Resources
Explore covalent electron sharing at the asymptotic internuclear limit: As two neutral hydrogen atoms in their ground state () approach from an infinite separation distance () to their equilibrium bond distance (), their total potential energy curve changes dramatically. (a) Describe the three competing electrostatic interaction terms that comprise the electronic potential energy as decreases from infinity. (b) Explain why the potential energy passes through a minimum at rather than continuing to decrease toward . (c) According to the quantum mechanical valence bond model, what fundamental requirement regarding electron spin (Pauli exclusion principle) must be satisfied for constructive electron sharing (bonding orbital) to occur rather than destructive repulsion (antibonding state) as ?
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) The three electrostatic interactions are: (1) nucleus-electron attraction between each nucleus and the other atom's electron (stabilizing, negative potential energy), (2) electron-electron repulsion between the two approaching electrons (destabilizing, positive potential energy), and (3) nucleus-nucleus repulsion between the two positive proton cores (destabilizing, positive potential energy). (b) At large , attraction dominates as the electrons are shared in the region between both positively charged nuclei, lowering the potential energy. At , net attractive forces balance net repulsive forces, establishing an energy minimum (). For , internuclear proton-proton repulsion and electron kinetic energy compression increase asymptotically toward . (c) The two shared electrons must have antiparallel (opposite) spins ( and ); opposite spins permit symmetric spatial wave function overlap with constructive interference and high electron density between the nuclei, satisfying the Pauli exclusion principle.
Steps
(a) Electrostatic Interaction Terms Governing Potential Energy
When two isolated hydrogen atoms approach one another, their interaction is governed by Coulomb's law. The total electronic potential energy consists of three competing electrostatic terms:
- Electron-Nucleus Attraction (Stabilizing):
Each positively charged nucleus attracts the electron belonging to the other atom (in addition to its own electron). This brings the negatively charged electron cloud between the positive nuclei, resulting in an attractive force and a negative contribution to the potential energy (). - Electron-Electron Repulsion (Destabilizing):
As the electron clouds begin to overlap in the internuclear region, like charges repel each other, contributing a positive potential energy term (). - Nucleus-Nucleus Repulsion (Destabilizing):
The two positively charged protons repel each other with an electrostatic energy proportional to , contributing a positive potential energy term ().
(b) Origin of the Potential Energy Minimum at
A stable covalent bond forms at the equilibrium internuclear distance because of the distance-dependent interplay between attraction and repulsion:
- At large separations ():
As the atoms approach from infinity (), the electron density shifts into the region between both nuclei. In this internuclear zone, the electrons simultaneously experience strong electrostatic attraction to both nuclei, screening the two nuclei from each other. Because the attractive term increases more rapidly in magnitude than the repulsive terms at moderate distances, the net potential energy decreases (). - At equilibrium ():
The derivative of the potential energy with respect to distance is zero: Here, the attractive forces pull inward with equal magnitude to the repulsive forces pushing outward. This represents the lowest potential energy state, corresponding to the experimental bond dissociation energy of (). - At short distances ():
If the atoms are forced closer together than , the shielding provided by the shared electron density is insufficient to mask the bare protons. The nuclear-nuclear repulsion term () escalates drastically. Simultaneously, quantum mechanical confinement (compression of electron kinetic energy) increases sharply. Consequently, total energy rises steeply toward , preventing nuclear collapse.
(c) Spin Requirement and the Pauli Exclusion Principle
According to the Pauli exclusion principle, no two electrons in a system can possess the exact same set of four quantum numbers:
- Antiparallel (Opposite) Spins ( and ):
For the two electrons to occupy the same spatial bonding region between the two nuclei, their spins must pair with opposite signs (antiparallel spin singlet state, ). This allows the total spatial wave function to be symmetric (), leading to constructive interference and an accumulation of electron density directly between the nuclei. - Common Pitfall:
If two electrons have parallel spins ( and ), the Pauli principle requires an antisymmetric spatial wave function (). This forces a nodal plane of zero electron density directly between the nuclei, creating a repulsive antibonding state () with no potential energy minimum.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the net electrostatic interaction terms by omitting electron-electron repulsion and treating the atom pair as only having one attractive and one repulsive force.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Electron-nucleus attraction between each electron and nucleus ⟹ Nucleus-nucleus repulsion between the two positive protons ⟹ Net electrostatic interaction is balanced by these two competing forces
CorrectThree distinct electrostatic interactions: (1) electron-nucleus attraction (stabilizing, negative potential energy), (2) electron-electron repulsion (destabilizing, positive potential energy), and (3) nucleus-nucleus repulsion (destabilizing, positive potential energy).
