Resources

An ionic compound consists of bismuth cations and phosphate anions (extPO43− ext{PO}_4^{3-}). Given that a 0.0500 mol0.0500\text{ mol} pure sample of this anhydrous compound contains 0.1500 mol0.1500\text{ mol} of phosphate ions, determine: (a) the oxidation state (ionic charge) of the bismuth ion, and (b) the complete chemical formula of the compound.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) +3+3 (or Bi3+\text{Bi}^{3+}), (b) BiPO4\text{BiPO}_4

Steps

01

Identify the Known Charges and Chemical Constraints

The polyatomic phosphate anion is given as POX4X3−\ce{PO4^3-}, which carries a net charge of −3-3.

Bismuth (Bi\ce{Bi}) is a Group 15 element with the valence electron configuration 6s26p36s^2 6p^3. In stable ionic compounds and oxysalts, its predominant and most stable oxidation state is +3+3, forming the bismuth cation BiX3+\ce{Bi^3+}.


02

Determine the Charge from Electrical Neutrality

An ionic compound is electrically neutral, meaning the total positive charge from cations must balance the total negative charge from anions:

Total positive charge+Total negative charge=0\text{Total positive charge} + \text{Total negative charge} = 0

In a formula unit containing bismuth cations BiXn+\ce{Bi^{n+}} and phosphate anions POX4X3−\ce{PO4^3-}:

  • Each phosphate ion contributes a charge of −3-3. For 0.0500 mol0.0500\text{ mol} of the compound, the 3−3- charge per phosphate unit accounts for 0.0500 mol×3=0.1500 mol0.0500\text{ mol} \times 3 = 0.1500\text{ mol} of negative charge equivalents.
  • To balance this negative charge, the bismuth cations must supply an equal magnitude of positive charge (+0.1500 mol+0.1500\text{ mol} of charge equivalents).
  • Since there is 0.0500 mol0.0500\text{ mol} of bismuth ions in the sample, the charge per bismuth ion is:

n=+0.1500 mol0.0500 mol=+3n = \frac{+0.1500\text{ mol}}{0.0500\text{ mol}} = +3

Thus, the oxidation state of the bismuth ion is +3+3 (representing the cation BiX3+\ce{Bi^3+}).


03

Write the Complete Chemical Formula

  1. Combine the ions: The cation is BiX3+\ce{Bi^3+} and the anion is POX4X3−\ce{PO4^3-}.
  2. Find the simplest whole-number ratio: Since both ions have equal and opposite charges (+3+3 and −3-3), they combine in a 1:11:1 ratio:

1(BiX3+)+1(POX4X3−)⟶BiPOX41(\ce{Bi^3+}) + 1(\ce{PO4^3-}) \longrightarrow \ce{BiPO4}

Common Pitfall: When working with polyatomic ions like POX4X3−\ce{PO4^3-}, parentheses are only needed if there is more than one polyatomic ion in the formula (e.g., CaX3(POX4)X2\ce{Ca3(PO4)2}). Because only one phosphate ion is present per formula unit here, no parentheses are used around POX4\ce{PO4}.

Therefore, the complete chemical formula of the compound is BiPOX4\ce{BiPO4}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the phosphate ion's charge with its subscript/quantity, mistakenly treating phosphate as having a -1 charge, leading to an oxidation state of +3 for bismuth.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Moles of phosphateMoles of compound=0.15000.0500=3  ⟹  Each formula unit contains 3 PO4 groups\frac{\text{Moles of phosphate}}{\text{Moles of compound}} = \frac{0.1500}{0.0500} = 3 \implies \text{Each formula unit contains } 3\text{ PO}_4\text{ groups}

    Correct

    Mole ratio of Bi3+:PO43−=1:1\text{Mole ratio of } \text{Bi}^{3+} : \text{PO}_4^{3-} = 1 : 1

    You calculated a 3:13:1 ratio of phosphate groups per formula unit, but in stable anhydrous bismuth phosphate, bismuth and phosphate combine in an equimolar 1:11:1 ratio.

  2. Step 2

    Assuming PO4 has a charge of −1:  ⟹  Charge of Bi+3(−1)=0  ⟹  Bi charge=+3\text{Assuming } \text{PO}_4 \text{ has a charge of } -1\text{:} \implies \text{Charge of Bi} + 3(-1) = 0 \implies \text{Bi charge} = +3

    Correct

    Charge of Bi+(−3)=0  ⟹  Bi charge=+3\text{Charge of Bi} + (-3) = 0 \implies \text{Bi charge} = +3

    You assumed that phosphate has a charge of −1-1, but the phosphate polyatomic anion is explicitly PO43−\text{PO}_4^{3-} and carries a fixed net charge of −3-3.

