Resources

An industrial synthetic route produces ibuprofen (Mr=206.29 g/molM_r = 206.29\text{ g/mol}) from isobutylbenzene via a multi-step pathway. In an initial test reaction using stoichiometric reagents, 134.22 g134.22\text{ g} of isobutylbenzene (Mr=134.22 g/molM_r = 134.22\text{ g/mol}) is reacted with stoichiometric quantities of acetic anhydride (Mr=102.09 g/molM_r = 102.09\text{ g/mol}), ethyl chloroacetate (Mr=122.55 g/molM_r = 122.55\text{ g/mol}), and hydroxylamine (Mr=33.03 g/molM_r = 33.03\text{ g/mol}). The sum of the molecular weights of all stoichiometric reactants fed into the balanced process equals 514.85 g/mol514.85\text{ g/mol}. Assuming 100%100\% chemical conversion and that only one mole of ibuprofen is generated per mole of isobutylbenzene consumed, calculate: (a) the percent atom economy (% AE\text{ AE}) of this synthesis, and (b) the environmental quotient or E-factor (E=mass of total waste (g)mass of target product (g)E = \frac{\text{mass of total waste (g)}}{\text{mass of target product (g)}}) for an ideal 100%100\% yield batch producing 206.29 g206.29\text{ g} of ibuprofen.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Atom Economy=40.07%\text{Atom Economy} = 40.07\%; (b) E-factor=1.50\text{E-factor} = 1.50

Steps

Part (a): Calculating the Atom Economy (% AE\% \text{ AE})

Atom economy measures the theoretical efficiency of a chemical reaction in converting mass from reactants into the desired product. It assumes a theoretical 100%100\% yield and is calculated using stoichiometric molar masses:

% Atom Economy=Molar mass of desired product∑(Molar masses of all stoichiometric reactants)×100%\% \text{ Atom Economy} = \frac{\text{Molar mass of desired product}}{\sum (\text{Molar masses of all stoichiometric reactants})} \times 100\%

From the given data:

  • Molar mass of ibuprofen (desired product)=206.29 g/mol\text{Molar mass of ibuprofen (desired product)} = 206.29\text{ g/mol}
  • ∑(Molar masses of all stoichiometric reactants)=514.85 g/mol\sum (\text{Molar masses of all stoichiometric reactants}) = 514.85\text{ g/mol}

Substitute these values into the equation:

% Atom Economy=206.29 g/mol514.85 g/mol×100%≈40.07%\% \text{ Atom Economy} = \frac{206.29\text{ g/mol}}{514.85\text{ g/mol}} \times 100\% \approx 40.07\%


Part (b): Calculating the Environmental Factor (E-factor\text{E-factor})

The E-factor\text{E-factor} is a green chemistry metric that evaluates the amount of waste generated per unit mass of final product:

E=Mass of total waste (g)Mass of target product (g)E = \frac{\text{Mass of total waste (g)}}{\text{Mass of target product (g)}}

For an ideal batch producing 1.00 mol1.00\text{ mol} (206.29 g206.29\text{ g}) of ibuprofen at 100%100\% conversion and yield:

  1. Total mass of reactants introduced: Mass of reactants=514.85 g\text{Mass of reactants} = 514.85\text{ g}
  2. Mass of target product formed: Mass of ibuprofen=206.29 g\text{Mass of ibuprofen} = 206.29\text{ g}
  3. Total mass of waste produced: By the law of conservation of mass, any mass from the stoichiometric reagents that is not incorporated into the final desired product ends up as by-product waste: Mass of waste=Total mass of reactants−Mass of desired product\text{Mass of waste} = \text{Total mass of reactants} - \text{Mass of desired product} Mass of waste=514.85 g−206.29 g=308.56 g\text{Mass of waste} = 514.85\text{ g} - 206.29\text{ g} = 308.56\text{ g}
  4. Calculate the E-factor: E=308.56 g206.29 g≈1.50E = \frac{308.56\text{ g}}{206.29\text{ g}} \approx 1.50

