Resources
Consider the constitutionally isomeric alkenes with the molecular formula : but--ene, -but--ene, -but--ene, and -methylprop--ene. Many students assume that the cis-isomer (-but--ene) is thermodynamically more stable than the trans-isomer (-but--ene) because both methyl groups reside on the same side of the double bond. Explain the true relative thermodynamic stability of these two geometric isomers in terms of steric repulsion, calculate their standard heats of combustion difference if and , and give the systematic IUPAC names of both stereoisomers.
Answer and steps
Final answer
Stability & energetic difference: is more stable by due to the relief of steric strain (van der Waals repulsion between methyl groups on the same side in the isomer); IUPAC names: and
Steps
IUPAC Nomenclature and CIP Rules
The stereoisomers of but--ene differ in the spatial arrangement of substituents across the rigid carbon-carbon double bond ():
- At each -hybridized carbon atom, compare the two bonded substituents using the Cahn–Ingold–Prelog (CIP) priority rules: a methyl group (, priority 1) has higher atomic priority than a hydrogen atom (, priority 2).
- When both higher-priority methyl groups lie on the same side of the double bond, the configuration is assigned the prefix (from the German zusammen, meaning "together"). The systematic IUPAC name is (commonly known as cis-but--ene).
- When the higher-priority methyl groups lie on opposite sides across the double bond, the configuration is assigned the prefix (from the German entgegen, meaning "opposite"). The systematic IUPAC name is (commonly known as trans-but--ene).
Steric Repulsion and Relative Thermodynamic Stability
- In , the two bulky methyl groups are forced into close proximity on the same side of the non-rotatable double bond. The electron clouds of their hydrogen atoms interpenetrate each other's van der Waals radii, creating non-bonded steric strain (van der Waals repulsion). This increases the internal potential energy of the molecule.
- In , the two methyl groups are oriented on opposite sides of the double bond (separated by an angle of approximately across the plane of the system), which relieves steric interference and minimizes van der Waals repulsion.
- Therefore, the isomer is thermodynamically more stable than the isomer.
Common Pitfall: Students sometimes assume that substituents placed on the same side "stabilize each other" through symmetry or dipole interaction. In acyclic alkenes without intramolecular hydrogen bonding, crowding like substituents onto the same face always destabilizes the molecule due to steric hindrance.
Quantitative Energy Difference from Heats of Combustion
Both isomers undergo complete combustion to yield identical molar amounts of carbon dioxide and water:
Since both reactions arrive at the exact same product energy level, the isomer with a more negative heat of combustion starts at a higher enthalpy level (is less stable):
Because releases more energy upon combustion, is more stable by .
Typical errors
01 The student misinterprets the negative values of heat of combustion and incorrectly concludes that the more negative value corresponds to higher thermodynamic stability.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
is more stable than because steric crowding brings the methyl groups close together to maximize bonding interactions. Steric hindrance destabilizes .
Correctis more stable than because having the bulky methyl groups on opposite sides minimizes steric strain (van der Waals repulsion). In , the methyl groups are forced onto the same side, causing destabilizing steric crowding.
Steric crowding between non-bonded groups causes electron-cloud repulsion (van der Waals strain), which raises the potential energy and destabilizes the molecule. Placing the methyl groups on opposite sides in relieves this repulsion, making the isomer more stable.
- Step 2
A more negative heat of combustion means lower energy and greater stability, so is more stable by .
Correct, meaning is more stable by .
Both isomers burn to give the exact same products (). Releasing more energy upon combustion (a more negative ) means the isomer started at a higher potential energy level on an enthalpy diagram, making it less stable than the isomer.
- Step 3
and
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the systematic IUPAC names for both stereoisomers.
You correctly calculated the numerical magnitude of the difference between the two combustion values ().
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated heat of combustion as absolute molecular enthalpy rather than energy released relative to identical combustion products.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that steric crowding creates stabilizing bonding interactions rather than destabilizing van der Waals repulsion, and you misconstrued a more exothermic combustion reaction as indicating lower initial reactant enthalpy.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Steric Crowding in Alkenes
Steric crowding between adjacent alkyl groups causes van der Waals repulsion, which destabilizes the isomer.
Always identify the isomer that places bulky groups farther apart (trans / E) as having lower steric strain and therefore higher thermodynamic stability.
- Enthalpy Level vs. Heat of Combustion
For constitutional or stereochemical isomers that combust to identical products, higher heat released ( or more negative ) indicates higher initial reactant enthalpy (lower stability).
Draw a vertical enthalpy diagram: place the identical products at the bottom, and place the isomer releasing more heat higher up.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet up the combustion enthalpy diagram with as the common reference energy level at the bottom.
Compare the magnitudes: releases , while releases .
Calculate the difference: .
Conclude that lies higher in potential energy, so is thermodynamically more stable by .
is more stable by ; systematic names: and .
