Resources
Consider the oxidation of aqueous thiosulfate ion () by aqueous halogens under two asymptotic oxidant-strength extremes: Reaction A (mild oxidant, standard iodine): ; Reaction B (strong oxidant limit, excess chlorine gas): . (a) Determine the average oxidation state of sulfur in , , and . (b) Identify the reducing agent and oxidizing agent in both reactions. (c) Calculate the number of moles of electrons lost per mole of in Reaction A versus Reaction B.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Average oxidation state of sulfur: in , in , and in . (b) In Reaction A, the reducing agent is and the oxidizing agent is ; in Reaction B, the reducing agent is and the oxidizing agent is . (c) In Reaction A, is lost per mole of ; in Reaction B, are lost per mole of .
Steps
Part (a): Determining the Average Oxidation State of Sulfur
By standard oxidation rules, oxygen in oxoanions has an oxidation state of . The sum of the oxidation states of all atoms equals the net charge of the polyatomic ion.
- In the thiosulfate ion (): Let be the average oxidation state of sulfur:
- In the tetrathionate ion (): Let be the average oxidation state of sulfur:
- In the sulfate ion (): Let be the oxidation state of sulfur:
Part (b): Identifying the Oxidizing and Reducing Agents
A reducing agent donates electrons (is oxidized, increasing its oxidation state), while an oxidizing agent accepts electrons (is reduced, decreasing its oxidation state).
-
Reaction A:
- The average oxidation state of sulfur increases from in to in (oxidation). Thus, is the reducing agent.
- The oxidation state of iodine decreases from in to in (reduction). Thus, is the oxidizing agent.
-
Reaction B:
- The average oxidation state of sulfur increases from in to in (oxidation). Thus, is the reducing agent.
- The oxidation state of chlorine decreases from in to in (reduction). Thus, is the oxidizing agent.
Part (c): Moles of Electrons Lost per Mole of
The number of moles of electrons lost can be determined either from the change in oxidation number or by writing the balanced half-reactions.
-
Reaction A (Mild Oxidation):
- Oxidation half-reaction:
- For every of reacted, of electrons are lost.
- Per mole of :
- Pitfall check: Notice that each sulfur atom increases in oxidation state by (from to ). Because each formula unit contains sulfur atoms, the total electrons lost per mole of thiosulfate is .
-
Reaction B (Strong Oxidation):
- Oxidation half-reaction:
- In this reaction, of directly yields of electrons.
- Oxidation state check: Each sulfur atom increases in oxidation state from to , which is a change of per sulfur atom. With sulfur atoms per formula unit:
Typical errors
01 The student calculates the electron loss in Reaction A based on the whole balanced equation (2 moles of S₂O₃²⁻) rather than normalizing per single mole of S₂O₃²⁻, arriving at 2 moles of electrons lost instead of 1.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
Reaction A: is the reducing agent; is the oxidizing agent. Reaction B: is the reducing agent; is the oxidizing agent.
- Step 3
Reaction A: shows transferred for the in the equation. Electrons lost per mole of in Reaction A .
CorrectYou recognized that are transferred for every of , but you forgot to divide by the stoichiometric coefficient of to find the ratio per single mole of .
- Step 4
Reaction B: shows transferred per . Electrons lost per mole of in Reaction B .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the average oxidation states of sulfur across all three polyatomic oxoanions.
You correctly assigned the oxidizing and reducing agents based on the changes in oxidation states.
You accurately identified the total moles of electrons transferred in each balanced redox equation.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou noticed in your written notes that were transferred for , but you skipped dividing by to express the final value per single mole.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the total electron transfer of the balanced chemical equation with the intensive quantity 'electrons transferred per mole of a specific reactant'.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Per-Mole Normalization
Moles of lost per mole of reactant equals .
Always explicitly divide the electron coefficient by the reactant's stoichiometric coefficient instead of taking the electron coefficient directly from the equation.
- Oxidation State Change Cross-Check
Electrons lost per formula unit equal .
For , verify that .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the oxidation half-reaction for thiosulfate: .
Divide the moles of electrons by the moles of thiosulfate reacting: .
In Reaction A, is lost per mole of ; in Reaction B, are lost per mole of .
02 The student confuses the definitions of oxidizing and reducing agents, identifying the oxidized species as the oxidizing agent and the reduced species as the reducing agent.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
: : :
- Step 2
Reaction A: is oxidized so it is the oxidizing agent; is reduced so it is the reducing agent. Reaction B: is oxidized so it is the oxidizing agent; is reduced so it is the reducing agent.
