Resources
Consider the homologous series of straight-chain aliphatic primary alcohols, . As the parameter approaches large values (e.g., to ), the physical properties transition from polar-solvent behavior to alkane-like hydrocarbon behavior. (a) For 1-eicosanol (, formula ), calculate the mass percentage of the hydrophilic hydroxyl functional group (, formula mass ) relative to the total molecular mass (). (b) Explain how the asymptotic dominance of the hydrophobic hydrocarbon chain over the single polar functional group governs the water solubility and physical state of 1-eicosanol compared to methanol ().
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; (b) Methanol is completely miscible with water because the hydrophilic group constitutes of its mass and favorable hydrogen bonding dominates; in 1-eicosanol, the nonpolar aliphatic chain accounts for of the molecular weight, meaning hydrophobic disruption of the water hydrogen-bonding network vastly exceeds the hydration energy of the single group, rendering 1-eicosanol a water-insoluble, waxy crystalline solid dominated by extensive intermolecular London dispersion forces.
Steps
Part (a): Calculating the Mass Percentage of the Hydroxyl Group
-
Identify the relevant masses:
- Molar mass of the hydroxyl functional group ():
- Total molar mass of 1-eicosanol ():
- Compute the mass percent:
Part (b): Impact of Chain Length on Solubility and Physical State
-
Solubility in Water:
- Methanol (, ): The polar, hydrophilic group makes up more than half of the molecular mass: The strong, favorable hydrogen bonding formed between the group and water molecules easily compensates for any minor disruption of water-water interactions caused by the tiny methyl group, rendering methanol completely miscible in water.
- 1-Eicosanol (, ): The nonpolar aliphatic tail constitutes approximately of the total mass. Inserting this vast, nonpolar hydrocarbon chain into water requires breaking a large network of strong water-water hydrogen bonds without forming sufficiently stabilizing intermolecular attractions in return (hydrophobic effect). The small hydration enthalpy of the single terminal group cannot compensate for this large unfavorable free energy change, making 1-eicosanol practically insoluble in water.
-
Physical State at Room Temperature:
- Methanol: With a tiny nonpolar surface area, its intermolecular London dispersion forces are weak. Although hydrogen bonding keeps it in the condensed phase, it remains a volatile liquid (boiling point , melting point ).
- 1-Eicosanol: The extensive 20-carbon saturated chain provides a very large surface area for additive intermolecular London dispersion forces. These cumulative dispersion forces between closely packed, aligned aliphatic chains are strong enough to hold the molecules in a rigid lattice, making 1-eicosanol a waxy, crystalline solid at room temperature (melting point ).
Typical errors
01 The student inverts the numerator and denominator when calculating the mass percentage.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
$ % = (298.55 / 17.01) 100% % = 1755%$$
Correct$ % = 100% 5.70%$$
You divided the total molar mass by the mass of the hydroxyl group rather than dividing the part by the whole. The mass percentage of a constituent functional group cannot exceed .
- Step 2
Methanol has a high proportion of polar , so it forms hydrogen bonds with water and is fully miscible as a liquid. 1-Eicosanol is dominated by the long nonpolar chain, making it insoluble in water, and strong London dispersion forces make it a solid.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly explained how dominant hydrogen bonding makes methanol miscible and liquid.
You accurately identified that extensive London dispersion forces across the 20-carbon chain make 1-eicosanol a solid and water-insoluble.
You recognized that calculating a percentage requires multiplying a ratio of molar masses by .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou placed the total molecular mass in the numerator and the functional group mass in the denominator instead of dividing the part by the whole.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisLosing track of the fundamental definition of mass percentage as , leading to a value well above .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Part vs. Whole Sanity Check
For any single component of a compound, .
Always verify that the numerator is the constituent part and that your final percentage is between and .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet up the fraction with the functional group mass () in the numerator and the total mass () in the denominator: .
Compute the quotient: .
(a) ; (b) Methanol is miscible and liquid due to favorable hydrogen bonding with water; 1-eicosanol is an insoluble solid because the extensive hydrophobic chain disrupts water's hydrogen-bond network and exhibits strong intermolecular London dispersion forces.
02 The student calculates the percentage of the hydrocarbon tail instead of the hydroxyl group by subtracting the -OH mass from the total.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You calculated the mass percentage of the alkyl chain () rather than the mass percentage of the hydroxyl functional group (, ) requested in part (a).
- Step 2
Methanol has a prominent polar -OH group that readily hydrogen bonds with water, making it water-soluble and liquid. For 1-eicosanol, the nonpolar chain dominates, preventing solubility in polar water, and large dispersion forces between chains make it a solid.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou clearly articulated how hydrogen bonding drives the water solubility and liquid state of methanol.
