{pH} = 4.745 + \log\left(\frac{0.300}{0.150}\right) = 4.745 + \log(2.00) = 4.745 + 0.301 = 5.046.

02

A student incorrectly calculates the pH\text{pH} of a buffer containing 0.050 M HNOX20.050\text{ M } \ce{HNO2} and 0.200 M KNOX20.200\text{ M } \ce{KNO2} (pKa=3.250\text{p}K_a = 3.250) using pH=pKa−log⁡([NOX2X−][HNOX2])\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a - \log\left(\frac{[\ce{NO2-}]}{[\ce{HNO2}]}\right). Determine (a) the correct pH\text{pH} and (b) the student's incorrect result.

Answer

(a) Correct pH=3.852\text{pH} = 3.852; (b) Incorrect pH=2.648\text{pH} = 2.648. Key steps: (a) pH=3.250+log⁡(0.2000.050)=3.250+log⁡(4)=3.250+0.602=3.852\text{pH} = 3.250 + \log\left(\frac{0.200}{0.050}\right) = 3.250 + \log(4) = 3.250 + 0.602 = 3.852. (b) Erroneous calculation: 3.250−0.602=2.6483.250 - 0.602 = 2.648.

03

You need to prepare a phosphate buffer at pH=7.400\text{pH} = 7.400 using HX2POX4X−\ce{H2PO4-} and HPOX4X2−\ce{HPO4^2-} (Ka2=6.20×10−8K_{a2} = 6.20 \times 10^{-8}, pKa2=7.208\text{p}K_{a2} = 7.208). Find the required molar ratio [HPOX4X2−][HX2POX4X−]\frac{[\ce{HPO4^2-}]}{[\ce{H2PO4-}]}.

Answer

Ratio =1.56= 1.56. Key steps: Use pH=pKa+log⁡([HPOX4X2−][HX2POX4X−])\text{pH} = \text{p}K_a + \log\left(\frac{[\ce{HPO4^2-}]}{[\ce{H2PO4-}]}\right). Rearrange: log⁡([HPOX4X2−][HX2POX4X−])=7.400−7.208=0.192\log\left(\frac{[\ce{HPO4^2-}]}{[\ce{H2PO4-}]}\right) = 7.400 - 7.208 = 0.192. Take the antilog: 100.192≈1.5610^{0.192} \approx 1.56.

Loading workspace…