02 The student subtracts the heats of combustion in reverse order without accounting for signs, obtaining a positive difference but misidentifying which isomer has higher energy.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
is more stable than because the methyl groups are on opposite sides, avoiding steric repulsion. In , steric repulsion between the cis methyl groups raises its energy.
- Step 2
= -2706.1 - (-2710.3) = +4.2
- Step 3
Because the difference is positive, releases more heat and is therefore less stable.
CorrectBecause , releases more heat upon combustion to the same products, confirming that sits at a lower enthalpy level and is more stable by .
Combustion is exothermic, so the enthalpy of combustion is negative. The quantity of heat released is given by the absolute value: releases , whereas releases only . Releasing more heat means the isomer begins at a higher potential energy level and is less stable.
- Step 4
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou clearly explained the stereochemical basis of steric strain between cis methyl groups.
You correctly computed the numerical value of .
You properly designated both stereoisomers with systematic and prefixes.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the algebraic sign convention of exothermic reactions () with the actual quantity of heat released (), leading to an inverted conclusion regarding relative ground-state stability.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Heat Released vs. Algebraic Enthalpy
Combustion is exothermic, so is negative. The heat released is the absolute value .
Always compare the magnitudes of when comparing heat released.
- Enthalpy Level and Stability
Isomers combust into identical products (). The isomer that releases more heat must have started higher on the enthalpy ladder.
More negative higher initial enthalpy lower thermodynamic stability.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompare the magnitude of energy released: for the isomer vs. for the isomer.
Recognize that releases more heat to form the exact same combustion products.
Conclude that starts at an enthalpy level higher, meaning is more thermodynamically stable by .
is more stable than by due to the absence of steric strain between the methyl groups; systematic IUPAC names are and .
03 The student confuses the IUPAC stereochemical descriptors (E) and (Z) with cis/trans nomenclature rules, assigning (Z) to the trans isomer and (E) to the cis isomer.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
is more stable than because steric clash occurs when both methyl groups are on the same side in the cis isomer. The trans isomer keeps the bulky methyl groups apart.
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
and
You inverted the and IUPAC stereodescriptors. Under CIP priority rules, methyl () has higher priority than hydrogen () at each carbon. When high-priority groups are on the same side (cis), the descriptor is (from zusammen); when on opposite sides (trans), the descriptor is (from entgegen).
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou clearly articulated how steric strain between the two methyl groups accounts for the difference in thermodynamic stability.
You carried out the arithmetic for the heats of combustion difference correctly.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou swapped the definitions of and prefixes when matching them with cis and trans configurations.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the Cahn–Ingold–Prelog descriptor (zusammen, together on the same side) with trans, and (entgegen, opposite sides) with cis.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- CIP (E)/(Z) Nomenclature
stands for zusammen (together/same side, corresponding to cis for simple disubstituted alkenes), while stands for entgegen (opposite, corresponding to trans).
Assign CIP priorities (1 vs 2) at each carbon: if priority-1 groups lie on the same side of the double bond, assign ; if on opposite sides, assign .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDetermine the higher-priority group on each carbon of but-2-ene: (priority 1) > (priority 2).
For the cis isomer, both groups are on the same side of the bond, giving the prefix (zusammen), so its IUPAC name is .
For the trans isomer, the groups are on opposite sides across the bond, giving the prefix (entgegen), so its IUPAC name is .
is more stable by ; the cis isomer is and the trans isomer is .
Lock it in
How does heat of combustion () indicate the thermodynamic stability of isomers?
Because isomers burn to identical products, the isomer with the less negative (releases less heat) starts at a lower energy level and is more stable.
Similar question
Two isomeric dimethylcyclopropanes have heats of combustion of and . State which value corresponds to trans--dimethylcyclopropane and which to cis--dimethylcyclopropane, and calculate their stability difference.
Answer
trans--dimethylcyclopropane has and cis--dimethylcyclopropane has ; the trans isomer is more stable by due to reduced steric crowding between the two methyl groups.
Explain why -hex--ene has a smaller magnitude of heat of hydrogenation than -hex--ene, and state what this reveals about their relative ground-state energies.
Answer
Both isomers hydrogenate to identical hexane (-hexane). The isomer is more stable (lower ground-state energy) due to minimal steric repulsion between ethyl and methyl groups, so it releases less energy during hydrogenation.
Consider -but--ene, -but--ene, and -methylprop--ene. Given that -methylprop--ene is more stable than both but--ene isomers, explain this trend in terms of alkene substitution patterns and hyperconjugation.
Answer
Alkene stability increases with the number of alkyl substituents attached to the carbons. While all three are disubstituted, geminal disubstitution in -methylprop--ene allows effective hyperconjugative electron donation without the steric crowding found in , and with slightly favorable electronic stabilization compared to .