Resources

A student adds 50.0 mL50.0\text{ mL} of pure liquid water (H2O\text{H}_2\text{O}) to 50.0 mL50.0\text{ mL} of pure liquid glacial acetic acid (CH3COOH\text{CH}_3\text{COOH}). A fellow student claims: 'Since the volumes are identical, neither component can be declared the solvent, and diluting this weak acid will decrease its percent ionization because adding solvent decreases all species concentrations.' (a) Resolving the component ambiguity using molar quantities (given densities: ρwater=1.00 g/mL\rho_{\text{water}} = 1.00\text{ g/mL}, ρacetic=1.05 g/mL\rho_{\text{acetic}} = 1.05\text{ g/mL}), definitively identify the solvent and the solute. (b) Using Le Chatelier's principle and Ostwald's dilution law, refute the student's second claim and prove whether diluting a weak acid increases or decreases its percent ionization (α\alpha).

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Moles of water: 2.77 mol2.77\text{ mol}; Moles of acetic acid: 0.874 mol0.874\text{ mol}. Water is the solvent (present in a substantially higher molar quantity, 76.0 mol%76.0\text{ mol}\%), and acetic acid is the solute. (b) Counter-intuitive resolution: Adding solvent (water) decreases the concentration of all species initially, but by Le Chatelier's principle, the equilibrium CH3COOH(aq)+H2O(l)⇌H3O+(aq)+CH3COO−(aq)\text{CH}_3\text{COOH}(aq) + \text{H}_2\text{O}(l) \rightleftharpoons \text{H}_3\text{O}^+(aq) + \text{CH}_3\text{COO}^-(aq) shifts toward the side with more dissolved aqueous particles (the products). Therefore, dilution strictly increases the percent ionization (α\alpha), directly contradicting the student's intuition.

Steps

01

Le Chatelier's Principle

Part (a): Identifying the Solvent and Solute Using Molar Quantities

In chemistry, when two liquids mix to form a homogeneous solution, the component present in the greatest molar quantity (number of moles, or molecules) is designated as the solvent, while the minor component is the solute. Comparing volumes alone can be misleading due to differences in density and molar mass.

  1. Calculate the mass of each liquid: Mass of water (mHX2O)=volume⋅ρwater=50.0 mL⋅1.00 g/mL=50.0 g\text{Mass of water } (m_{\ce{H2O}}) = \text{volume} \cdot \rho_{\text{water}} = 50.0\text{ mL} \cdot 1.00\text{ g/mL} = 50.0\text{ g} Mass of acetic acid (mCHX3COOH)=volume⋅ρacetic=50.0 mL⋅1.05 g/mL=52.5 g\text{Mass of acetic acid } (m_{\ce{CH3COOH}}) = \text{volume} \cdot \rho_{\text{acetic}} = 50.0\text{ mL} \cdot 1.05\text{ g/mL} = 52.5\text{ g}
  2. Convert each mass to moles using molar masses:
    • Molar mass of HX2O≈18.02 g/mol\ce{H2O} \approx 18.02\text{ g/mol}: nHX2O=50.0 g18.02 g/mol≈2.77 moln_{\ce{H2O}} = \frac{50.0\text{ g}}{18.02\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2.77\text{ mol}
    • Molar mass of CHX3COOH≈60.05 g/mol\ce{CH3COOH} \approx 60.05\text{ g/mol}: nCHX3COOH=52.5 g60.05 g/mol≈0.874 moln_{\ce{CH3COOH}} = \frac{52.5\text{ g}}{60.05\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.874\text{ mol}
  3. Compare molar proportions: Total moles=2.77 mol+0.874 mol=3.644 mol\text{Total moles} = 2.77\text{ mol} + 0.874\text{ mol} = 3.644\text{ mol} Mole percent of water=2.77 mol3.644 mol⋅100%≈76.0 mol%\text{Mole percent of water} = \frac{2.77\text{ mol}}{3.644\text{ mol}} \cdot 100\% \approx 76.0\text{ mol}\% Because water provides 76.0 mol%76.0\text{ mol}\% of the mixture (more than 33 times as many molecules as acetic acid), water is the solvent and acetic acid is the solute.