Key Takeaway & Common Pitfall

  • Atom Economy vs. Reaction Yield: Atom economy is a theoretical measure based entirely on balanced chemical equations and stoichiometric ratios, regardless of laboratory yield.
  • Calculating Waste: In the absence of additional solvents or catalysts specified in the problem, mass conservation directly yields Waste=Reactants−Product\text{Waste} = \text{Reactants} - \text{Product}. An E-factor of 1.501.50 means that for every 1.00 kg1.00\text{ kg} of ibuprofen synthesized via this traditional route, 1.50 kg1.50\text{ kg} of chemical waste is generated.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the atom economy denominator with the sum of starting substrate and target product or solely the starting hydrocarbon reactant mass, dividing by the mass of isobutylbenzene instead of total reactant mass.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    % AE=Mr(ibuprofen)Mr(isobutylbenzene)×100%  ⟹  % AE=206.29134.22×100%=153.70%\%\text{ AE} = \frac{M_r(\text{ibuprofen})}{M_r(\text{isobutylbenzene})} \times 100\% \implies \%\text{ AE} = \frac{206.29}{134.22} \times 100\% = 153.70\%

    Correct

    % AE=Mr(desired product)∑Mr(all stoichiometric reactants)×100%=206.29 g/mol514.85 g/mol×100%≈40.07%\%\text{ AE} = \frac{M_r(\text{desired product})}{\sum M_r(\text{all stoichiometric reactants})} \times 100\% = \frac{206.29\text{ g/mol}}{514.85\text{ g/mol}} \times 100\% \approx 40.07\%

    Atom economy measures the proportion of mass from all input reactants incorporated into the target molecule. Dividing only by the molar mass of isobutylbenzene ignores the other required stoichiometric reactants and results in an impossible atom economy greater than 100%100\%.

  2. Step 2

    mass of total waste=514.85 g−206.29 g=308.56 g  ⟹  E=308.56 g206.29 g=1.50\text{mass of total waste} = 514.85\text{ g} - 206.29\text{ g} = 308.56\text{ g} \implies E = \frac{308.56\text{ g}}{206.29\text{ g}} = 1.50

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the conservation of mass to find the total mass of waste generated from the stoichiometric feed.

You correctly set up and evaluated the ratio of waste mass to product mass to calculate the E-factor.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect denominator in atom economy formula

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the main organic starting substrate as the sole input reactant in the atom economy formula rather than summing all stoichiometric reagents required by the balanced synthesis.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Atom Economy Denominator Rule
  • The denominator of atom economy must include the stoichiometric sum of all reactants shown in the balanced equation, not just the primary organic starting material: % AE=Molar mass of desired product∑Molar masses of all reactants×100%\%\text{ AE} = \frac{\text{Molar mass of desired product}}{\sum \text{Molar masses of all reactants}} \times 100\%.

  • Always verify that the denominator accounts for every stoichiometric reactant, and check that theoretical % AE≤100%\%\text{ AE} \le 100\%.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the total stoichiometric mass of all reactants fed into the process: ∑Mr(reactants)=514.85 g/mol\sum M_r(\text{reactants}) = 514.85\text{ g/mol}.

  2. Divide the molar mass of ibuprofen by this total reactant mass: % AE=206.29 g/mol514.85 g/mol×100%≈40.07%\%\text{ AE} = \frac{206.29\text{ g/mol}}{514.85\text{ g/mol}} \times 100\% \approx 40.07\%.

Final answer

(a) Atom Economy=40.07%\text{Atom Economy} = 40.07\%; (b) E-factor=1.50\text{E-factor} = 1.50

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the theoretical definition of atom economy to ensure all auxiliary stoichiometric reagents are included in the denominator.

