Resources

A student attempts to describe an electron in the ground state of a multi-electron helium atom (He\text{He}) using the Bohr model versus the Quantum Mechanical model. (a) In the Bohr model, the energy of a one-electron ion is En=−(13.606 eV)Z2n2E_n = -(13.606\text{ eV}) \frac{Z^2}{n^2}. If the student neglects electron-electron repulsion and sets Z=2,n=1Z = 2, n = 1, calculate the predicted total ground-state energy for both electrons combined. (b) The experimentally measured total ground-state energy of neutral helium is −79.005 eV-79.005\text{ eV}. Contrast how the quantum mechanical model addresses electron-electron shielding and repulsion (using effective nuclear charge ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} and electron spin quantum numbers ms=+12,−12m_s = +\frac{1}{2}, -\frac{1}{2}) versus the total failure of the Bohr model to incorporate electron-electron potential energy terms V12=+e24πϵ0r12V_{12} = +\frac{e^2}{4\pi \epsilon_0 r_{12}}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) For one electron, E1=−13.606×2212=−54.424 eVE_1 = -13.606 \times \frac{2^2}{1^2} = -54.424\text{ eV}. For two non-interacting electrons: Etotal=2×(−54.424 eV)=−108.85 eVE_{\text{total}} = 2 \times (-54.424\text{ eV}) = -108.85\text{ eV}; (b) The Bohr model yields an error of −29.85 eV-29.85\text{ eV} because it cannot account for interelectronic repulsion (+V12+V_{12}). Quantum mechanics introduces the Pauli Exclusion Principle (requiring opposite spins ms=±12m_s = \pm \frac{1}{2} for the two 1s1\text{s} electrons) and shielding, resulting in an effective nuclear charge Zeff≈1.69Z_{\text{eff}} \approx 1.69 rather than Z=2Z = 2, which brings the variational quantum mechanical expectation value into precise agreement with the experimental value of −79.01 eV-79.01\text{ eV}.

Steps

Part (a): Bohr Model Energy for Two Non-Interacting Electrons

  1. Calculate the single-electron energy: In the Bohr model, the energy level for a hydrogen-like atom or ion with atomic number ZZ and principal quantum number nn is given by: En=−(13.606 eV)Z2n2E_n = -(13.606\text{ eV}) \frac{Z^2}{n^2}

    For helium, the atomic number is Z=2Z = 2. For the ground state, n=1n = 1: E1=−(13.606 eV)2212=−(13.606 eV)⋅4=−54.424 eVE_1 = -(13.606\text{ eV}) \frac{2^2}{1^2} = -(13.606\text{ eV}) \cdot 4 = -54.424\text{ eV}

  2. Sum over both electrons: Neglecting any mutual repulsion between the two electrons, the total ground-state energy is the simple sum of the individual orbital energies: Etotal=E1+E1=2⋅(−54.424 eV)=−108.85 eVE_{\text{total}} = E_1 + E_1 = 2 \cdot (-54.424\text{ eV}) = -108.85\text{ eV}

Part (b): Comparison Between the Bohr and Quantum Mechanical Models

  1. Failure of the Bohr Model:

    • The Bohr model treats electrons as localized particles in deterministic circular orbits and provides no natural way to incorporate the positive potential energy of electron-electron repulsion: V12=+e24πϵ0r12V_{12} = +\frac{e^2}{4\pi \epsilon_0 r_{12}}
    • Because V12>0V_{12} > 0, omitting it severely overestimates the stability (binding energy) of the atom, predicting −108.85 eV-108.85\text{ eV} compared to the actual experimental value of −79.005 eV-79.005\text{ eV}—an error of approximately +29.85 eV+29.85\text{ eV}.
  2. Resolution by the Quantum Mechanical Model:

