Resources

Solid potassium chlorate decomposes upon heating according to the equation: 2KClO3(s)→2KCl(s)+3O2(g)2\text{KClO}_3(s) \rightarrow 2\text{KCl}(s) + 3\text{O}_2(g). A chemist heats a 24.52 g24.52\text{ g} sample of KClO3\text{KClO}_3 in an unsealed crucible until decomposition ceases. After cooling, the residual solid KCl\text{KCl} weighs 14.91 g14.91\text{ g}. (a) Calculate the theoretical mass of O2(g)\text{O}_2(g) evolved that accounts for the apparent mass discrepancy. (b) Explain how this observed mass loss satisfies the law of conservation of mass despite appearing to violate it in an open crucible boundary.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Mass of O2 evolved=24.52 g−14.91 g=9.61 g\text{Mass of O}_2\text{ evolved} = 24.52\text{ g} - 14.91\text{ g} = 9.61\text{ g}; (b) The open crucible constitutes an open thermodynamic system where gaseous oxygen escapes into the atmosphere; when the mass of the escaped gas (9.61 g9.61\text{ g}) is summed with the solid residue (14.91 g14.91\text{ g}), the total (24.52 g24.52\text{ g}) exactly equals the initial reactant mass, confirming mass conservation.

Steps

Part (a): Calculating the Mass of Evolved OX2(g)\ce{O2}(g)

  1. State the Governing Principle:
    According to the Law of Conservation of Mass, matter cannot be created or destroyed in a chemical reaction. Therefore, the total mass of the reactants must equal the total mass of all products formed: Mass of Reactants=Mass of Products\text{Mass of Reactants} = \text{Mass of Products}
  2. Set Up the Mass Balance Equation:
    For the complete decomposition of potassium chlorate: 2KClOX3(s)→2KCl(s)+3OX2(g)2\ce{KClO3}(s) \rightarrow 2\ce{KCl}(s) + 3\ce{O2}(g) The initial mass of KClOX3\ce{KClO3} equals the sum of the masses of residual solid KCl\ce{KCl} and evolved gaseous OX2\ce{O2}: m(KClOX3)=m(KCl)+m(OX2)m(\ce{KClO3}) = m(\ce{KCl}) + m(\ce{O2})
  3. Compute the Mass of OX2\ce{O2}:
    Rearranging to solve for the mass of oxygen gas released: m(OX2)=m(KClOX3)−m(KCl)m(\ce{O2}) = m(\ce{KClO3}) - m(\ce{KCl}) m(OX2)=24.52 g−14.91 g=9.61 gm(\ce{O2}) = 24.52\text{ g} - 14.91\text{ g} = 9.61\text{ g}

Part (b): Reconciling the Apparent Mass Loss with Mass Conservation

  • Open System Boundary:
    An unsealed crucible is an open thermodynamic system, which freely exchanges matter and energy with the surroundings.
  • Explanation of Apparent Loss:
    While the reactant KClOX3\ce{KClO3} and product KCl\ce{KCl} are non-volatile solids that remain in the crucible, oxygen (OX2\ce{O2}) is generated in the gas phase and escapes into the surrounding atmosphere. Because the balance only weighs the crucible and the remaining solid residue (14.91 g14.91\text{ g}), the mass appears to decrease.
  • Conclusion:
    When the mass of the escaped gas (9.61 g9.61\text{ g}) is accounted for and added to the mass of the solid residue (14.91 g14.91\text{ g}): 14.91 g+9.61 g=24.52 g14.91\text{ g} + 9.61\text{ g} = 24.52\text{ g} The total mass of the products matches the initial mass of the reactant exactly, confirming that mass is fully conserved.

Common Pitfall: An apparent loss or gain of mass during a reaction does not mean mass conservation has failed. A mass decrease indicates an uncaptured gaseous product escaping into the air, while a mass increase (such as burning magnesium in an open dish) indicates a gaseous reactant entering from the air.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misidentifies the oxygen evolved as atomic oxygen rather than diatomic oxygen gas when attempting a molar mass calculation, leading to an incorrect molar interpretation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Mass of reactant=24.52 g  ⟹  Mass of KCl=14.91 g  ⟹  Mass of O=24.52 g−14.91 g=9.61 g\text{Mass of reactant} = 24.52\text{ g} \implies \text{Mass of KCl} = 14.91\text{ g} \implies \text{Mass of O} = 24.52\text{ g} - 14.91\text{ g} = 9.61\text{ g}

  2. Step 2

    Molar mass of oxygen=16.00 g/mol  ⟹  Moles of oxygen gas=9.61 g/16.00 g/mol=0.60 mol\text{Molar mass of oxygen} = 16.00\text{ g/mol} \implies \text{Moles of oxygen gas} = 9.61\text{ g} / 16.00\text{ g/mol} = 0.60\text{ mol}

    Correct

    M(OX2)=32.00 g/mol  ⟹  n(OX2)=9.61 g32.00 g/mol≈0.300 molM(\ce{O2}) = 32.00\text{ g/mol} \implies n(\ce{O2}) = \frac{9.61\text{ g}}{32.00\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.300\text{ mol}

    Elemental oxygen gas exists as diatomic molecules (OX2\ce{O2}), so its molar mass is 2×16.00 g/mol=32.00 g/mol2 \times 16.00\text{ g/mol} = 32.00\text{ g/mol}, not 16.00 g/mol16.00\text{ g/mol}.

