Resources

Students frequently confuse the sign convention for ion charges when relating atomic number to electron count. A selenium ion is represented as 3479Se2−^{79}_{34}\text{Se}^{2-}. (a) Calculate the exact number of protons, neutrons, and electrons in this ion. (b) Contrast this with an erroneous calculation where the negative charge sign is subtracted from the atomic number rather than added.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Protons: 3434, Neutrons: 4545, Electrons: 3636; (b) An incorrect subtraction yields 34−2=3234 - 2 = 32 electrons, which erroneously describes a dication ( extSe2+\ ext{Se}^{2+}) rather than the true dianion ( extSe2−\ ext{Se}^{2-}).

Steps

Part (a): Determining Protons, Neutrons, and Electrons

In standard nuclide notation, an atom or ion is written as: XZAX2Z2AXXq\ce{^{A}_{Z}X^{$q$}} where:

  • ZZ is the atomic number (number of protons).
  • AA is the mass number (total number of protons plus neutrons).
  • qq is the net ionic charge.

For the selenium ion 3479Se2−^{79}_{34}\ce{Se}^{2-}:

  1. Number of Protons (p+p^+):
    The atomic number is given by the subscript: Protons=Z=34\text{Protons} = Z = 34
  2. Number of Neutrons (n0n^0):
    The mass number is the sum of protons and neutrons (A=p++n0A = p^+ + n^0). Therefore: Neutrons=A−Z=79−34=45\text{Neutrons} = A - Z = 79 - 34 = 45
  3. Number of Electrons (e−e^-):
    Each proton carries a +1+1 charge and each electron carries a −1-1 charge. The net charge qq satisfies: Charge (q)=Protons−Electrons\text{Charge } (q) = \text{Protons} - \text{Electrons} Electrons=Z−q=34−(−2)=34+2=36\text{Electrons} = Z - q = 34 - (-2) = 34 + 2 = 36

Thus, the ion contains 3434 protons, 4545 neutrons, and 3636 electrons.


Part (b): Contrasting with the Common Sign Error

  • The Common Pitfall:
    Students often see the minus sign in Se2−\ce{Se}^{2-} and intuitively subtract 22 from the atomic number: Incorrect Electron Count=34−2=32 electrons\text{Incorrect Electron Count} = 34 - 2 = 32\text{ electrons}
  • Why This Is Erroneous:
    Because electrons are negatively charged, gaining electrons increases negative charge, while losing electrons produces a positive charge:

    • Having 3434 protons and 3232 electrons gives a net charge of: 34 protons (+34)+32 electrons (−32)=+234\text{ protons } (+34) + 32\text{ electrons } (-32) = +2 This corresponds to the dication SeX2+\ce{Se^2+}.
    • The given species is a dianion (SeX2−\ce{Se^2-}), which requires an excess of negative charge: 34 protons (+34)+36 electrons (−36)=−234\text{ protons } (+34) + 36\text{ electrons } (-36) = -2

Therefore, subtracting the charge value incorrectly predicts a positive ion (SeX2+\ce{Se^2+}) with a deficit of electrons, rather than the actual negative ion (SeX2−\ce{Se^2-}) that has gained 22 extra electrons.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student subtracts the mass number and atomic number in reverse or miscalculates the neutron count by subtracting the charge instead of the atomic number from the mass number.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Protons=34\text{Protons} = 34

  2. Step 2

    Neutrons=79−2=77\text{Neutrons} = 79 - 2 = 77

    Correct

    Neutrons=A−Z=79−34=45\text{Neutrons} = A - Z = 79 - 34 = 45

    You subtracted the charge magnitude (22) from the mass number (7979) instead of subtracting the atomic number (3434). Neutrons reside in the nucleus, so their count depends only on mass number and atomic number: Neutrons=A−Z\text{Neutrons} = A - Z.

  3. Step 3

    Electrons=34+2=36\text{Electrons} = 34 + 2 = 36

  4. Step 4

    Erroneous electrons=34−2=32  ⟹  The erroneous calculation gives 32 electrons instead of 36, which is 4 electrons fewer and corresponds to a 2+ cation.\text{Erroneous electrons} = 34 - 2 = 32 \implies \text{The erroneous calculation gives } 32 \text{ electrons instead of } 36, \text{ which is } 4 \text{ electrons fewer and corresponds to a } 2+ \text{ cation.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the atomic number as 3434 protons.

You accurately determined that a 2−2- anion has gained 22 electrons, yielding 3636 electrons.

You thoroughly explained why subtracting the charge leads to an erroneous 2+2+ cation with 3232 electrons.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Subtracted ionic charge instead of atomic number when finding neutrons

In Step 2, you wrote 79−2=7779 - 2 = 77 by picking the superscript charge 2−2- instead of the subscript atomic number 3434.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You momentarily conflated the charge adjustment used for electron counts with the formula for neutron count. The net charge only affects the electron cloud; the nucleus consists strictly of protons and neutrons, where Neutrons=A−Z\text{Neutrons} = A - Z.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Nucleus vs. Electron Cloud
  • The net charge qq alters only the number of electrons (e−=Z−qe^- = Z - q). It has zero effect on the nucleus.