You identified electron-nucleus attraction and nucleus-nucleus repulsion, but you omitted electron-electron repulsion. In a two-electron, two-nucleus system, like charges repel one another, so the two electrons also repel each other.
- Step 2
At attraction reaches maximum strength ⟹ For the two positive nuclei repel each other strongly as ⟹ The strong nuclear repulsion causes potential energy to rise sharply
CorrectAt , the net attractive forces balance the net repulsive forces (both nuclear-nuclear and electron-electron) such that , establishing a potential energy minimum. For , nuclear-nuclear repulsion and electron kinetic energy compression increase steeply toward .
Attraction does not peak or reach a maximum strength at ; electrostatic attraction actually continues to strengthen at shorter distances. Instead, is the equilibrium distance where the inward attractive forces exactly balance all outward repulsive forces.
- Step 3
Electrons must have opposite (antiparallel) spins to pair up ⟹ Pauli exclusion principle requires and in the shared orbital
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified electron-nucleus attraction and proton-proton repulsion.
You recognized that internuclear repulsion rises steeply at short distances ().
You accurately stated that the Pauli exclusion principle requires opposite () spins for pairing in a bonding orbital.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated the approaching hydrogen atoms as containing only one attractive and one repulsive force, overlooking the repulsion between the two approaching electrons.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conceptualized bond equilibrium as a simple two-body contest between nuclear repulsion and electron-nucleus attraction, rather than accounting for all pairwise Coulomb interactions among four charged particles (two protons and two electrons).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Count all pairwise charges
For charged particles, there are pairwise electrostatic interactions.
With 2 nuclei () and 2 electrons (), count all total terms: 4 attractive electron-nucleus interactions, 1 repulsive nucleus-nucleus interaction, and 1 repulsive electron-electron interaction.
- Equilibrium condition
A potential energy minimum occurs where net force is zero: .
Describe equilibrium as the point where total attractive forces balance total repulsive forces, not where attraction reaches a peak.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationList all electrostatic terms: electron-nucleus attraction (stabilizing), nucleus-nucleus repulsion (destabilizing), and electron-electron repulsion (destabilizing).
Express the equilibrium state: at , the sum of attractive forces equals the sum of repulsive forces (), yielding the minimum total potential energy.
Note short-distance behavior: for , internuclear repulsion and electron kinetic compression dominate, causing to rise steeply.
(a) Three terms: electron-nucleus attraction, nucleus-nucleus repulsion, and electron-electron repulsion. (b) A minimum occurs at because net attraction balances net repulsion (); compression past causes steep repulsion. (c) Antiparallel spins () allow constructive interference under the Pauli exclusion principle.
02 The student believes that identical parallel electron spins maximize constructive interference or symmetric bonding, confusing triplet and singlet spin requirements under the Pauli exclusion principle.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Electron - nucleus attraction ⟹ - Nucleus - nucleus repulsion ⟹ - Electron - electron repulsion
- Step 2
Electron-nucleus attraction lowers energy until ⟹ Below , nuclear and electronic repulsions increase steeply as ⟹ Repulsion dominates at very short internuclear distances
- Step 3
Electrons must have parallel spins with same magnetic spin quantum number ⟹ Parallel spins allow constructive quantum overlap to form the bond
CorrectElectrons must possess antiparallel (opposite) spins ( and ).
You wrote that electrons require parallel spins with the same magnetic spin quantum number. According to the Pauli exclusion principle, the total electronic wave function must be antisymmetric. Because a bonding orbital requires a symmetric spatial wave function (constructive overlap between nuclei), the spin wave function must be antisymmetric, which requires antiparallel (opposite) spins (). Parallel spins force an antisymmetric spatial state with a nodal plane between the nuclei, creating a repulsive antibonding state.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified all three electrostatic interactions that dictate covalent bond energetics.
You explained the balance of attractive and repulsive forces that produces the equilibrium bond distance .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the spin symmetry requirements of the Pauli exclusion principle, assuming that identical (parallel) spins promote constructive spatial interference rather than realizing that sharing a symmetric spatial orbital requires an antisymmetric, paired (antiparallel) spin state.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Pauli Principle & Total Wave Function Symmetry
Electrons are fermions; their total wave function must be antisymmetric with respect to electron exchange.
Check whether the spatial state is symmetric (bonding) or antisymmetric (antibonding); choose the opposite spin symmetry so the overall product remains antisymmetric.
- Spin Pairing in a Single Molecular Orbital
Two electrons occupying the exact same spatial orbital must have opposite spin quantum numbers ( and , singlet state).