CorrectReaction A: Reducing agent is ; oxidizing agent is . Reaction B: Reducing agent is ; oxidizing agent is .
An oxidizing agent causes another substance to be oxidized while itself being reduced (electron acceptor). Conversely, a reducing agent causes another substance to be reduced while itself being oxidized (electron donor). Because is oxidized in both reactions, it acts as the reducing agent, while and are reduced and act as the oxidizing agents.
- Step 3
Reaction A: lose , so lost per . Reaction B: loses , so lost per .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly set up the oxidation state equations using oxygen as and correctly determined average oxidation numbers, including the in tetrathionate.
You correctly identified which chemical species underwent oxidation and which underwent reduction in both reactions.
You accurately calculated the stoichiometric moles of electrons exchanged per mole of thiosulfate reactant.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou named the substance being oxidized as the 'oxidizing agent' and the substance being reduced as the 'reducing agent'.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the process a reactant undergoes with its role as an agent. An 'agent' is named after what it does to the other reactant: a reducing agent reduces something else by giving up electrons, which causes the reducing agent itself to be oxidized.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Agent vs. Process Rule
The substance oxidized is the reducing agent (electron donor); the substance reduced is the oxidizing agent (electron acceptor).
Whenever you identify that a reactant undergoes oxidation, immediately label it as the reducing agent.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecall the functional definition: an agent facilitates a process on another reactant.
Because sulfur increases in oxidation state from to (Reaction A) and to (Reaction B), loses electrons (undergoes oxidation).
By losing electrons, supplies electrons to reduce the halogen, making the reducing agent in both reactions.
Halogens ( and ) accept these electrons, decreasing their oxidation states from to (undergoing reduction), which makes them the oxidizing agents.
(a) in , in , and in . (b) In Reaction A, reducing agent: , oxidizing agent: ; in Reaction B, reducing agent: , oxidizing agent: . (c) Reaction A: lost per mole of ; Reaction B: lost per mole of .
03 The student forces oxidation states to be integers by miscalculating the net charge or atom count of tetrathionate, concluding that sulfur in S₄O₆²⁻ has an oxidation state of +3.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
Average oxidation states across equivalent or chemically distinct resonance atoms in polyatomic species can be fractional. Furthermore, the sum of all oxidation numbers must equal the overall charge of the ion (), not .
- Step 3
- Step 4
- Step 5
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly set up and solved the oxidation number equations for and .
You correctly identified the oxidizing agents and reducing agents based on electron transfer.
You accurately determined the moles of electrons lost per mole of thiosulfate in both reactions.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou equated the sum of the oxidation states of tetrathionate to instead of because you believed that oxidation states must always evaluate to integers.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou held the misconception that an individual element's calculated average oxidation state in a polyatomic ion must always be an integer, which prompted you to change the net charge of the ion in your equation.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Fractional Average Oxidation States
Average oxidation states in ions or molecules can be non-integers (e.g., in , in ) because different atoms of the same element can have different formal local environments.
Always strictly set the sum of oxidation numbers equal to the true net charge of the formula unit, even if the resulting average value is fractional.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet the sum of oxidation states equal to the overall net charge of : .
Simplify the algebraic equation: .
Solve for the average oxidation state: (or ).
(a) Average oxidation state of sulfur: in , in , and in . (b) In Reaction A, the reducing agent is and the oxidizing agent is ; in Reaction B, the reducing agent is and the oxidizing agent is . (c) Reaction A: lost per mole of ; Reaction B: lost per mole of .
Lock it in
How do you calculate the moles of electrons transferred per mole of a reactant from a balanced half-reaction?
Divide the coefficient of by the stoichiometric coefficient of that reactant: .
Similar question
Consider the reaction: . How many moles of electrons are lost per mole of oxalate ion ()?
Answer
. Key steps: Each gains (total transferred). Dividing by the coefficient of oxalate: lost per mole of (or carbon goes from to , so per ion).
Dichromate oxidizes ethanol under acidic conditions: . Calculate the moles of electrons transferred (a) per mole of and (b) per mole of .
Answer
(a) ; (b) . Key steps: Total electrons transferred in the equation is (since each changes by , ). Per mole of : . Per mole of : .
In basic solution, hydrazine reduces bromate: . Determine the moles of electrons lost per mole of and verify your answer using the change in oxidation number of nitrogen.
Answer
per mole of . Key steps: Bromine decreases from in to in ( gained per ). Total electrons transferred . Per mole of : . Verification: Nitrogen increases from in to in , so each of the nitrogen atoms loses , giving lost per mole of .