You correctly linked the extensive hydrocarbon chain of 1-eicosanol to nonpolar insolubility in water and solid state due to dispersion forces.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou solved for the complementary portion of the molecule (the hydrocarbon tail) rather than the specified functional group ().
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou focused on finding the mass of the hydrocarbon tail that was discussed in the introductory text, mistakenly putting that value in the numerator instead of the mass of the group specified by the question.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Check the Target Moiety
The numerator in a mass percent calculation must strictly represent the specific atom, ion, or functional group requested.
Highlight the exact species named in the prompt (here, the group, ) before writing the ratio.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the target moiety mass: .
Divide by total molar mass: .
Compute the final percentage: .
(a) ; (b) Methanol is water-soluble and liquid due to dominant polar hydrogen bonding, whereas 1-eicosanol is water-insoluble and a waxy solid due to the dominant nonpolar chain and additive dispersion forces.
03 The student attributes the solid state of 1-eicosanol to stronger hydrogen bonding rather than dispersion forces along the hydrocarbon tail.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
Methanol is miscible in water due to hydrogen bonding, whereas 1-eicosanol is insoluble because the large nonpolar chain cannot interact favorably with water.
- Step 3
1-Eicosanol is a solid because having a much larger molecule allows it to form more hydrogen bonds per molecule than methanol.
Correct1-Eicosanol is a solid at room temperature because its extensive 20-carbon nonpolar tail provides a very large surface area for strong, cumulative intermolecular London dispersion forces, whereas each molecule still possesses only one group for hydrogen bonding.
Both 1-eicosanol and methanol are primary mono-alcohols with exactly one group, so 1-eicosanol cannot form more hydrogen bonds per molecule. Its solid state at room temperature is driven by cumulative London dispersion forces between long, closely packed hydrocarbon chains.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the mass percentage of the functional group in 1-eicosanol.
You clearly explained why methanol is water-soluble while 1-eicosanol is water-insoluble based on nonpolar chain dominance.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that a larger molecular size increases the capacity for hydrogen bonding, overlooking that both molecules contain only a single hydroxyl functional group and that molecular size primarily scales London dispersion forces.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identify Functional Group Stoichiometry
In a homologous series of mono-alcohols (), every molecule has exactly one group regardless of chain length.
Check how many hydrogen-bond donor and acceptor groups are present per molecule before attributing property differences to hydrogen bonding.
- Identify the Force Scaling with Chain Length
As hydrocarbon chain length and surface area increase, additive London dispersion forces scale dramatically, raising melting and boiling points.
Attribute phase changes along an aliphatic series to cumulative dispersion forces between nonpolar tails, not to hydrogen bonding.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationNote that both methanol () and 1-eicosanol () possess exactly one group, meaning their capacity for hydrogen bonding per molecule is identical.
Consider the 20-carbon aliphatic chain: it provides a very large surface area for additive London dispersion (van der Waals) forces.
Conclude that these extensive dispersion forces allow the long, flexible chains to pack tightly into a solid lattice at room temperature, whereas methanol's tiny nonpolar surface area yields only weak dispersion forces, keeping it a liquid.
(a) ; (b) Methanol is miscible with water because hydrogen bonding dominates its small mass, whereas 1-eicosanol is insoluble due to the hydrophobic disruption caused by its vast nonpolar tail ( of mass). 1-Eicosanol is a solid at room temperature because extensive, additive intermolecular London dispersion forces along the 20-carbon chain hold the molecules tightly together, whereas both molecules have only one group for hydrogen bonding.
Lock it in
What is the general formula for the mass percentage of a specific component or functional group in a molecule?
. Always place the part over the whole.
Similar question
Calculate the mass percentage of the hydroxyl group (, ) in ethanol (, molar mass ). Express your answer to three significant figures.
Answer
.
1-Octanol (, molar mass ) has a hydroxyl mass percent of . Explain why 1-octanol is virtually insoluble in water whereas 1-propanol (, hydroxyl mass percent ) is completely miscible.
Answer
In 1-propanol, the short 3-carbon chain causes minimal disruption to water's hydrogen-bonding network, so favorable hydrogen bonding from the group dominates and confers miscibility. In 1-octanol, the nonpolar 8-carbon chain accounts for nearly of the molecular mass; the energy penalty of disrupting water-water hydrogen bonds greatly exceeds the weak hydration energy of a single group, causing phase separation.
Ethylene glycol (, molar mass ) has two groups (). Calculate the total mass percentage of hydroxyl groups in ethylene glycol and predict whether it has a higher or lower boiling point than 1-butanol (, molar mass ).
Answer
. Ethylene glycol has a significantly higher boiling point ( vs. for 1-butanol) because its two hydroxyl groups allow extensive intermolecular hydrogen bonding networks in multiple directions despite having a lower total molar mass.