    • Pauli Exclusion Principle and Spin: The quantum model uses wavefunctions rather than fixed trajectories. The two electrons can occupy the same spatial ground-state orbital (1s1\text{s}) only because their spin magnetic quantum numbers are antiparallel: ms=+12andms=−12m_s = +\frac{1}{2} \quad \text{and} \quad m_s = -\frac{1}{2}
    • Shielding and Effective Nuclear Charge (ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}): Because each electron's probability cloud partially shields the nucleus from the other, neither electron feels the full nuclear pull of Z=2Z = 2. A variational treatment using trial wavefunctions yields an effective nuclear charge of: Zeff≈2−516≈1.69Z_{\text{eff}} \approx 2 - \frac{5}{16} \approx 1.69 Substituting Zeff≈1.69Z_{\text{eff}} \approx 1.69 into the energy expectation value accounts for the repulsive term ⟨V12⟩\langle V_{12} \rangle, raising the total theoretical ground-state energy from −108.85 eV-108.85\text{ eV} to −77.5 eV-77.5\text{ eV} (and to the exact −79.01 eV-79.01\text{ eV} when electron correlation is fully included).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates the energy of only a single electron and forgets to sum over both electrons to find the total combined ground-state energy.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    E1=−(13.606 eV)×(2212)  ⟹  E1=−(13.606 eV)×4=−54.424 eVE_1 = -(13.606\text{ eV}) \times \left(\frac{2^2}{1^2}\right) \implies E_1 = -(13.606\text{ eV}) \times 4 = -54.424\text{ eV}

  2. Step 2

    Etotal=−54.424 eVE_{\text{total}} = -54.424\text{ eV}

    Correct

    Etotal=2×E1=2×(−54.424 eV)=−108.85 eVE_{\text{total}} = 2 \times E_1 = 2 \times (-54.424\text{ eV}) = -108.85\text{ eV}

    Neutral helium contains two electrons. When mutual electron-electron repulsion is neglected, the total energy of the atom is the sum of both individual electron energies: Etotal=E1+E1=−108.85 eVE_{\text{total}} = E_1 + E_1 = -108.85\text{ eV}.

  3. Step 3

    The Bohr model does not account for the electron repulsion term V12V_{12}, giving an overbound single-electron value. In quantum mechanics, electrons repel each other so each screens the nucleus, reducing the attraction to Zeff<2Z_{\text{eff}} < 2 and allowing two paired spins ms=+12,−12m_s = +\frac{1}{2}, -\frac{1}{2} in the ground state.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly evaluated the Bohr energy formula for a helium nucleus with Z=2Z = 2 and n=1n = 1.

You clearly identified that omitting interelectronic repulsion V12V_{12} causes the non-interacting model to overestimate binding.

You correctly articulated how quantum mechanics resolves multi-electron states through nuclear shielding (Zeff<2Z_{\text{eff}} < 2) and spin pairing (ms=±12m_s = \pm \frac{1}{2}).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Single-electron vs multi-electron total energy omission

You reported the orbital energy of a single electron as the total energy of the entire neutral helium atom.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating individual orbital energy (EnE_n) with the total electronic energy (EtotalE_{\text{total}}) of a multi-electron system by overlooking the total electron count (N=2N = 2).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Count the Total Electrons
  • The total electronic energy of an unperturbed multi-electron system is the sum over all electrons: Etotal=∑i=1NEiE_{\text{total}} = \sum_{i=1}^{N} E_i.

  • Always verify the neutral atom's atomic number ZZ and multiply or sum the single-electron energy across all electrons in the atom.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify that neutral helium (He\text{He}) has Z=2Z = 2 protons and therefore 22 electrons in its ground state.

  2. Sum the single-electron energies: Etotal=E1+E1=2×(−54.424 eV)E_{\text{total}} = E_1 + E_1 = 2 \times (-54.424\text{ eV}).

  3. Calculate the combined total: Etotal=−108.85 eVE_{\text{total}} = -108.85\text{ eV}.

Final answer

(a) Etotal=−108.85 eVE_{\text{total}} = -108.85\text{ eV}; (b) The Bohr model cannot include interelectronic repulsion (V12V_{12}), overestimating binding energy (−108.85 eV-108.85\text{ eV} vs −79.01 eV-79.01\text{ eV}). Quantum mechanics resolves this via shielding (Zeff≈1.69Z_{\text{eff}} \approx 1.69) and opposite electron spins (ms=±12m_s = \pm \frac{1}{2}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • When calculating the total energy of an atom or ion, always state the electron count NN explicitly before writing EtotalE_{\text{total}}.