  3. Step 3

    The crucible is open to the air, so the oxygen produced escapes into the room.  ⟹  Mass is still conserved because the mass of the escaped gas plus the residual solid equals the starting mass.\text{The crucible is open to the air, so the oxygen produced escapes into the room.} \implies \text{Mass is still conserved because the mass of the escaped gas plus the residual solid equals the starting mass.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the law of conservation of mass to determine the 9.61 g9.61\text{ g} mass loss.

You clearly explained how an open system allows gaseous products to escape while total mass remains conserved.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Diatomic gas treated as atomic species

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated atomic oxygen (O\ce{O}) with elemental oxygen gas (OX2\ce{O2}), using the atomic molar mass of 16.00 g/mol16.00\text{ g/mol} instead of the molecular molar mass of 32.00 g/mol32.00\text{ g/mol}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Diatomic Element Identification
  • Gaseous elemental oxygen, nitrogen, hydrogen, and halogens naturally form diatomic molecules (HX2\ce{H2}, NX2\ce{N2}, OX2\ce{O2}, FX2\ce{F2}, ClX2\ce{Cl2}, BrX2\ce{Br2}, IX2\ce{I2}).

  • Always write oxygen gas as OX2\ce{O2} and double the atomic weight when calculating its molar mass: M(OX2)=2×16.00 g/mol=32.00 g/molM(\ce{O2}) = 2 \times 16.00\text{ g/mol} = 32.00\text{ g/mol}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that oxygen gas evolved from the reaction is diatomic: OX2(g)\ce{O2}(g).

  2. Calculate the molar mass of OX2\ce{O2}: 2×16.00 g/mol=32.00 g/mol2 \times 16.00\text{ g/mol} = 32.00\text{ g/mol}.

  3. Calculate moles of OX2\ce{O2}: n=9.61 g32.00 g/mol=0.300 moln = \frac{9.61\text{ g}}{32.00\text{ g/mol}} = 0.300\text{ mol}.

Final answer

(a) 9.61 g9.61\text{ g} of OX2(g)\ce{O2}(g); (b) In an open crucible, gaseous OX2\ce{O2} escapes into the atmosphere; adding the escaped gas mass (9.61 g9.61\text{ g}) to the solid residue (14.91 g14.91\text{ g}) yields 24.52 g24.52\text{ g}, confirming mass conservation.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Remember the 'Have No Fear Of Ice Cold Beer' mnemonic for diatomic elements: HX2\ce{H2}, NX2\ce{N2}, FX2\ce{F2}, OX2\ce{O2}, IX2\ce{I2}, ClX2\ce{Cl2}, BrX2\ce{Br2}.

  • Check that your chemical formulas in calculations match the exact phase and molecular state given in the balanced chemical equation.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the physical escape of gas from an open system with mass destruction during a chemical decomposition.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Mass of OX2=24.52 g−14.91 g=9.61 g\text{Mass of } \ce{O2} = 24.52\text{ g} - 14.91\text{ g} = 9.61\text{ g}

  2. Step 2

    Mass is lost because chemical bonds are broken by heating, destroying solid mass during thermal decomposition.  ⟹  The law of conservation of mass only holds approximately for solids, not when substances decompose completely.\text{Mass is lost because chemical bonds are broken by heating, destroying solid mass during thermal decomposition.} \implies \text{The law of conservation of mass only holds approximately for solids, not when substances decompose completely.}

    Correct

    The open crucible is an open system that allows gaseous OX2\ce{O2} to escape into the atmosphere. The mass is not destroyed; adding the escaped gas mass (9.61 g9.61\text{ g}) to the solid residue (14.91 g14.91\text{ g}) yields 24.52 g24.52\text{ g}, exactly matching the initial mass and fully satisfying the law of conservation of mass.