Pair bonding electrons with antiparallel spins rather than parallel spins.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationApply the Pauli exclusion principle to the two-electron valence bond wave function: must be antisymmetric.
For constructive interference that builds electron density between the nuclei, the spatial wave function must be symmetric: .
To maintain total antisymmetry, the spin component must be antisymmetric (a singlet state): .
Conclude that the two electrons must possess antiparallel (opposite) spins with and .
(c) The shared electrons must have antiparallel (opposite) spins ( and ); opposite spins allow a symmetric spatial orbital with constructive interference between the nuclei while satisfying the Pauli exclusion principle.
03 The student attributes the steep energy increase at R < R_0 entirely to electron-electron repulsion, wrongly claiming the nuclei are shielded and do not repel.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Electron-nucleus attraction ⟹ Nucleus-nucleus repulsion ⟹ Electron-electron repulsion
- Step 2
Attraction dominates at intermediate distances reaching minimum energy at ⟹ At the electrons are squeezed together into a very small volume ⟹ Electron-electron repulsion increases to infinity while nuclei remain shielded
CorrectAt , inward attraction balances outward repulsion. For , the electron cloud can no longer shield the nuclei, so nucleus-nucleus (proton-proton) Coulomb repulsion increases steeply as alongside kinetic energy confinement.
While you correctly noted that attractive forces dominate at intermediate distances to produce a minimum, your explanation for is incorrect. At distances shorter than the equilibrium bond length, the electron cloud cannot shield the two positively charged protons from each other; bare nucleus-nucleus Coulomb repulsion and electron kinetic energy compression dominate the steep rise toward .
- Step 3
Electrons must have paired opposite spins ⟹ Antiparallel spins satisfy the Pauli exclusion principle
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the three fundamental electrostatic forces acting between two approaching hydrogen atoms.
You recognized that intermediate-distance attraction produces the energy well at .
You correctly identified that electrons must possess antiparallel spins to form a stable covalent bond under the Pauli exclusion principle.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that the shared electron cloud continues to shield the two atomic nuclei even at internuclear separations smaller than the bond length, overlooking that nuclear-nuclear repulsion diverges strongly as internuclear distance approaches zero.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Nuclear Shielding Breakdown
At distances , electron density is pushed outward away from the internuclear axis, leaving the positive nuclei unshielded.
Attribute the steep repulsive wall primarily to direct nucleus-nucleus electrostatic repulsion () and kinetic confinement rather than electron-electron repulsion alone.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecall that at , net attractive electrostatic forces are balanced by repulsive forces ().
Recognize that as , the internuclear separation between the two positively charged protons approaches zero.
Observe that Coulombic nuclear repulsion scales as , which diverges toward because the finite electron cloud cannot stay exclusively between the collapsing nuclei.
Conclude that the steep potential energy wall at is dominated by direct internuclear proton-proton repulsion and quantum kinetic compression.
(a) Three terms: electron-nucleus attraction, electron-electron repulsion, and nucleus-nucleus repulsion. (b) Energy reaches a minimum at because attractive forces balance repulsive forces; at , shielding breaks down and direct nucleus-nucleus repulsion (along with kinetic compression) rises asymptotically toward . (c) The electrons must have antiparallel (opposite) spins () to form a symmetric spatial bonding state obeying the Pauli exclusion principle.
Lock it in
What are the three distinct electrostatic interaction terms in an approaching system?
- Electron-nucleus attraction (stabilizing, negative ).
- Electron-electron repulsion (destabilizing, positive ).
- Nucleus-nucleus repulsion (destabilizing, positive ).
Similar question
Consider the helium hydride molecular ion . How many total pairwise electrostatic interactions exist among its two nuclei and two electrons? Classify each as attractive or repulsive.
Answer
Total interactions = .
- Attractive (4 terms): each of the two electrons attracted to the helium nucleus () and to the hydrogen proton ().
- Repulsive (2 terms): electron-electron repulsion (1 term) and helium-proton nucleus-nucleus repulsion (1 term).
Explain mathematically why the bond length of a diatomic molecule is located at the minimum of the potential energy curve rather than where the attractive force is greatest.
Answer
The force between the two nuclei is given by . At equilibrium, the net force must be zero (), which corresponds directly to the minimum of where . Attraction alone does not determine equilibrium; stability requires that net attraction and net repulsion cancel each other out.
Why do two hydrogen atoms with parallel electron spins ( for both) fail to form a stable covalent bond when they approach one another?
Answer
By the Pauli exclusion principle, identical spins require an antisymmetric spatial wave function. This creates a nodal plane (zero electron density) between the nuclei, preventing electron sharing and resulting in purely repulsive potential energy at all distances (an antibonding state with no energy minimum).