  • Practice comparing independent-particle approximations (neglecting VijV_{ij}) with experimental multi-electron ionization energies.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student squares the nuclear charge after multiplying rather than before, computing -(13.606 × 2)² instead of -(13.606) × 2².

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    E1=−(13.606 eV×2)2=−(27.212 eV)2=−740.493 eVE_1 = -(13.606\text{ eV} \times 2)^2 = -(27.212\text{ eV})^2 = -740.493\text{ eV}

    Correct

    E1=−(13.606 eV)Z2n2=−(13.606 eV)×2212=−54.424 eVE_1 = -(13.606\text{ eV}) \frac{Z^2}{n^2} = -(13.606\text{ eV}) \times \frac{2^2}{1^2} = -54.424\text{ eV}

    You applied the exponent of 2 to the product of 13.606 eV13.606\text{ eV} and ZZ rather than only to ZZ. The formula specifies that only ZZ is squared: En=−(13.606 eV)Z2n2E_n = -(13.606\text{ eV}) \frac{Z^2}{n^2}.

  2. Step 2

    Etotal=2×(−740.493 eV)=−1480.986 eVE_{\text{total}} = 2 \times (-740.493\text{ eV}) = -1480.986\text{ eV}

    Correct

    Etotal=2×E1=2×(−54.424 eV)=−108.848 eV≈−108.85 eVE_{\text{total}} = 2 \times E_1 = 2 \times (-54.424\text{ eV}) = -108.848\text{ eV} \approx -108.85\text{ eV}

    Your method of summing the two non-interacting electron energies by multiplying by 2 was correct, but your result was affected by the calculation error in the previous step.

  3. Step 3

    The Bohr model lacks inter-electron potential energy V12V_{12}, completely neglecting electron-electron interactions.

  4. Step 4

    Quantum mechanics includes repulsion by treating electrons as 3D wavefunctions where shielding lowers the nuclear charge to ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}, with opposite spins ms=+1/2m_s = +1/2 and −1/2-1/2 occupying the 1s state.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that for two independent, non-interacting electrons, the total energy is twice the single-electron ground-state energy.

You provided an accurate explanation of why the Bohr model fails due to omitting inter-electronic repulsion.

You accurately explained how quantum mechanics incorporates shielding to yield an effective nuclear charge alongside paired spins.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Order of Operations / Exponent Grouping

You accidentally placed parentheses around both the coefficient 13.60613.606 and the base Z=2Z=2 before squaring.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

In the hydrogen-like energy formula En=−RyZ2n2E_n = -R_y \frac{Z^2}{n^2}, the exponent applies solely to the base variable ZZ, not to the multiplying prefactor Ry=13.606 eVR_y = 13.606\text{ eV}. Grouping the prefactor inside the exponent (Ry×Z)2(R_y \times Z)^2 unnaturally squares the energy unit and magnifies the energy by a factor of 13.60613.606.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Exponent Precedence
  • Exponents precede multiplication: in c⋅x2c \cdot x^2, only xx is squared, so c⋅x2≠(c⋅x)2c \cdot x^2 \neq (c \cdot x)^2.

  • Always evaluate powers like Z2Z^2 or n2n^2 first before multiplying by the constant prefactor.

Physical Unit Check
  • The Rydberg constant Ry=13.606 eVR_y = 13.606\text{ eV} already carries units of energy (eV\text{eV}).

  • Notice that squaring (13.606 eV)2(13.606\text{ eV})^2 would result in eV2\text{eV}^2, which signals an incorrect formula structure.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute Z=2Z = 2 and n=1n = 1 into E1=−(13.606 eV)Z2n2E_1 = -(13.606\text{ eV}) \frac{Z^2}{n^2}.