Part (b): Effect of Dilution on Percent Ionization (α\alpha)

The student's intuition that "dilution lowers concentrations, so ionization decreases" confuses total ion concentration with the fraction of acid molecules that ionize (percent ionization, α\alpha).

Consider the acid dissociation equilibrium: CHX3COOH(aq)+HX2O(l)⇌HX3OX+(aq)+CHX3COOX−(aq)\ce{CH3COOH(aq) + H2O(l) <=> H3O+(aq) + CH3COO-(aq)}

  • The reactant side contains 11 dissolved solute particle (CHX3COOH\ce{CH3COOH}), while the product side contains 22 dissolved solute particles (HX3OX+\ce{H3O+} and CHX3COOX−\ce{CH3COO-}). Liquid water is the solvent in large excess, so its activity remains approximately constant.
  • When solvent is added, the solution volume increases, momentarily lowering the molar concentrations of all dissolved species by a dilution factor ff (f>1f > 1): Qc=[HX3OX+]dil[CHX3COOX−]dil[CHX3COOH]dil=[HX3OX+]0f⋅[CHX3COOX−]0f[CHX3COOH]0f=Q0f<KaQ_c = \frac{[\ce{H3O+}]_{\text{dil}}[\ce{CH3COO-}]_{\text{dil}}}{[\ce{CH3COOH}]_{\text{dil}}} = \frac{\frac{[\ce{H3O+}]_0}{f} \cdot \frac{[\ce{CH3COO-}]_0}{f}}{\frac{[\ce{CH3COOH}]_0}{f}} = \frac{Q_0}{f} < K_a
  • Because Qc<KaQ_c < K_a, Le Chatelier's principle dictates that the system shifts in the forward direction (toward the side with more dissolved aqueous particles) to restore equilibrium.
  • This forward shift converts a larger proportion of undissociated CHX3COOH\ce{CH3COOH} molecules into ions, thereby increasing the percent ionization (α\alpha).
02

Ostwald's Dilution Law

For a weak monobasic acid of initial concentration CC and degree of dissociation α\alpha: Ka=Cα21−αK_a = \frac{C\alpha^2}{1 - \alpha}

For a weak acid where α≪1\alpha \ll 1, this simplifies to: Ka≈Cα2  ⟹  α≈KaCK_a \approx C\alpha^2 \implies \alpha \approx \sqrt{\frac{K_a}{C}}

  • As water is added, the nominal concentration CC decreases (C→0C \to 0).
  • Since KaK_a is a constant at fixed temperature, the value of α\alpha must increase proportionally to 1C\frac{1}{\sqrt{C}}.

Conclusion: Diluting a weak acid strictly increases its percent ionization (α\alpha), refuting the student's claim.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student identifies the solvent based purely on the greater mass rather than the greater number of moles.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    mass of water=50.0 mL×1.00 g/mL=50.0 g  ⟹  mass of acetic acid=50.0 mL×1.05 g/mL=52.5 g\text{mass of water} = 50.0\text{ mL} \times 1.00\text{ g/mL} = 50.0\text{ g} \implies \text{mass of acetic acid} = 50.0\text{ mL} \times 1.05\text{ g/mL} = 52.5\text{ g}

  2. Step 2

    Since 52.5 g>50.0 g, acetic acid has the greater mass.  ⟹  Acetic acid is the solvent and water is the solute.\text{Since } 52.5\text{ g} > 50.0\text{ g}\text{, acetic acid has the greater mass.} \implies \text{Acetic acid is the solvent and water is the solute.}

    Correct

    nHX2O=50.0 g18.02 g/mol≈2.77 mol  ⟹  nCHX3COOH=52.5 g60.05 g/mol≈0.874 mol  ⟹  Water is the solvent and acetic acid is the solute.n_{\ce{H2O}} = \frac{50.0\text{ g}}{18.02\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2.77\text{ mol} \implies n_{\ce{CH3COOH}} = \frac{52.5\text{ g}}{60.05\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.874\text{ mol} \implies \text{Water is the solvent and acetic acid is the solute.}

    In liquid-liquid solutions, solvent vs. solute status is determined by the component present in the greatest number of moles (mole fraction), not mass. Because water has a much lower molar mass (18.02 g/mol18.02\text{ g/mol}) than acetic acid (60.05 g/mol60.05\text{ g/mol}), water provides 2.77 mol2.77\text{ mol} compared to only 0.874 mol0.874\text{ mol} of acetic acid. Therefore, water is the solvent (76.0 mol%76.0\text{ mol}\%).

