Resources

An active pharmaceutical ingredient is prepared in a multi-step sequence. Step 1 couples two precursors with an atom economy of 82.5%82.5\% and operates at a 75.0%75.0\% isolated chemical yield. Step 2 purifies and converts the intermediate to the final drug target with an atom economy of 94.0%94.0\% and an 85.0%85.0\% chemical yield. In Step 1, 120 kg120\text{ kg} of total raw materials produces 74.2 kg74.2\text{ kg} of isolated intermediate. In Step 2, this 74.2 kg74.2\text{ kg} of intermediate requires an additional 25.8 kg25.8\text{ kg} of coreagent and 300 kg300\text{ kg} of recyclable solvent (of which 15.0%15.0\% is unrecoverable and discarded as chemical waste) to isolate 59.3 kg59.3\text{ kg} of final purified API. Calculate (a) the overall theoretical atom economy of the two-step linear synthetic sequence and (b) the cumulative EE-factor of the entire process including the lost solvent to three significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Overall Atom Economy =77.6%= 77.6\%; (b) Cumulative E-factor=2.22 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = 2.22\text{ kg waste/kg product}

Steps

01

Identify Total Material Consumed Across the Process

(a) Overall Theoretical Atom Economy

Atom economy (AE\text{AE}) measures the proportion of reactant mass converted into desired products based on stoichiometric molar masses: AE=Molar mass of desired productTotal molar mass of all stoichiometric reactants×100%\text{AE} = \frac{\text{Molar mass of desired product}}{\text{Total molar mass of all stoichiometric reactants}} \times 100\% For a linear multi-step synthesis without branching, the theoretical atom economy of the overall sequence is the multiplicative product of the individual step atom economies: AEoverall=AE1×AE2\text{AE}_{\text{overall}} = \text{AE}_1 \times \text{AE}_2 Substitute the given values: AEoverall=0.825×0.940=0.7755=77.6%\text{AE}_{\text{overall}} = 0.825 \times 0.940 = 0.7755 = 77.6\%

(b) Cumulative EE-Factor of the Entire Process

The environmental factor (EE-factor) quantifies the mass of waste generated per kilogram of final product: E-factor=Total mass of wasteMass of final product=Total mass of inputs consumed−Mass of final productMass of final productE\text{-factor} = \frac{\text{Total mass of waste}}{\text{Mass of final product}} = \frac{\text{Total mass of inputs consumed} - \text{Mass of final product}}{\text{Mass of final product}}

  • Step 1 raw materials: 120 kg120\text{ kg}
  • Step 2 additional coreagent: 25.8 kg25.8\text{ kg}
  • Step 2 unrecoverable solvent: Because 85.0%85.0\% of the solvent is recovered and reused within the cycle, only the lost portion counts toward chemical waste: Mass of lost solvent=300 kg×0.150=45.0 kg\text{Mass of lost solvent} = 300\text{ kg} \times 0.150 = 45.0\text{ kg}

Common Pitfall: Do not double-count the 74.2 kg74.2\text{ kg} of isolated intermediate as an external input in Step 2. It is an internal stream originating directly from the 120 kg120\text{ kg} of Step 1 raw materials. Likewise, do not include the recyclable portion of the solvent (255 kg255\text{ kg}) in the waste stream.

Total inputs consumed=120 kg+25.8 kg+45.0 kg=190.8 kg\text{Total inputs consumed} = 120\text{ kg} + 25.8\text{ kg} + 45.0\text{ kg} = 190.8\text{ kg}

02

Calculate Total Waste

Total mass of waste=Total inputs consumed−Mass of final API\text{Total mass of waste} = \text{Total inputs consumed} - \text{Mass of final API} Total mass of waste=190.8 kg−59.3 kg=131.5 kg\text{Total mass of waste} = 190.8\text{ kg} - 59.3\text{ kg} = 131.5\text{ kg}

03

Compute Cumulative EE-Factor

E-factor=131.5 kg waste59.3 kg API≈2.2175 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = \frac{131.5\text{ kg waste}}{59.3\text{ kg API}} \approx 2.2175\text{ kg waste/kg product}

