Resources
Consider a standard zinc-copper galvanic cell at equilibrium at : (a) A student predicts: 'Because adding an inert salt like to the cathode compartment introduces spectator ions, the cell potential will remain unaffected.' If adding selectively precipitates as insoluble (), use Le Chatelier's principle and the Nernst equation to determine whether increases, decreases, or remains unchanged. (b) If the precipitation drops from to while remains , calculate the new operational cell potential at .
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Intuition fails because selectively removes the reactant via precipitation, shifting the equilibrium toward the reactants and increasing , thereby causing to decrease significantly; (b) .
Steps
Part (a): Qualitative Analysis using Le Chatelier's Principle and the Nernst Equation
- Chemical Effect of Adding : When solid sodium sulfide () dissolves in the cathode compartment, it dissociates completely into and : Although is indeed an inert spectator ion, the sulfide ion () is not inert. It reacts with dissolved ions to form an extremely insoluble black precipitate of copper(II) sulfide (): This precipitation drastically reduces the concentration of free in the cathode compartment.
- Le Chatelier's Principle: The overall cell reaction is: Since is a key reactant, removing it shifts the equilibrium to the left (toward the reactants). Consequently, the chemical driving force of the forward reaction decreases, which causes to decrease.
- Thermodynamic Basis via the Nernst Equation: The Nernst equation describes the cell potential under non-standard conditions at : The reaction quotient for the cell reaction (omitting pure solids) is: As plummets due to precipitation, increases dramatically. Because appears in the subtracted term, a larger results in a significantly lower .
Part (b): Calculating the New Operational Potential
-
Identify the Number of Electrons Transferred (): From the half-reactions:
- Oxidation:
- Reduction:
Therefore, .
- Calculate the Reaction Quotient (): Given and the new depleted concentration :
-
Substitute into the Nernst Equation:
Evaluating the logarithm and quotient:
Common Pitfall: Focusing solely on the spectator cation () while ignoring the reactivity of the anion () leads to the false conclusion that cell potential remains constant. Whenever salts are added to galvanic half-cells, always inspect for side reactions like precipitation or complexation that alter ion concentrations.
Typical errors
01 The student inverts the reaction quotient as Q = [Cu²⁺]/[Zn²⁺], mistakenly predicting that E_cell increases and obtaining an erroneously high potential.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Precipitating decreases . By Le Chatelier's principle, decreasing reactant concentration shifts the reaction left.
- Step 2
In the Nernst equation, . Because decreases, decreases, which subtracts a smaller number, so increases.
Correct. Because decreases, increases dramatically, subtracting a larger term and causing to decrease.
You placed reactants over products when writing . For the reaction , the reaction quotient must be .
- Step 3
E_{} = E^_{} - \log Q Q = = = 1.00 10^{-15}
CorrectQ = = = 1.00 10^{15}
You correctly set up the form of the Nernst equation with , but carried over the inverted expression for from the previous step.
- Step 4
\log Q = -15 E_{} = 1.10 - 0.0296 (-15) = 1.10 + 0.444 = 1.544_
Correct\log Q = 15 E_{} = 1.10 - 0.0296 15 = 1.10 - 0.444 = +0.656_
Your arithmetic was executed cleanly, but because was inverted, you added instead of subtracting it.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly applied Le Chatelier's principle to deduce that decreasing reactant concentration shifts the reaction to the left.
You selected the correct form of the Nernst equation at and identified .
You performed the logarithmic calculation and algebraic arithmetic correctly.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou wrote the reaction quotient as reactants over products rather than products over reactants, which inverted the sign of the logarithmic term in the Nernst equation.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Define Reaction Quotient Q
For any redox reaction, , omitting pure solids and liquids.
Always write the chemical equation first and verify that products are in the numerator and reactants are in the denominator.
- Reconcile Le Chatelier and Nernst
A shift toward the reactants means the chemical driving force drops, so must decrease.