  3. Step 3

    CHX3COOH+HX2O⇌CHX3COOX−+HX3OX+  ⟹  Dilution lowers species concentrations, so Q=[CHX3COOX−][HX3OX+][CHX3COOH] becomes less than Ka.  ⟹  By Le Chatelier’s principle, the system shifts right to produce more ions.\ce{CH3COOH + H2O <=> CH3COO- + H3O+} \implies \text{Dilution lowers species concentrations, so } Q = \frac{[\ce{CH3COO-}][\ce{H3O+}]}{[\ce{CH3COOH}]} \text{ becomes less than } K_a. \implies \text{By Le Chatelier's principle, the system shifts right to produce more ions.}

  4. Step 4

    By Ostwald’s dilution law, Ka≈Cα2, so α≈KaC.  ⟹  As C decreases, percent ionization α increases, refuting the claim.\text{By Ostwald's dilution law, } K_a \approx C\alpha^2\text{, so } \alpha \approx \sqrt{\frac{K_a}{C}}. \implies \text{As } C \text{ decreases, percent ionization } \alpha \text{ increases, refuting the claim.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accurately converted volumes to masses using the provided densities.

You correctly wrote the acid ionization equilibrium and evaluated the reaction quotient QcQ_c relative to KaK_a.

You applied Le Chatelier's principle and Ostwald's dilution law correctly to prove that percent ionization increases upon dilution.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Mass vs. Moles in Solvent Identification

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You relied on mass comparison rather than converting to molar quantities. In chemistry, solution components of the same phase are classified by particle count (moles), meaning the component with the highest mole fraction is the solvent.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Solvent Criterion in Liquid Mixtures
  • When two liquids form a homogeneous mixture, the solvent is the component with the greatest number of moles (n=mMn = \frac{m}{M}), not the greatest mass or volume.

  • Always divide each component's mass by its molar mass to compare moles before assigning solvent and solute roles.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. nHX2O=50.0 g18.02 g/mol≈2.77 moln_{\ce{H2O}} = \frac{50.0\text{ g}}{18.02\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2.77\text{ mol}

  2. nCHX3COOH=52.5 g60.05 g/mol≈0.874 moln_{\ce{CH3COOH}} = \frac{52.5\text{ g}}{60.05\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.874\text{ mol}

  3. Since nHX2O>nCHX3COOHn_{\ce{H2O}} > n_{\ce{CH3COOH}} (2.77 mol>0.874 mol2.77\text{ mol} > 0.874\text{ mol}), water constitutes 76.0 mol%76.0\text{ mol}\% of the solution.

Final answer

Water is the solvent, and acetic acid is the solute.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice converting masses of mixed liquids to moles to establish mole fractions before naming the solvent.

  • Remember that substances with small molar masses contain far more particles per gram than substances with large molar masses.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the decrease in absolute hydronium ion concentration upon dilution with the fraction of acid molecules ionized.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    mass of water=50.0 g; moles of water=50.0 g18.02 g/mol=2.77 mol  ⟹  mass of acetic acid=52.5 g; moles of acetic acid=52.5 g60.05 g/mol=0.874 mol  ⟹  Water is present in greater moles, so water is the solvent and acetic acid is the solute.\text{mass of water} = 50.0\text{ g};\, \text{moles of water} = \frac{50.0\text{ g}}{18.02\text{ g/mol}} = 2.77\text{ mol} \implies \text{mass of acetic acid} = 52.5\text{ g};\, \text{moles of acetic acid} = \frac{52.5\text{ g}}{60.05\text{ g/mol}} = 0.874\text{ mol} \implies \text{Water is present in greater moles, so water is the solvent and acetic acid is the solute.}