  • Perform a quick sanity check whenever you calculate atom economy: since no atoms can be created, atom economy cannot exceed 100%100\%.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student defines the E-factor as the ratio of total waste to total reactant mass rather than total waste to mass of desired product.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    % AE=(206.29514.85)×100%=40.07%\% \text{ AE} = \left(\frac{206.29}{514.85}\right) \times 100\% = 40.07\%

  2. Step 2

    mass of total waste=514.85 g−206.29 g=308.56 g\text{mass of total waste} = 514.85\text{ g} - 206.29\text{ g} = 308.56\text{ g}

  3. Step 3

    E=mass of wastemass of total reactants=308.56 g514.85 g=0.60E = \frac{\text{mass of waste}}{\text{mass of total reactants}} = \frac{308.56\text{ g}}{514.85\text{ g}} = 0.60

    Correct

    E=mass of total wastemass of target product=308.56 g206.29 g≈1.50E = \frac{\text{mass of total waste}}{\text{mass of target product}} = \frac{308.56\text{ g}}{206.29\text{ g}} \approx 1.50

    You divided by the total mass of reactants rather than the mass of the target product. The E-factor evaluates waste produced per unit mass of desired product.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the percent atom economy using stoichiometric molar masses.

You correctly used mass balance to find the mass of chemical waste formed.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula denominator confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the definition of E-factor with a fraction of total input, placing total reactant mass in the denominator instead of the target product mass.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define E-Factor Correctly
  • E=mwastemdesired productE = \frac{m_{\text{waste}}}{m_{\text{desired product}}}, representing kilograms of waste generated per kilogram of product.

  • Always place the mass of the final desired product in the denominator, never the total mass of inputs or reactants.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the E-factor definition: E=mass of total wastemass of target productE = \frac{\text{mass of total waste}}{\text{mass of target product}}.

  2. Substitute the calculated waste mass (308.56 g308.56\text{ g}) and ibuprofen product mass (206.29 g206.29\text{ g}): E=308.56 g206.29 gE = \frac{308.56\text{ g}}{206.29\text{ g}}.

  3. Calculate the quotient: E≈1.50E \approx 1.50.

Final answer

(a) % AE=40.07%\% \text{ AE} = 40.07\%; (b) E=1.50E = 1.50

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between fractional mass metrics (relative to total input) and the E-factor (relative to desired output).

  • Practice recalculating E-factors across different chemical reaction pathways using target product mass as the base.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student forgets to subtract the mass of the product from the total reactant mass, mistaking the total mass of reactants fed for the mass of waste.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    % AE=206.29514.85×100%=40.07%\text{\% AE} = \frac{206.29}{514.85} \times 100\% = 40.07\%

  2. Step 2

    mass of total waste=514.85 g\text{mass of total waste} = 514.85\text{ g}

    Correct

    mass of total waste=514.85 g−206.29 g=308.56 g\text{mass of total waste} = 514.85\text{ g} - 206.29\text{ g} = 308.56\text{ g}

    By the conservation of mass, the total reactant mass equals the product mass plus the waste mass. Therefore, you must subtract the target product mass (206.29 g206.29\text{ g}) from the total reactant mass (514.85 g514.85\text{ g}) to find the waste.

  3. Step 3

    E=514.85 g206.29 g=2.50E = \frac{514.85\text{ g}}{206.29\text{ g}} = 2.50

    Correct

    E=308.56 g206.29 g≈1.50E = \frac{308.56\text{ g}}{206.29\text{ g}} \approx 1.50

    Because you used the total reactant mass in the numerator rather than the mass of waste, your calculated E-factor was shifted upward by exactly 1.001.00 (E+1=2.50E + 1 = 2.50).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled and calculated the percent atom economy formula.

You identified the correct mass values for both the target product and the total reactant feed.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating Total Reactants with Total Waste

You treated the entire 514.85 g514.85\text{ g} of incoming reactants as waste instead of subtracting the desired ibuprofen product mass.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Misinterpreting mass conservation in E-factor calculations. The E-factor evaluates the ratio of waste to product, mwastemproduct\frac{m_{\text{waste}}}{m_{\text{product}}}, where mwaste=mreactants−mproductm_{\text{waste}} = m_{\text{reactants}} - m_{\text{product}} under complete conversion.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Conservation of Mass in Batch Synthesis
  • Mass of Reactants=Mass of Desired Product+Mass of Waste\text{Mass of Reactants} = \text{Mass of Desired Product} + \text{Mass of Waste}

  • Always isolate the waste term: Mass of Waste=Mass of Total Raw Materials−Mass of Final Product\text{Mass of Waste} = \text{Mass of Total Raw Materials} - \text{Mass of Final Product}.