  • Always find neutrons using strictly the mass number and atomic number: n0=A−Zn^0 = A - Z.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Neutrons=A−Z=79−34=45\text{Neutrons} = A - Z = 79 - 34 = 45

Final answer

(a) Protons: 3434, Neutrons: 4545, Electrons: 3636; (b) An incorrect subtraction yields 34−2=3234 - 2 = 32 electrons, which erroneously describes a dication (SeX2+\ce{Se^2+}) rather than the true dianion (SeX2−\ce{Se^2-}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Remind yourself that net ionic charge only modifies electrons, never the nucleus.

  • Practice labeling AA, ZZ, and qq directly above or beside nuclide symbols before calculating subatomic particles.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the mass number with the neutron count directly rather than subtracting the atomic number from the mass number.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Protons=34\text{Protons} = 34

  2. Step 2

    Neutrons=79\text{Neutrons} = 79

    Correct

    Neutrons=A−Z=79−34=45\text{Neutrons} = A - Z = 79 - 34 = 45

    The superscript 7979 represents the total mass number AA (protons plus neutrons), not the neutron count alone. To find neutrons, subtract the atomic number from the mass number: 79−34=4579 - 34 = 45.

  3. Step 3

    Electrons=34+2=36\text{Electrons} = 34 + 2 = 36

  4. Step 4

    Erroneous calculation gives 34−2=32 electrons. This gives 32 electrons instead of 36 electrons, creating a difference of 4 electrons and treating Se2− as if it lost electrons.\text{Erroneous calculation gives } 34 - 2 = 32 \text{ electrons. This gives } 32 \text{ electrons instead of } 36 \text{ electrons, creating a difference of } 4 \text{ electrons and treating } \text{Se}^{2-} \text{ as if it lost electrons.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly read the atomic number as 3434 protons.

You handled the 2−2- charge convention properly by adding 22 electrons to get 3636 electrons.

You provided a thorough explanation in part (b) highlighting the mistake of treating an anion as having lost electrons.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Mass Number vs. Neutron Count Confusion

You wrote the mass number 7979 directly as the number of neutrons.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the mass number AA as representing only neutrons, overlooking that AA is the combined sum of both protons and neutrons (A=p++n0A = p^+ + n^0).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Nuclide Notation Meaning
  • In ZAXq^{A}_{Z}\text{X}^{q}, the superscript AA is the mass number (p++n0p^+ + n^0) and the subscript ZZ is the atomic number (p+p^+).

  • Always compute neutrons by calculating n0=A−Zn^0 = A - Z rather than reading AA directly as neutrons.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify A=79A = 79 and Z=34Z = 34.

  2. Neutrons=A−Z=79−34=45\text{Neutrons} = A - Z = 79 - 34 = 45.

Final answer

(a) Protons: 3434, Neutrons: 4545, Electrons: 3636; (b) Subtracting gives 3232 electrons, which represents Se2+\text{Se}^{2+} (electron loss) instead of Se2−\text{Se}^{2-} (electron gain).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice labeling AA, ZZ, and qq explicitly before calculating subatomic particles.

  • Remember the relationship: Neutrons=Mass Number−Atomic Number\text{Neutrons} = \text{Mass Number} - \text{Atomic Number}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Determine the number of protons, neutrons, and electrons in the phosphide ion 1531P3−^{31}_{15}\text{P}^{3-}.

Answer

Protons: 1515, Neutrons: 1616, Electrons: 1818. Key steps: Z=15Z = 15 protons; neutrons =A−Z=31−15=16= A - Z = 31 - 15 = 16; electrons =Z−q=15−(−3)=18= Z - q = 15 - (-3) = 18.

02

An ion of iron is represented as 2656Fe3+^{56}_{26}\text{Fe}^{3+}. (a) Calculate its protons, neutrons, and electrons. (b) What subatomic particle count would change if the ion were reduced to 2656Fe2+^{56}_{26}\text{Fe}^{2+}, and by how much?

Answer

(a) Protons: 2626, Neutrons: 3030, Electrons: 2323. Key steps: n=56−26=30n = 56 - 26 = 30; e=26−3=23e = 26 - 3 = 23. (b) Only the electron count changes; it increases by 11 (from 2323 to 2424 electrons).

03

An unknown ion ZAX2−^{A}_{Z}\text{X}^{2-} contains 1818 electrons and 1818 neutrons. Identify the atomic number ZZ, the mass number AA, and the chemical symbol of element X\text{X}.

Answer

Z=16Z = 16, A=34A = 34, and the element is sulfur (X1634X216234SX2−\ce{^{34}_{16}S^2-}). Key steps: e=Z−q  ⟹  18=Z−(−2)  ⟹  Z=16e = Z - q \implies 18 = Z - (-2) \implies Z = 16 (Sulfur); A=Z+n=16+18=34A = Z + n = 16 + 18 = 34.

Loading workspace…