Rounded to three significant figures: E-factor=2.22 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = 2.22\text{ kg waste/kg product}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student averages the individual atom economies instead of multiplying them, resulting in an overestimated overall atom economy.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    AE overall=(82.5%+94.0%)/2  ⟹  AE overall=176.5%/2=88.3%\text{AE overall} = (82.5\% + 94.0\%) / 2 \implies \text{AE overall} = 176.5\% / 2 = 88.3\%

    Correct

    AEoverall=AE1×AE2=0.825×0.940=77.6%\text{AE}_{\text{overall}} = \text{AE}_1 \times \text{AE}_2 = 0.825 \times 0.940 = 77.6\%

    For a multi-step linear sequence, each successive reaction introduces its own stoichiometric byproducts, so theoretical atom economies combine multiplicatively rather than as an arithmetic mean.

  2. Step 2

    Lost solvent=300 kg×0.150=45.0 kg  ⟹  Total mass inputs=120 kg+25.8 kg+45.0 kg=190.8 kg\text{Lost solvent} = 300\text{ kg} \times 0.150 = 45.0\text{ kg} \implies \text{Total mass inputs} = 120\text{ kg} + 25.8\text{ kg} + 45.0\text{ kg} = 190.8\text{ kg}

  3. Step 3

    Waste=190.8 kg−59.3 kg=131.5 kg  ⟹  E-factor=131.5 kg/59.3 kg=2.22\text{Waste} = 190.8\text{ kg} - 59.3\text{ kg} = 131.5\text{ kg} \implies E\text{-factor} = 131.5\text{ kg} / 59.3\text{ kg} = 2.22

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly isolated the unrecovered solvent fraction instead of treating the full solvent charge as waste.

You correctly avoided double-counting the intermediate stream when summing external process inputs.

You calculated the final process waste mass and cumulative EE-factor accurately to three significant figures.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Averaged Atom Economies Instead of Multiplying

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the overall atom economy across consecutive synthetic steps as an arithmetic mean rather than a compounding multiplicative efficiency ratio.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Compounding Linear Atom Economy
  • AEoverall=∏i=1nAEi\text{AE}_{\text{overall}} = \prod_{i=1}^n \text{AE}_i

  • Multiply the fractional atom economies of each sequential step together, just as you do for multi-step chemical yields.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. AEoverall=AE1×AE2\text{AE}_{\text{overall}} = \text{AE}_1 \times \text{AE}_2

  2. AEoverall=0.825×0.940=0.7755\text{AE}_{\text{overall}} = 0.825 \times 0.940 = 0.7755

  3. AEoverall=77.6%\text{AE}_{\text{overall}} = 77.6\%

Final answer

(a) Overall Atom Economy =77.6%= 77.6\%; (b) Cumulative E-factor=2.22 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = 2.22\text{ kg waste/kg product}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Remember that synthetic metrics measuring fraction of mass incorporated compound multiplicatively across linear steps.

  • Double-check that the overall atom economy is always lower than or equal to the lowest individual step atom economy in a linear sequence.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student includes the intermediate product mass twice when tallying total inputs, incorrectly counting it as an external input in Step 2.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    AEoverall=0.825×0.940  ⟹  AEoverall=0.7755=77.6%\text{AE}_{\text{overall}} = 0.825 \times 0.940 \implies \text{AE}_{\text{overall}} = 0.7755 = 77.6\%

  2. Step 2

    Lost solvent=300 kg×0.150=45.0 kg\text{Lost solvent} = 300\text{ kg} \times 0.150 = 45.0\text{ kg}

  3. Step 3

    Total mass inputs=120 kg+74.2 kg+25.8 kg+45.0 kg=265.0 kg\text{Total mass inputs} = 120\text{ kg} + 74.2\text{ kg} + 25.8\text{ kg} + 45.0\text{ kg} = 265.0\text{ kg}

    Correct

    Total mass inputs=120 kg+25.8 kg+45.0 kg=190.8 kg\text{Total mass inputs} = 120\text{ kg} + 25.8\text{ kg} + 45.0\text{ kg} = 190.8\text{ kg}

    You included the 74.2 kg74.2\text{ kg} of isolated intermediate as an external input. The intermediate is an internal transfer stream formed from the 120 kg120\text{ kg} of Step 1 starting materials, so adding it double-counts that mass.

