Resources
A student claims that because electrons repel each other due to like charges, the two electrons in the helium atom () must occupy separate orbitals with parallel spins, predicting a ground state configuration of with orbital diagram and to satisfy Hund's rule. Identify the fundamental conceptual error in this reasoning, and explain why the ground state must be by contrasting the energy cost of orbital promotion with the scope of Hund's rule.
Answer and steps
Final answer
The student's error lies in misapplying Hund's rule to non-degenerate orbitals. Hund's rule applies strictly to degenerate orbitals (orbitals with identical energy levels, such as the three or five orbitals within the same subshell). The energy required to promote an electron from the orbital to the higher principal quantum level subshell (the Aufbau energy gap, ) is far larger than the interelectronic repulsion (pairing energy) incurred by placing both electrons in the orbital. Therefore, the ground state pairs both electrons in the orbital with antiparallel spins () in compliance with the Pauli exclusion principle.
Steps
Identify the Conceptual Error: The Scope of Hund's Rule
The student's error lies in misapplying Hund's rule of maximum multiplicity across orbitals of different energy levels.
- The Scope of Hund's Rule: Hund's rule states that for degenerate orbitals (orbitals of equal energy, such as the three orbitals or five orbitals), electrons remain unpaired with parallel spins to minimize electrostatic repulsion before pairing begins.
- The Error: The and orbitals are non-degenerate; they belong to completely different principal quantum shells ( versus ). Hund's rule does not dictate electron distribution across different energy levels.
Compare the Energetics: Orbital Promotion vs. Electron Pairing
To determine the true ground state, we must evaluate the competing energetic factors:
- Orbital Promotion Energy ():
- Promoting an electron from the shell to the shell requires overcoming a substantial nuclear attraction. In a helium atom, this excitation gap is extraordinarily large:
- Pairing Energy ():
- Pairing two electrons in the same orbital introduces electrostatic repulsion (electron-electron repulsion energy). However, this repulsion is significantly smaller than the massive required to promote an electron into the higher orbital ().
Because the energy penalty for orbital promotion vastly outweighs the pairing energy penalty, the atom minimizes its total energy by placing both electrons in the lowest available orbital (). The proposed configuration is not the ground state, but an excited state.
Application of the Pauli Exclusion Principle
According to the Aufbau principle, electrons fill the lowest-energy available orbital first.
- By the Pauli exclusion principle, no two electrons in an atom can have the same four quantum numbers .
- Therefore, the two electrons occupying the single orbital must have opposite (antiparallel) spins: one with and the other with .
Thus, the ground state configuration of helium is:
Common Pitfall
A frequent misconception is assuming that electron repulsion prevents any two electrons from sharing an orbital if an empty orbital exists anywhere in the atom. While electrons do repel, this repulsion only drives electrons into separate orbitals when those orbitals are degenerate (equal in energy). When orbitals differ in energy, electrons will pair up in the lower-energy orbital as long as the pairing energy is less than the orbital energy gap.
Typical errors
01 The student believes Hund's rule applies globally to all subshells and incorrectly claims the Pauli exclusion principle forbids placing two electrons in the same orbital altogether.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Hund's rule requires all available subshells to be half-filled before pairing, so electrons must separate into and .
CorrectHund's rule applies strictly to degenerate orbitals (orbitals of identical energy, such as the three orbitals in a subshell). It does not apply between non-degenerate orbitals like and .
You treated Hund's rule as a rule that applies across different subshells and energy levels, but it only governs orbitals that share the exact same energy (degenerate orbitals).
- Step 2
The Pauli exclusion principle strictly prevents two electrons from occupying the same orbital because electrons cannot have the same spatial coordinates.
CorrectThe Pauli exclusion principle requires that no two electrons share all four quantum numbers , allowing two electrons to share the orbital as long as they have opposite spins ( and ).
You concluded that the Pauli exclusion principle prevents two electrons from sharing an orbital, but two electrons can occupy the same spatial orbital if their spin quantum numbers are antiparallel.
- Step 3
Therefore, promotion to is mandatory to avoid violating quantum mechanics, making the true ground state.
CorrectBecause the energy required to promote an electron from to () is much larger than the interelectronic pairing energy (), the ground state is (), whereas is an excited state.
You designated the promoted configuration as the ground state, but the large orbital promotion energy penalty makes an excited state.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that Hund's rule and the Pauli exclusion principle are the key quantum principles governing atomic electron arrangements.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou extended Hund's rule across different principal energy levels and misunderstood the Pauli exclusion principle as a ban on orbital sharing rather than a restriction on identical quantum states.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Hund's Rule Scope
Hund's rule applies solely to degenerate orbitals (orbitals with identical energy within the same subshell, like ).
Never spread electrons across different subshells to satisfy Hund's rule; fill lower-energy orbitals first according to the Aufbau principle.