  3. Step 3

    Formula contains 1 Bi and 3 PO4  ⟹  Bi(PO4)3\text{Formula contains } 1\text{ Bi and } 3\text{ PO}_4 \implies \text{Bi}(\text{PO}_4)_3

    Correct

    BiPO4\text{BiPO}_4

    Because one Bi3+\text{Bi}^{3+} cation balances one PO43−\text{PO}_4^{3-} anion (+3+(−3)=0+3 + (-3) = 0), the formula unit requires no subscripts or parentheses.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the principle of electrical neutrality to set the sum of positive and negative charges to zero.

You identified +3+3 as the required oxidation state for the bismuth ion.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Misidentifying Polyatomic Ion Charge

You reassigned a charge of −1-1 to the phosphate ion instead of using its given charge of −3-3.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the charge of the polyatomic ion as an adjustable variable rather than a fixed chemical property of the PO43−\text{PO}_4^{3-} ion.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Keep Polyatomic Ion Charges Invariant
  • Polyatomic ions like phosphate (PO43−\text{PO}_4^{3-}) have a fixed net charge that does not change between different compounds.

  • Always substitute −3-3 for the charge of each PO43−\text{PO}_4^{3-} ion when setting up charge-balance equations.

Balance Equal and Opposite Charges with a 1:1 Ratio
  • When a monoatomic or polyatomic cation and anion have identical charge magnitudes (+n+n and −n-n), they combine in a 1:11:1 stoichiometric ratio.

  • Pair one Bi3+\text{Bi}^{3+} with one PO43−\text{PO}_4^{3-} directly to form BiPO4\text{BiPO}_4 without extra parentheses or subscripts.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the invariant charge of the phosphate anion from the problem statement: PO43−\text{PO}_4^{3-} has a net charge of −3-3.

  2. Apply electrical neutrality: one bismuth cation must balance one phosphate anion, giving Charge(Bi)+(−3)=0  ⟹  Bi3+\text{Charge}(\text{Bi}) + (-3) = 0 \implies \text{Bi}^{3+}.

  3. Combine the ions in the simplest whole-number ratio of 1:11:1 to obtain the neutral formula BiPO4\text{BiPO}_4.

Final answer

(a) +3+3, (b) BiPO4\text{BiPO}_4

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the fixed chemical formulas and charges of common polyatomic anions, particularly sulfate (SO42−\text{SO}_4^{2-}), nitrate (NO3−\text{NO}_3^-), carbonate (CO32−\text{CO}_3^{2-}), and phosphate (PO43−\text{PO}_4^{3-}).

  • Practice constructing ionic formulas for ions with matching charge magnitudes (+2/−2+2/-2, +3/−3+3/-3) to reinforce when parentheses and subscripts are unnecessary.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student knows bismuth typically has a +3 oxidation state and incorrectly forces a 1:1 ratio, writing the formula as BiPO4 and ignoring the given 3:1 mole ratio when deducing the formula.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    n(POX4X3−)n(compound)=0.15000.0500=3\frac{n(\ce{PO4^3-})}{n(\text{compound})} = \frac{0.1500}{0.0500} = 3

  2. Step 2

    Bismuth forms BiX3+ and phosphate is POX4X3−  ⟹  Oxidation state of bismuth=+3\text{Bismuth forms } \ce{Bi^3+} \text{ and phosphate is } \ce{PO4^3-} \implies \text{Oxidation state of bismuth} = +3

  3. Step 3

    Since BiX3+ and POX4X3− balance each other with 1:1 ratio:  ⟹  BiX3(POX4)X3 [crossed out]  ⟹  BiPOX4\text{Since } \ce{Bi^3+} \text{ and } \ce{PO4^3-} \text{ balance each other with 1:1 ratio:} \implies \ce{Bi3(PO4)3} \text{ [crossed out]} \implies \ce{BiPO4}

    Correct

    1(BiX3+\ce{Bi^3+}) + 1(POX4X3−\ce{PO4^3-}) \longrightarrow BiPOX4\ce{BiPO4}

    You correctly wrote the simplest formula BiPOX4\ce{BiPO4}, but you initially wrote BiX3(POX4)X3\ce{Bi3(PO4)3} to match your Step 1 ratio of 3 before crossing it out. An ionic formula must represent the simplest whole-number ratio consistent with overall electrical neutrality.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the mathematical ratio of phosphate moles to compound moles.

You identified the stable ionic charge of bismuth as +3+3.

