Resources
A student attempts to construct the ground-state electron configuration of the cobalt(II) ion (, ) by first writing neutral cobalt as , and then removing two electrons from the subshell to yield , arguing that half-filled subshells provide maximum thermodynamic stability. Explain the flaw in this reasoning based on shielding and effective nuclear charge during ionization, provide the correct ground-state configuration for , and state whether is paramagnetic or diamagnetic, including the number of unpaired electrons.
Answer and steps
Final answer
Flaw: When transition metals form cations, electrons in orbitals with the highest principal quantum number () are lost before electrons because electrons have higher average spatial radial distribution and experience lower effective nuclear charge upon filling ; Correct configuration: ; Magnetic property: Paramagnetic with unpaired electrons.
Steps
Identifying the Flaw in the Student's Reasoning
The student assumed that electrons are removed in the reverse order of the Aufbau filling scheme ( before ) to achieve the special stability of a half-filled subshell (). However, ionization order does not simply invert Aufbau filling order:
- Spatial Distribution and Distance: Electrons in the orbital have a principal quantum number of , meaning their radial probability density extends significantly farther from the nucleus than that of electrons ().
- Shielding and Effective Nuclear Charge (): As the subshell fills across the first-row transition series, the inner electrons shield the outer electrons from the full nuclear charge. Consequently, the electrons experience a lower effective nuclear charge () than the electrons.
- Energy Inversion upon Occupation: Once the subshell begins filling, the orbitals drop lower in energy than the orbital. Therefore, removing electrons from the outermost, highest-energy subshell requires less energy than removing electrons from the lower-energy subshell.
When first-row transition metals ionize, electrons are always removed from the outermost valence shell with the highest principal quantum number () before any () electrons are lost.
Writing the Correct Ground-State Configuration for
- Neutral Cobalt (, ):
- Ionization to Cobalt(II) (): Remove the two outermost electrons from the subshell:
Magnetic Properties and Unpaired Electrons
To determine the magnetic properties, distribute the valence electrons across the five degenerate orbitals according to Hund's rule and the Pauli exclusion principle:
- Place one spin-up electron into each of the five orbitals: electrons total ( singly occupied orbitals).
- Pair the remaining electrons with opposite spins in the first two orbitals:
- Orbital 1: (paired)
- Orbital 2: (paired)
- Orbital 3: (unpaired)
- Orbital 4: (unpaired)
- Orbital 5: (unpaired)
- Number of unpaired electrons:
- Magnetic property: Because it possesses unpaired electrons, is paramagnetic (attracted to an external magnetic field).
Typical errors
01 The student accepts the incorrect configuration [Ar] 4s² 3d⁵ by prioritizing half-filled d subshell stability over the principle that 4s electrons are removed first during ionization of transition metals.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The student's reasoning is correct because a half-filled subshell minimizes electron-electron repulsion and maximizes exchange energy, making it more stable than losing electrons.
CorrectThe reasoning is flawed because once the subshell begins filling, orbitals drop lower in energy than the orbital. The electrons have a higher principal quantum number (), extend farther radially from the nucleus, and are shielded by inner electrons, experiencing a lower . Therefore, the two electrons are lost first.
You agreed with the prompt's hypothetical student instead of identifying the flaw. Although half-filled subshells offer exchange stabilization in neutral ground states, transition metal cations ionize from the outermost shell () first because electrons experience greater shielding and lower effective nuclear charge than electrons.
- Step 2Correct
Because you removed electrons from the subshell rather than the outermost subshell, your resulting electron configuration retained the electrons instead of losing them.
- Step 3
Paramagnetic, with unpaired electrons.
CorrectParamagnetic, with unpaired electrons.
You correctly deduced that five electrons would yield unpaired spins, but applying Hund's rule to the correct configuration gives unpaired electrons (two doubly occupied orbitals and three singly occupied orbitals).
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou remembered that half-filled subshells provide exchange energy stabilization in neutral atoms.
You correctly identified that unpaired electrons impart paramagnetism to an ion.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou prioritized half-filled subshell stability over the transition metal ionization rule: electrons with the highest principal quantum number (, the subshell) are always removed before electrons because electrons experience greater radial extension, lower , and higher orbital energy in occupied transition metal species.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- First-In, First-Out for $4s$ in Transition Metals
During transition metal ionization, electrons with the highest principal quantum number are lost first: remove electrons before removing any electrons.
Always write the neutral configuration first (), then subtract electrons starting entirely from the orbital before touching the orbital.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify that neutral cobalt (, ) has the ground-state configuration .
To form , remove the electrons from the outermost valence shell with () because they experience greater shielding and lower than the inner electrons.
Write the resulting cation ground-state configuration: .
Apply Hund's rule to distribute electrons across the five degenerate orbitals: three orbitals hold electron each and two orbitals hold paired electrons, leaving unpaired electrons.
Conclude that because unpaired electrons remain, is paramagnetic.
Flaw: Ionization removes electrons from orbitals of highest principal quantum number () first due to lower and greater shielding by ; Correct configuration: ; Magnetic property: Paramagnetic with unpaired electrons.