- Pauli Exclusion Principle
An orbital can hold up to two electrons provided their spins are opposite ( and ).
Allow up to two electrons per box/orbital with antiparallel arrows () before moving to higher energy subshells.
- Aufbau Gap vs. Pairing Energy
Electrons will pair in a lower orbital whenever the orbital gap exceeds the pairing repulsion energy (for He, ).
Identify configurations with electrons promoted to higher subshells before lower ones are filled as excited states, not ground states.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify that Hund's rule applies only to degenerate orbitals within the same subshell, meaning and are outside its scope.
Apply the Pauli exclusion principle correctly: two electrons can occupy the orbital as long as their spins are antiparallel ().
Compare the energy costs: promoting an electron to requires , which is far greater than the electron-electron pairing energy in .
Conclude that helium's ground state minimizes total energy by pairing both electrons in , yielding (), while is an excited state.
The claim misapplies Hund's rule, which applies only to degenerate orbitals. Promoting an electron to the higher orbital costs far more energy () than electron pairing in . According to the Pauli exclusion principle, two electrons can share the orbital with opposite spins, making the ground state.
02 The student correctly notes Hund's rule is for degenerate orbitals but assumes electron-electron electrostatic repulsion is always greater than the 1s-to-2s energy gap.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Hund's rule only applies to degenerate orbitals, so it cannot be invoked across different shells like 1s and 2s.
- Step 2
However, the Coulombic repulsion between two negative electrons in the small 1s orbital is so large that it exceeds the 1s to 2s promotion energy.
CorrectThe orbital promotion energy from to () is far larger than the interelectronic pairing repulsion energy () in the orbital ().
You overestimated the magnitude of Coulombic repulsion relative to the excitation energy. In a helium atom, promoting an electron across principal quantum shells ( to ) requires nearly , which vastly exceeds the energy penalty of electron pairing.
- Step 3
Minimizing electrostatic repulsion is always more important than orbital energy, so separating electrons into 1s:[↑] 2s:[↑] achieves the lower total energy.
CorrectBecause the energy cost of promotion vastly outweighs the pairing repulsion, the atom achieves minimum total energy by placing both electrons in the orbital with antiparallel spins () in accordance with the Pauli exclusion principle.
Because of the incorrect premise in Step 2, you reached the wrong conclusion. The configuration is an excited state, whereas is the true ground state.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that Hund's rule is restricted to degenerate orbitals and does not govern non-degenerate subshells.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeAssuming that electrostatic repulsion between paired electrons is always greater than the energy required to promote an electron to a higher principal energy level.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated electrostatic repulsion as the absolute governing factor in electron configuration rather than balancing it against the much larger orbital energy gap (Aufbau promotion penalty).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Degeneracy vs. Non-degeneracy
Hund's rule dictates parallel spins and separate orbital occupancy only within degenerate orbitals (same subshell, same energy).
Check whether the orbitals under comparison have the exact same energy before invoking Hund's rule.
- Promotion Energy vs. Pairing Energy
Promotion between principal shells requires overcoming nuclear attraction (typically tens of ), which is much larger than electron pairing repulsion ().
Always pair electrons in lower-energy orbitals before promoting to a higher shell, unless orbitals are degenerate or nearly degenerate.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompare the energy cost of promoting an electron from to () against the pairing energy ().
Because , the atom minimizes total energy by pairing both electrons in the orbital rather than exciting one to .
Apply the Pauli exclusion principle, which requires the two paired electrons in the same orbital to have antiparallel spins ().
The ground-state electron configuration of helium is , represented as .
Lock it in
Under what specific condition does Hund's rule apply to electron filling?
Hund's rule applies strictly to degenerate orbitals (orbitals having the exact same energy, such as the three orbitals within a single subshell).
Similar question
A student writes the orbital diagram for beryllium () as to minimize repulsion between the two valence electrons. Explain why this is an excited state rather than the ground state.
Answer
The ground state of Be is (). The energy gap between the and subshells () is significantly greater than the pairing energy required to place two electrons with opposite spins in the orbital. Hund's rule does not apply across the non-degenerate and subshells.
State whether the electron configuration for carbon () represents the ground state, an excited state, or an impossible state, and explain using Hund's rule and the Pauli exclusion principle.
Answer
It represents an excited state. It does not violate the Pauli exclusion principle because the two electrons have opposite spins. However, it violates Hund's rule because the three orbitals () are degenerate, so spreading electrons with parallel spins into separate orbitals () minimizes pairing repulsion without paying an orbital promotion penalty.
In a certain transition metal ion, the pairing energy is measured to be , while the crystal field splitting energy between two sets of -orbitals is . Will the next electron pair up in the lower-energy orbital set or be promoted to the higher-energy set, and what state does this determine?
Answer
The electron will be promoted to the higher-energy orbital set. Since (), promoting the electron costs less energy than paying the pairing repulsion penalty, producing a high-spin ground state configuration.