Check that your qualitative Le Chatelier shift and your quantitative Nernst trend point in the exact same direction before finalizing your answer.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the balanced cell reaction: .
Set up the reaction quotient with products over reactants: .
Calculate with depleted : .
Evaluate the Nernst equation: .
(a) decreases; (b)
02 The student uses n = 1 instead of n = 2 in the Nernst equation, doubling the reduction term and obtaining 0.212 V.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Precipitation of lowers the reactant concentration . By Le Chatelier's principle, removing reactant shifts equilibrium left, so decreases. From , lower increases , which decreases .
- Step 2
For , .
Correctand
Each zinc atom is oxidized by losing electrons, and each copper(II) ion is reduced by gaining electrons, so the balanced cell reaction transfers moles of electrons, not .
- Step 3
- Step 4Correct
Your calculation followed directly from your substituted value of . Using the correct value yields .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that precipitation of decreases reactant concentration and shifts the equilibrium left.
You accurately connected the increase in the reaction quotient to a decrease in cell potential via the Nernst equation.
You calculated the reaction quotient and correctly.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou counted mole of electrons transferred per atom rather than writing out the oxidation and reduction half-reactions to count the total charge change.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the coefficient of the chemical species in the balanced equation (1 mole of reacting with 1 mole of ) with the number of moles of electrons transferred () during the redox process. Each mole of loses 2 electrons to form , making .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Separate into half-reactions to identify $n$
In the Nernst equation, is the total moles of electrons transferred in the balanced redox equation.
Always write out the balanced oxidation half-reaction () and reduction half-reaction () and read directly from the electron coefficient.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the balanced half-reactions: and , which gives .
Substitute and into the Nernst equation: .
Compute the potential change: .
03 The student misapplies the sign in the Nernst equation by writing a plus sign instead of a minus sign, incorrectly concluding that E_cell increases to 1.544 V.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Adding precipitates , reducing . Removing a reactant shifts the system to the left according to Le Chatelier's principle.
- Step 2
Using with , as drops, increases. Since the log term is added, increases.
Correct. As drops, increases, and subtracting a larger positive term causes to decrease.
The standard Nernst equation at has a negative sign in front of the logarithmic term: . Because increases, the subtracted term increases, which makes decrease.
- Step 3
,
- Step 4Correct
Your arithmetic was accurate, but your final numerical answer was affected by the sign error in the Nernst equation introduced in Step 2.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou recognized that sulfide ions selectively precipitate copper(II) ions, drastically lowering .
You correctly used Le Chatelier's principle to deduce that removing a reactant shifts the equilibrium toward the reactants.
You correctly formulated the reaction quotient and computed its logarithm as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou recalled the Nernst equation with an incorrect positive sign between and the concentration term instead of a negative sign (). This led to a conclusion that contradicted your own Le Chatelier analysis, which showed the system shifting to the left.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Thermodynamic Connection: $\Delta G = -nFE$
From , dividing both sides by yields .
Whenever you write the Nernst equation in terms of , always verify that the sign is minus: .
- Cross-Check with Le Chatelier's Principle
A shift toward reactants reduces the electrochemical driving force ( decreases). A shift toward products increases .
If your Le Chatelier analysis indicates a shift to the left, ensure your Nernst equation yields .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the correct form of the Nernst equation at : .
Substitute , , and : .
Compute the subtracted term: .
Subtract from the standard potential: .
(a) decreases; (b)
Lock it in
How is the reaction quotient defined for any general equilibrium or redox reaction ?
. Memory cue: It is always 'Products over Reactants' (P over R).
Similar question
For the galvanic cell with , write the reaction quotient and state whether increases or decreases if is lowered by precipitation.
Answer
. Lowering the product decreases , shifting the equilibrium forward and causing to increase.
A voltaic cell operates on at with . If the solution pH is raised from to while and , calculate the new cell potential .
Answer
. At , . . Using Nernst (): .
In a Daniell cell (), ammonia is added to the cathode to form , reducing free to while . Calculate at .
Answer
. Products over reactants yields . Then .