  4. Step 4

    Waste=265.0 kg−59.3 kg=205.7 kg\text{Waste} = 265.0\text{ kg} - 59.3\text{ kg} = 205.7\text{ kg}

    Correct

    Waste=190.8 kg−59.3 kg=131.5 kg\text{Waste} = 190.8\text{ kg} - 59.3\text{ kg} = 131.5\text{ kg}

    Your formula for waste mass was set up logically, but your numerical result was affected by the double-counted intermediate in Step 3.

  5. Step 5

    E-factor=205.7 kg59.3 kg=3.47E\text{-factor} = \frac{205.7\text{ kg}}{59.3\text{ kg}} = 3.47

    Correct

    E-factor=131.5 kg59.3 kg≈2.22 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = \frac{131.5\text{ kg}}{59.3\text{ kg}} \approx 2.22\text{ kg waste/kg product}

    You applied the correct definition of the EE-factor, but the value reflects the propagated error from earlier steps.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the overall theoretical atom economy by multiplying the step atom economies.

You properly determined the mass of discarded solvent from the unrecoverable percentage.

You correctly set up the general definitions for total waste and environmental factor.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Double-counting internal intermediate in cumulative mass balance

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating internal process intermediate streams with fresh external raw material inputs across a multi-step system boundary.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
System Boundary and Internal Streams
  • In a multi-step synthetic sequence, an intermediate generated in an earlier step is an internal stream, not a new external input.

  • Draw a single boundary box around the entire sequence and sum only the mass streams that enter from outside the box (fresh reagents and unrecovered solvent).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Total external inputs=120 kg (Step 1 raw materials)+25.8 kg (Step 2 coreagent)+45.0 kg (lost solvent)=190.8 kg\text{Total external inputs} = 120\text{ kg (Step 1 raw materials)} + 25.8\text{ kg (Step 2 coreagent)} + 45.0\text{ kg (lost solvent)} = 190.8\text{ kg}

  2. Total waste=Total external inputs−Final API=190.8 kg−59.3 kg=131.5 kg\text{Total waste} = \text{Total external inputs} - \text{Final API} = 190.8\text{ kg} - 59.3\text{ kg} = 131.5\text{ kg}

  3. E-factor=131.5 kg waste59.3 kg API≈2.2175 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = \frac{131.5\text{ kg waste}}{59.3\text{ kg API}} \approx 2.2175\text{ kg waste/kg product}

Final answer

(a) 77.6%77.6\%; (b) 2.22 kg waste/kg product2.22\text{ kg waste/kg product}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • When calculating the cumulative EE-factor across multi-step syntheses, sketch an overall system boundary to exclude all isolated or unisolated intermediates from the external input sum.

  • Verify that recyclable solvents are split into recovered vs. unrecovered streams before tallying inputs or waste.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student divides total waste by total raw materials instead of the mass of the final product when calculating the E-factor.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    AEoverall=0.825×0.940  ⟹  AEoverall=0.7755=77.6%\text{AE}_{\text{overall}} = 0.825 \times 0.940 \implies \text{AE}_{\text{overall}} = 0.7755 = 77.6\%

  2. Step 2

    Lost solvent=300 kg×0.150=45.0 kg  ⟹  Total mass inputs=120 kg+25.8 kg+45.0 kg=190.8 kg\text{Lost solvent} = 300\text{ kg} \times 0.150 = 45.0\text{ kg} \implies \text{Total mass inputs} = 120\text{ kg} + 25.8\text{ kg} + 45.0\text{ kg} = 190.8\text{ kg}

  3. Step 3

    Waste=190.8 kg−59.3 kg=131.5 kg\text{Waste} = 190.8\text{ kg} - 59.3\text{ kg} = 131.5\text{ kg}

  4. Step 4

    E-factor=131.5 kg/190.8 kg=0.689E\text{-factor} = 131.5\text{ kg} / 190.8\text{ kg} = 0.689

    Correct

    E-factor=131.5 kg waste59.3 kg API=2.22 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = \frac{131.5\text{ kg waste}}{59.3\text{ kg API}} = 2.22\text{ kg waste/kg product}

    You divided waste by total input mass instead of the mass of the desired product. The Sheldon EE-factor is defined as mass of waste divided by mass of desired product.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly computed the cumulative atom economy by multiplying the step values.