  2. Compute the exponent first: Z2=22=4Z^2 = 2^2 = 4.

  3. Multiply the prefactor: E1=−(13.606 eV)×4=−54.424 eVE_1 = -(13.606\text{ eV}) \times 4 = -54.424\text{ eV}.

  4. Sum both non-interacting electrons: Etotal=2×(−54.424 eV)=−108.85 eVE_{\text{total}} = 2 \times (-54.424\text{ eV}) = -108.85\text{ eV}.

Final answer

Etotal=−108.85 eVE_{\text{total}} = -108.85\text{ eV}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check that you only square the variables ZZ and nn when working with the Bohr formula.

  • Verify your units at each stage: ensure intermediate constants are not squared if they already have energy dimensions.

  • Compare Bohr non-interacting baseline energies against experimental multi-electron ionization values to build physical intuition for electron-electron repulsion.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student forgets to square the atomic number Z in the Bohr formula, using Z instead of Z².

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    E1=−(13.606 eV)×(21)=−27.212 eVE_1 = -(13.606\text{ eV}) \times \left(\frac{2}{1}\right) = -27.212\text{ eV}

    Correct

    E1=−(13.606 eV)×2212=−(13.606 eV)×4=−54.424 eVE_1 = -(13.606\text{ eV}) \times \frac{2^2}{1^2} = -(13.606\text{ eV}) \times 4 = -54.424\text{ eV}

    You substituted Zn=21\frac{Z}{n} = \frac{2}{1} instead of Z2n2=2212=4\frac{Z^2}{n^2} = \frac{2^2}{1^2} = 4, omitting the square on the nuclear charge.

  2. Step 2

    Etotal=2×(−27.212 eV)=−54.424 eVE_{\text{total}} = 2 \times (-27.212\text{ eV}) = -54.424\text{ eV}

    Correct

    Etotal=2×(−54.424 eV)=−108.85 eVE_{\text{total}} = 2 \times (-54.424\text{ eV}) = -108.85\text{ eV}

    Your method of summing the two non-interacting electron energies was correct, but your final numerical value was affected by the earlier calculation of E1E_1.

  3. Step 3

    The Bohr model fails because it assumes fixed independent orbits and has no repulsion term V12V_{12}. ⟹\Longrightarrow The quantum mechanical model uses electron density distributions where mutual repulsion gives an effective nuclear charge Zeff<2Z_{\text{eff}} < 2, accommodating two electrons with ms=+1/2m_s = +1/2 and −1/2-1/2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly multiplied the single-electron energy by 2 to account for both electrons in the non-interacting model.

You clearly explained the limitation of the Bohr model regarding interelectronic repulsion.

You accurately identified that the quantum model resolves this through shielding, reduced effective nuclear charge ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}, and opposite spin quantum numbers.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula Exponent Error

You wrote 21\frac{2}{1} instead of 2212\frac{2^2}{1^2} when evaluating Z2n2\frac{Z^2}{n^2}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the square in the Z2Z^2 term of the hydrogen-like energy equation En=−E0Z2n2E_n = -E_0 \frac{Z^2}{n^2}, which leads to underestimating the Coulombic binding energy of multi-proton nuclei by a factor of ZZ.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Bohr Formula Dependence
  • The energy of a hydrogen-like system scales quadratically with nuclear charge: En∝Z2/n2E_n \propto Z^2 / n^2.

  • Always write out (Z)2(Z)^2 and (n)2(n)^2 with explicit exponents before inserting numerical values.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate the single-electron energy with Z=2Z = 2 and n=1n = 1: E1=−(13.606 eV)×2212=−(13.606 eV)×4=−54.424 eVE_1 = -(13.606\text{ eV}) \times \frac{2^2}{1^2} = -(13.606\text{ eV}) \times 4 = -54.424\text{ eV}.

  2. Sum the energies of the two non-interacting electrons: Etotal=2×E1=2×(−54.424 eV)=−108.85 eVE_{\text{total}} = 2 \times E_1 = 2 \times (-54.424\text{ eV}) = -108.85\text{ eV}.