You recognized that ionic compound formulas must be written in the simplest electrically neutral ratio, giving BiPOX4\ce{BiPO4}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Overriding calculated mole ratios with recalled charges

You crossed out your initial formula attempt without reconciling how the calculated ratio of 3 relates to the unit charges and empirical formula.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the mole ratio calculation and charge balancing as two separate, conflicting tasks. When they appeared to disagree, you discarded your quantitative ratio instead of connecting mole amounts to total equivalent charges to deduce the oxidation state systematically.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Empirical Formulas of Ionic Compounds
  • Ionic formulas always express the simplest whole-number ratio of cations to anions that achieves zero net charge.

  • Always reduce unsimplified subscripts like BiX3(POX4)X3\ce{Bi3(PO4)3} to their lowest integer ratio BiPOX4\ce{BiPO4}.

Charge Balance from Quantitative Mole Data
  • In an electrically neutral compound, ∑(nion×zion)=0\sum (n_{\text{ion}} \times z_{\text{ion}}) = 0, where zz is the ionic charge.

  • Use the total moles of charge supplied by known anions to solve for the unknown charge of the metal cation before writing the final formula.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the known ion and its charge: phosphate is POX4X3−\ce{PO4^3-}, carrying a −3-3 charge per ion.

  2. Determine the charge equivalents: the total negative charge supplied by phosphate must be balanced by an equal magnitude of positive charge from bismuth cations.

  3. Solve for the oxidation state of bismuth: balancing a 1:11:1 ratio of +3+3 and −3-3 gives an oxidation state of +3+3 for bismuth (BiX3+\ce{Bi^3+}).

  4. Combine the ions into the lowest whole-number ratio: 1(BiX3+)+1(POX4X3−)⟶BiPOX41(\ce{Bi^3+}) + 1(\ce{PO4^3-}) \longrightarrow \ce{BiPO4}.

Final answer

(a) +3+3 (or BiX3+\ce{Bi^3+}), (b) BiPOX4\ce{BiPO4}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how total ionic charge relates to mole ratios in neutral crystalline lattices.

  • Practice deriving unknown transition metal oxidation states directly from quantitative sample data rather than relying on memorized common charges.

  • Solve the targeted practice exercises below to strengthen your formula-writing workflow.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

An ionic compound consists of aluminum cations (Al3+\text{Al}^{3+}) and phosphate anions (PO43−\text{PO}_4^{3-}). Determine: (a) the oxidation state of the aluminum ion, and (b) the complete chemical formula of the compound.

Answer

(a) +3+3, (b) AlPO4\text{AlPO}_4. The ions carry +3+3 and −3-3 charges. They combine in a 1:11:1 stoichiometric ratio to achieve electrical neutrality (+3+(−3)=0+3 + (-3) = 0), yielding the empirical formula AlPO4\text{AlPO}_4 without parentheses.

02

A neutral ionic compound consists of iron cations (Fen+\text{Fe}^{n+}) and carbonate anions (CO32−\text{CO}_3^{2-}). A 0.200 mol0.200\text{ mol} pure sample of the anhydrous compound contains 0.400 mol0.400\text{ mol} of iron ions and 0.600 mol0.600\text{ mol} of carbonate ions. Determine: (a) the oxidation state of iron, and (b) the complete chemical formula.

Answer

(a) +3+3, (b) Fe2(CO3)3\text{Fe}_2(\text{CO}_3)_3. The mole ratio of Fe\text{Fe} to CO32−\text{CO}_3^{2-} is 0.400:0.600=2:30.400 : 0.600 = 2 : 3. Three carbonate ions contribute 3×(−2)=−63 \times (-2) = -6 total negative charge. Two iron ions must balance this with +6+6, giving +6/2=+3+6 / 2 = +3 per iron ion (Fe3+\text{Fe}^{3+}).

03

An anhydrous transition metal salt is composed of titanium cations (Tin+\text{Ti}^{n+}) and sulfate anions (SO42−\text{SO}_4^{2-}). Quantitative analysis shows that the salt has a sulfate-to-titanium molar ratio of 2:12:1. Determine: (a) the oxidation state of titanium, and (b) the complete chemical formula of the compound.

Answer

(a) +4+4, (b) Ti(SO4)2\text{Ti}(\text{SO}_4)_2. Two sulfate anions carry a total negative charge of 2×(−2)=−42 \times (-2) = -4. For electrical neutrality, the single titanium cation must provide a +4+4 charge (Ti4+\text{Ti}^{4+}). The resulting neutral chemical formula is Ti(SO4)2\text{Ti}(\text{SO}_4)_2.

Loading workspace…