E-Factor Sanity Check
  • mreactantsmproduct=mwaste+mproductmproduct=E+1\frac{m_{\text{reactants}}}{m_{\text{product}}} = \frac{m_{\text{waste}} + m_{\text{product}}}{m_{\text{product}}} = E + 1

  • If your numerator equals the total mass fed into the reactor, your result is E+1E + 1, not EE.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. E=mass of total wastemass of target productE = \frac{\text{mass of total waste}}{\text{mass of target product}}

  2. E=308.56 g206.29 g≈1.50E = \frac{308.56\text{ g}}{206.29\text{ g}} \approx 1.50

Final answer

(a) Atom Economy=40.07%\text{Atom Economy} = 40.07\%; (b) E-factor=1.50\text{E-factor} = 1.50

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice applying the conservation of mass relationship Waste=Reactants−Product\text{Waste} = \text{Reactants} - \text{Product} when calculating green chemistry metrics.

  • Review the formal definition of the E-factor to ensure the numerator includes only non-target byproducts and waste streams.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

The industrial synthesis of ethylene oxide proceeds via direct oxidation: 2 CX2HX4+OX2→2 CX2HX4O\ce{2 C2H4 + O2 -> 2 C2H4O}. Using molar masses CX2HX4=28.05 g/mol\ce{C2H4} = 28.05\text{ g/mol}, OX2=32.00 g/mol\ce{O2} = 32.00\text{ g/mol}, and CX2HX4O=44.05 g/mol\ce{C2H4O} = 44.05\text{ g/mol}, calculate the percent atom economy of this addition reaction.

Answer

Total reactant mass: 2(28.05)+32.00=88.10 g/mol2(28.05) + 32.00 = 88.10\text{ g/mol}. Desired product mass: 2(44.05)=88.10 g/mol2(44.05) = 88.10\text{ g/mol}. % AE=88.1088.10×100%=100%\%\text{ AE} = \frac{88.10}{88.10} \times 100\% = 100\%.

02

In a substitution reaction, 11-bromobutane (Mr=137.02 g/molM_r = 137.02\text{ g/mol}) reacts with sodium hydroxide (Mr=40.00 g/molM_r = 40.00\text{ g/mol}) to produce butan-11-ol (Mr=74.12 g/molM_r = 74.12\text{ g/mol}) and sodium bromide (Mr=102.89 g/molM_r = 102.89\text{ g/mol}). Calculate: (a) the percent atom economy for butan-11-ol, and (b) the ideal E-factor assuming 100%100\% yield and stoichiometric inputs.

Answer

(a) Total reactant mass =137.02+40.00=177.02 g/mol= 137.02 + 40.00 = 177.02\text{ g/mol}. % AE=74.12177.02×100%≈41.87%\%\text{ AE} = \frac{74.12}{177.02} \times 100\% \approx 41.87\%. (b) Waste mass =177.02−74.12=102.90 g= 177.02 - 74.12 = 102.90\text{ g}. E-factor=102.90 g74.12 g≈1.39\text{E-factor} = \frac{102.90\text{ g}}{74.12\text{ g}} \approx 1.39.

03

A pharmaceutical intermediate (Mr=180.0 g/molM_r = 180.0\text{ g/mol}) is synthesized from an aryl bromide (Mr=157.0 g/molM_r = 157.0\text{ g/mol}), an amine (Mr=73.0 g/molM_r = 73.0\text{ g/mol}), and a stoichiometric base (Mr=101.0 g/molM_r = 101.0\text{ g/mol}). If a batch run produces 360.0 g360.0\text{ g} of the intermediate while generating 40.0 g40.0\text{ g} of unreacted residue and 262.0 g262.0\text{ g} of stoichiometric by-product salts, calculate the experimental E-factor of this specific run.

Answer

Total waste mass =40.0 g+262.0 g=302.0 g= 40.0\text{ g} + 262.0\text{ g} = 302.0\text{ g}. Target product mass =360.0 g= 360.0\text{ g}. E-factor=302.0 g360.0 g≈0.84\text{E-factor} = \frac{302.0\text{ g}}{360.0\text{ g}} \approx 0.84.

Loading workspace…