Final answer

Etotal=−108.85 eVE_{\text{total}} = -108.85\text{ eV}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check that you square both ZZ and nn whenever evaluating Bohr energy levels: En=−(13.606 eV)Z2n2E_n = -(13.606\text{ eV})\frac{Z^2}{n^2}.

  • Compare the non-interacting theoretical energy (−108.85 eV-108.85\text{ eV}) with the experimental value (−79.01 eV-79.01\text{ eV}) to observe that interelectronic repulsion raises the total energy by +29.84 eV+29.84\text{ eV}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Using the Bohr hydrogenic formula En=−(13.606 eV)Z2n2E_n = -(13.606\text{ eV})\frac{Z^2}{n^2}, calculate the total ground-state energy of a lithium ion with two electrons (Li+\text{Li}^+, Z=3Z = 3), assuming both electrons occupy n=1n = 1 and mutual repulsion is neglected.

Answer

For Z=3,n=1Z = 3, n = 1, each electron has E1=−(13.606 eV)3212=−122.45 eVE_1 = -(13.606\text{ eV})\frac{3^2}{1^2} = -122.45\text{ eV}. For both electrons combined, Etotal=2×(−122.45 eV)=−244.91 eVE_{\text{total}} = 2 \times (-122.45\text{ eV}) = -244.91\text{ eV}.

02

In a variational quantum mechanical treatment of neutral helium, the effective nuclear charge felt by each electron is reduced from Z=2Z = 2 to Zeff=1.6875Z_{\text{eff}} = 1.6875 due to shielding. Using the effective hydrogenic formula Eapprox=2×[−(13.606 eV)Zeff212]E_{\text{approx}} = 2 \times \left[-(13.606\text{ eV})\frac{Z_{\text{eff}}^2}{1^2}\right], compute the approximate total ground-state energy.

Answer

Zeff2=(1.6875)2≈2.8477Z_{\text{eff}}^2 = (1.6875)^2 \approx 2.8477. The single-electron effective energy is −(13.606 eV)×2.8477≈−38.74 eV-(13.606\text{ eV}) \times 2.8477 \approx -38.74\text{ eV}. Summing for both electrons gives Eapprox=2×(−38.74 eV)=−77.49 eVE_{\text{approx}} = 2 \times (-38.74\text{ eV}) = -77.49\text{ eV} (much closer to the experimental −79.01 eV-79.01\text{ eV} than the unshielded −108.85 eV-108.85\text{ eV}).

03

The first ionization energy of helium is IE1=+24.59 eV\text{IE}_1 = +24.59\text{ eV} (removing the first electron to form He+\text{He}^+), and the second ionization energy is IE2=+54.42 eV\text{IE}_2 = +54.42\text{ eV} (removing the remaining electron from He+\text{He}^+). (a) Express the total experimental ground-state energy EtotalE_{\text{total}} of neutral He\text{He} in terms of IE1\text{IE}_1 and IE2\text{IE}_2. (b) Explain why IE1<IE2\text{IE}_1 < \text{IE}_2 using the concepts of electron-electron repulsion and ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}.

Answer

(a) Complete atomization requires removing both electrons to infinity (E=0E = 0), so Etotal=−(IE1+IE2)=−(24.59 eV+54.42 eV)=−79.01 eVE_{\text{total}} = -(\text{IE}_1 + \text{IE}_2) = -(24.59\text{ eV} + 54.42\text{ eV}) = -79.01\text{ eV}. (b) In neutral He\text{He}, two electrons repel each other and shield the nucleus, so each experiences Zeff≈1.69<2Z_{\text{eff}} \approx 1.69 < 2, making the first electron easier to remove (IE1=24.59 eV\text{IE}_1 = 24.59\text{ eV}). Once one electron is removed, the remaining electron in He+\text{He}^+ experiences the full unshielded nuclear charge Z=2Z = 2, requiring much more energy to remove (IE2=54.42 eV\text{IE}_2 = 54.42\text{ eV}).

Loading workspace…