02 The student correctly removes 4s electrons to obtain a 3d⁷ ion, but pairs electrons without following Hund's rule, concluding that the ion has 1 unpaired electron.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Electrons in the orbital experience greater shielding from the inner electrons and have a higher principal quantum number, so they feel a lower effective nuclear charge and are removed first before electrons.
- Step 2
- Step 3
In , three pairs of electrons form in the first three orbitals and one electron remains in the fourth orbital. Paramagnetic, with 1 unpaired electron.
CorrectPlace one electron into each of the five degenerate orbitals before pairing: gives unpaired electrons, making paramagnetic.
According to Hund's rule, electrons must singly occupy all five degenerate orbitals with parallel spins before any pairing occurs. Distributing electrons yields two doubly occupied orbitals and three singly occupied orbitals, giving unpaired electrons rather than .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that electrons are lost before electrons due to shielding and lower effective nuclear charge.
You accurately determined the ground-state electron configuration of as .
You correctly concluded that the species is paramagnetic because it has unpaired electrons.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou paired electrons in the first three orbitals before singly occupying all five degenerate orbitals, leaving one orbital empty.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisMisunderstanding how electrons occupy degenerate orbitals under Hund's rule: pairing causes inter-electronic repulsion, so the lowest-energy state requires maximizing total spin by singly occupying each equal-energy orbital before pairing begins.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Hund's Rule of Maximum Multiplicity
For degenerate orbitals, the lowest-energy state has the maximum number of unpaired electrons with parallel spins. Always put one electron in each orbital of a subshell before pairing.
Draw all five orbital boxes for any subshell. Place single up-arrows () in all five boxes first, then add down-arrows () to pair up remaining electrons.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecall that a subshell contains degenerate orbitals: .
Apply Hund's rule: place one spin-up electron in each of the orbitals first ( electrons used).
Pair the remaining electrons with opposite spin in the first two orbitals.
Count the resulting distribution: two orbitals are paired (), and three orbitals remain singly occupied ().
Paramagnetic with unpaired electrons.
03 The student removes one electron from 4s and one from 3d to yield [Ar] 4s¹ 3d⁶, failing to recognize that all valence 4s electrons are lost before 3d electrons.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Ionization removes one outermost 4s electron first due to lower effective nuclear charge, but the second electron comes from 3d to balance orbital occupancy.
CorrectWhen transition metals ionize, all electrons in the highest principal quantum level () are removed before electrons because electrons have a larger average radial distribution and experience greater shielding (lower ) from the occupied subshell.
You correctly recognized that electrons have lower effective nuclear charge, but both electrons must be fully emptied before removing any electrons. There is no principle of balancing occupancy between and during ionization.
- Step 2Correct
Because both valence electrons are lost from the orbital during the formation of , the configuration is rather than .
- Step 3
Paramagnetic, with 5 unpaired electrons.
CorrectParamagnetic, with 3 unpaired electrons.
You correctly determined that the ion is paramagnetic, but for the true ground state , the five orbitals contain two paired pairs and three singly occupied orbitals, giving 3 unpaired electrons.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that electrons experience lower effective nuclear charge than electrons.
You correctly identified that the resulting ion contains unpaired electrons and is therefore paramagnetic.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that ionization splits electron loss between and subshells to balance occupancy, rather than completely emptying the outermost shell before touching orbitals.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- First-in, first-out rule for transition metal ionization
For first-row transition metals, electrons are added to before during neutral atom buildup, but during cation formation, all electrons are removed first ( before ).
When ionizing a neutral transition metal atom, completely remove all electrons from the highest principal quantum level () before removing any electrons.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the electrons with the highest principal quantum number : the two electrons in the subshell ().
Remove both electrons to form : .
Distribute the 7 electrons into five orbitals using Hund's rule: , , , , .
Correct configuration: ; Magnetic property: Paramagnetic with 3 unpaired electrons.
Lock it in
When first-row transition metals () form positive ions, which subshell loses electrons first?
The subshell loses electrons first because electrons extend farther radially and experience a lower effective nuclear charge ().
Similar question
Write the ground-state electron configuration of the iron(III) ion (, ) and state its number of unpaired electrons.
Answer
with unpaired electrons. Neutral iron is . Removing three electrons takes both electrons first, followed by one electron, leaving five singly occupied orbitals.
The copper(II) ion (, ) is commonly found in aqueous solutions. Determine its ground-state electron configuration, its magnetic property (paramagnetic or diamagnetic), and the number of unpaired electrons.
Answer
, paramagnetic with unpaired electron. Neutral copper is . Ionizing two electrons removes the single electron first, then one electron, leaving nine electrons (four paired sets and one unpaired electron).
Explain why zinc forms only the cation () under standard chemical conditions, provide its electron configuration, and state whether it is attracted to an external magnetic field.
Answer
Configuration: . Ionization removes the two outermost electrons from neutral . The resulting filled subshell has all electrons paired, making diamagnetic (not attracted to, but weakly repelled by, an external magnetic field).