  2. Step 2

    CHX3COOH+HX2O⇌CHX3COOX−+HX3OX+  ⟹  Ka=[CHX3COOX−][HX3OX+][CHX3COOH]\ce{CH3COOH + H2O <=> CH3COO- + H3O+} \implies K_a = \frac{[\ce{CH3COO-}][\ce{H3O+}]}{[\ce{CH3COOH}]}

  3. Step 3

    Diluting the solution increases the volume, so [HX3OX+]=10−pH decreases.  ⟹  Since percent ionization is α=[HX3OX+]Cinitial and [HX3OX+] decreases, α must decrease, supporting the student’s claim.\text{Diluting the solution increases the volume, so } [\ce{H3O+}] = 10^{-\text{pH}} \text{ decreases.} \implies \text{Since percent ionization is } \alpha = \frac{[\ce{H3O+}]}{C_{\text{initial}}} \text{ and } [\ce{H3O+}] \text{ decreases, } \alpha \text{ must decrease, supporting the student's claim.}

    Correct

    Dilution decreases all aqueous concentrations by factor f>1f > 1, making Qc=Q0f<KaQ_c = \frac{Q_0}{f} < K_a. By Le Chatelier's principle, the equilibrium shifts right toward the side with more aqueous ions. By Ostwald's dilution law, α≈KaC\alpha \approx \sqrt{\frac{K_a}{C}}, so as CC decreases, α\alpha increases.

    You treated CinitialC_{\text{initial}} as a constant while only evaluating the numerator [HX3OX+][\ce{H3O+}]. Dilution decreases both [HX3OX+][\ce{H3O+}] and CinitialC_{\text{initial}}, but CinitialC_{\text{initial}} decreases by a factor of ff whereas [HX3OX+][\ce{H3O+}] decreases only by approximately f\sqrt{f} because the equilibrium shifts forward to produce additional ions. Therefore, the ratio α=[HX3OX+]Cinitial\alpha = \frac{[\ce{H3O+}]}{C_{\text{initial}}} strictly increases.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the moles of water and acetic acid from their volumes and densities.

You correctly identified water as the solvent and acetic acid as the solute based on molar amounts.

You correctly formulated the aqueous acid-base dissociation equilibrium and its KaK_a expression.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing Ion Concentration with Percent Ionization

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that because the absolute hydronium ion concentration [HX3OX+][\ce{H3O+}] decreases upon dilution, the degree of ionization α=[HX3OX+]C\alpha = \frac{[\ce{H3O+}]}{C} must also decrease, neglecting the fact that the total concentration CC decreases by a larger factor and that dilution shifts the equilibrium toward the side with more dissolved particles.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Distinguish Concentration from Ionization Fraction
  • Percent ionization measures the fraction of dissolved acid molecules converted to ions (α=[HX3OX+]C\alpha = \frac{[\ce{H3O+}]}{C}), not the absolute molarity of [HX3OX+][\ce{H3O+}].

  • When diluting an acid, remember that while [HX3OX+][\ce{H3O+}] decreases (raising pH), the fraction of acid molecules that dissociate (α\alpha) increases.

Apply Le Chatelier's Principle to Dilution
  • Adding solvent lowers all solute concentrations equally at the moment of mixing. For HA(aq)⇌HX+(aq)+AX−(aq)\ce{HA(aq) <=> H+(aq) + A-(aq)}, the reaction quotient becomes Q=Q0f<KaQ = \frac{Q_0}{f} < K_a, forcing a forward shift.

  • Compare the number of aqueous solute species on both sides: dilution always favors the side with more aqueous solute particles.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate the effect of dilution by a volume factor f>1f > 1 on the reaction quotient: Qc=[HX3OX+]0f⋅[CHX3COOX−]0f[CHX3COOH]0f=Q0f<KaQ_c = \frac{\frac{[\ce{H3O+}]_0}{f} \cdot \frac{[\ce{CH3COO-}]_0}{f}}{\frac{[\ce{CH3COOH}]_0}{f}} = \frac{Q_0}{f} < K_a.

  2. Because Qc<KaQ_c < K_a, Le Chatelier's principle dictates that the system shifts forward (to the right) toward the side with more dissolved ions, ionizing a greater fraction of the original acid molecules.

