Resources
An analytical chemist is given a sample of an unknown white crystalline substance. Elemental microanalysis reveals that the sample contains exactly of calcium (atomic mass ), of carbon (atomic mass ), and of oxygen (atomic mass ). The chemist dissolves the sample in excess hydrochloric acid, producing carbon dioxide gas and a single aqueous salt solution with no insoluble residue. (a) By calculating the empirical formula and mole ratios of the constituents, determine whether the original sample is a pure compound or a heterogeneous mixture of elements. (b) Working backwards from these analytical mass values, determine the empirical formula of the substance.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) The sample is a pure compound because the elements are present in definite, small whole-number molar ratios (, , , yielding a molar ratio of ). (b) The empirical formula is (calcium carbonate).
Steps
Calculate the Moles of Each Constituent Element
To determine the empirical formula and mole ratios, convert the given mass of each element into moles using the formula:
- Calcium ():
- Carbon ():
- Oxygen ():
Determine the Simplest Whole-Number Mole Ratio (Part b)
Divide each mole value by the smallest calculated quantity ():
The simplest whole-number atomic ratio is . Therefore, the empirical formula of the substance is:
Distinguish Between a Pure Compound and a Mixture (Part a)
- Law of Definite Proportions: In a pure chemical compound, elements are chemically combined in fixed, definite, small whole-number ratios by moles. The quantitative analysis establishes an exact mole ratio of .
- Physical and Chemical Evidence: A physical mixture of the elemental forms would consist of metallic calcium (a reactive metal), elemental carbon (a black solid such as graphite), and elemental oxygen (a diatomic gas). Such a mixture could not form a uniform, homogeneous white crystalline solid. Furthermore, adding produces carbon dioxide and a clear aqueous solution of calcium chloride () with zero solid carbon residue:
Because the elements exist in a constant, fixed stoichiometric ratio and exhibit chemical behavior distinct from the separate free elements, the sample is a pure compound.
Typical errors
01 A student uses mass ratios directly instead of converting to moles, leading to an incorrect ratio and formula.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You simplified the mass ratios rather than converting each mass to moles. Chemical formulas represent atom-to-atom or mole ratios, so you must divide each mass by its atomic mass () before simplifying.
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
Your empirical formula followed directly from the mass ratio calculated in Step 1. Using the correct molar ratio () yields .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that a fixed, definite elemental proportion indicates a pure chemical compound rather than a mixture.
You demonstrated clear algebraic ability to simplify a three-part ratio into whole numbers.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou simplified the given gram masses directly instead of converting them to moles first.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing mass ratios with stoichiometric molar ratios. Because atoms of different elements have different atomic masses, a ratio by mass does not equal a ratio of atoms.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Subscripts Represent Moles, Not Grams
Chemical formulas represent the ratio of atoms (or moles of atoms), not their masses.
Always convert mass to moles via before dividing by the smallest value to find empirical formula subscripts.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate moles of each element: , , and .
Divide each mole value by the smallest value (): , , .
Combine the whole-number ratios into the empirical formula: .
(a) Pure compound; (b)
02 A student treats oxygen as diatomic O2 when calculating moles, halving the mole count of oxygen and finding an incorrect empirical formula.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
,
- Step 2Correct
Chemical formulas express the relative number of individual atoms of each element in a compound. You should use the molar mass of atomic oxygen () rather than diatomic oxygen gas (, ).
- Step 3
The constant ratio and complete dissolution mean it is a pure compound.
- Step 4Correct
Your mathematical procedure for finding whole-number ratios was logically executed, but the resulting formula was affected by the incorrect mole count of oxygen from Step 2.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly converted the masses of calcium and carbon into moles.
You correctly identified that the substance is a pure compound based on the constant stoichiometric ratio and its dissolution behavior.
You correctly followed the mathematical procedure of dividing by the smallest value and scaling by an integer to find a whole-number ratio.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo; this stems from a conceptual confusion between elemental oxygen as a free diatomic gas () and oxygen as a constituent element within a chemical compound.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou used the molar mass of molecular oxygen gas () rather than the atomic mass of oxygen (). Empirical formulas represent the ratios of individual atoms (or moles of atoms) chemically bonded in a compound, so every element must be converted using its atomic molar mass.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Atomic vs. Molecular Molar Mass in Formulas
Empirical formulas represent ratios of constituent atoms. Always use the atomic molar mass of each element (), never the molecular mass of its diatomic standard state (such as , , , or ).
When microanalysis gives the mass of an element (like oxygen, nitrogen, or chlorine) in a compound, divide by the atomic mass from the periodic table: .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecalculate the moles of oxygen atoms using its atomic molar mass: .
Set up the molar ratio of atoms: .
Divide each quantity by the smallest mole value (): , , .
Write the empirical formula using these whole-number subscripts: .
(a) The sample is a pure compound. (b) The empirical formula is .
03 A student multiplies the masses by molar masses instead of dividing, resulting in an inverted ratio and an invalid empirical formula.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
To convert mass () into amount of substance in moles (), divide mass by molar mass (). Multiplying grams by yields units of rather than moles.
- Step 2
The constituents have a fixed ratio so the sample is a pure compound.
- Step 3
36.03: = 11.1, = 1.0, = 5.33 3: = 33, = 3, = 16 = {33}3{16}
Correct0.2495: = 1.00, = 1.00, = 3.01 3 = 3
Your ratio reduction technique was mathematically valid, but your result was distorted because it inherited the incorrect mole values from Step 1.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the sample as a pure chemical compound because its elements are combined in a fixed ratio.
You correctly applied the procedure for finding empirical ratios by dividing each value by the smallest number and attempting to clear decimals.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou set up the mole conversion as instead of .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou did not use dimensional analysis to verify the units of your conversion; grams must be divided by grams per mole to cancel grams and leave moles in the numerator.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Unit Cancellation Check
Always write out your units explicitly and ensure that grams cancel out to leave .
- Reasonableness of Empirical Subscripts
Typical simple inorganic compounds have small whole-number subscripts (usually between and ).
If your empirical formula yields unusually large subscripts such as or , pause and recheck your initial mole calculations.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate moles by dividing each elemental mass by its molar mass: , , and .
Divide each mole value by the smallest value (): , , and .
Write the resulting simplest whole-number ratio as the empirical formula.
(a) Pure compound; (b)
Lock it in
What do the subscripts in a chemical formula represent: mass ratios or mole/atom ratios?
Subscripts represent mole (atom) ratios, never mass ratios. Because different elements have different molar masses, equal masses do not mean equal numbers of atoms.
Similar question
A sample contains of magnesium (atomic mass ) and of oxygen (atomic mass ). Determine its empirical formula.
Answer
Empirical formula: . Key steps: , . Ratio .
Analysis of a gaseous hydrocarbon shows it contains carbon (atomic mass ) and hydrogen (atomic mass ) by mass. Determine the empirical formula.
Answer
Empirical formula: . Key steps: In a sample, and . Ratio . Multiply by to get .
A student mixes of iron powder and of sulfur powder at room temperature. (a) Is this solid a compound or a mixture? (b) If they are heated and react completely to form iron(II) sulfide (, , ), which element is in excess and by how many grams?
Answer
(a) A heterogeneous mixture (the components retain their individual physical properties and are not chemically bonded in a fixed stoichiometric ratio). (b) Iron is in excess by . Key steps: , . Ratio in is , so sulfur is in excess in moles, but checking required iron mass: reacts with all ? Wait: requires . Thus is limiting, so sulfur is in excess by of sulfur.