    Chemical reactions and bond breaking never destroy mass. The apparent mass loss occurs strictly because an unsealed crucible is an open system from which the oxygen gas escapes into the surroundings.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the numerical difference between the starting sample and the final residue equals the mass of oxygen produced.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Open-system gas escape confused with mass destruction

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated an open thermodynamic system as a closed boundary and assumed that breaking chemical bonds during decomposition destroys physical mass rather than converting matter into an unmeasured gas phase.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Universal Conservation of Mass
  • In any chemical reaction, atoms and total mass are strictly conserved; breaking or forming chemical bonds rearranges atoms but never creates or destroys mass.

  • Always treat mass conservation as an exact law in chemical reactions, regardless of whether substances are solids, liquids, or gases.

Open vs. Closed Systems
  • An open container allows volatile products (such as gases) to disperse into the surrounding air, creating an apparent mass decrease on a balance.

  • When an open reaction shows a decrease in mass, account for escaping gaseous products before evaluating mass conservation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the physical states in the balanced equation: 2 KClOX3(s)→2KCl(s)+3OX2(g)\ce{2KClO3}(s) \rightarrow 2\ce{KCl}(s) + 3\ce{O2}(g).

  2. Recognize that an unsealed crucible allows the gaseous product OX2(g)\ce{O2}(g) to leave the crucible and enter the surrounding atmosphere.

  3. Add the mass of the escaping gas to the mass of the remaining solid: 14.91 g(KCl)+9.61 g(OX2)=24.52 g14.91\text{ g} (\ce{KCl}) + 9.61\text{ g} (\ce{O2}) = 24.52\text{ g}.

  4. State that because total reactant mass equals total product mass (24.52 g=24.52 g24.52\text{ g} = 24.52\text{ g}), the law of conservation of mass holds exactly.

Final answer

(a) 9.61 g9.61\text{ g}; (b) The reaction takes place in an open system where the formed OX2\ce{O2} gas escapes into the atmosphere. Adding the escaped gas mass (9.61 g9.61\text{ g}) to the solid residue (14.91 g14.91\text{ g}) yields 24.52 g24.52\text{ g}, which equals the initial mass, confirming exact conservation of mass.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between open and closed thermodynamic systems during chemical changes.

  • Practice tracking phase changes and gaseous products when balancing mass in open containers.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 10.00 g10.00\text{ g} sample of calcium carbonate (CaCOX3\ce{CaCO3}) is heated in an open vessel and completely decomposes into solid CaO\ce{CaO} and gaseous COX2\ce{CO2}. The remaining solid weighs 5.60 g5.60\text{ g}. Find the mass and the number of moles of carbon dioxide gas that escaped.

Answer

Mass of COX2=10.00 g−5.60 g=4.40 g\ce{CO2} = 10.00\text{ g} - 5.60\text{ g} = 4.40\text{ g}. Moles of COX2=4.40 g44.01 g/mol=0.100 mol\ce{CO2} = \frac{4.40\text{ g}}{44.01\text{ g/mol}} = 0.100\text{ mol}.

02

When solid sodium azide decomposes via 2NaNX3(s)→2Na(s)+3NX2(g)2\ce{NaN3}(s) \rightarrow 2\ce{Na}(s) + 3\ce{N2}(g), a 13.00 g13.00\text{ g} sample releases nitrogen gas into the air. If 4.60 g4.60\text{ g} of sodium metal remains, calculate the mass of nitrogen gas released and determine its mole quantity.

Answer

Mass of NX2=13.00 g−4.60 g=8.40 g\ce{N2} = 13.00\text{ g} - 4.60\text{ g} = 8.40\text{ g}. Because nitrogen gas is diatomic (NX2\ce{N2}, M=28.02 g/molM = 28.02\text{ g/mol}), moles of NX2=8.40 g28.02 g/mol=0.300 mol\ce{N2} = \frac{8.40\text{ g}}{28.02\text{ g/mol}} = 0.300\text{ mol}.

03

A student burns 2.43 g2.43\text{ g} of magnesium ribbon in an open crucible to form magnesium oxide (2Mg(s)+OX2(g)→2MgO(s)2\ce{Mg}(s) + \ce{O2}(g) \rightarrow 2\ce{MgO}(s)). The final solid product weighs 4.03 g4.03\text{ g}. Explain the apparent mass increase using mass conservation, and calculate the moles of OX2\ce{O2} gas absorbed from the surroundings.

Answer

The open crucible absorbs oxygen from the surrounding air; total mass is conserved because m(Mg)+m(OX2)=m(MgO)m(\ce{Mg}) + m(\ce{O2}) = m(\ce{MgO}). Mass of OX2\ce{O2} consumed =4.03 g−2.43 g=1.60 g= 4.03\text{ g} - 2.43\text{ g} = 1.60\text{ g}. Moles of OX2=1.60 g32.00 g/mol=0.0500 mol\ce{O2} = \frac{1.60\text{ g}}{32.00\text{ g/mol}} = 0.0500\text{ mol}.

Loading workspace…