You properly isolated the unrecovered solvent loss instead of counting the total solvent volume.

You avoided double-counting the intermediate stream when determining total process inputs.

You correctly computed the net mass of waste produced across the entire process.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Denominator confusion in E-factor

You divided by the total input mass of 190.8 kg190.8\text{ kg} instead of the desired product mass of 59.3 kg59.3\text{ kg}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the definition of Environmental Factor (EE-factor =mass of wastemass of product= \frac{\text{mass of waste}}{\text{mass of product}}) with a fractional waste yield or mass-fraction metric (mass of wastetotal mass inputs\frac{\text{mass of waste}}{\text{total mass inputs}}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
$E$-factor denominator definition
  • E-factor=Total mass of wasteMass of final productE\text{-factor} = \frac{\text{Total mass of waste}}{\text{Mass of final product}}

  • Always place the final desired product mass in the denominator, never total inputs or total reactants.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. E-factor=Mass of wasteMass of final API=131.5 kg59.3 kgE\text{-factor} = \frac{\text{Mass of waste}}{\text{Mass of final API}} = \frac{131.5\text{ kg}}{59.3\text{ kg}}

  2. E-factor≈2.2175 kg waste/kg product≈2.22 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} \approx 2.2175\text{ kg waste/kg product} \approx 2.22\text{ kg waste/kg product}

Final answer

(a) Overall Atom Economy =77.6%= 77.6\%; (b) Cumulative E-factor=2.22 kg waste/kg productE\text{-factor} = 2.22\text{ kg waste/kg product}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the key green metrics by their denominators: Atom Economy divides by reactant formula weight, Process Mass Intensity (PMI) divides total inputs by product mass, and EE-factor divides waste mass by product mass.

  • When calculating EE-factor, verify that an EE-factor above 11 makes physical sense whenever the waste exceeds the final product mass.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A linear three-step peptide synthesis exhibits theoretical atom economies of 90.0%90.0\%, 85.0%85.0\%, and 80.0%80.0\% across Steps 1, 2, and 3, respectively. Calculate the theoretical atom economy of the overall three-step sequence to three significant figures.

Answer

AEoverall=0.900×0.850×0.800=0.612=61.2%\text{AE}_{\text{overall}} = 0.900 \times 0.850 \times 0.800 = 0.612 = 61.2\%.

02

In a two-step pharmaceutical route, Step 1 uses 50.0 kg50.0\text{ kg} of starting material to yield 30.0 kg30.0\text{ kg} of intermediate. Step 2 combines this 30.0 kg30.0\text{ kg} intermediate with 15.0 kg15.0\text{ kg} of coupling agent and 200 kg200\text{ kg} of solvent (of which 10.0%10.0\% is lost to waste) to yield 25.0 kg25.0\text{ kg} of purified target. Calculate the cumulative EE-factor for the process.

Answer

Total inputs consumed =50.0 kg+15.0 kg+(200 kg×0.10)=85.0 kg= 50.0\text{ kg} + 15.0\text{ kg} + (200\text{ kg} \times 0.10) = 85.0\text{ kg}. Total waste =85.0 kg−25.0 kg=60.0 kg= 85.0\text{ kg} - 25.0\text{ kg} = 60.0\text{ kg}. Cumulative EE-factor =60.0 kg/25.0 kg=2.40 kg waste/kg product= 60.0\text{ kg} / 25.0\text{ kg} = 2.40\text{ kg waste/kg product}.

03

A chemist evaluates two synthetic routes to the same target drug: Route A is a linear two-step sequence with AE1=80.0%\text{AE}_1 = 80.0\% and AE2=80.0%\text{AE}_2 = 80.0\%. Route B is a single-step reaction with AE=70.0%\text{AE} = 70.0\%. Based purely on theoretical atom economy, which route is greener, and what is the difference in overall atom economy?

Answer

Route A overall AE=0.800×0.800=0.640=64.0%\text{AE} = 0.800 \times 0.800 = 0.640 = 64.0\%. Route B has AE=70.0%\text{AE} = 70.0\%. Route B is greener by 6.0%6.0\% (70.0%−64.0%70.0\% - 64.0\%).

Loading workspace…