  3. Confirm using Ostwald's dilution law: for a weak acid with α≪1\alpha \ll 1, Ka≈Cα2  ⟹  α≈KaCK_a \approx C\alpha^2 \implies \alpha \approx \sqrt{\frac{K_a}{C}}. As CC decreases upon dilution, α\alpha must increase.

Final answer

Diluting a weak acid strictly increases its percent ionization (α\alpha), refuting the fellow student's claim.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Ostwald's dilution law and practice deriving α≈Ka/C\alpha \approx \sqrt{K_a / C}.

  • Use the reaction quotient QcQ_c rather than intuitive reasoning about single ion concentrations whenever solution volume changes.

  • Solve problems that contrast pH change (which tracks [HX3OX+][\ce{H3O+}]) with percent ionization change upon dilution.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A chemist mixes 100.0 g100.0\text{ g} of pure methanol (CHX3OH\ce{CH3OH}, M=32.04 g/molM = 32.04\text{ g/mol}) with 100.0 g100.0\text{ g} of pure water (HX2O\ce{H2O}, M=18.02 g/molM = 18.02\text{ g/mol}). Identify the solvent and the solute, giving their mole percentages.

Answer

nHX2O=100.018.02≈5.55 moln_{\ce{H2O}} = \frac{100.0}{18.02} \approx 5.55\text{ mol}; nCHX3OH=100.032.04≈3.12 moln_{\ce{CH3OH}} = \frac{100.0}{32.04} \approx 3.12\text{ mol}. Water is the solvent (64.0 mol%64.0\text{ mol}\%) and methanol is the solute (36.0 mol%36.0\text{ mol}\%) because water is present in greater moles.

02

An aqueous antifreeze solution consists of 60.0 g60.0\text{ g} of ethylene glycol (CX2HX6OX2\ce{C2H6O2}, M=62.07 g/molM = 62.07\text{ g/mol}) and 40.0 g40.0\text{ g} of water (HX2O\ce{H2O}, M=18.02 g/molM = 18.02\text{ g/mol}). Although ethylene glycol makes up 60%60\% of the total mass, identify the solvent by calculating the mole fraction of each component.

Answer

nglycol=60.0 g62.07 g/mol≈0.967 moln_{\text{glycol}} = \frac{60.0\text{ g}}{62.07\text{ g/mol}} \approx 0.967\text{ mol}; nHX2O=40.0 g18.02 g/mol≈2.22 moln_{\ce{H2O}} = \frac{40.0\text{ g}}{18.02\text{ g/mol}} \approx 2.22\text{ mol}. Water's mole fraction is XHX2O=2.222.22+0.967≈0.70X_{\ce{H2O}} = \frac{2.22}{2.22 + 0.967} \approx 0.70 (70 mol%70\text{ mol}\%). Water is the solvent and ethylene glycol is the solute.

03

A 0.10 M0.10\text{ M} solution of a weak acid HA\ce{HA} has Ka=1.0×10−5K_a = 1.0 \times 10^{-5}. (a) Calculate its percent ionization α\alpha. (b) If the solution is diluted tenfold with water to 0.010 M0.010\text{ M}, calculate the new α\alpha and verify whether dilution increased or decreased percent ionization.

Answer

(a) α1≈KaC1=1.0×10−50.10=1.0×10−4=0.010\alpha_1 \approx \sqrt{\frac{K_a}{C_1}} = \sqrt{\frac{1.0 \times 10^{-5}}{0.10}} = \sqrt{1.0 \times 10^{-4}} = 0.010 (1.0%1.0\%). (b) α2≈KaC2=1.0×10−50.010=1.0×10−3≈0.0316\alpha_2 \approx \sqrt{\frac{K_a}{C_2}} = \sqrt{\frac{1.0 \times 10^{-5}}{0.010}} = \sqrt{1.0 \times 10^{-3}} \approx 0.0316 (3.2%3.2\%). Dilution from 0.10 M0.10\text{ M} to 0.010 M0.010\text{ M} increases the percent ionization from 1.0%1.0\% to 3.2%3.2\%.

Loading workspace…